This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Discuss Thomas Mann's "A Death In Venice". Also, Find An Interpretation Of The Story And Write Whether You Agree Or Not With What It Says.

1967 words - 8 pages

Thomas Mann's A Death in VeniceMann's A Death in Venice is the story of a respectable writer, Gustav von Aschenbach, and the slow self-degradation which led to the ending of his life. Beginning in early childhood, Aschenbach had based every action and thought he ever had on self-discipline and reason. He avoided thoughts of a carefree and disruptive nature, anything that took him away from his beloved routine. The story leads to his break from the 'normal' of society and his own standards, as he joins a class of people that he was previously disgusted by.The purpose of the story seems to have been aimed at proving what mishaps occur when a person looses track of reason and instead chooses to follow his or her desires. A Death in Venice delivers a warning to all those who secretly want to follow in Aschenbach's footsteps: it is a fatal decision that can cost a person everything. Restrained passion, such as in Aschenbach's case, can eventually lead to discord; therefore, do not completely restrict yourself, but do not completely give in to it, either.ANALYSIS- Kerrin Ross MonahanAlthough there are several different interpretations of A Death in Venice, the one that I agreed with the most was the online criticism of Kerrin Ross Monahan. She believes that Mann's story has to do mainly with death, and mortality. Monahan makes several points, of which seven stood out particularly. First, she notes that Aschenbach, without dreams and ambition, has been already dead for a long time. Second, that Tadzio is a link to decay, and that the minor characters who are described throughout the story represent death and the devils of underground Greek mythology. Third, that death can also be shown in the cycle of time--the story begins in Spring and ends in Autumn. Fourth, the lack of women in the story is because of their role as life-givers, which would contradict with the purpose of the story. Fifth, that Venice itself is a symbol of death. Sixth, that Aschenbach's succumbing to passion and chaos is what ultimately led to his death. Seventh, that homosexuality is a theme present from the moment Aschenbach sees Tadzio, and finally, that cholera is a representation of passion and the disease it spreads.Regarding Aschenbach's lack of ambition and dreams, I agree that he is a lifeless character. As proof, one of his greatest passions is to grow old. Old age commonly represents the beginning of the decline of a person's life. This passion is unimaginative and dry, as the onlything he has to do to reach it is keep on living. As an artist, it would be imagined that Aschenbach would have moments of extreme passion during which he would create his greatest works. It is completely the opposite, as the readers are told that his success as a writer came from his solid work regime, one built on a day-to-day schedule that did not give him time to culture any sort of unique artistry.On the other hand, Aschenbach could not possibly be as lifeless as he is made out to be. His...

Find Another Essay On Discuss Thomas Mann's "A Death In Venice". Also, find an interpretation of the story and write whether you agree or not with what it says.

"Night" by Elie Wiesel: Elie once said that whoever witnesses an atrocity and does nothing to stop is just as guilty as the one committing it. Write whether you agree or disagree with this statement

460 words - 2 pages not commit, whether they could have done something to stop it or not. During the Holocaust there were over 6 million people persecuted, but there were many more silent bystanders who were unable to do anything because they feared for their lives. It is human nature to look after your own wellbeing and those closest to you, and many people felt if they tried to do something to stop the persecution of Jews it would endanger them in one way or

Discuss Whether or not Globalisation is the Death of Culture

2174 words - 9 pages often for wealth and trading purposes, and can at times come at the expense of culture. Culture is an expression, rather than a simple definition. It links us to places and peoples through mediums such as religion, clothing, food, or the media. The media in particular is continuously advertising different cultures across the globe.Globalisation also presents us with the dissolution of national state boundaries, representing the magnitude and

What would you identify as “fundamentally problematic and distasteful” (in Merchant of Venice, Shakespeare)? Do you agree with his assessment?

521 words - 2 pages What would you identify as "fundamentally problematic and distasteful" (in Merchant of Venice)? Do you agree with his assessment?There has been a lot of controversy about William Shakespeare's play, Merchant of Venice. Contrasting views are held on the anti-Semitic values in the play, which are identified as "fundamentally problematic and distasteful". However, I do not agree that the play has any "fundamentally problematic and distasteful

Shylock in The Merchant of Venice by William Shakespeare, to what extent do you agree with the statement "Shylock is a two-dimensional villain who does not deserve our sympathy"

549 words - 2 pages There are two assumptions made within this one statement. The first assumption is that Shylock is assumed as a two-dimensional villian who does not have any real motives for his actions and the second assumption is that he does not deserve our sympathy. Therefore, in this essay, we will explore how much of a villain Shylock really is, whether or not his actions call for our sympathy and if he has motives for his actions.Firstly, is Shylock a two

An essay on whether willy loman in death of a sales man is truly a tragic hero or not

621 words - 2 pages Willy is pitiful is that he decides to kill himself so that his family can collect the benefits. What he doesn't realize it is that his family needs him more than the money.The last two criteria for a tragic hero are fairly similar to one another. A tragic hero must come from a high social status, and he must also make his final fall from a high position in life. Willy Loman does not meet either of these requirements. Willy is just an average

