This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Discipline Alternatives To Punishment. Essay

1342 words - 5 pages

"Discipline Alternatives to Punishment"IntroductionDiscipline alternatives are the positive methods of procedure or practices which child and youth workers use to control or correct inappropriate behavior. There is sufficient evidence to indicate that punishment, one form of discipline, is not an effective technique to use with troubled youth (Krueger, 102). Punishment may provide immediate control in some situations, but over time, it usually leads to more severe behavior patterns than the ones the user was trying to correct. In other words, punishment reinforces poor self-images, and this often leads to more self-destructive behavior. Discipline alternatives, on the other hand, can be effective if used as part of an overall positive approach or treatment plan. Effective discipline alternatives improve children's self-images, and lead to more self-fulfilling behavior (Pearce, 1).Significance of IssueMore than 125,000 of America's youth were in custody in nearly 3,500 public and private juvenile correctional facilities across the nation (Snyder). The majority of youth enter correctional facilities with a broad range of intense educational, mental health, medical, and social needs. Large numbers of incarcerated juveniles are marginally literate or illiterate and have experienced school failure and retention (Center on Crime, Communities, and Culture, 24). These youth are also disproportionately male, poor, minority, and have significant learning and/or behavioral problems that entitle them to special education and related services. Because education is critical to rehabilitation for troubled youth, it is considered the "foundation for programming in most juvenile institutions". Helping youth acquire educational skills is also one of the most effective approaches to the prevention of delinquency and the reduction of recurring crime. Literacy skills are essential to meet the demands of a complex, high-tech world in school and at work. Higher levels of literacy are associated with lower rates of juvenile delinquency, re-arrest, and crime recurrence (Building Blocks for Youth).Discussion of IssueBefore a discipline alternative is used, all preventive alternatives should be exhausted first. This means that children and youth workers look at the child's relationships, treatment environment, and other specific activities to see if there is anything that can be changed to prevent the child from acting inappropriately. Once all possible changes are made or proposed, then the alternative is chosen in case the behavior still persists after the prevention strategies are employed (Malone). Punishment focuses entirely on dealing with a problem after it occurs. It relies on the penalty or pain which is suffered after behaving inappropriately to deter the offender form behaving the same way in the future, and child and youth workers should exhaust all feasible efforts in preventing this belittlement (Krueger, 103).Effective discipline alternatives concentrate on...

Find Another Essay On Discipline Alternatives to Punishment.

Corporal Punishment is physical abuse Essay

824 words - 3 pages Corporal Punishment is physical abuseCorporal punishment is the execution of a judicially imposed sentence that inflicts a manner of physical pain upon the offenders body without killing him. In the past corporal punishment included flogging, whipping, branding and facial or bodily mutilation of all types. Corporal punishment also refers to the discipline of children at home and in schools but it was made illegal for punishing schoolchildren in

Corporal Punishment in American Homes Essay

1632 words - 7 pages fix or at least deal with the problems that may have occurred many years ago as a child. Paul C. Holinger suggests, "Effective alternatives to physical punishment exist to help children tolerate frustrations, regulate tension, behave in socially-acceptable ways, develop appropriate ethical and moral standards, and improve self-esteem."   There are alternative forms of discipline for which a parent may use and see positive results. These may

Corporal Punishment

1989 words - 8 pages Punishment and Alternatives, and the National Coalition to Abolish Corporal Punishment in Schools (My ParenTime 1). These organizations provide counseling and alternatives to corporal punishment. Anyone who is against this kind of discipline and wants to learn more, or anyone who is in favor of it and wants to find out the negative effects can contact these organizations. People need to realize that it is the year 2001 and things are not as acceptable

Caning in Singapore Schools to Be Replaced by Non-Violent Disciplines

2251 words - 10 pages methods are more effective in reducing such misconducts in schools than caning. Hence, Singapore Ministry of Education should switch to these more effective alternatives in maintaining school discipline. In addition, the caning policy in Singapore schools directly defies The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, which states that children should be protected against all forms of physical violence. Such violent physical punishment

Corporal Punishment In Schools

1782 words - 8 pages notify the parents when their child is misbehaving can help in the discipline process because then the whole controversial process is not laid upon the shoulders of the teacher. In addition to this, sometimes a child will be more willing to behave for one or the other, so in involving both, the discipline is bound to occur.In conclusion, I believe that there are alternatives to corporal punishment. I think that it is everyone's right to learn in

