This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Discuss: Hume, A Treatise Of Human Nature, Bk Iii, Part 1, Section 1.

2558 words - 10 pages

"..when you pronounce any action or character to be vicious, you mean nothing but that from the constitution of your nature you have a feeling or sentiment of blame from the contemplation of it,"The purpose of this essay is to examine Hume's statement contained within the title and explore the possible interpretations and arguments of it. In order to do this I will first discuss the idea of this form of moral subjectivism, before observing other possible interpretations as well as any counter-arguments of Hume's proposition that come to mind.Of course, it has now become all too apparent that classifying Hume's proposition as a form of moral subjectivism needs to be further illustrated before this essay can progress. It appears, at least, that the proposition is an endorsement of moral subjectivism insomuch as it acknowledges the individuals interpretation of 'any act or character', rather than a universal one. As such, it would be fair to suggest that in this passage Hume has no regard for such philosophical concepts as Absolute Good. From this it can be concluded that, since the individual is responsible for classifying an act of character rather than some innate idea of good and evil, this is a form of moral subjectivism.While this is seemingly apparent it remains to be seen if this is a reoccurring theme in Hume's work, or if, instead, this is in some way an objective approach. However, were one to regard the following passage they would see that this possibility is unlikely;"Extinguish all the warm feeling and prepossessions in favour of virtue, and all disgust or aversion to vice: render men totally indifferent towards these distinctions; and morality is no longer a practical study, nor has any tendency to regulate our lives and actions"From this, combined with the original statement, it can be said that Hume is arguing that morals are entirely subjective. As he has said, in simpler terms, were one to remove himself from the belief in a moral guide, they would cease to have an affect on his life. That is to say that morality has only as much power and bearing as one allows it. To go further, a person will view an act as immoral, not because it is, but simply because to that individuals mind it is.But why is this? This does not help demonstrate that morality is subjective, only that some follow a code more so than others. This understanding of the Good must originate from somewhere, surely, or else it would be impossible to consider any act foul or virtuous. Nevertheless, because a concept of morality is held dear to somebody does not necessarily mean that it cannot be subjective.Yet, the very fact that we can pronounce an act or character to be vicious shows that moral value is derived, to some extent, from the individual's own constitution. One cannot conclude that something is vicious, without they themselves having a grasp of the concept of vicious. This can indeed be reached upon from an external source without rendering it objective.To...

Find Another Essay On Discuss: Hume, A Treatise of Human Nature, BK III, Part 1, section 1.

A weird life - PART 1

2492 words - 10 pages . My heart was like a black-shaped box always staying in the shadows.Surprisingly, more boys liked me as a person than girls. Part of the reason was jealously, but I didn't believe that that was the entire reason. The boys didn't really care whether I was the daughter of a famous actor, or whether I was a poor girl who lived on the streets; they took me for who I was. My three closest friends, Michael, Peter and Rossie, were the few people who I

A Beginner's Guide to Hacking - Part 1

1755 words - 7 pages that occur when the Internet is accessed.When a program transfers data between your computer and the Internet, it uses TCP/IP. First, it sends the request to your TCP/IP protocol, which are part of the Transport Layer in the OSI Model. Your TCP/IP protocol then takes the data, breaks it down into packets, transfers it to the Network Layer, which passes it to the Data Link Layer, and eventually travels through the physical layer until it reaches

Having A Premature Baby (Part 1)

2506 words - 10 pages . What a lot of fuss. This time though I was allowed to go home and organise myself.I got to King Edward Hospital and was taken up to the ante natal ward and shown my bed for the next 13 weeks. Well this is something to look forward but if it is for my babies sake then it is worth it. My blood pressure was taken and the docotr explained what was happening. OK so I had pre-eclampsia and needed to take it easy so I can give my baby the best chance

13 reasons why section 1 journal

682 words - 3 pages little rumour had driven Hannah to her death. So far I think that the book has been amazing. Each chapter ends with a cliffhanger and it makes you want to read more. By the end of the first section I was kind of frustrated knowing I wouldn’t be able to read more for a while. What got me going through the chapters is the amount of emotion in it. It is very dark and that makes you want to read more. I also think that the controversy over the topic

Financial Statements part 1

334 words - 2 pages Financial Statements Paper Part 1 Financial Statements Paper Part 1 In using the 2003 Landry's Restaurants, Inc. Annual Report the following questions will be answered: A.) What does the income statement tell us about the company? Why is this statement important? What business decisions could be made using the income statement? B.) What does the balance sheet tell us about the company? Why is the balance sheet important? What