Essay: I had to write an essay about a conflict in my life, and how I handled it. If it was overcome or not. I also had to present a clear thesis in my essay

529 words - 2 pages One Family, Two SocietiesGrowing up in a Pakistani household I was expected not to question or disrespect my father in any way. My father who was raised in Pakistan was a stern man, and stubborn at that. My father and I never really talked about anything serious. There came a point where I started to think and express my own opinions, which were different from what my father had. Over the past year I had become more independent of my father due

Women of "The Underdogs" We were asked to write a 7-8 page paper on Mariano Azuela's "The Underdogs," and how women were portrayed in it, as well as whether or not we felt the portrayal was accurate

2386 words - 10 pages to join in the fight for independence. As with many countries during this time, women's rights had been limited for centuries, so the changes that were made in Mexico during the Enlightenment allowed women to break free of the mold that society had placed upon them and explore other avenues. They could work outside of the home, receive an education, and participate in politics, even if it was to a limited extent. Many women did participate in the

Compare attitudes towards the nude and discuss, with reference to Cabanel's 'Venus' and Manet's 'Olympia', whether or not they offer an adequate response

2407 words - 10 pages that a nude should be erotic, but I don't believe that is it's only purpose. I also agree with his point that if it does not evoke any feeling then it is 'bad art' and I think this is true to say of all art in every genre. I believe a painting has to make you feel something whether it's a bad feeling or a good one, as then it is creating a response- this is what I believe good art does. For me I get more out of looking at Manet's Olympia than I do

Agree or disagree with the following statement: Oedipus is more of a hero than Odysseus. You will also need to define "hero"

612 words - 2 pages makes his journey more difficult. In Homer's "The Odyssey" and Sophocles, "Oedipus the King", the epic heroes Odysseus and Oedipus' differences vary slightly, not so much where you can say one is more of a hero than the other. The statement Oedipus is more of a hero that Odysseus can neither be agreed with nor disagreed with.Odysseus is unique among epic heroes in that his strength comes not from inhumane powers or exceptional physical ability

Do you agree with the death penalty

508 words - 2 pages “beyond a reasonable doubt.” Unfortunately, DNA evidence is not available in most cases. So, as long as the death penalty is in place, you are pretty much GUARANTEED to occasionally execute an innocent person.Really, that should be reason enough for most people to oppose it. If you need more, read on:2. Because of higher pre-trial expenses, longer trials, jury sequestration, extra expenses associated with prosecuting & defending a DP

'If you cannot communicate it, it isn't knowledge.' Agree or disagree and discuss

912 words - 4 pages know, but you're not necessarily sure of how you know, and would find it hard to express your thoughts on it as it just doesn't link with anything else you already know. On the contrary, just because the person is unable to communicate it effectively he might still know what he wants to communicate. From my personal experience, a couple of times when I have wanted to buy a computer piece here in Brazil, my Portuguese has been inadequate to

Similar Essays

The Triumph Of Disaster In Thomas Mann's Death In Venice

1971 words - 8 pages complex figurative speech, and thus an accurate representation of the book's style. Through the imagery paints Mann an authentic picture of a truly breathtaking specimen of human, perhaps semi-divine, beauty; otherwise, the reader would find it difficult to believe a man of such dignity and ethics falling woefully in love. He says of Tadzio, "His face recalled the noblest moment of Greek sculpture--pale, with a sweet reserve, with clustering honey

Symbols, Symbolism And Irony In Thomas Mann's Death In Venice

2303 words - 9 pages Symbols, Symbolism and Irony in Thomas Mann's Death in Venice       In the novel Death in Venice, by Thomas Mann, an observer compliments the main character Gustave von Aschenbach by saying, " 'You see, Aschenbach has always lived like this '-here the speaker closed the fingers of his left hand to a fist-'never like this '-and he let his hand hang relaxed from the back of his chair" (p. 1069).  This is a perfect description of Aschenbach

"Lady Macbeth Is The Real Driving Force Behind The Death Of Duncan" Discuss The Statement And Decide Whether Or Not You Agree

790 words - 4 pages The story of "Macbeth" is a tragedy. The statement means whether or not lady Macbeth is responsible for Duncan's death. I think that Lady Macbeth is the driving force behind the death of Duncan because she uses her status as his wife to pressurize him. She uses emotional blackmail to convince her hesitant husband to kill Duncan. Lady Macbeth is loving towards her husband but also ambitious, this is shown by her instant desire for Macbeth to

Greek Mythology In Thomas Mann's Death In Venice

1401 words - 6 pages chair and is later pronounced dead. Death in Venice is a perfect example of what happens when an individual represses his or her passions for too long. In the beginning of the story, Aschenbach appears to be a man who is very rational in thought and disciplined in life. He has seemingly mastered his passions and managed to keep them stifled. But as was illustrated in this novella, one can only keep passions repressed for so long before