Dispute Resolution Processes Essay

2502 words - 10 pages

This paper will examine when it is appropriate to attempt alternative dispute resolution (ADR) processes for disputes and conversely when it is fitting for matters to be decided in a courtroom with black-robed judges and well dressed lawyers. Complementing the correct ‘intervention [courtroom, facilitative ADR or another form of ADR] at the right time, price and place with the right disputants’ is not necessarily an easy task (Wade 2010, p. 13) and the line separating alternative dispute resolution processes and judicial intervention can be blurred especially as judicial officers conduct, refer or mandate parties to participate in ADR (Sourdin, 2009, p. 190). Proof that fine panelled courtrooms may not be the answer to dispute settlement is the move towards the ‘mandatory’ use of alternative methods prior to hearings (Ardagh and Cumes, 2007, p. 206).
Do most people with problems want pain relief quickly and inexpensively?
Yes most people in pain want relief quickly and inexpensively but they often want other things too. They want to be heard, they want to heal the hurt and they want a ‘satisfactory [and]… enduring’ outcome (Moore, 2004, p. 2). They also want to change from having ‘a destructive interaction to a constructive one’ (Ardagh, 1999, as cited by Spencer and Hardy, 2009, p. 165).

There are differing views about the suitability of facilitative ADR approaches for various types of conflict. Some believe that this type of ADR is more appropriate for addressing ‘interest disputes than rights disputes’ (Boulle & Nesic, 2001 as cited by Van Gramberg, 2006, p. 121). Van Gramberg states that ‘personal grievances’ may be adequately resolved by facilitative processes but where a law or legal right has been breached then an ADR response is generally not suited to this type of dispute (2006 p. 121). Not all agree with Van Gramberg’s view and restorative justice advocates believe that the criminal victim offender mediation (VOM) and circle sentencing models (for example) can satisfy a victim’s need for justice (Queensland Department of Justice and Attorney-General, 1995, p. 2).

Whilst traditional court process are a vital part of our ‘legal culture’ there is an emerging trend of attempting to negotiate and resolve matters without court intervention and this ‘early problem solving just “makes more sense”’ (Scott, 2008 as cited by Spencer and Hardy, 2009, p. 689) as it allows parties to have greater influence over the outcomes (Zehr, 1985, p. 4). In addition to being usually cheaper and quicker, other ‘benefits’ of mediation include creating a more sustainable outcome as parties in conflict are in charge of the process rather than having it imposed by another. Mediation creates the scope for relationships to be repaired if parties are willing to listen to and acknowledge the other (Street, 2003).

The timeliness that is usually associated with mediation and other ADR processes can be an important contributor to...

Find Another Essay On Dispute Resolution Processes

Benefits of Alternative Dispute Resolution Essay

2283 words - 9 pages The purpose of this paper is to discuss what Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) is and how it came about, what different types of ADR there is to choose from and how ADR benefits both parties compared to litigation. ADR can quickly resolve almost any minor issue regarding most civil cases family, neighbors, employers, contractors, etc. ADR includes mediation (also known as conciliation), arbitration and settlement conferences. Some of the

Conflict Management Essay

4784 words - 20 pages , not the least of which is the current adversarial nature of the industry and its methodologies for resolving disputes.This paper describes a conflict discussion and comparison of dispute resolution techniques. The effort began with the definition of conflict and dispute. In the chapter 2, we discuss the classification and the real causes of conflict. These discussions were essential not only to discuss those elements separately, but also to draw an

Conflict Resolution

820 words - 3 pages sides are not highlighted.(5) Withdrawing in which either one or both sides withdraws from conflict.The term conflict resolution is also known as dispute resolution or alternative dispute resolution. Other methods adopted for conflict resolution includes negotiation, mediation, and diplomacy. Sometimes arbitration, litigation, and formal complaint processes such as ombudsman processes are also referred as conflict resolution".Storybook 1.In this

Internal Memo for Client

1804 words - 7 pages dispute resolution, trial and verdict, judgment and appeal.Initial court paper must be file by the plaintiff in a form of complaint or petition. Then documents will provide an outline of the case against the defendant. The complaint document must include the name of the defendant or parties involved. The complaint should also include a demand judgment or a relief against the defendant. The plaintiff should seek out from the judge on how the payment

