Disciplining Addictions: The Bio Politics Of Methadone And Heroin In The United States Journal Review

1378 words - 6 pages

Running head: Heroin or Methadone Which Harms More? 1
" " " " " " " " "
Heroin or Methadone Which Harms More? Journal Review Andrew Gomez
Concordia University- Portland
" " " " " " " " "

Heroin or Methadone, Which Harms More? 2
Philippe Bourgois conducted a study regarding heroin addicts and the method of
treatment issued in the United States. The purpose was to expose the failing form of treatment by
using interviews with a few individuals who are currently under treatment. The treatment given
by health clinics is doses of methadone. The reason methadone is given to heroin addicts is due
to its ability to block the pleasure that heroin stimulates. However, by issuing daily doses of
methadone, most patients become tolerant and the entire treatment becomes counter productive.
While Bourgois clearly states that the methadone treatment works for some, most continue to
suffer without being entirely clean. Methadone clinics are required to randomly drug test their
clients and statistics show that 16%-60% of people fail urine tests (p. 180). Despite the large
difference between the two numbers, the statistics report that the treatment is not working.
Because methadone blocks the effects of heroin, this drug is not producing the dirty urine
samples. It is known that crack cocaine stimulates the effects of methadone. This explains the
large amounts of failed drug tests. Bourgois exposes the faulty clinic treatments and goes out on
the limb and accuses methadone clinics to be "legalized dope dealers," (p. 178). As he explains,
methadone clinics are for-profit treatment centers that cost $12 a day (p.176). At times, the
dosages patients receive are not strong enough to block the high heroin gives. Patients then
request for a higher amount of methadone, but their request isn't satisfied because of a failed
drug test. Patients are actually given much less than before, which does not suit them at all.
Bourgois stresses the fact that the clinics seem to be in charge of the patient's life instead of the
other way around. Instead of realistically attempting to aid a drug addict in need, methadone
clinics follow their own rules for the most part and make giants profits. While Bourgois does his
fair share of critiquing of the system of heroin treatment, he does so by adding an alternative.

Heroin or Methadone, Which Harms More? 3
Bourgois adds information regarding the legalization of medically prescribed heroin in
Switzerland. Instead of tackling one drug (heroin) by enforcing another (methadone),
Switzerland prescribes doses of heroin (p. 187). Depending on the status of the patient, an
amount of heroin is distributed. The set amount is slowly reduced until the patient is no longer
being given heroin. In the United States, one is required to quit the hard drug all at once. Studies
in Switzerland show their method not only aids more drug addicts, but reduces the number of
individuals with HIV, hepatitis, and tuberculosis. Aside from the reduction of diseases,...

Find Another Essay On DISCIPLINING ADDICTIONS: THE BIO-POLITICS OF METHADONE AND HEROIN IN THE UNITED STATES Journal Review

Howard Zinn's A Review of A People’s History of The United States

1201 words - 5 pages A Review of A People’s History of The United States      A People’s History of the United States concentrates on the personal experiences and struggles of people who lived in the United States from 1492-present. It is a view of history from the common man’s perspective, rather than the view of the leaders and upper class of this country.      The book revolves around the views of history from the oppressed point of view

Review of Norman E. Saul Distant Friends: the United States & Russia, 1763-1867

742 words - 3 pages In Distant Friends: The United States & Russia, 1763-1867 Norman Saul analyzes the relationship between the United States and Russia, beginning in the colonial period, in 1763, and continuing after the Civil War to 1867. The author focuses on the nature and chronology of this relationship by examining the political, economic, diplomatic, and cultural ties between the nations. One point emphasized repeatedly is how very different America was to

Viewing Politics and Government As a United States Citizen

1656 words - 7 pages Born and raised in support of our national government, my recent interest in the way our great nation is governed began in the classroom. I found my American Government class to be quite interesting and the Bush and Clinton scandals only increased my interest in American politics. Ever since, I have a strong belief in our government and will support it throughout my life. I always keep up with the events in Washington and follow today's issues

United States Immigration Policy Review

1426 words - 6 pages passed in 1996 that had a devastating impact on immigrants in general. Among them were The Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Acts that established new grounds for inadmissibility to, and deportation from, the United States by broadening the definition of what constitutes an aggravated felony. This new definition would be applied retroactively and require the mandatory detention of all undocumented immigrants who were now

International Relations Theory Book Review on The Bottom Billion by Paul Collier And The United States Of Europe by T.R. Reid

