Discuss The Confusion Of Dramatic Genres In The Caretaker.

1245 words - 5 pages

The Caretaker by Harold Pinter breaks the boundaries of the classical dramatic genres. What is more, he also abandons the concept of the classical tragic hero described by Aristotle and uses the more modern idea presented by Arthur Miller in his essay Tragedy and the Common Man. Additionally, in his Poetics, Aristotle set number of guidelines by which the dramatic works should be arranged and what crucial elements of the dramatics works, the playwrights should consider and follow. However, in The Caretaker, Harold Pinter do not follow those patterns, instead he blends genres such as, tragedy, comedy, farce, realism, naturalism and the Theatre of the Absurd. This mixture of various styles is essential to the entire play but also to the specific elements of the play. Namely, those are the language, the plot and the interaction between characters.
In his Poetics Aristotle claims that the primary purpose of a good tragedy is to invoke both pity and fear. In order to do so, the tragic hero has to be highly renowned and prosperous person. Only then it is possible to present the change in fortune from good to bad due to some extreme error made by the hero. However, Harold Pinter in The Caretaker does not follow any of those rules. The main characters are ordinary men. They have flaws but they are not predestined to commit a critical mistake which would henceforth, affect their lives and their surroundings. As a result, the presentation of the tragic hero in reference to The Caretaker is similar to the one portrayed in the Arthur Miller’s essay Tragedy and the Common Man who explains that common people are equally important to be a subject of a tragedy as the high lords or the kings. Unlike the high-borne, common people usually trying to go from bad to good. For instance, Davies who is a homeless man strives to improve his social standing. In other instances common tragic heroes may also face

Aristotle also mentions that the tragedy should have a high style and an embellished language. Nonetheless, the language in The Caretaker is not sophisticated and there are many repetitions and vernacular words. Most of the dialogues are written in a very simple language and the characters discuss on various occasions trivial matters. For example, Aston and Davies often talk about the shoes which are important to the play but nevertheless; the topic of the discussion is frivolous. If we were to compare the style, the language and the dialogues of The Caretaker with the ancient tragedies, the initial would have a plain style, simplistic language and uncomplicated dialogues.
As it was mentioned at the beginning of this essay, Harold Pinter in The Caretaker blends different dramatic genres which was not common among the classical plays. Those were usually pure tragedies or comedies, whereas Pinter combines three different dramatic genres with two major literary movements and one theatrical school. This experiment gave a new quality to the theatre, which...

Find Another Essay On Discuss the Confusion of Dramatic Genres in The Caretaker.

"Noises Off" by Michael Frayn: Written vs. Dramatic vs. Visual - An analysis of comedy throughout the ages, world and genres

2063 words - 8 pages From sardines to booze, an axe to flowers, and form to farce; Michael Frayn's "Noises Off" is a tantalizing script and a thrill for the eyes. The script has taken three forms: written, dramatic and visual, though each one is unique in its own right. Each version brings to life a new piece of the story creating, essentially, three different stories depending on how you perceive each one. Through my evaluation of each, I propose that the dramatic

Discuss the dramatic presentation of relationships between parents and children in Hamlet

1205 words - 5 pages A major theme in the play is the relationship between parents and children, with the play centred round the eponymous main character revenging the death of his father. We see filial interactions constantly: Old Hamlet and Young Hamlet, Old Fortinbras and Young Fortinbras, Polonius and Laertes, and Claudius and Hamlet. Young Hamlet seems to idolise his father, calling him a “Hyperion”, and his devotion shows that he clearly loved him

The Creation of Suspense in Different Film Genres

2875 words - 12 pages The Creation of Suspense in Different Film Genres We humans demand a lot nowadays where a film is concerned. No longer do we want simple, traditional storylines (well at least I don’t!), but instead we expect big explosions, top-notch special effects and quality acting. Film directors have a tough task keeping its audience happy; however the more suspense they create in their films, the more appreciative we will be of

Popular Genres of Music in the US: Hip-hop

832 words - 4 pages Hip-hop is one of the most popular genres of music in the U.S. It is very influential in today’s youth, especially young African-American males. It has created such a false image for them, leading them to believe that much of what the rappers talk about is appropriate. Nowadays, some of the most popular rap songs and lyrics are just too graphic for them to be listening to at their age. Hip-hop music causes African-American males to

Discuss the relationship between film form and meaning in 'The Shining'. Give examples of how genres utilize formal and narrative conventions to create meaning

