This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Discuss The Extent To Which Public Servants Owe A Duty Of Care Under The Tort Of Negligence

2565 words - 10 pages

IntroductionThe tort of negligence was established by the House of Lords in Donoghue v Stevenson [1932]. In this case the claimant’s friend ordered a bottle of ginger beer for the claimant. The ginger beer was contained in an opaque bottle. Having drunk some of the ginger beer, the claimant poured the remainder into her glass. As she did so, the remains of a decomposed snail fell out. The claimant became ill and sued the manufacturer of the ginger beer. The House of Lords held that manufacturers owe a duty of care to the consumers of their products and that a consumer can sue a manufacturer if he or she is harmed or injured due to the manufacturer’s negligence. In order to make a successful claim under the tort of negligence the claimant must therefore establish three things. Firstly, that the defendant owed the claimant a duty of care. Secondly, that the defendant breached the duty i.e. he or she was negligent Finally, the claimant must establish that he or she suffered loss or harm as a result of the negligence.An individual that has suffered harm as a consequence of the negligence of a public servant e.g. the police, the fire service, the ambulance service etc. will not succeed under the tort of negligence unless the public servant owed the claimant a duty of care. The purpose of this essay is to discuss the extent to which public servants owe a duty of care to members of the public.The Duty of CareIn Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] Lord Atkin explained that ‘you must take reasonable care to avoid acts and omissions which you can reasonably foresee would be likely to injure your neighbour’ (Macintyre 2005 pg. 347). He defined the term ‘neighbour’ as persons closely and directly affected by your acts and omissions. Under the neighbourhood test a defendant owed a duty of care if the claimant would be ‘closely and directly’ affected by the defendant’s actions and if the defendant ought to reasonably foresee that his failure to take care might cause the claimant harm (Macintyre 2005 pg 347). In Anns v Merton LBC [1978] Lord Wilberforce developed the test created by Lord Atkin in Donoghue v Stevenson [1932]. Lord Wilberforce’s formulation became known as the ‘Two Stage Test’ (Giliker and Beckwith 2004 pg 31). A duty of care would be owed if there is a sufficient relationship of ‘proximity or neighbourhood’ between the claimant and defendant so that the defendant can reasonably foresee that negligence on his part would be likely to harm the claimant and if there are no policy considerations that would justify denying a duty of care in such circumstances. In subsequent cases the courts sought to limit the imposition of a duty of care. For example, in Murphy v Brentwood DC [1990] the House of Lords expressed concern about the ‘potentially extensive liability permitted’ under the two stage test (Giliker and Beckwith 2004 pg 33). Their Lordships overruled the decision in Anns v...

Find Another Essay On Discuss the extent to which public servants owe a duty of care under the tort of negligence

Discuss the extent to which the American reform movements of 1825-1850 sought to expand democratic ideals in America

1009 words - 4 pages . McGuffey invented the "McGuffey Reader." This was a standard reader that all children read based on their grade. In a passage from a McGuffey Reader from 1836, a poor young boy discusses how his parents are "very good to save some of their money in order that I may learn to read and write." He is referring to tax-supported public schools, which were a result of the education reform movement.Alcohol abuse was becoming widespread throughout the

Discuss the extent to which the Somme Offensive was a failure

1583 words - 6 pages the extent to which it was a failure. The appalling conditions and low morale had a significant impact on the Allied chances of success and major events, such as individual battles, were also important factors that affected the Allied chances of winning the Somme Offensive. In the ensuing discussion, it will be obvious to what extent the Somme Offensive was a failure.The purposes for beginning the Somme Offensive are vital in determining to what

Extent to which state has legal duty to protect

2200 words - 9 pages 1. Introduction The Constitution of the Republic of South Africa contains a Bill of Rights which clearly states that “Everyone has the right to freedom and security of the person, which includes the right to be free from all forms of violence from either private or public sources” . This constitutional right clearly illustrates the creation of a positive legal duty on the police to protect all citizens from violence in any form. This legal

Essay prompt: Discuss the extent to which there was colonial unity and identity in America by the eve of the American Revolution

1185 words - 5 pages Parliament." He goes on to say that nature will not allow America to be lumped into the "Mass" of Great Britain. Here, he indicates that the Americans have gained an identity all their own, and are no longer identified as British subjects.However, there was still a lack of unity in the Southern colonies at this time. The Carolina Regulators wreaked havoc in North and South Carolina, which showed the beginning of a conflict between western frontiersmen

Discuss the extent to which International assistance can and should be effectively used to achieve security sector reform as part of post-conflict peace-building

