Disclosure Of Executive Health Information: Balancing Investor Rights And Executive Privacy

1713 words - 7 pages

Though the Securities and Exchange Commission rules governing selective disclosure and insider trading contain no provisions relating specifically to the health of executives, publicly traded companies must nonetheless manage the potential implications of their key executives’ health on perceptions of the company’s future success as well as their propriety in disclosing information material to investors. This can be a difficult task, as an employer disclosing particulars about an employee’s health seems to run contrary to the special privacy protections given health information in the U.S., yet such information can undeniably affect investors’ decisions. Recently, the Securities and Exchange Commission launched a probe to evaluate statements made by Apple, Inc. regarding the health of CEO Steve Jobs. While not yet a formal investigation, this unprecedented evaluation of health-related disclosures raises significant issues about how such information should be treated and how the rights of investors are to be weighed against the rights of executives. Additionally, if this practice becomes regular, it could lead to unfair and burdensome erosions of executives’ rights to privacy and medical autonomy.

Background

In 2003, Jobs was diagnosed with a rare form of pancreatic cancer that, unlike most forms of the disease, could be treated reliably and successfully with a surgical procedure. Against the recommendations of his doctors, Jobs initially tried to address his illness by adopting a special diet regimen. However, nine months after his diagnosis, he was forced to accept the prescribed treatment when a scan revealed that the tumor in his pancreas had grown. Apple broke the news about Jobs’ illness and surgery on the heels of the 2004 procedure, stating that he was “cured” and would resume his duties as CEO in a matter of months. The company’s stock value subsequently dropped 2.4%. In 2008, speculation about Jobs’ health again gathered momentum due to his increasingly thin appearance. Investor unease came to a head in October, when an erroneous item stating that Jobs had suffered a heart attack was posted on CNN.com’s iReport website. By the time Apple was able to rebut the report publicly its stock value had dropped 10%, demonstrating how closely investors associate Jobs’ leadership with Apple’s success. A December announcement that Jobs would not deliver his customary keynote presentation the following January at the annual Macworld Expo only served to exacerbate investor concerns.

On January 5th of 2009, coincidental with the start of the popular Macworld Expo event, Apple released a communication from Jobs stating that tests had confirmed what was causing his weight loss and that the remedy was “relatively simple and straightforward.” Nine days later, on January 14th, the company released another statement from Jobs, which explained that the CEO had decided to take a five month medical leave because he had recently learned that his...

Find Another Essay On Disclosure of Executive Health Information: Balancing Investor Rights and Executive Privacy

Internet - Disclosure of Personal Information On-line and Identity Theft

1870 words - 7 pages Disclosure of Personal Information On-line and the Occurrence of Identity Theft Introduction Identification is a critical and common process which we encounter on a regular basis as we carry out our daily activities. Companies, government agencies and institutions routinely ask individuals for personal information in order to help identify a specific individual from another. In the past, people have relied upon face-to-face

Effectiveness of Non-Executive Directors Essay

1019 words - 4 pages The effectiveness of non-executive directors is becoming to be seen as critical for the contribution to the effectiveness of corporate governance in providing investor protection. Relevant situational and sectoral experience enhances the effectiveness of non-executive directors. Jebb (1998) cited in Ahwireng-Obeng, Mariano and Viedge (2005) suggests that it is a better strategy to hire non-executive directors who have experience in similar as

Executive Summary of Calyx $ Corolla

1740 words - 7 pages Executive Summary Calyx & Corolla is a young company that offers a very unique choice for customers who are interested in buying fresh flowers. Fresh flowers industry valued approximately $9 Billion in the United States in 1990 with steady market growth rate of 7.7% since 1985. However, the market potential did not reach the top yet. US fresh flowers market still has more room to grow. Per capita consumption of flowers and plants in the US

The Glass Ceiling and the Lack of Female Executive Leadership

2355 words - 9 pages number of facts that verify that female professionals deserve equal rights and working conditions. The glass ceiling is a phenomenon which originated within the past few decades and may be defined as lack of promotion opportunities for female professionals at an executive level. It is true that excessive discrimination by gender is punishable by law in vast majority of developed democratic nations, however many companies find loopholes of

