This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Discretion In Legal Decision Making Essay

2468 words - 10 pages

Discretion In Legal Decision MakingBeleid is a Dutch concept, difficult to translate, that is an integral part of Dutch culture and society. The English equivalent, policy, covers only half of its meaning. The definition of beleid, according to an authoritative dictionary of the Dutch language, refers to a set of contradictory connotations: on one hand, beleid means to manage and administer (besturen) based on principles and policies. This would allude to top-down planning if a second meaning were not implied simultaneously, that is, considerate treatment (bedachtzaamheid), preferably by hearing all those concerned and giving them a say. Strictly speaking, these connotations contain opposites: either one can take decisions against the wishes of at least some of those concerned or one can come to an agreement with mutual consent, which implies a nondecision in the case of a veto or resistance. In theory and practice, beleid is a mixture of both.Beleid is the art of rule making and rule implementation in context. The legalistic model of law is always formulated top-down: law binds public agencies, which should not do anything not within the law. The concept of beleid is the expression of a bottom-up strategy, either by the managers of implementation agencies who formulate guidelines or by street-level officers who have to render rules and guidelines "workable" in their daily practice. As complex organizations, government agencies tend to specify their mission in terms of beleid, sometimes vaguely as declarations of intent, sometimes explicitly as guidelines.Of course, civil servants and the police everywhere resort to such informal strategies. What differentiates the Dutch situation may simply be the publicity and legitimacy with which they do so. Instead of being forced to maintain a façade of strict legalism, lowerlevel agents enjoy discretionary power and formulate their beleid. It may achieve quasi-legal status as a yardstick for the performance of a public agency.Informal Pragmatism and the Sliding ScaleTo better understand beleid, one must assess the internal legal culture in the Netherlands. While external legal culture refers to the legal consciousness of the people at large, internal legal culture refers to the opinions about law among the legal professionals, "the values, ideologies and principles of lawyers, judges and others who work within the magic circle of the legal system" (Friedman 1975: 194). Because of its nonlegalistic leaning, one can characterize Dutch internal legal culture as "informal pragmatism." A basic tenet is that a rule should only be applied if some goal is served by it, thus not for its own sake. Dutch policy makers, civil servants, and legal practitioners are very concerned about the adverse effects of too strict a rule enforcement (for example, leading to black markets and deviant subcultures). Rules cannot control everything, and compliance needs social agreement; these are the dominant feelings....

Find Another Essay On Discretion In Legal Decision Making

Strategies in Decision Making Essay

1372 words - 5 pages A quote by Albert Einstein states, "The significant problems we face cannot be solved at the same level of thinking we were at when we created them." (Khurana, 2006). Success in problem solving and decision-making lies in the ability of an individual to think critically, identify the most significant problem needing a solution, and prevent the problem from reoccurring. Problems can be found in all aspects of an organization and can be in the

Emotions in decision-making Essay

579 words - 2 pages follow in the steps of their leaders.The emotions in decision making that was learned from this movie is that emotions are a very powerful to deal with in situations. Emotions are a mental state that arises spontaneously rather than through conscious effort and is often accompanies by physiological changes. It is also a state of mental agitation or disturbance. It is the part of the conscious that involves feeling.The employees of Enron emotions

Decision Support Systems in Organizational Decision Making

880 words - 4 pages Decision Support Systems in Organizational Decision Making Decision making refers to the process of finding and selecting options according to the priorities and values of the person making the decision. Since there are many choices involved, it is important to identify as many options as possible so as to pick the option that best fits a company’s target, goals, values and vision. Due to the integral role of decision making in company growth

Decision Making in Dow Chemical

772 words - 3 pages In this case report we will analyze the interviewing's article of Richard M Hodgetts to find out the decision making style of Mr. Stavropoulos, a former CEO of Dow Chemical, and discover how he saw the relationship of decision making to corporate structure.Mr. Stavropoulos's Decision Making Style? According to the Decision Making Styles described by the Leadership Management Development Centre there are four basic decision making styles

Ethics in Business Decision Making

993 words - 4 pages The field of ethics (or moral philosophy) involves systematizing, defending, and recommending concepts of right and wrong behavior (Fieser, 2009). Many of the decisions one faces in a typical day could result in a multitude of outcomes. At times it can be hard to determine whether or not the decision you are making is an ethical one. Many philosophies have been devised to illustrate the different ways of evaluating moral decisions. Normative