1292 words - 5 pages interventions, international standard-setting, and trade policy--that to date have been used for other purposes. The agencies that control these instruments have neither knowledge of nor interest in the problems of the bottom billion. “The United States Of Europe By T.R. ReidIt is simple to scoff at the accessories of the European Union. Its flag of 12 gold stars on blue is insipid. Its nationwide festival Europe Day, honor the Schuman assertion

The Constitution and Freedom of Religion in the United States

1165 words - 5 pages stemmed from the establishment of the Constitution of the United States that guaranteed religious freedom. This reasoning is best illustrated by the trials by two religious groups, who lived at different times, in what is now the Northeastern United States. Religious instability plagued Europe during the 16th and 17th centuries, as monarchs were excommunicated and countries faced both internal and external conflicts. In 1570, Catholic

The Perception of Age and Aging in the United States

2310 words - 9 pages According to the Merriam-Webster online dictionary, the word elderly means “rather old; being past middle age; characteristics of later life.” When an individual is categorized as being old, they feel insulted and may immediately become defensive, this is due to the fact that society has played a major role in the way we interpret the word “elderly”. Some individuals use the known phrase “You are as old as you feel”, as they are quite

Hardships of Filipinos and Filipino-Americans in the United States

1532 words - 6 pages Many people of different races and ethnicities have migrated and are still migrating to the United States of America with hopes of finding better opportunities and achieving their American Dream for their families. Majority of them are Asians from developing countries such as Korea, China, Thailand, Vietnam, Philippines, and more. Unfortunately, they all had their own share of struggles especially in attaining acceptance from the American

Disciplining the Disciplinarian

3271 words - 13 pages DISCIPLINING THE DISCIPLINARIAN 1Disciplining the Disciplinarian:A Parenting Class on Child Discipline and Stress ManagementMasele IveyWRI 1200 Research, Argument, and WritingSeptember 9, 2012Professor WilsonAbstractChild abuse is a very serious and real problem in the United States with nearly 3.3 million reports of abuse submitted to Child Protective Services in 2010. Statistics show that an estimated 81% of the perpetrators were parents

Federalism and Poverty in the United States

2011 words - 8 pages Federalism and Poverty in the United States Many Americans believe that the federal government is too big, both in the number of agencies it directs and in the scope of its powers. Some people also think that the daily business of Capitol Hill has no effect on their lives, in part because they believe that politicians do not understand their problems. This dissatisfaction with Washington, D.C., in recent years has renewed debate over the

Immigration and Nativism in the United States

2141 words - 9 pages Immigration and Nativism in the United States In the United States, the cliché of a nation of immigrants is often invoked. Indeed, very few Americans can trace their ancestry to what is now the United States, and the origins of its immigrants have changed many times in American history. Despite the identity of an immigrant nation, changes in the origins of immigrants have often been met with resistance. What began with white

Similar Essays

Politics In The United States Of America

1295 words - 5 pages Politics in the United States of America Introduction This paper seeks to research on Americans interest in Crimea with regard to the sanctions that have been attached to Russia recently by President Barrack Obama of the United States. Several banks have been blacklisted by the US government following the Russian infiltrations in Ukraine (Fisher 13). Majority of Russian businessmen in the United States who have close links with Vladimir Putin

Politics In The United States Of America

1383 words - 6 pages opinions. Opinion based on humanitarian grounds that urge the president to intervene using military action, is one of them. The proponents argue from the point of view that suffering demands action (Moyn 3). This group believes that the United States is in the best position than any other country to stop the suffering of the Syrian people and the bloodshed going on, and therefore no action from the US means more innocent lives will continue to be

Mexican Americans In United States And Politics

2157 words - 9 pages Mexican-Americans in United States and Politics "We need a Mexican but it’s more important that he be American" This quote, taken from the play Los Vendidos by Luis Valdez, well illustrates the ambivalence and hypocrisy Anglos have projected towards Mexicans for the last two centuries. Specifically, this quote refers to the United States government needing a "brown face" in the crowd at one of their meetings to showcase their supposed

A Review Of The Development Of Internet And Cyberlaw In United States

1322 words - 5 pages A Review of the development of Internet and Cyberlaw in United States The history of Internet can be traced back to the Arpanet 1968, a military research network sponsored by the Advanced Research Projects Agency (ARPA). The ultimate purpose for the invention of the internet was to ensure the military communication during wartime. It was later developed to the private sectors and university researches in the 20th Century. This was the period