Internal Memo for Client

1801 words - 7 pages , alternative dispute resolution, trial and verdict, judgment and appeal.Initial court paper must be file by the plaintiff in a form of complaint or petition. Then documents will provide an outline of the case against the defendant. The complaint document must include the name of the defendant or parties involved. The complaint should also include a demand judgment or a relief against the defendant. The plaintiff should seek out from the judge on how the

Employment Dispute Resolution

1138 words - 5 pages Every employer would like to avoid workplace disputes. However, this is not always possible and litigation is an option. The most common option for commercial disputes is called alternative dispute resolution (ADR), which is primarily an alternative method other than litigation, used to settle legal disputes and employment conflict situations. ADR processes, when properly used, provide due process and an opportunity to be heard in a less formal

The roles of various enforcement agencies, discussing the limitations of legal aid and evaluating the usefulness of alternatives to the court system in resolving disputes

1304 words - 5 pages can take into account factors that a court could not as they are not legally bound by the rules of evidence that do apply in court rooms. Decisions made by State and federal tribunals can appeal to higher courts if needed.The main aim for primary dispute resolutions (PDR) is to conduct disputes between parties outside of courts to save them money, time and also not to involve lawyers, judges and juries. Dispute resolution processes that are

Alternative Dispute Resolution

3377 words - 14 pages process is binding meaning that the parties have to do it. This is not so for the other processes. In conclusion arbitration maybe the most potent and strong method of reaching a resolution but it may not be the right method for the dispute in question. This is why all previous methods of ADR must be tried in an effort to save commercial, working or trade relationships. What must be realised by the parties involved is

The Pros and Cons of Alternative Dispute Resolution

3748 words - 15 pages disadvantages and focus primarily on mediation. The next section will explain the process of mediation and then go on to give reasons as to why court-ordered mediation is inappropriate. ADR is a term generally used to refer to informal dispute resolution processes in which the parties meet with a professional third party (not a judge in his professional capacity and sometimes more than one third party) who helps them resolve their

Globalization Process of Judicial

3045 words - 12 pages Globalization, Processes Of Judicial Globalization, Processes Of Judicial The connection between globalization and dispute resolution by means of various types of procedures has several aspects beyond simply judicial processes involved in globalization. Three significant aspects of globalization have a direct influence upon dispute resolution: The growing globalization of legal culture, due to the fast circulation of information

Features of The Litigation and Mediation Process

931 words - 4 pages There are various features of both the litigation and mediation processes, each affecting the parties to a dispute. Determining these effects depends on the process, what approach is taken by the third parties, the role of the third party, the subject of the disputes and the binding nature of the final outcome. The objectives of each process also play a vital role in determining the impact that is felt by parties. There are a multitude of

Similar Essays

Dispute Resolution Processes Essay

1425 words - 6 pages Dispute Resolution Processes Wherever there is a human-interaction, conflict is virtually unpreventable. For-instance, some conflict may well erupt a dispute in any structure of relationships, and other perhaps resulting in extremely compound international confrontation and hostility. It isn't that they can't see the solution. It is that they can't see the problem (G. K. Chesterton). Consequently, dispute resolution processes have been

Legal Process Essay

2269 words - 10 pages IntroductionDue to the evolution of family groups, societies and communities, people have established a variety of methods to deal with specific disputes and conflict. Issues of legal cost and access to justice have given rise to various alternative processes avoiding the formal Criminal Justice System. The purpose of this essay is to describe Alternative Dispute Resolution methods and principles, and to explore the strengths and limitations of

Dispute Summary Essay

848 words - 3 pages An alternative dispute resolution describes numerous approaches to resolve conflict, which avoid the cost, delay, and unpredictability of the traditional adjudicator processes at the same time improving workplace communication and morale. This paper will discuss the advantages of using an alternative dispute resolution within the workplace, the types of alternate dispute resolution that can be chosen based on what would best fit the dispute

Dispute Summary Essay

1169 words - 5 pages fair and equitable way" without necessitating the expense of a "traditional lawsuit" (Wikipedia).The Alternative Dispute Resolution processes in this case appear to meet this standard of fairness and equity. The facts of the case make plain that the plaintiff was operating in a hostile work environment. As such, she is clearly deserving of an award of both compensatory damages and attorney's fees. However, although the plaintiff's former employer