Discrimination Within The Death Penalty Essay

2185 words - 9 pages

Discrimination Within the Death Penalty

“They [prisoners sentenced to death] are almost all poor, usually white, often high school dropouts. Most have never killed before. Most are from the South” (Benac).

Opponents of the death penalty have said that capital punishment does nothing to deter crime. There is some critical information that is important to know before going more in depth on this discussion. The purpose of this paper is not to discuss whether capital punishment is effective in deterring crime nor does it present any ethical arguments regarding it. It is to discuss whether it is used in a universally just and fair manner. Presently, approximately 3, 565 prisoners are living on death row. The costs for death penalty cases are enormous, possibly soaring in to the millions. (National Association…) “Since 1973, over 160 children [defined as anyone under the age of 18] in the U.S. have been sentenced to die” (National Association…). It is possible that ten percent of death row inmates are mentally retarded. “Approximately 90% of those whom prosecutors seek to execute are African-Americans or Latino” (National Association…). Considering all of the above facts, there are obviously some distinct problems with the manner in which the death penalty is imposed. In particular, class differences along with race can drastically affect the manner in which death penalty cases are handled.
Costs:
Lower class people get a worse defense than wealthy people. The costs for a capital defense case can add up quickly: DNA tests, experts, background and psychiatric investigations. Many lower class people have to “depend upon public attorneys who are not really qualified” (ABCNEWS.com…). There is a bill in Congress that would regulate state standards for appointed defense attorneys for capital cases but it is doubtful that this will be a quick solution. There is also a bill in Congress that would guarantee DNA analysis for inmates, both federal and state, after their convictions. (ABCNEWS.com…) The awareness of this problem is even occurring in the Supreme Court.
Problems:
There have been many attempts to fix what is wrong with capital punishment and sentencing. According to Supreme Court Justice Harry Blackman in the Collins versus Collins 1994 decision, “the death penalty remains fraught with arbitrariness, discrimination, caprice, and mistake…” (Culver). It has to be admitted that race plays a part as well as class since normally the two social aspects go hand in hand. Not only race of the defendant but of the victim have to be considered when understanding the idiosyncrasies of sentencing. While race may be focused on more in the media, class or socioeconomic status controls the reins even more. “The vast majority of people executed since 1977, when employed, worked in menial or low-paying jobs at the time they committed their capital crimes” (Culver). Not only is income level influential but educational level is as...

Find Another Essay On Discrimination Within the Death Penalty

Opposing the Death Penalty Essay

1770 words - 8 pages commit murder. Some feel the system is setup to set us up and fail us. According to Mary Meehan from americanmagazine.org: “there is racial and economic discrimination in application of the death penalty.” It is said and believed that there are more African Americans on death row than there are Caucasians. It is sad to say we are still living in a world where racism exist and is still powerful in some sense. Racism is one of the

The Death Penalty Essay

3803 words - 15 pages issue. Murder has no color, class, or IQ A murderer is a murderer. When a loved one is killed, I doubt anyone could take comfort in the fact that the perpetrator had a low IQ, was black instead of white, or poor instead of rich. Ernest van den Haag wrote:"If and when discrimination occurs it should be corrected. Not, however, by letting the guilty blacks escape the death penalty because guilty whites do, but by making sure that the guilty white

The Death Penalty

1236 words - 5 pages , because people can use the law to get rid of the people they don’t like. I realize that there are a lot of fail-safes in place in so that this wont happen but there is still a chance. In Bedau’s argument he states,” The nations death row has always had a disproportionately large population of African- American...”(362). Until there is no chance of discrimination I think there shouldn’t even be a death penalty. Another issue discussed is that there

Against the death penalty

1122 words - 5 pages mentally ill people is unconstitutional (“Facts”) Furthermore, there is much discrimination in the system. Criminals who kill whites are more likely to face the death penalty than those who kills African-Americans (“Facts”). Rich men or women are also less likely to face charges than their poor counterparts (“Facts”). The poor can’t hire a good enough defense to protect themselves. This is why there is many appeals under the name

