Discuss Whether It Is Possible To Maintain The Neutrality Of Humanitarian Aid

2785 words - 11 pages

The provision of humanitarian aid has become an increasingly contentious and complicated issue. A contributing factor has been the expanding numbers of humanitarian actors (Marriage, 2008: 2) and consequentially greater competition for funding and operational field space. Governmental and inter-governmental agencies have blurred the lines of pure humanitarianism by integrating these activities with their own state’s military and political objectives (Rigby, 2001). This is further exacerbated in contexts of conflict. ‘The combatant/noncombatant distinction is also lost when state military forces participate in humanitarian activities.’ (Mills, 2005: 165). International Humanitarian Organisations (IHOs) and Non-Governmental Organisations (NGOs) attempt to combat this perception by declaring (amongst others) their principles of neutrality in the implementation of their mission interventions to alleviate suffering of affected populations they assess to be most in need.

In this essay, the nature of neutrality and its purpose and this principled application in humanitarian aid will be discussed. Furthermore, it will aim to demonstrate that while it may be desirable to seek neutrality of humanitarian aid, in reality on the ground and in constantly and rapidly changing circumstances, this is increasing difficult to achieve and maintain. The growing complexity of the interplay between governmental and inter-governmental agencies, IHOs and NGOs in the humanitarian field and increased politicisation and conditionality attached to humanitarian aid further complicates this position.

The structure of this examination will begin firstly by defining the key terms of ‘humanitarian aid’ and ‘neutrality’. Secondly, there will be an analysis of how humanitarian aid operates in contexts of conflict and where neutrality has been implemented and has faced challenges as an approach to effective humanitarian aid provision. Thirdly, humanitarian aid will be reviewed when used as a military or political tool on behalf of governments. Finally before concluding, there will be a brief consideration of the influence that funding may have on humanitarian aid neutrality.

Defining Humanitarian Aid

Humanitarian aid activities particularly in situations of open conflict or directly after the damage caused by a natural disaster; are most commonly associated with the delivery of medical and relief aid materials including non-food items (NFIs). This can be to supplement what is provided by the Government or state authorities or in the absence of such capabilities. The giving of basic material goods identified as needed for survival is at the core of many humanitarian organisations’ objectives.

In addition to providing material assistance, some organisations take up an active role in advocating for human rights issues or when lobbying for military intervention to allow access or to protect populations in need. From a governmental and inter-governmental agency...

Find Another Essay On Discuss Whether it is Possible to Maintain the Neutrality of Humanitarian Aid

Is it possible to speak of an English Culture?

2167 words - 9 pages that it is actually not possible to speak of terms such as 'English', 'Scottish', 'Welsh' and 'Irish' in a political sense until the C18th century. 'Nations' still less 'nation-states' had yet to emerge. Thus to speak of 'English' or 'Irish' for example before this time is more of a geographical statement than a political one.In conclusion I feel that it is not actually possible to speak of an English culture as such. Perhaps England is too diverse

Is it possible to define ‘art’?

2136 words - 9 pages other than the formal elements of an object have any relevance whatsoever in regard to its aesthetic value, or whether it is even a piece of art. Indeed he wrote in 1913: ‘To appreciate a work of art we need bring with us nothing but a sense of form...every other sort of representation is irrelevant.’ What Bell means by this is that what a work of art represents, for example, is entirely unrelated to its aesthetic value. Subsequently, Bell

Is it Possible to Harmonise International Trade?

2546 words - 10 pages trade law is not possible due to dissimilar perspectives on fraud issues. It is argued that international trade law harmonisation is not possible because of diverse interpretations due to cultural differences. Chuah claims “different countries will apply the “harmonised” rules differently and this thus defeats the intended object” (2013, p. 20). Since each country involved in global trade vary in cultural practices, values, primary language, socio

The Effects of Conduction in Heat Saving Devices (Build a heat-saving device that will allow a beaker of boiling water to maintain the highest possible temperature.)

1346 words - 5 pages during a hot day, when it gets wet and you're trying to stay warm, it's useless. A Thermos or Dewar Flask is the perfect example of all three types of heat transfer. It's a bottle with a silvery inside (preventing radiation), which is vacuum sealed into another bottle (convection), making sure that as little as possible of the innermost bottle is touching anything else (conduction). When a liquid is poured into the inside of a thermos, you can expect

Sun Gazing, Surviving Off of the Sun: Is It Possible and Is It Safe?

