Discontinuity In Self Reliance And When I Consider How My Light Is Spent

1862 words - 7 pages

Discontinuity in Self-Reliance and When I Consider How My Light Is Spent  

 
   Ralph Waldo Emerson emphatically proclaims in "Self-Reliance" that "the highest merit we ascribe to Moses, Plato, and Milton is that they set naught at traditions but spoke…what they thought" (515). Emerson declares that Milton’s greatness is attributed not to conformity but rather to originality. Milton’s break with consistent expectations is epitomized in his use of a Petrarchan sonnet in the poem "When I Consider How My Light Is Spent." Nonconformity and discontinuity in a man’s approach to life are the doctrines espoused by Emerson in his work "Self-Reliance," and Milton embodies an Emersonian outlook while inwardly searching for personal truth in his sonnet. The lack of formal structure in the works of the two authors enhances rather than inhibits the reader’s grasp of the literature. Although both Emerson and Milton employ a discontinuous literary style in their respective works, Emerson revels in his lack of continuity to further promulgate his ideology of nonconformity and inconsistency while Milton’s use of discontinuity is procured in an attempt to understand his place before God. The foundation for comparing the two works will be based on the following definition of discontinuity: any literary approach that deviates from standard structural form.

The absence of formal structure in Emerson’s "Self-Reliance" has been derided by some critics as an "insuperable handicap" to an appropriate understanding of the work (Warren 200). A thorough examination of the work, however, evokes two fundamental claims: Emerson provides a basis for some semblance of structure, and complete continuity is antithetical to the fundamentals of Emerson’s "Self-Reliance." Emerson’s original style is seen as a "strategy" to highlight his philosophical tenets rather than a haphazard infirmity to the reader’s understanding of the work (Buell 173).

As for the organization of "Self-Reliance," it is fair to say that there is more order than the reader first notices and that "Emerson provides enough clues to ensure continuity, though in a studiously offhand…manner"(174). Jonathan Bishop, in his Emerson on the Soul, states that Emerson is a "worker in sentences and single verses"; however, Emerson ties these verses together with structurally sound conclusions and catalogued guides (57). Evidence of discontinuity can be seen when the reader comes upon the sentence, "the other terror that scares us from self-trust is our consistency." Immediately, the reader wonders what the other terror is that Emerson has omitted. It is not till the conclusion of Emerson’s work "I hope in these days we have heard the last of conformity and consistency" that the reader realizes that conformity is the missing terror (520). The Emersonian tactic of delaying an answer till the conclusion is an original stylistic application of discontinuity and this approach simultaneously "reassures us that...

Find Another Essay On Discontinuity in Self-Reliance and When I Consider How My Light Is Spent

Individualism and how it is evident in Ralph Waldo Emerson's story "Self Reliance".

674 words - 3 pages In society today it is very hard to be your own individual self. We see people as either individualists or conformists. If you're not with the "in" crowd then you are considered to be "weird" or "un-cool". Ralph Waldo Emerson's essay "Self-Reliance" had several themes that focused on the topic of individualism. Emerson said that "imitation is suicide," (Emerson p.867) He explains that if you are not true in the sense of individualism, then you

How I Spent My Summer Vacation

702 words - 3 pages full of festivities we decided to venture out to the City of Chihuahua to site see. I must say it is a beautiful city. Most of the roads are lined with little shops full of handmade merchandise, lots and lots of ice cream shops and fruit stands. My children were amazed by all the ice cream. Many large historical buildings and statues to tour if you are into getting to know the culture more in depth. However, after several hours of walking in the

How I Wish I Spent My Summer Vacation

1465 words - 6 pages someone entered! I would be lost in the dang thing, but I would still have a great time! Well, I guess I should give you some information on just what is so important about this Brobdingnagian place.The most exciting room is my bedroom. It isn't like a regular room with all my stuff in it. Its just the place that contains my bed. So why is it so special? Well, my bed is a racecar bed, and it lays on a racing track. When it is time for me to get up in

Self-Reliance and transcendentalism and how they relate to modern day life

832 words - 3 pages believe in yourself, but you can't survive by yourself. I think to become self-reliant you must get help from others first and learn and be taught how to create something new, but not what.There are many examples of transcendentalism and Emerson's Self Reliance in today's modern day society. There are examples everywhere you look; in the media, songs, T.V. shows, and many other places. One strong example of transcendental thought is in the song

Welfare Reform: Promoting Independence and Self-Reliance

1985 words - 8 pages Welfare Reform: Promoting Independence and Self-Reliance Mary Smith gets up every day at 6 am and begins to hustle around the house. She rouses her three children from their slumber and forces them to get ready for school. Once the kids are on the bus, she hops in her car and heads off to her job at the local fast food restaurant. After working her seven hours at the restaurant, she goes to her night course at the college in town. The

