Dispute Resolution In The Merchant Of Venice

1315 words - 5 pages

Shakespearean literature has been long commended by scholars for its incorporation of legal discourse into its plot structures that further paves way for interdisciplinary study of law. Practically all of Shakespearean texts are known to have tangential relation and relevance to legal practice but plays like “Merchant of Venice” have scenes that do not only depict a courtroom trial but also shed light on some key aspects and methods of dispute resolution that are arbitration, conciliation, negotiations and mediation.
“The merchant of Venice” is not only appreciated by literary enthusiasts but it has also generated great interest in Lawyers more than any other Shakespearean text, sparking profound commentary on the legal facets that are assessed academically. Before delving deep in to the legal themes entailed in the play, the substance of the prose will examine the definition of the term “Alternative Dispute Resolution” or ADR. Alternative Dispute Resolution refers to a repertoire of mechanism that can substitute court trials and largely entail discussions between the disputant parties.
These methods are also referred to as “out of court settlements”, whereby the parties involved in the dispute are encouraged to negotiate and find a solution to resolve their dispute. The ADR system is subdivided into the following categories that are negotiation, mediation and arbitration. The process of negotiation consists of dialogues between the disputant parties whereas, “arbitration” and “mediation” require the involvement of a third party to act as a mediator or conciliator in order to find a solution and make unbiased judgment in the matter. It is important to understand that the decisions in a dispute are non-binding if they are made through “mediation” and “negotiations”; it is largely contingent upon the willingness of the parties to establish a truce.
On the other hand, “arbitration” can either be binding or non-binding depending upon the nature of agreement with the third party. In a non-binding arbitration, the disputant parties may reject or accept the decision off their own accord but a binding arbitration is much like a judicial decision and requires compliance to the verdict whether or not it is approved by the parties. In the play “the merchant of Venice”, the dispute lies between a Christian merchant Antonio and a Jewish moneylender named Shylock. Before, the establishment of the bond between the two parties, there were extraneous variables that contributed to the exacerbation of the conflict that stemmed not only from religious differences, but other deep-seated grievances against each other as well.
Therefore, any form of negotiations or mediation seemed practically ineffective in seeking out a solution for their problem because their dispute went beyond Antonio’s inability to pay off the loan. Their earlier negotiations entitled Shylock to a pound of Antonio’s flesh in case he was unable to pay him back; Antonio’s calculation caused...

Find Another Essay On Dispute Resolution in The Merchant of Venice

The Merchant of Venice Essay

521 words - 2 pages The Merchant Of VeniceAct 1In the fist act, Antonio is introduced as the Merchant of Venice. A friend of him, Bassanio, desperately needs money because all of his money is on his ships and he wants to go to Belmont to visit the woman of his dreams, Portia. Therefore he goes to Antonio to ask if he is willing to go to Shylock and ask him if he can have 3000 ducats. Antonio agrees and goes to Shylock and explains that he has to pay it back within

The Merchant of Venice Essay

2976 words - 12 pages The Merchant of Venice is shows the dynamics of love and to what extent humans will go to show love, they will use their wealth and even be prepared to give up their life for the people they love. Both Antonio and Portia love Bassanio differently. Portia perceives Antonio’s phileo in competition with her eros, (both forms of love will be defined later) and throughout the play she is seen trying to defeat Antonio’s phileo and she does this by

The Merchant Of Venice

756 words - 3 pages Appearances and Decisions ''Don't judge a book by its cover'' is a famous phrase everyone has heard. In the play, The Merchant of Venice, Shakespeare clearly states that outer appearances aren't important throughout many scenes in the play. The inner qualities such as honesty, charity, and kindness are more important. Portia, a beautiful woman, hopes to find a husband ,but she must fulfill her father's will. He designs a lottery

The Merchant of Venice

2425 words - 10 pages The Merchant of Venice The Merchant of Venice was written in 1598 by William Shakespeare. The story is set in Elizabethan times, which was the sixteenth century. People back then were quite prejudiced towards any race that was not Christian. They would have hated Jews. When Shylock would come onto the stage, the audience would have just booed him back off. The Christians had their reasons for hating the Jews. The fact that they supposedly

Racism in The Merchant of Venice

2202 words - 9 pages Racism in The Merchant of VeniceWilliam Shakespeare's satirical comedy, The Merchant of Venice, believed to have been written in 1596 was an examination of hatred and greed. The premise deals with the antagonistic relationship between Shylock, a Jewish money-lender and Antonio, the Christian merchant, who is as generous as Shylock is greedy, particularly with his friend, Bassanio. The two have cemented a history of personal insults, and