1749 words - 7 pages Sun Gazing is the practice of staring at the Sun for nourishment or as a spiritual practice. It is a Native American tradition, but has also appeared in many cultures, dating back as far as the ancient Egyptians, the ancient Yogis, and even the early Aztecs, Incas, and possibly the Mayans. It is believed to be a method of healing, curing physical and mental illnesses. Sun Gazing gurus have even claimed that it can lead to supernatural powers

Discuss some of the obstacles that can hold social workers back, in their efforts to achieve and maintain good practice.

1001 words - 4 pages Social work is a caring and rewarding profession that involves working with vulnerable members of society, enabling them to acquire a better life for themselves. Although Social work does have its benefits and sense of achievements it can also be very challenging and stressful for the worker. There is a general awareness, of some of the barriers that social workers face in their profession, but there is also an essential need to promote

The Necessary Mitigated Evil: Humanitarian Aid in Sub-Saharan Africa

1887 words - 8 pages Due in part to its tumultuous past, sub-Saharan Africa is a region of the world that is stricken with war, famine, and poverty. Many people in richer parts of the world, including North America and Europe, view helping the people who inhabit this part of the world as their duty and obligation. Both non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and governmental organizations such as the United Nations (UN) alike send humanitarian aid to sub-Saharan

It is in the government’s interest to encourage smoking. Discuss.

1652 words - 7 pages Laura Howe 12STK Feb ‘05 It is in the government’s interest to encourage smoking. Discuss. Since early in the twentieth century the evidence for the detrimental health effects of smoking has increased steadily. With the awareness of the health consequences of smoking, the proportion of smokers dropped and the evidence for the health benefits of smoking cessation began to accumulate. It is widely know

Sharia: Is it Possible to Transcend the Rules in Today’s Secular Society?

1111 words - 4 pages they Sharia or the laws of Timbuktu violate fundamental public policy of the state or the federal government, then the courts will not apply it. Whether the parties agreed not, the courts will simply refuse to apply it because it violates public policy.” (Elliot, “The Man…”) Public policy, simply put is the principle that establishes that any injury to the public good is a basis for denying the legality of a contract or other transaction. The

To what extent is it possible to discredit the 'black legend of childhood' (Keith Wrightson) in 16th and 17th century England?

2384 words - 10 pages mother’s milk. It must also be noted that some prescriptive literature advised against mothers initially breast feeding their children as colostrums was thought to be harmful . Stone further claims that the cessation of wet nursing in the 18th century is proof that parents had become less neglectful; however wet nursing continued until the 19th century in English aristocracy . Other historians maintain that infants were sent away to wet

'The core function of the police should be to maintain order.' Discuss with particular reference to Wilson and Kelling's 'broken windows' thesis.

2371 words - 9 pages will lead to higher levels of crime and disorder. In order to determine whether the core function of the police should be to maintain order, it is useful to understand why the police force was created in the first place, to look at the theory in practice and to evaluate its success on crime rates.Typically, the task faced by the police in the early 19th century was that of maintaining order. The role of the police at this time, before a

Similar Essays

Is It Possible To Travel At The Speed Of Light?

3982 words - 16 pages comes with many cautionary points that could inhibit any sort of progress in this topic. Why it’s possible Regardless of the benefits and consequences, is it even possible to have an object of mass travel at the speed of light? Is it possible for astronauts to visit other galaxies in a shuttle and live to return? No amount of research and testing will matter if it is entirely impossible to bend known physics in this way. The question of whether

Cutting Humanitarian Aid To Somalia Essay

1156 words - 5 pages generosity of the United States and the broader international community by using foreign humanitarian aid to bolster its capacity and maintain its control of southern Somalia. The group has raised funds through “taxing” aid distributors or forcing them to pay fees at checkpoints in order to operate in a given area” (Harnisch, C. 2010). Al Shabab sells portions of the humanitarian aid food supply in order to buy weapons for its militia. It has created

Why Is It Important For A Corporation To Maintain The Confidence Of The Stockholder?

554 words - 2 pages objective snapshot of a corporation's success.It is important for a corporation to maintain the confidence of the stockholder so they willcontinue to either buy, or hold the stock they currently own. Once a poor earningsreport comes out (especially one without a good explanation), the confidence of thestockholder can be lost. It is very easy for the stockholder to lose confidence especiallyif the industry that company is in isn't doing so well. By

Discuss Whether Or Not Globalisation Is The Death Of Culture.

2174 words - 9 pages increasing impact of social interaction and organisation. This links distant regions across the globe, economically and socially, and often through the medium of the media. Positive theorists of globalisation believe that it is both eventual and irreversible, and will bring huge benefits to mankind, but those opposed to globalisation believe it is only making lives and economies unequal. This leads us to a frequently posed question as to whether