Discuss Critically The Validity Of The Contention That The Motivation To Work Well Depends On More Than A High Salary And Good Working Conditions.

1609 words - 6 pages

1) Discuss critically the validity of the contention that the motivation to work well depends on more than a high salary and good working conditions.This essay will define what motivation is, the influence and effect that money and good working conditions have on staff and the other factors and issues that motivate staff to work in the context of the workplace.In order to critically discuss and evaluate what motivates staff in the workplace it is imperitive to firstly define the concept of motivation. Motivation can be defined as the force or process which impels people to behave in the way they do; Newcomb (1950) said that an organism is motivated:' when - and only when - it is characterized both by a state of drive and by a direction of behaviour towards some goal which is selected in preference to all other possible goals. Motive, then is a concept which joins together drive and goal'.This implies that providing the drive for staff to achieve goals that have been set is a vital and important part of the managerial role.Although it is apparent that to become or be motivated does not always rely on drive and goals - it can often arise through voluntary action as well. McDougall (1908) made this extension of the concept of motivation to 'voluntary behaviour' explicit by suggesting that instincts were the 'prime movers' of all human activity. McDougall disagrees with the drive theorists arguing that the instincts of staff in the workplace provide a major source of motivation.Hebb (1949) also disagrees with the assumptions that directed and persistant behaviour is always preceeded by 'extra neural bodily irritants'. Hebb claims that 'The term motivation then refers to: (1) To the existence of an organisational phase sequence, (2) to its direction or content, and (3) to its persistence in a given direction or stability of content. There are obviously many schools of thought and theories on exactly what is motivation and why people are motivated, but it seems that the general concensus opinion lies with Maslow (1970) 'Motivation is the force or combination of forces which lead us to behave as we do'. The actual force or forces that motivate will be now be discussed.Money is an important factor in the motivation of employees, as profit acts as a measure of success of a business, so many people judge their own success or failure and the esteem in which they are held by the employer or the renumeration received for the job done. It must be mentioned that although a high salary is not the only motivator, it can act as an incentive to work more productively;'Pay buys the goods and services that people want to satisfy other needs. The more boring the job, and the less its intrinsic interest the greater the importance of money as a motivator and incentive to effort'. Hammond (1988).An organisation offers both intrinsic and extrinsic rewards to its employees. It must be realised that pay is only an extinsic reward. Employees derive intrinsic rewards from the...

Find Another Essay On Discuss critically the validity of the contention that the motivation to work well depends on more than a high salary and good working conditions.

To what extent can working conditions affect well-being in the workplace?

1643 words - 7 pages their work, colleagues, management, organizational culture, structure and policies. Employees with a high level of well-being are more productive and engaged at work (Cooper and Cartwright, 1994). However, employee well-being is subjective. Different occupations and individuals have different requirements for optimal well-being (Havlovic and Keenan, 1995). Organizational initiatives and working conditions can also impact the well-being of each

'Power is a central feature of all workplace interactions'. With reference to the work of Foucault, critically discuss this view

3342 words - 13 pages workplace interactions. Following on, the essay will discuss the work of Michel Foucault.The 'Orthodox Consensus'.The view that organizations are consensual collectivities (Thompson and Mc Hugh, 1995), which is adopted by the management writers, has lead to an acceptance of 'zero-sum' notions of power, in which incompatible differences of resources and interests are explicitly ruled out.This is not, however the case for all mainstream writing. Some

Discuss the aspects of good and evil in shakespear's work

513 words - 2 pages which provided the substance of Bradley's famous lectures on Shakespeare early in the present century. These four plays account for more than half of the vast body of Shakespearean criticism in existence. The flow of commentary has by no means abated; indeed now more than ever before 'definition' of Shakespearean tragedy is the literary critic's bow of Achilles. Whether great tragedy (or great art in general) is susceptible to definition is a moot

The Work of WWII That Evokes A More Powerful Reaction

1345 words - 5 pages colonies at the time. The excerpt from “Night”, however, was not written from a political leader, therefore had more room for expression and veracity to expose to the world. “ They struck her several times on the head – blows that might have killed her. Her little boy […] did not cry out; her did not say a word. He was not even weeping now.”(Littell, 1138)[1]. This quote depicts the desperate and frightening conditions Jews of all ages had to

As I know more about Japan, I realize that education is important for people to get well-paid jobs in the high-ranked companies. There is a compet

664 words - 3 pages As I know more about Japan, I realize that education is important for people to get well-paid jobs in the high-ranked companies. There is a competition among those who apply for jobs, and companies tend to use candidates’ educational background to decide who should be employed. The similar situation occurs in Thailand. I am going to talk about the how Thai people think about education, using the concept of stereotype and the ideology of