Comparing Ideology in Emerson's Self Reliance and Catcher in the Rye

898 words - 4 pages Non-conformist Ideology in Emerson's Self Reliance and Catcher in the Rye      Human beings all around the world are different in many ways. They all have their unique and physical characteristics, as well as different personalities. They each also have different ideas and thoughts on different topics. America is made up of a great amount of diverse people with diverse, even conflicting opinions and ideas. Diversity is a major

Self-Reliance by Ralph Waldo Emerson: Non Conformity in Thought and Action

1804 words - 7 pages and integrity by giving significant examples from the history. Moreover, his ideals which he represented in Self-Reliance became the inspiration for many important people in American history. Firstly, Self-Reliance was one of the vital keys of writings that represented the ethic of American individualism. In Self Reliance, Emerson urged his readers to stand out when it comes to their individual thoughts without any fear of being misunderstood. For

Death in Emily Dickinson's Because I Could Not Stop for Death, I Heard A Fly Buzz-When I Died, and I Felt A Funeral In My Brain

1330 words - 5 pages Death in Emily Dickinson's "Because I Could Not Stop for Death," "I Heard A Fly Buzz-When I Died," and "I Felt A Funeral In My Brain" Emily Dickinson's poems "Because I Could Not Stop for Death", "I Heard A Fly Buzz-When I Died", and "I Felt A Funeral In My Brain" all deal with one of life's few certainties, death. Dickinson's intense curiosity towards mortality was present in much of her work, and is her legacy as a poet. "Because I

Themes of individualism in Ralph Waldo Emerson's, "Self-Reliance"

1008 words - 4 pages everyone else. This, now that I look back on it and because of what Emerson says in "Self-Reliance," was a big mistake that I made in my life. But I look towards the future now and try not to get stuck in the past like Emerson suggests, so I think I'm my own person now and can still shape my destiny.In conclusion, Emerson was a non-conformist who wrote about what he believed and he didn't care what anyone else thought about it. I also know exactly

The Yellow Wallpaper in the Context of Emerson’s Self-Reliance

1288 words - 5 pages of her family’s restraints. It was here she studied patterns of detestable yellow wallpaper in a prison-like room where she was sequestered. “I never say a worse paper in my life-committing every artistic sin.” (Gilman, 1772)    This pattern in the paper turned out to be the very tool of analyzing her own sickness. Her mind was not sound when the story began. It is mentioned that she has a baby, and that another woman is caring

"Nature and Self-Reliance" by Ralph Waldo Emerson

567 words - 2 pages questions, and even answers for the question we have not even shape which will help us to keep the integrity of one's internal evolution. Emerson believed that when people begin to realize that autonomy and the expression of your thoughts is right for them, then many good changes will happen in society. Emerson's was one of the leaders in the extended view of progressive learning, but also offers insights into age-old or "natural method" as better than new technology based on experimentation. In many of his writings he compares the beauty of the nature, and expresses, in the writings of Nature and Self-Reliance that we can find the answers to all challenges.

Similar Essays

Legacies In Ozymandias And When I Consider How My Light Is Spent

1687 words - 7 pages The Petrarchan sonnets “Ozymandias” by Percy Bysshe Shelley and “When I Consider How My Light Is Spent” by John Milton both consider a man’s legacy after death. However, both poems talk about a man’s legacy from very different perspective and come to their own conclusions. In “Ozymandias”, a traveler describes a broken statue of King Ozymandias (the Greek name for the Egyptian Pharaoh Ramses II) and the barren ruins surrounding the statue

When I Consider How My Light Is Spent

2356 words - 9 pages John Milton’s Sonnet XIX, known as “When I Consider How My Light Is Spent” is a poem considering one’s disabling affliction in light of a time-less truth that the Apostle Paul wrote of: all things work to the good who love God and one thereby learns to be content in all things. Milton’s disabling affliction was blindness and by most interpretative accounts he was blind when he wrote Sonnet XIX. Under God’s providence Milton “considers” his dark

Philosophy Of Milton In When I Consider How My Light Is Spent And Borges In Poema De Los Dones

3178 words - 13 pages The Philosophy of Milton in When I Consider how my Light is Spent and Borges in Poema de los dones          Jorge Luis Borges espoused a philosophy that "all men are each other" (Stabb 52). His literature frequents the theme by finding the repetition of events that transpire regardless of the person involved. His becoming blind coincided with his appointment as Director of the National Library of Argentina, and he understood this

Comparing Do Not Go Gentle Into That Good Night And When I Consider How My Light Is Spent

1188 words - 5 pages Comparing Dylan Thomas's poem Do Not Go Gentle Into That Good Night and John Milton's poem When I consider How My Light Is Spent Dylan Thomas's poem "Do not go gentle into that good night" and John Milton's poem "When I consider how my light is spent" were written during times of trouble in their respective poet's life. Thomas was faced with losing his father to death; Milton was dealing with becoming completely blind at the age of forty