3491 words - 14 pages agencies that deal with security, which collectively form the 'security sector' becomes pertinent for the success of post-conflict peace-building.The wartime human and material destruction imposes needs for massive technical assistance and socioeconomic resources vital to a successful post-war transformation to peace. The security sector, given its centrality, as often the case, to the outbreak of conflicts and the criminal damage and heinous human

Discuss the extent to which Vianne Rocher and Francis Reynaud are outsiders in the novel "Chocolat" written by Joanne Harris

772 words - 3 pages and the village people ignore her and her daughter and Reynaud tries to stop the village people from accepting her as one of their own.The extent to which Vianne Rocher is an outsider is that she has just moved from America " we are going to start a new life from New York..." (Chapter:1, page:11) ,and she also has to remind her daughter Anouk to speak French "I have to remind her to speak French..."(page:12) which immediately tells you that they

The Ingredients Required to Establish the Tort of Negligence

2281 words - 9 pages The tort of Negligence is defined by Winfield as, ‘as breach of a legal duty to take care which results in damage to the claimant’ . To bring an action in the tort of negligence it’s not enough to prove that defendant behaved carelessly. It is just one of the ingredients required to establish the tort of negligence, the claimant must prove that the defendant owes the claimant a duty of care. The defendant has acted in breach of that duty and as

With reference to either waste management in urban areas or transport management in urban areas, discuss the extent to which sustainability can be

895 words - 4 pages approximately 38% of organic material which is biodegradable, so it can be composted either by individuals or on a larger scale. If composting is carried individually in house owners’ garden it reduces the costs for the local authority to dispose of it. Large-scale composting involves collecting compost from homes and from public waste. The material is broken down by microbes which produces 2 useful products: biogas and a nitrogen-rich fertiliser

The Test Of Remoteness In The Tort Of Negligence

826 words - 4 pages The law places a limit upon the extent to which the defendant is liable for the loss which occurs from his breach of a duty of care to the plaintiff, once it is established that the loss sustained by the plaintiff is one recoverable in negligence. The test of remoteness of damage limits this liability by defining certain types of damage or losses as being irrecoverable as a matter of law. The test is carried out to protect the defendant in

Common Law in Australia: The Tort Of Negligence

9095 words - 36 pages suffered are a result of a risk to which the injured party consented, eg participating in a dangerous sport. This assumption of risk does not excuse any Negligence that may have occurred by other parties at the time the risk was taken.Agar v Hyde:Plaintiffs were injured in a game of Rugby Union when packing into scrums. They sue the International Rugby Football Board arguing that the rule makers they are under a duty of care to all players in the

Duty of care is the responsibility to do everything reasonably

1907 words - 8 pages for negligence. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, but the appeal was later accepted. If the decision was made that mother could be sued for accidentally harming herself while pregnant, many pregnant women, or women considering pregnancy would be very afraid for the 9 months they carry their child. The ideal way to deal with this problem is to allow a mothers duty of care to her fetus as a moral responsibility, which many women generously

Similar Essays

Legal Systems: Duty Of Care And Negligence

1406 words - 6 pages concept is influential to courts in limiting liability in negligence. Over the years, tort law has evolved to become more sophisticated. In the same regard, courts have found ways to limit liability in negligence especially under the concept of duty of care. Justifying the defendant’s liability to the plaintiff is a critical process. The first aspect of duty of care that courts use to limit liability in negligence is assessing how the duty of

Duty Of Care And The Public Policy Issue

2446 words - 10 pages LAW OF TORTIntroductionThe case of Mitchell v Glasgow City Council1, hereinafter referred to as 'Mitchell v Glasgow CC' is a fascinating scenario in which the principles of the duty of care as expounded upon in the seminal case of Caparo Industries plc v Dickman2, hereinafter referred to as 'Caparo v Dickman', are tested to the extreme. This matter also references public policy issues, e.g. whether it was equitable that a public authority should

Discuss The Extent To Which Trade Theory Can Be Used To Explain The Competitiveness Of Locations

3091 words - 12 pages Competitions between countries striving for trade surpluses have led to a number of scholars to establish various schools of thoughts, which could be utilized by government and large multinational corporations to decide on trade policies and seek best business investment opportunities.In the 18th Century, Adam Smith published his famous Wealth of Nations (1776). Smith's theory, Theory of Absolute Advantage was the first to explain why

Discuss The Extent To Which You Think That Goals Are Determined By The Overarching Culture Of A Society As Opposed To Smaller Social Groups Or Subcultures

1106 words - 4 pages Pascal Cisangani 23023554 / 23345853 Danai MuswaziDiscuss the extent to which you think that goals are determined by the overarching culture of a society as opposed to smaller social groups or subculturesDefinition of key termersCulture and subcultureA culture is made up of beliefs, behaviors, objects, and other characteristics that members of a specific group or society have in common. Through this, individuals and groups define themselves