Critically Discuss Hakim's Argument That Women's Heterogeneous Preferences Regarding Work And Family Are The Main Determinants Of Female Employment Patterns (Full Time And Part Time) In The UK

4570 words - 19 pages Hakim’s ‘adaptive’ women. A further example of a structural constraint is the introduction of the European Working Time Directive (EWTD), a limit on the number of hours employees are permitted to work. The EWTD will greatly affect ‘work-centred’ women by limiting the time they can dedicate to work. Arguments illustrating that the EWTD legislation benefits employers more than employees, due to its restrictive applicability

Outline the different types of aid. Discuss the view that foreign aid benefits the donor more than the recipient

1074 words - 4 pages . This makes the situation a long term problem and thus, more and more interest is piled on. The donor is highly beneficial this way as the longer the debt cancellation takes, the more money the donor can earn. On the other hand, the recipient also risks the possible increase of indebtedness.Another example that donor countries benefit more from aid is when support is given to finance imports from donor countries. The donor usually gives money in

Discuss the contention that national cultures are converging and thus cross cultural sensitivity is no longer applicable

1575 words - 6 pages Discuss the contention that national cultures are converging and therefore cross-cultural sensitivity is no longer applicable.The above brief has proved to present a broad array of approaches in confirming or refusing the contention of converging national cultures. This essay shall concern itself with the study of the extent to which, organisational and societal cultural values have converged, with a particular emphasis on the operations of

"Throughout the colonial period, economic concerns had more to do with the settling of Britich North America than did religious concerns" Assess the validity of this statement

595 words - 2 pages The statement "Throughout the colonial period, economic concerns had more to do with the settling of Britich North America than did religious concerns" is in a way true. The settling of British North America reflected and equal amount of economic and religious concerns. But the colonies that were founded mainly based on religious concerns were also founded with thoughts of making money.The colonies of New England, Maryland, Pennsylvania, Rhode

"Economic concerns had more to do with the settling of British North America than did religious concerns"- Assess the validity of this statement

1533 words - 6 pages upsetting the conditions in England greatly. Due to these changes, many people thought that a new start would be a good idea. They figured that they didn't have much to lose, so they might as well adventure to America with hopes of a better future.Great Britain also sought to solve other economic problems through American colonization. For example, England needed to multiply and find more of its diminishing materials and resources, create another

Essay discussing the validity of critics as well as Oscar Wilde in defense of his literary work "A Portrait of Dorian Gray."

707 words - 3 pages Andrew GordonAugust 28, 2003One of the most ruthless leaders of the post-enlightened world, Napoleon Bonaparte, noted in his maxims that "Four hostile newspapers are more to be feared than a thousand bayonets." Herein, Napoleon makes it abundantly clear of the effect of critics and there influence to readers; they could turn armies or simply stop the reading of a book. The remarkably erudite - himself a critic - Oscar Wilde, in a modernly

Similar Essays

Motivation To Work Well Depends More Than High Wages And On Working Co

1493 words - 6 pages Motivation to Work Well Depends More Than High Wages and on Working Conditions 1) Discuss critically the validity of the contention that the motivation to work well depends on more than a high salary and good working conditions. This essay will define what motivation is, the influence and effect that money and good working conditions have on staff and the other factors and issues that motivate staff to work in the context of the workplace

Consider The Arguments Both For And Against The Contention That Gender Is A Product Of Nurture Rather Than Nature

2014 words - 8 pages job, there were greater opportunities for learning as children of both sexes were encouraged to do their work and stay in education in order to get a better job later on in life. Middle class children of both sexeshad an advantage as schools favoured and transmitted the dominant middle class culture which working class homes did not have. This weakens the idea that only a person's gender shapes their future. (Halsey et al 1980: Bernstein 1977

"No Job Is More Vital To Society Than That Of The Manager." (Henry Mintzberg). Discuss

1273 words - 5 pages . Without a manager to plan, organize, lead and control an organization, what would be the effect on society? Considering a manager's fulfillment of these basic four roles and the impact these have on society will provide us with an understanding that, as Henry Mintzberg stated, "No job is more vital to society than that of the manager."Breaking down the roles that a manager carries out and considering examples will show that these roles are vital to

Examine The Contention That Urban Policy Should Focus On Places Rather Than People

1571 words - 6 pages regeneration. She believed that rather than helping the people, you need to first help the economy and so, took an economic focus, and she concentrated on the place rather than the people. It wasn't until 1990 when John Major took over, that the policy changed again to a hybrid of the periods of urban policy. He introduced a socio-economic policy, concentrating not just on the economy or the social aspects but also on how the effect one another and how