Disclosure Of Genetic Tests For Health Insurance

2006 words - 9 pages

Genetic testing in relation to insurance has been an issue since the start of the Human Genome Project. Advances in technology have significantly increased the precision and availability of genetic testing. These tests can predict the possibility of future illnesses in individuals or can rule out alleged genetic conditions. As genetic testing became more prominent, interest in the use of genetic information increased. Concerns about to whom the information is disclosed and how the information is being used have arisen. Morris admits that in a case study that was conducted in Ireland, 20.6% of the participating respondents voiced their belief that there may be benefits from disclosing genetic tests results to insurers and the other 73.4% of the respondents stated that insurance should not use genetic tests as a basis for deciding on whether or not to insure an applicant (2010). Genetic tests should not be disclosed to insurance companies because of the potential for discrimination in health insurance coverage and the workplace and because of insufficient anti- discrimination legislation.
Insurance companies are concerned that the principles their business rests upon will deteriorate if they are denied access to genetic test information (Morris, 2010). Life insurance is based upon the concept that premium paid by an individual is adequate in covering the risk that individual brings into the insurance fund. Morris pointed out that currently, life insurance companies already have the right to differentiate premiums based on the risk that each applicant has (2010). In order to classify applicants by risk insurers uses a process called medical underwriting. Medical underwriting is a health insurance term referring to the use of medical information in the evaluation of an applicant for life or health insurance. As part of the underwriting process, two decisions are made. The first is whether to offer or deny coverage and the second is what premium rate to set for the policy. According to Wolf and Kahn, once the process of underwriting is completed, the insurer then looks over the information and writes various exclusions into the policy, depending on the risks discovered (2007).
Traditionally, life insurance companies used family history in order to seek out hereditary data. Now, the availability of precise genetic tests, presents an opportunity for accurate classification of applicants for insurance. Raithatha and Smith argue the point that genetic tests are not all that much different than family history and other medical tests (2004). Therefore, insurers argue that genetic tests should not raise new ethical and legal questions (Morris, 2010). In fact, Raithatha and Smith state that currently insurance companies are required to treat genetic tests in a different manner compared to other tests, which in itself, generates discrimination (2004).
If genetic predispositions are not disclosed to insurance companies, then negative consequences for the...

Find Another Essay On Disclosure of Genetic Tests for Health Insurance

Buying the Correct Health Insurance for You

1057 words - 5 pages Market place insurance plans seem to be a good idea for insurance shoppers to find the best plan at a competitive price, but in reality it may create a lot of confusion and uncertainty of what services will actualy be provided by these different plans. In this paper I will provide some suggestions for individuals, small businesses and large businesses that may help making a decision when it come to choosing an insurance policy. Individuals

Health Insurance Portability Act of 1996 (Hippa): Is It Best for Us of Not?

1224 words - 5 pages Avneet Khabra Health Careers Ms. Behler December 18, 2013 Hippa? Is it best for us, or not? Hippa is the acronym for the Health Insurance Portability Act of 1996. Confidentiality is a huge issue to the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (Hippa) mainly due to protection of the clients. The act sets standards for the storage and privacy of personal medical data. The rule was enacted on August 21, 1996 by the 104th United States

Health Insurance: For Our Nation...For Us All?

693 words - 3 pages health insurance for all American citizens, requires the creation of new hospitals, and satellite facilities; including, but not limited to, MRI, CAT and CT Scanners, Pharmacies, Birthing Centers with Level III Neonatal Intensive Care Units, Out-patient Surgery Centers, Ambulatory Care Units, Burn Centers, Holistic & Alternative medical treatment centers, with corresponding professional staff. Counterpoint On the other hand, many people

Disclosure of Executive Health Information: Balancing Investor Rights and Executive Privacy

1713 words - 7 pages the aforementioned pressures, executives’ rights to keep their individual health information private must be carefully protected for two key reasons. First, some serious illnesses carry negative stigma, which can affect a sufferer’s future opportunities if their condition was made public. Second, the push for disclosure of health information and the formal expansion of materiality to health topics may ultimately affect executives’ rights to

Weighing the Risks of Going without Health Insurance

734 words - 3 pages , while the probability of bad things not happening to you is great. You spend a small amount of money to buy insurance, once the unfortunate thing, insurance will be able to reduce the loss caused by the distress. In other words, you pay the insurance fee, once something happens, the insurer will pay you a certain amount of reparations to compensate you for the loss. For health insurance, people pay insurance premium is for when I was sick, the