Bad Decision-Making in Hamlet

789 words - 3 pages murderer of his father. Laertes, the son of the king’s associate, makes a bad decision in the play. When Laertes’ father, Polonius, is killed, Laertes is outraged and seeks vengeance. Laertes made a bad decision in the play, but he could have tried using the decision-making process, weighing possible alternatives, and he could have changed the outcome of the play if he had made careful decisions. Laertes’ main decision in Hamlet was how to seek

Decision Making in Thailand Culture

1333 words - 5 pages Decisions-making are to be made at all levels, either in group of individuals, but perhaps, is the most important of all in managerial activities. It is the common event and most critical role of a senior manager. It tells how a manager deals with information. Basically, decision-making is apprehensive with the handling of creating choices and decisions to be chosen among them. Those decisions can be groups under different categories and each

Conscience In Ethical Decision Making

1435 words - 6 pages Conscience in ethical decision making"Critically assess the nature and role of conscience in ethical decision making. Consider whether conscience alone is a satisfactory moral authority."Jonathon WyvillOver the years, psychologists have marvelled at the mind's ability to process external action, discriminate it, identify it, and to make moral, conscious decisions. The development of psychology and the understanding of the human mind has been a

Conscience In Ethical Decision Making

1410 words - 6 pages more full acknowledges the individual's active role in moral decision making. It promotes a sense of autonomy and responsibility in decision making, rather than a reaction to external or internal controls (Philosophical Investigations 2009).Whilst environmental factors such as upbringing and childhood experience have an impact upon an individual's perception of what is regarded as right and wrong, in terms of ethical decision-making, Aquinas

Decision Making in Managerial Accounting

2668 words - 11 pages performed and also in making decision that touch on the firm (Maksoud, 2011). Analysis of the Fund Flow The most important of fund flow analysis is to evaluate the firm’s working capital for specific accounting periods. This is achieved through the preparation of fund flow statements that showcase all the inflows and outflows of funds resulting from the various operations of the business. Reichelstein (2000) notes that generation of the working

Decision Making Skills in Business Environment

1578 words - 7 pages Decision making can be defined as a mental process of making choices among possible alternatives to make a practical decision (Reason, 1990; Wang, 2000). From selecting what items to buy in a supermarket to deciding which television channel to watch, we often have to make decisions in different conditions, particularly when we are facing uncertainties and trade-offs. Admittedly, decision-making skills have become increasing important when it

Similar Essays

“According To Legal Positivism There Is No Scope For Interpretation In Judicial Decision Making And The Judge Is Strictly Rule Bound.” Discuss Critic

2692 words - 11 pages the possibility of a legal norm changing. In some cases a judge may have doubts about the norms that s/he wants to use in decision-making. The legal positivist theory reduces a judge’s capabilities and abilities as well as implying that their interpretations may not be sufficient. Yet, arguably, the legal system should trust its legal practitioners in interpreting certain legal norms in distinctive ways and/or make changes that seem necessary. For

Law And Morality. Speaks Of The Dilemma Of Making A Decision That Someone Must Die In Order For The Others To Survive. Explains And Justifies The Decision By Using Legal Tools Such As Law And Moralit

2117 words - 8 pages It is not an everyday occurrence that someone must decide the fate of another's life. The dilemma of making a decision that someone must die in order for the others to survive, can obviously be troubling. The process in which the termination of one's life may be easy to make, but to justify that decision is the most difficult one. This paper is given a situation in which a decision of taking one's life is essential. The situation is that a

Decision Making In Nursing Essay

945 words - 4 pages the steps involved in it “in order to develop our own decision making style” and be successful as nurses in the future (B. Kunkel, 2014). The New Jersey Board of Nursing provides a Seven Step Decision Making Model that “has been designed to assist nurses in using the information available to them for resolving scope of practice issues.” Any nurse that has a question about nursing practice “can refer to this model and follow each step to make her

Decision Making In Action Essay

900 words - 4 pages Decision Making Process in ActionAccording to Webster's Dictionary the definition of "decision" is the "1. a: act or process of deciding b: a determination arrived at after consideration: CONCLUSION." (http://www.m-w.com/). Organizations and individuals make decisions every day. Decisions are made by flipping a coin, taking a guess, thinking about the thoughts and feelings of others, considering values and beliefs, complying with a mission