Distinctions And Comparisons Between Aristotle And Plato

1638 words - 7 pages

The ideas introduced by Plato on the theory of forms, where deducted and critiqued by Aristotle. Both philosophers can be viewed as having opposing ideologies. Nonetheless, Plato and Aristotle are in agreement on certain factors of their philosophy.
Many have scrutinized and compared the dissimilarities and similarities of Aristotle's doctrine of categories and Plato's theory of forms. The observations found are of an interesting nature.
The beauty behind the writings of Plato is to not accept what is interpreted through the senses. In Plato's theory of forms, Plato explained the immaterial world as the realm containing the perfect form of objects and ideas that are presented on Earth. For instance, the idea of justice is inadequate on Earth, but in an alternate universe the idea of justice is in its perfect form.
When comparing living things, Plato would describe the object he viewed in the physical world as an idea or an imperfect form of the object he studied. If Plato were to observe a tree in the physical realm he would add “ness” to an object to make it known that the tree he saw before him was participating in the form of a tree, and is merely an outline of an ideal tree.
Aristotle disagreed with Plato’s ideology of an immaterial world and an invisible world not seen by the human eye. The system of Aristotle’s logical explanations against Plato’s theory of forms, were made through observations of the physical world. Aristotle unlike Plato trusted the senses as a tool to judge reality. He found Plato’s theory of forms defective, for he thought true reality contained concrete objects that one perceived through the senses. To oppose Plato’s theory, Aristotle created his doctrine of categories.
The doctrine of categories explained that an object contains certain groups that define that particular object, whether it be quality, quantity, relation or substance. Aristotle considered every characteristic examined in a particular object as a distinction that defined that specific entity. Aristotle believed that the substance of a particular living thing (such as a bird) indicates a true independent existence. The other qualities of a living thing such as height and color are imitative traits of being in that they are present only to an individual substance.
As Aristotle studied an object he would use the word “this” to describe that he was observing a particular object. When examining an animal like a horse, he would bear in mind that the horse was independent of other horses due to certain physical characteristics that separated that individual horse from other horses. The natural scientist and philosopher, Aristotle opposed Plato’s perspective of not considering characteristics that an object contained which created an individual identity of that specific object.
Plato’s concept of an alternate universe, containing perfect forms of objects was in Aristotle’s view a foolish assumption. Aristotle believed that there was a point in...

Find Another Essay On Distinctions and Comparisons between Aristotle and Plato

Plato and Aristotle Essay

1272 words - 5 pages addressing emotional stability. One important consideration is the approach Plato takes in relation to Aristotle. It is this approach that we will see actually mirroring between how they treat emotional well-being and their tolerance for imitation. In order to understand this hypothesis that each thinker’s handling of wellness is representative of how they handle imitation (and thus, representation), we need to step back and examine how in

Comparing Plato and Aristotle Essay

2127 words - 9 pages mastery of these abilities is called intellectual virtue. There are many similarities between Plato's and Aristotle's work considering Plato was once Aristotle's teacher. However there are also many differences. Plato claims there are three virtues in a stable state: wisdom, courage, and moderation. Aristotle says there are only two virtues: intellectual and moral. In Book II of Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics he uses the idea of the mean to

Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle

856 words - 3 pages Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle, three men considered to be the quintessential basis of ancient Greek philosophy. Not only were they responsible for Greek enlightenment, but also foreshadowed the coming of Christ in there speculations. Plato, the protégé of Socrates, became the first to document the philosophy of his teacher, which in turn is passed down to Aristotle. This process of mentoring aided ancient man in the intellectual evolution

Political Justice: Plato and Aristotle

2208 words - 9 pages Plato and Aristotle had different ideas of politics and political justice. In The Republic, Plato creates the ideal city, which is needed to guarantee justice. He aims to create a peaceful united city that will lead to the greater good of the community and individuals. Unlike Plato who imagines the ideal city, Aristotle looks at actual cities in The Politics. He doesn't want to create the ideal city; he aims to improve the existing city. While

Classical Theories - Aristotle and Plato

1909 words - 8 pages Plato and Aristotle have both documented strong opinions about the influence and social purpose of poetry. Plato, in The Republic, outlines reasons for his `refusal to admit the imitative kind of poetry'(Plato cited in ed. Adams 1992, p. 31). Plato's reference to `poetry' does not apply to the poetry of contemporary society, as it was a performance art and not meant for silent reading and reflection. Julia Annas (1981, p. 94) believes that