Contemporary Issues in The Merchant of Venice

1085 words - 4 pages Contemporary Issues in The Merchant of Venice     Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice is still relevant today because it deals with issues which still affect us. Throughout the play a distinction is made between how things appear and how they are in reality.  The issue of appearance versus reality is demonstrated in varied ways, mainly by the use of real-life situations.  The first representation of this is Shylock's

Women in "The Merchant of Venice"

701 words - 3 pages Characters of Women in "The Merchant of Venice" In his relatively short play, "The Merchant of Venice", Shakespear introduces very new and bright ideas such as women's rights and their equality with men which were totally unacceptable for the people of the Elizabethan time. In that male dominated world women were considered no better than cattle or land and to talk directly about their rights and needs was useless and even

Generosity In Shakespeare's "The Merchant Of Venice"

1123 words - 5 pages In William Shakespeare's play called The Merchant of Venice, the antagonist of the play is Shylock, a wealthy Jewish moneylender. He is probably the most memorable character in the play because of Shakespeare's excellent characterization of him. He is depicted as a greedy man and he is obsessed with money. Another important character is Bassanio, he tries to borrow money from his close friend, Antonio, in order to marry a wealthy heiress, Portia

Religion in The Merchant of Venice

1949 words - 8 pages Religion was a major factor in a number of Shakespeare’s plays. Religion motivated action and reasoning. In Shakespeare’s “The Merchant of Venice,” religion was more than a belief in a higher being; it reflected moral standards and ways of living. In the “Merchant of Venice,” “a Christian ethic of generosity, love, and risk-taking friendship is set in pointed contrast with a non-Christian ethic that is seen, from a Christian point of view, as

Unresolved Issues in The Merchant of Venice

1018 words - 4 pages For much of the play, The Merchant of Venice appears to be vintage Shakespearean farce. A group of buffoons vie to marry the beautiful and wealthy Portia; women dress up as men and fool their betrothed; servants are willing accomplices in playful deceits. Where Merchant of Venice departs from the pattern of a typical Shakespearean farce is with the appearance of Shylock, the Jew. Shylock transforms this play from a simple comedy to a work of

Dispute Resolution in the People's Republic of China

1632 words - 7 pages is to utilise friendly negotiation. The objective is to resolve dispute in the most informal, private and friendly manner. Such an approach to dispute resolution is even gaining international prominence:"China's new and flexible method of seeking amicable and friendly settlements on the basis of mutual understanding, fairness, and justice is the cause of its worldwide recognition."The foreign investors need to appreciate that this is an approach

Similar Essays

The Merchant Of Venice Essay

1209 words - 5 pages Comparison and Contrast of Shylock and Claudius Introduction This essay looks into the lives of Shylock and Antonio. These are two of Shakespearean antagonists of all time. They are alike in more ways than one. Shylock in Merchant of Venice is a Jewish moneylender based in Venice. He has been tormented and repressed mainly by the Christian population. One finds it easy to sympathize with him mainly because he has his own reasons to be loathing

The Merchant Of Venice Essay 1139 Words

1139 words - 5 pages The Merchant of Venice is a play written by William Shakespeare in 1596 and finished writing it in 1598. The play starts off with Bassanio wanting to marry Portia. He confronts Antonio to ask him for a loan so he can have enough money to marry his soon to be wife. Antonio finds he doesn’t have enough money to give Bassanio the loan so he agrees to be the person to guarantee the loan. The two of them find Shylock to give him the loan. Portia then

The Merchant Of Venice Essay 1524 Words

1524 words - 7 pages In the city of Venice, tension arises between a moneylender and a merchant. William Shakespeare conveys this tension through his play The Merchant of Venice. The play is about a merchant, Antonio, who wants to help his friend, Bassanio, regarding his financial problems. However, Antonio’s money is at sea, so Antonio is forced to borrow money from Shylock who is a Jewish moneylender in Venice. Antonio and Shylock despise each other. Shakespeare

"The Merchant Of Venice" Essay

1844 words - 7 pages English Coursework: The Merchant of VeniceThe "merchant of Venice" is a multifarious play with many levels of interpretation. Telling the story of a Jewish merchant living in the predominately Christian capital of Venice, it can be seen as a play about persecution, justice and of social cruelty. The "merchant of Venice" is representatively driven by the same set arguments of racial and religious prejudice that existed in Shakespearean society.In