Discuss The Extent To Which The Somme Offensive Was A Failure.

1583 words - 6 pages

To most, the Somme Offensive was one of the biggest failures of World War I. By discussing the purposes, leadership, conditions, morale and events of the Somme Offensive we can determine to what degree it was a failure. Each of these individual factors is essential in deciding to what extent it was a failure. The purposes for beginning the Somme Offensive and the ineffective leadership that made the decisions are both critical factors effecting the extent to which it was a failure. The appalling conditions and low morale had a significant impact on the Allied chances of success and major events, such as individual battles, were also important factors that affected the Allied chances of winning the Somme Offensive. In the ensuing discussion, it will be obvious to what extent the Somme Offensive was a failure.The purposes for beginning the Somme Offensive are vital in determining to what extent it was a failure. Haig and Joffre's original intention at the Somme was to relieve the pressure on Verdun and to break through the German lines to decisively change the war from stalemate to movement. Within the first few weeks they realise that this is not possible and turn to a war of attrition. Laffin, a well-respected World War I historian, states that Haig could not call off the offensive because it "would be an open admission of failure." This is truthful in that it would be a personal failure, but it would also be a national failure and a strategic blow that would lower morale and the Allies chances of winning the war. Because of the nature of attrition warfare, the Germans soon learnt to minimise their casualties, as General Sixt von Armin explained after the war. "One of the most important lessons drawn from the Battle of the Somme is that, under heavy, methodical artillery fire, the front line should be only thinly held, but by reliable men and a few machine guns ... When this was not done, the casualties were so great before the enemy's attack was launched that the possibility of the front line repulsing the attack by its own unaided efforts was very doubtful." So the Somme Offensive changed to a war of attrition on both sides. Therefore, it can be determined that the Somme Offensive was a failure according to the original plans for the battle.The ineffectual leadership during the Somme Offensive greatly hampered its chances of success. Many of the leaders were in command because of their social status, not because of their abilities as military commanders. Laffin states that Rawlinson, with support from his superiors, gave orders "that advancing troops were not to charge, merely to walk." Laffin believes that this was because the British "staff had convinced themselves that the troops would become confused if other tactics were employed ... This belief resulted from the idea ... that the volunteers of Kitchener's Army were very dull men. This was not so; many intelligent men had responded to the call for the New Army." What Rawlinson was actually...

Find Another Essay On Discuss the extent to which the Somme Offensive was a failure.

Essay prompt: Discuss the extent to which there was colonial unity and identity in America by the eve of the American Revolution.

1185 words - 5 pages Parliament." He goes on to say that nature will not allow America to be lumped into the "Mass" of Great Britain. Here, he indicates that the Americans have gained an identity all their own, and are no longer identified as British subjects.However, there was still a lack of unity in the Southern colonies at this time. The Carolina Regulators wreaked havoc in North and South Carolina, which showed the beginning of a conflict between western frontiersmen

Discuss the extent to which trade theory can be used to explain the competitiveness of locations.

3091 words - 12 pages Competitions between countries striving for trade surpluses have led to a number of scholars to establish various schools of thoughts, which could be utilized by government and large multinational corporations to decide on trade policies and seek best business investment opportunities.In the 18th Century, Adam Smith published his famous Wealth of Nations (1776). Smith's theory, Theory of Absolute Advantage was the first to explain why

To what extent was China's failure to effectively deal with the West up to 1842 a consequence of its traditional attitude to foreign states?

1819 words - 7 pages China's failure to effectively deal with the West up to1842 is largely attributed to its traditional attitude of foreign inferiority. The Chinese had an innate and a deeply ingrained belief that they were the superior nation. For over two thousand years, China was consumed by their own self-importance in the world, fueled essentially by their early philosophy of being at the centre of the world, their self-imposed isolation and their economic

Discuss the extent to which you think that goals are determined by the overarching culture of a society as opposed to smaller social groups or subcultures

1106 words - 4 pages Pascal Cisangani 23023554 / 23345853 Danai MuswaziDiscuss the extent to which you think that goals are determined by the overarching culture of a society as opposed to smaller social groups or subculturesDefinition of key termersCulture and subcultureA culture is made up of beliefs, behaviors, objects, and other characteristics that members of a specific group or society have in common. Through this, individuals and groups define themselves

It was inevitable that Cuba would experience a revolution. Castro merely exploited this opportunity. To which extent Castro was responsible for the Cuban revolution.

1386 words - 6 pages It was inevitable that Cuba would experience a revolution. Castro merely exploited this opportunity. To which extent Castro was responsible for the Cuban revolution.Fidel Castro, throughout the Cuban revolution, and until today, is one of the greatest influences concerning Cuba, economically and socially. His contribution and leadership throughout the Cuban revolution, along with his commander in chief, Che Guevara, were the right and left rails

Australia was a better place in which to live for women in 1945 than it was in 1900.' Discuss this statement with reference to the status of women.