Corporal Punishment in Public Schools

784 words - 3 pages Corporal punishment is defined as “an infliction of punishment to the body.” My primary reason for not approving corporal punishment would be that corporal punishment creates a negative reaction from the student’s perspective plus additional problems in the end. To discipline students in a way that will harm them into non-misbehavior is not the way to go. I claim that corporal punishment in public schools should not be permitted

Severe and Physical Punishment Necessary in Ships in the Royal Navy

999 words - 4 pages discipline in the Navy’. Whilst this may be true, contemporary sources clearly demonstrate that unnecessary violence did occur, perhaps best shown by John Smiths appeal to the court. This seems to illustrate that due to the subjective nature of punishment within the Navy the degree of violence ‘did vary greatly’. However, the court-martial of Captain Corbet clearly confirms that ‘it was not tolerated’. It was also true, that flogging was justified due to

Why spanking works

1429 words - 6 pages like to site countries like Sweden as showing how the ban on corporal punishment has benefited society. However, a study conducted over the decade following that law made in 1979 found that overall child abuse rates increased 489% , the rate of assault by minors against minors increased 672%, and that since the law was put into place "parents had not ... found constructive alternatives to physical punishment. For most parents the alternative was

The Use of Corporal Punishment in Schools

1708 words - 7 pages Abstract Recently, as the value of education is increasing, corporal punishment became hot issue on the world because there is no any appropriate answer about” Should corporal punishment be for discipline?” According to a history of corporal punishment of Wikipedia, the practice was recorded as early as c 10th Century BC in Míshlê Shlomoh. Even though corporal punishment is not correct way for discipline like people usually think, how the

The Controversy Around Corporal Punishment

1443 words - 6 pages parents or teachers because they knew they could be whipped for doing so. Regardless of what the experts preached, the undeniable fact is the 'uncivilized' practice of whipping children produced more civilized young people”. As Alvy continues on into the article “Spanking Should Be Illegal” he mentions the innumerable different alternatives to corporal punishment. Spanking a child is not the only way to discipline them, and it is not an

The Effectiveness of Corporal Punishment on Correcting Behavior of Middle School Children

897 words - 4 pages the student, in addition to his/her social, emotional cognitive development. This research will attempt to identify corporal punishment and its effectiveness in correcting a student’s behavior in the middle school settings. Description of Corporal Punishment Discipline and punishment are not synonymous. In some cases, parents and education leaders who are strict disciplinarians seldom resort to punishment. Corporal punishment is a form of

Similar Essays

Children Discipline And Physical Punishment Essay

1046 words - 4 pages physical punishment and some alternatives to physical discipline when disciplining the children.What is Discipline?First of all, it is important to define the word discipline, so that we can understand its relationship with any method of discipline, especially physical punishment.Usually discipline is thought of in very negative concepts. In fact, many people cannot hear the word "discipline" without hearing something negative, so sometimes it is better

Corporal Punishment: Good Or Bad? Essay

514 words - 2 pages and keep try to achieve that goal and get their treat.Corporal punishment is an unjust way to discipline a child it does too much harm to the child and only brings fear to them. In this era of reform, the alternatives to corporal punishment should be used more to teach children self-discipline rather than being cooperative only because of fear. People should use ways of discipline such as verbal correction, reasoning, and time-outs. Therefore corporal punishment should be banned in Canada.

Effectiveness Of Corporal Punishment And Learning Theory Alternatives

1202 words - 5 pages Corporal punishment is effective in the short-term, but other alternatives, based more on learning theory, are more effective in long-term behavioural modification. The media, such as Time magazine, discusses the issue of corporal punishment using emotive language and vague claims, as opposed to empirical evidence and references to surveys. Therefore, this essay seeks to discuss the effectiveness of corporal punishment, and learning theory

Corporal Punishment And Parents Essay

1619 words - 7 pages The most important argument in favour of corporal punishment, which is the excuse of most of the parents when they are asked to stop the physical punishment, is that it teaches discipline to the children. The conventional parents give the name of discipline to the use of physical force to enforce their orders on their offspring’s. But actually discipline is of two types as defined in a journal named “The State of Research on the Effects of