Executive Summary for Landry's and Southwest Airlines

1323 words - 5 pages 23,000 people. The company was featured as one of the leading restaurant companies of the 2000's by Restaurants and Institutions, Seafood Leader and Restaurant Hospitality (www.landrysrestaruants.com, 2010). Tilman J. Fertitta, Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of Landry's continue to promote dedication to high quality and customer services. This is what helps launch Landry's Restaurants, Inc. as one of America's largest

The Powers of the Executive Branch

896 words - 4 pages Federal government has remained a central figure in the American democracy due to its force in encouraging innovation, diversity in group policies, protecting the rights of the minority, redistribution of resources and empowering those who needed intervention among other functions. However, after the 9/11 attacks, there was need to reconsider the expansion of the federal government and particularly the Executive Branch. This is because the

Compensation and Benefits Plan Executive Summary

881 words - 4 pages Executive SummarySMC Company, in an effort to be competitive in the local labor market, needs to establish and bring to the forefront an aggressive compensation and benefits package for its current and future employees. It is imperative that SMC be able to provide a wide variety of compensation and benefits to stabilize its work force and provide for long term relationships between employer and employee. The benefit of having a comprehensive

Machiavelli’s The Prince and the Modern Executive

1990 words - 8 pages The Prince and the Modern Executive     Few question The Prince’s place in the canon of western literature. That it marks a turning point in our collective history, the origin of the study of politics as a science (Pollock 43), is alone enough to warrant its classification as a "Great Book. Its author, Niccolo Machiavelli, a contemporary of Copernicus, is generally accepted as an early contributor to the scientific revolution, because he

The Role of the Executive Branch

1189 words - 5 pages The Role of the Executive Branch The Constitution declares that the executive power shall reside in the president and mentions “executive departments,” but it does not go into detail about the structure or organization of the president’s branch of government (Pfiffner, James 118). The Constitution grants the president limited powers, which is a good thing because we’re not looking for an authoritarian leader to run our

Disclosure of Genetic Tests for Health Insurance

2006 words - 9 pages tests should not be disclosed to insurance companies because of the potential for discrimination in health insurance coverage and the workplace and because of insufficient anti- discrimination legislation. Insurance companies are concerned that the principles their business rests upon will deteriorate if they are denied access to genetic test information (Morris, 2010). Life insurance is based upon the concept that premium paid by an individual

Balancing Public Health and Personal Liberty

1736 words - 7 pages pleasurable and exciting experience of driving. However, this law could be defended by stating that motorbike accidents pose an economic burden on the society as well as an economic and financial burden on the families of the injured. However, opposition to this law has left this law acceptable only in half the states. (Bayer, R., 2007) Thus, taking all the above questions into consideration, choosing individual rights over health of the community

Similar Essays

Case Analysis Public Health Vs. Privacy Rights, In Neonatal Hiv Testing

1907 words - 8 pages the importance of named testing to save lives and prevent the disease. This is not a an effective action because he is merely breaking the law.The effect on individual liberty is apparent. Dr. Tremblay is violating the civil rights of the mothers, including: their right to privacy, their autonomy, their anonymity, and he is discriminating (by profiling). He is removing their ability to not know, rewriting their consent and agreement to take the

Executive Powers And Executive Challenges Don't Coincide

1461 words - 6 pages country on his own. Because of this, we have a two house Congress. If the President comes up with an idea, he has to make sure Congress approves and vice versa- the bills passed by Congress have to be passed by the President. The national debt is probably the biggest issue in the country right now, so it is time to fix it. However, that might be easier said than done. There are many different views throughout the country, and Obama has to deal with

Executive Roles And Responsibilities Essay

2455 words - 10 pages confidence. Save yourself the heartache, backup your data, and minimize loss. This would be a great time to segway to defining disaster recovery at this juncture of executive responsibilities. Disaster Recovery Plan (DRP) identifies the plans for reconstructing an organization's computer facilities and/or other information resources in the event of a natural or man-made disaster or series

Role Of Executive Branch Essay

1020 words - 5 pages Powers set forth by the Executive Branch still and always have remained under the direction of the President of the United States. The President is responsible for implementation, and enforcing of laws. Also part of the executive branch is the Vice Presidents who assumes the presidential duties should the need arise. The executive branch has not always played the same role as it does today in health policies. This essay reviews the duties of