1752 words - 7 pages than just housewives and seamstresses, but gave them a voice and new role in society, which they freely and enthusiastically pursued.Between 1900 and 1945 many women fought for their rights, as a means to improve their lifestyles and role in Australian society. With the improvement of female positions in society, came a greater freedom and access to education. One of the most significant women's rights activists was Catherine Spence, a South

Identify the key elements which account for the success or failure of social movements. Discuss with reference to examples.

1757 words - 7 pages stance and it will inevitably lead to failure of the group.In Conclusion I have examined some aspects of social movements which if they are not in place could lead to failure of the movement. Without mobilization of a group then it is obvious that a movement won't even be able to get off the ground. This mobilization can either come from a tight close-knit ecology as was seen with the student movement in China or linkage of social networks. Where

Discuss the extent to which the American reform movements of 1825-1850 sought to expand democratic ideals in America.

1009 words - 4 pages . McGuffey invented the "McGuffey Reader." This was a standard reader that all children read based on their grade. In a passage from a McGuffey Reader from 1836, a poor young boy discusses how his parents are "very good to save some of their money in order that I may learn to read and write." He is referring to tax-supported public schools, which were a result of the education reform movement.Alcohol abuse was becoming widespread throughout the

The Extent to Which Austria was the Main Obstacle to the Unification of Italy in the Period 1815-1849

3023 words - 12 pages The Extent to Which Austria was the Main Obstacle to the Unification of Italy in the Period 1815-1849 In the period immediately after the Vienna settlement in 1815 and up to the widespread revolutions throughout Europe and especially Italy in 1848 and 1849, the prospect of a united Italy seemed almost a distant dream. There were a range of obstacles in between progress to a unified state. These included the outright

Examin the daily lives of the inhabitants of Deir el-Medina and assess the extent to which religion was a dominant force in their lives.

1174 words - 5 pages family. These tombs were situated in the Valley of the Kings -burial place to the pharaohs of the 18th, 19th and 20th dynasties.Religion played quite a substantial role in the economy as the priests used it as a somewhat manipulative tool in order to receive taxes from the villagers. The people left goods and food for the gods in the temples, which the priests would then redistribute as wages. They weren't deceiving the people in doing so, this was

Discuss the extent to which Vianne Rocher and Francis Reynaud are outsiders in the novel "Chocolat" written by Joanne Harris

772 words - 3 pages and the village people ignore her and her daughter and Reynaud tries to stop the village people from accepting her as one of their own.The extent to which Vianne Rocher is an outsider is that she has just moved from America " we are going to start a new life from New York..." (Chapter:1, page:11) ,and she also has to remind her daughter Anouk to speak French "I have to remind her to speak French..."(page:12) which immediately tells you that they

Similar Essays

Why Was The First Day Of The Battle Of The Somme A Failure?

1065 words - 4 pages Germans into the Montaubau Valley. General Rawlinson had nearly not included this division in the plans, and was going to replace them. Over the whole war, the British took about 15 miles. These were about the only successes of a very dreadful war, but why was the Somme, in particular the first day, such a failure?There were big problems with the trenches. The German trenches overlooked the British trenches, and so the Germans could see through

To What Extent Was The U.S. Failure In Vietnam Predictable

1910 words - 8 pages A. Plan of Investigation The investigation evaluates to what extent the failure of the United States in the Vietnam War was predictable. It assesses how this failure was predictable in the long and short-term and what factors were involved. The two sources used for a deeper study are from America in Vietnam, by Guenter Lewy and The army and Vietnam by Andrew F. Krepinevich Jr. Their origins, purpose, values and limitations will be discussed to

The Extent To Which England Was A Protestant Country By 1547

976 words - 4 pages The Extent to Which England was a Protestant Country by 1547 In this essay, I shall be exploring the extent of how Protestant a country England was by 1547. The differences between Protestantism and Catholicism form a solid base in order to understand the situation in 1547 and decide which religion became more popular. Traditional Catholic beliefs rested on seven Sacraments: Baptism, Penance and Reconciliation, Last

Discuss The Extent To Which Public Servants Owe A Duty Of Care Under The Tort Of Negligence

2565 words - 10 pages the duty i.e. he or she was negligent Finally, the claimant must establish that he or she suffered loss or harm as a result of the negligence.An individual that has suffered harm as a consequence of the negligence of a public servant e.g. the police, the fire service, the ambulance service etc. will not succeed under the tort of negligence unless the public servant owed the claimant a duty of care. The purpose of this essay is to discuss the extent