The Death Penalty

1899 words - 8 pages 1976 that capital punishment was ruled unconstitutional by the Supreme Court. Their reason for this decision was that the death penalty was "cruel and unusual punishment" under the Eighth Amendment." (The Death Penalty). The decision was reversed when new methods of execution were introduced.The discrimination and unfairness of the criminal justice system is growing out of proportion. Innocent people are put to death each year. The elimination of injustice and discrimination must first stop within society.

the death penalty

2058 words - 8 pages for a different deed. It is a point where abolitionists stress the point, that discrimination is present due to the fabrication of evidence and skill of lawyers. Secondly the social and legal grounds on which the states claim that the death penalty is pain free remains debatable. Not only does the author describe the possibility of physical pain correlating directly to the method of execution, he argues that the mental torment an offender faces

Against the Death Penalty

1821 words - 7 pages The Death Penalty Human rights are fundamental rights which every human being is entitled to just because they are human. The death penalty is the ultimate, irreversible denial of human rights. It is the cold blooded killing of a human being in the name of ‘justice’. In 1948, the United Nations adopted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights; in Articles 3 and 5 it states that “no one shall be subjected to cruel

The Death Penalty

628 words - 3 pages The Death PenaltyIs the death penalty just or unjust? It has been argued that capitol punishment is imposed merely to gratify a desire for revenge. Whether or not a punishment is legal depends upon whether or not it serves a valid goal or purpose of a policy. The death penalty is usually defended on two grounds; is useful and that is just . Is capitol punishment moral or immoral? Is the death penalty moral? Capitol punishment is imposed to spare

The Death Penalty - 1799 words

1799 words - 7 pages Almost all nations in the world either have the death sentence or have had it at one time. It was used in most cases to punish those who broke the laws or standards that were expected of them. Since the death penalty wastes tax money, is inhumane, and is largely unnecessary it should be abolished in every state across the United States. The use of the death penalty puts the United States in the same category as countries like Iran and Saudi

The Death Penalty Debate

1768 words - 7 pages "The death penalty issue is obviously a divisive one. But whether one is for or against, you can not deny the basic illogic - if we know the system is flawed, if we know there are innocent people on Death Row, then until the system is reformed, should we not abandon the death penalty to protect those who are innocent?" --Richard LaGravenese In the United States the death penalty is used as a punishment for capital offenses. These

The Death Penalty

920 words - 4 pages The death penalty continues to be an issue of controversy and is an issue that will be debated in the United States for many years to come. According to Hugo A. Bedau, the writer of “The Death Penalty in America”, capital punishment is the lawful infliction of the death penalty. The death penalty has been used since ancient times for a variety of offenses. The Bible says that death should be done to anyone who commits murder, larceny, rapes

Similar Essays

Death Penalty And Discrimination Essay

1644 words - 7 pages The Death Penalty: The Discrimination Within Throughout America's history, the death penalty has been applied disproportionately tot he poor and blacks. The death penalty, legal execution, has existed as long as has human culture. Capital Punishment, the death penalty, is punishment by death. This is the practice of the gas chamber, electrocution, lethal injection, hanging, or firing squad in the United States. In most cultures, this sentence is

Death To The Death Penalty Essay

1371 words - 6 pages sentenced to the death penalty but little did Miriam know he was also sentenced. For some 20 years Michael Ryan's execution was carried out through every appeal on and on. The pain that Kelle’s family inflicted was insufferable. As unfortunate as the occurrence was it is safe to say this continues to be the pain of many murder victims families. The death penalty provides nothing but pain for the victims family, the economy and the society

The Death Penalty Essay 1092 Words

1092 words - 4 pages and emotional costs of the punishment. Within the physical aspects of the death penalty, it costs around 90,000 a year per inmate to stay on death row. The average estimated amount for each inmate, in total, is two million dollars. Death row costs almost four times as much as life imprisonment without parole. Since the death penalty costs such a great amount of money, this leads tax payers to pay thousands of unnecessary money towards the cause. If

Death To The Death Penalty Essay

1236 words - 5 pages Life is the most precious good that a human being possesses. Therefore, it is not a coincidence that one of the first human rights listed in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights is the right to life. The third article states that a person has the right not to be killed by any other human being, and this is where the nations that apply the death penalty are failing (Source 1). The death penalty or capital punishment is a legal process in