ISU part 1

925 words - 4 pages with a history of illegal drugs, are highly are risk of using them. Studies show that parents who sit down and discuss this risk taking behavior with their teens, are more likely to have a drug free child. Parents play a key part in a teen’s development and parents should talk to their teen often about illegal drugs and what they do to one’s health. Ways to get help There are many government run rehabilitation centers that help with illegal

Assignment 1 Part B:

1316 words - 6 pages Assignment 1 Part B: It is imperative that all educators implement a holistic and inclusive curriculum into their daily classroom practices, in order to recognise the different learning styles of their students and develop instructional approaches that will accommodate these styles. Through creating responsive and inclusive classrooms, teachers are acknowledging the presence of culturally diverse students and the need for these students to find

False Love part 1

718 words - 3 pages False Love part 1"Damn, why did I do that?" Heather said to herself. She looked at the view around her. "It's so peaceful here, I wish I could enjoy it better." Heather leaned on the balcony rail. "Why did I have to fall in love with that creep? Nick I hate you! Yet I still love you." She stared at the setting sun. A tear drop went down her cheek. "I should be going inside now." Heather said to herself.She walked into her room and sat in front

Buses: Part 1

917 words - 4 pages I got on the Troost Avenue bus stop around seven P.M. With me I had a gray sweatshirt and a pair of pants, stuffed into my newly purchased single-strap backpack. Also, I had brought along my toothbrush, and stolen my dad's sole supply of AIM whitening toothpaste. I knew he'd care, but I didn't. I'd be damned if I were going to have bad breath on my venture. In my pocket I had a large kitchen knife, with plastic handle, and 400 dollars in cash. I

Histor project Part 1

939 words - 4 pages diminish or deal with polio, AIDS, smallpox, malaria, and SAR • (Van de Water) • In response to the famine in the horn of Africa, the UN had delivered 63,000 tons of humanitarian aid including 31,500 tons of beneficial food • Treated 1 million kids for malnutrition • Immunized 1.5 million children against deadly diseases in Somalia ( To end hunger, malnutrition and food insecurity FAO: Food and Agricultural Organization • Sending

Globalisation of the Media Part 1 - Ownership

2339 words - 9 pages Essay #1 - Media OwnershipMass media is ideally what its name suggests, a voice for the masses. But, as the line between the business and editorial side of journalism grows hazier, it is instead becoming a tool for the minority of corporate and political elites. Increasingly concentrated ownership has created an oligopoly in the media industry. The result is homogenized and watered down content heavily influenced by owner and advertiser

Similar Essays

A Treatise Of Human Nature: David Hume´S Philosophy

932 words - 4 pages , convey to him these impressions; but proceed not so absurdly, as to endeavor to produce the impressions by exciting the ideas" (Pg. 9, Paragraph 8). This is reasonable, as none of us can truly envision a sour taste without first having experienced it via our sense of taste. The only possible contradiction to this that Hume can find is that of gradient colors. If presented with a progression of shades of blue, with one shade missing, it is not difficult for us to conjure the idea of this missing shade, even if we have never seen it before. Works Cited: Hume, David. A Treatise of Human Nature. (1739).

Part 1 Question 1 Essay

825 words - 4 pages thus are moving them in the intended way of the mover. “So far we have regarded action of a political kind as instrumental in relation to some purpose or other. Every purpose, we have seen, whatever its nature, provided only that it requires the active participation of other men, demands of it promoters some political action and sets in motion a technique for rallying assents,” (S, 22). It is important to note that the smallest component of

A Vampire's Story Part 1 Essay

625 words - 3 pages A Vampire's story part 1Christopher was stalking him prey in the black of the night. Of course his prey couldn't' see him. Stupid humans can't see well in the dark, this one is going to be very easy. As Chris stalked his prey he noticed something that put a big grin on his face. The girl was walking into an alley.Chris jumped off the roof top and landed on his feet gracefully. He turned a corner and collided with the girl."I'm so sorry miss. I

A Demon Story Part 1 Essay

1512 words - 6 pages work uniform hugged her body to the perfections of her curves. She was molded to the flawless fantasies of that of a young man.Caught in by her luscious visual presentation, Stephen was responsible for a careless mistake. He stepped on an undersized twig that triggered a slight thud which caused the attention of the enigmatic human female. Concealed by the shadows of the street lamps he hid himself well, making sure his presence wasn’t