2390 words - 10 pages Shining (based on the Stephen King book) involves a seemingly typical family of three, Jack and Wendy Torrance, and their son Danny. Jack has been selected to - well, overlook - The Overlook, which he thinks will give him the time and space he needs to work on his novel. From the time the family moves into the otherwise deserted hotel, however, there are strange goings on. The boy, Danny, who has visions, sees twin girls who died years before in the

The Caretaker by Harold Pinter

1995 words - 8 pages The Caretaker by Harold Pinter In this essay I will take the position that the audience see Davies as both a social victim and a social parasite. Firstly a definition of a social victim and a social parasite will be given. A social victim is an individual who is looked down upon by other members of society, vulnerable to blame and not accorded the same rights as others. Therefore this disenfranchised group of people do not experience the

Discuss the Importance and Dramatic Impact of the Inspector's Final Speech in "An Inspector Calls" by J.B.Priestley (continued)

1105 words - 4 pages wants war". War, which was of course to follow in 1914. This technique is successful because it causes the audience to realise how arrogant the character of Mr.Birling is and what bad judgement he has.The Inspector leaves, dramatically, without giving the characters a chance to recover from his words. It is significant because for a few seconds after his dramatic departure, they are all better people for his visit. It does not take long for the

The Significance of Language in Dramatic Productions

2043 words - 8 pages The Significance of Language in Dramatic Productions The significance of language in any dramatic production, or indeed any piece of performance art, be it song, poetry or whatever, is undoubtedly of great importance, as it is not only the medium through which

Discuss the dramatic effectiveness of A View From the Bridge with

1566 words - 6 pages Discuss the dramatic effectiveness of A View From the Bridge with reference to one or two key scenes. Arthur Miller wrote 'A View form the Bridge' in 1955. He wrote the play in the style of a Greek tragedy set in the 1940s America. Arthur Miller was interested in the lives of dockworkers and longshoremen. This was because he previously worked in Brooklyn on the docks and his parents were immigrants. He wanted to write about something

The Use of Different Genres in Thelma and Louise and Pulp Fiction

1479 words - 6 pages films is both have very similar genres such as, comedy, romance, action and musical. Another similarity between the two films is both are also classified as a crime film and a buddy film. Another similarity between the two films is the rape of Thelma in Thelma and Louise and the male rape of Marsellus in Pulp Fiction. Both were powerful and dramatic scenes, especially in Pulp Fiction. The difference between the two

Discomfort, Irritation, and Confusion of The Bath

1103 words - 4 pages of the norm confronts people, they are suddenly caught off guard, and instead of dealing with the situation, they shy away from it in attempt to return to their protective glass case; the norm. Raymond Carver forces his readers to face discomfort, irritation, and confusion through reading "The Bath". His language is dry, and the story is short. The characters do not have names, the language does not flow well, and the ending leaves the reader

Similar Essays

The Caretaker Essay

678 words - 3 pages The Caretaker How does the opening of the play set the tone for what will follow? The opening of the play starts off by describing the scene and how everything on the stage would be set out, following that it briefly describes what will happen when the curtains are raised. From the opening of the play it jumps right into the story as though we are picking it up from where we left off, it doesn’t really have a beginning where you are

Discuss The Dramatic Role Or Significance Of The Witches In This Play

1160 words - 5 pages emphasis on the antithesis to the divinely ordained order of the universe and helps create dramatic emphasis. As evident from the play, special uses of clothing and weather helps determine the true character of the witches.Shakespeare has chosen to write this play where the topics explored within the play were very relevant to the time in which it was written. Practising witchcraft became an executable offence in 1604 so the witches in the play

Discuss The Dramatic Effectiveness Of John Proctor In Arthur Miller’s The Crucible

2823 words - 11 pages Untitled Discuss the dramatic effectiveness of John Proctor in Arthur Miller's The Crucible. Conflict is at the heart of all drama. In Arthur Miller's The Crucible, John Proctor is at the heart of the conflict. He is a strong willed character, who seems, throughout the play, to be in some kind of strong dispute with someone at every point. Usually for what we, the audience, agree with or believe is right. Proctor

The Evolution Of Movie Genres Essay

2444 words - 10 pages It’s no question that genre is a very important factor in a screenwriter’s pursuit of creating a highly marketable film. Considering genre types in writing a script for an upcoming film is important to not only the target audience, but the technical characteristics of certain genres. Every film created is categorized into a specific genre based on elements of that genre type, as well as accompanied by technical aspects that classify a film as