Considerations for the Genetic Modificaiton of Wheat

2233 words - 9 pages . These are just some of the things that effect wheat. The Growing of wheat also has a large impact on the environment and the cycles of matter because of the large usage of fertilizers and pesticides. Faster growth, more nutritious wheat, and better tasting food are just some of the characteristic that can be improved in genetically modified food. Genetic engineering opens the door to new methods for managing Fusarium and other fungal diseases

This paper is about different kinds of employee benefits. From health insurance to dental insurance and savings plans

1078 words - 4 pages The pathologists here at the Jeffersonian institute work very hard and are a necessity that this institute cannot exist without them. Pathologist need employee benefits such as health insurance, time off, retirement and savings plan. They also need a dental plan and long term disability insurance. If the pathologists that are employed here get those items the chance of them staying here for a long time is guaranteed. So this is my

Discussion of the Feasibility of a Centralized “National Health Insurance Fund

1130 words - 5 pages National Insurance Fund which aims to counter the effects of the present inefficient health system. The Health Insurance fund will progress over a 14 year period, with primitive campaigns and projects initiating in 2012 among 10 districts which are still yet to be identified. Dr.Aaron Motswaledi himself acknowledged the fact that “The first five years of implementation will be the toughest.” The fund will be compulsory for everyone and is accessible to

Standardized Tests: Do They Really Work for Raising the Rank of the US in World Education?

2398 words - 10 pages for the students. Not only do schools suffer but students also suffer from the consequences of the emphasis put on standardized tests. Upon teachers being let go a larger classroom is formed. Within classrooms of large sizes teachers can’t assist and aid all of the children. Some children will be over-looked and receive little or no help. This makes it difficult for children to pay attention so they can learn and it can cause them to lose

Economic Implications of National and Private Health Insurance in the United States

3007 words - 12 pages associated with poor insurance plans that require individuals to pay high premiums and deductibles, which may or may not contain good benefits such as free preventative care. In addition, due to the past economic recession in 2008, many employers could not afford to pay for health benefits and canceled numerous plans for many employees. This effectively increased the rate of uninsured Americans as well as the increasing health care costs. One

Commitment To Privacy: The Dual Goals of The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPPA

1560 words - 6 pages In 1996 the federal government passed a law called The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPPA) with “dual goals of making health care delivery more efficient and increasing the number of Americans with health insurance coverage” (Nass & Levit). The 1990’s brought about the realization that the medical industry would be run more efficiently by computerizing medical records. Title II of HIPPA, titled Administration

Similar Essays

Preventing Genetic Discrimination Health Insurance Companies

2232 words - 9 pages police and security force. Logically, how do we then expect the sick to pay more in premiums then those individuals that are healthy? (Kass, 1992). The most predominant argument against the disclosure of genetic test results to insurance companies concentrates on the issue of genetic discrimination. As stated before, genetic tests should not be disclosed to insurance companies because of the potential for discrimination in health insurance

Prenatal Genetic Tests: The Future Of Procreation

2392 words - 10 pages tested for certain genetic changes. Only embryos without these changes are implanted in the uterus to initiate a pregnancy ("What are the types of genetic tests?”). The technology to perform preimplantation genetic diagnosis has been worked on for years, but is finally becoming a reality. Many people think that this technique is unethical because you are playing the hand of God, and killing humans. Preimplantation genetic diagnosis and prenatal

History Of Health Insurance Essay

2211 words - 9 pages and other approaches to treatment. Health insurance has increased and been an important issue for all employers, the government and employees ever since. Importance of Health Insurance Having health insurance is valuable for a number of reasons. Having health insurance is important for multiple reasons. One reason is that people without insurance are given less medical care and less timely care. People without health insurance are also less

Is Health Insurance For Everyone Essay

869 words - 4 pages insurance, the government has now enacted applying a penalty fee for not having insurance. I have talked to many people in my community who would rather pay a penalty than have to pay insurance premiums or copays they cannot afford. Some would rather pay then be forced into a decision based on the principle of freedom. U.S. News reports that nearly four million people refused or failed to sign up for health insurance, and will pay the penalty in 2015