Aristotle and Plato "Ideal Government"

1618 words - 7 pages Aristotle and Plato had this idea in their minds that there was an Ideal Government. Meaning that there was a way for someone or a group of people to perfectly control a community where everybody would have equal rights, there would be no fights and everything was perfectly under control. As of right now we believe that there is no possible way for somebody to do that, but back then Aristotle and Plato believed that they were perfectly right

Comparisons between Gatsby and Myrtle

667 words - 3 pages unfold and reach its end, we see the last similarities between the two characters. Their deaths hold similar aspects in their own way. Though one is a mistake, there is not confusing that both characters were ultimately killed. Myrtle’s death was an accident caused by Daisy running her over with the car. This death, nonetheless, caused Gatsby’s demise in the end. Wilson, Myrtle husband, intending to kill Myrtle’s lover, assumes it is Gatsby, and

Historical Views of Leadership: Plato and Aristotle

1780 words - 7 pages considered citizens. None of these have a say in the government. Like Plato, he believed that the individual soul “contains a rational ruling part and an irrational part that is ruled” (Edel, 1967, p. 153), and this carries over into his idea of the State. Therefore, Aristotle did, in fact, believe in an inherent difference between leaders and followers. His pool of leaders is just larger than Plato’s. Finally, Aristotle agreed with Plato

Examining the Ethics of Plato and Aristotle

1051 words - 4 pages This essay will be examining the ethics of Plato (428-347 BCE) and Aristotle (384-322 B.C). I will firstly attempt to summarise the five fundamental concepts of Plato and Aristotle before providing my own opinion and view on their ethics. I will concentrate on their theories on the good life as a life of justice, censorship, knowledge and the good life. I will first examine Plato’s ethics. Plato was a philosopher who was both a rationalist

Arroyo Administration: The Plato and Aristotle Views

2842 words - 11 pages enough to support their basic needs and some minute luxuries. At the bottom are the poor. These are those that could not even support their necessities. And this class actually constitutes a large proportion of our population. That is why Philippines can still be considered a poor country, belonging to the third world. The classification of the people today is somewhat the same with what Plato and Aristotle had described. However, there are

A Comparison of Plato and Aristotle

1892 words - 8 pages proceeded to ratify it. According to Plato and Aristotle, a Bill of Rights is not necessary because it does not improve the good of the community.Another point of discrepancy between the philosophers and today's society involves the topic of slavery. Aristotle argues for the naturalness of slavery in The Politics, yet slavery has been considered grotesque for quite some time. In correlation to slavery, there is the undermining of the female population

Similar Essays

Comparison Between Aristotle And Plato Essay

1380 words - 6 pages what sets the guidelines for societal behavior.Aristotle puts emphasis on the institution of the polis (Hacker 77). This institution is not the state or society merely the larger unit of the two (hacker 77). Neither Plato nor Aristotle foundit to be necessary to distinguish between the state nor society and therefore it is difficult to define polis (Hacker 77). The polis was set up to allow political participation on the part of the average

Conversation Between Plato And Aristotle Essay

969 words - 4 pages Dialogue Between Plato and Aristotle 2 As students file into the auditorium of the Academy the first thing that we all notice is the two professors that were standing at the front of the room. After all the students were seated that is when the first professor stepped forward to address the class. Plato: Good Morning Students! Students: Good Morning Professor! Plato: Many of you may know who I am and then there are those of you that do not

A Essay Written To Describe The Difference Between Plato And Aristotle

1616 words - 6 pages state before oneself, this state is highly unfeasible due to the fact that humans are not completely flawless.The separation between professor and pupil can be seen in Aristotle's Politics, whereas Plato maintains Socrates' quest for the ideal state founded solely upon reason, Aristotle generates the idea that one can only attain the best form of government through practice and progression.Aristotle regards monarchy, aristocracy and constitutional

Discuss One Disagreement Or Agreement Between Plato And Aristotle. Who Do You Think Is More Consistent With Greek Cultural Tradition?

675 words - 3 pages as “The Reader” simply because he tended to overachieve by writing notes and doing extra reading to know more than others. Aristotle established a school called Lyceum and believed that a person needed only logic which was the technical test for the truth. Mean while, between Plato and Aristotle, they had a handful of differences and agreements on certain aspects such as the knowledge of forms and reality; world/forms/ideas. Aristotle was