Identifying The Day We Were Dogs

1010 words - 4 pages

Identifying The Day We Were Dogs

 
     Whether or not "The Day We Were Dogs" (1993) is a magical realist story is questionable. Often stories are misidentified because of the closeness of literature such as magical realism, the fantastic, and the sublime. The story leaves a lot to one's imagination instead of presenting it in the text. Elena Garro blends two days and two completely different worlds together in this story.

The magical elements depend on how one uses his or her imagination throughout this story. The girls could either be pretending to be dogs or they could have actually become dogs. If they are in fact real dogs, they are able to talk, and their dog Toni also talks. Also, magic numbers are used throughout the story. The main magical element is the blending of the two days. The story jumps back and forth between the two and never distinguishes between them.

The realistic elements include Toni's actions. He shows how dogs spend their days lying under a tree and eating all day. Another realistic element depends on how one accepted the events that happened within the two parallel days. If the girls were not actually turned in to dogs but were just pretending, then this fact is another realistic element. Children often pretend they are animals, expecially dogs.

In magical realism, "the text contains something we cannot explain according to the laws of the universe as we know them" (Faris 167) and the "descriptions detail a stong presence of the phenomenal world" (Faris 169). These quotes explain why one might think that this story is magical realism due to the two different worlds that are going on at the same time. Also, one "experience[s] the closeness or near-merging of two realms, two worlds" (Faris 172), and the "boundary is blurred between fact and fiction" (Faris 173) in 'The Day We Were Dogs.' If in fact the girls were turned into dogs, this occurrence would also point to this story being magical realism because "metamorphoses are a relatively common event" (Faris 178).

The characters in this story did not hesitate. As a matter of fact, they did not hesitate when the children were turned into dogs and could speak. The reader does hesitate quite a bit. There is no hesitation between the author and the events. The author, Elena Garro, in the way she blends the two worlds and the two days together, leaves a lot of questions to the reader. It is difficult to figure out what is happening in the two different days. One tries to figure out if the girls are actual dogs or if they are just pretending.

The purpose of the story seems to be to heighten one's sense of reality about the world around him or her. It shows there may possibly be other dimensions and other worlds that are taking place at the same time. It makes one wonder about the world as we know it.

In fantastic literature, there is either the uncanny (which is the natural) and the marvelous (which is the supernatural). Both are used in this story...

Find Another Essay On Identifying The Day We Were Dogs

Relates to "When we were kings", "Bowling for columbine", and "Do the right thing"

1108 words - 4 pages Force is something that we have all experienced. Force can be positive or negative. Violence and persuasion are two types of force that are present in the three movies. The three movies we watched in class all use force to get their message across. In Bowling for Columbine Michael Moore uses persuasion as a type of force; while Do the Right Thing and When we were Kings use violence as a force. Force can have a great impact on a person's

In the documentary When We Were Kings, how does the filmaker position the veiwer feel about the documentary?

867 words - 3 pages When We Where KingsDocumentary studies by TristanThe documentary, When We Were Kings, is the story of Muhammad Ali's return to Africa to regain his title as heavyweight boxing champion of the world from George Forman. As the filmmaker follows the fight to Africa, we see the build up to the championship fight as well as a connotative story developing regarding the nation of Africa. With the use of actuality footage, archival footage and

Women of "The Underdogs" We were asked to write a 7-8 page paper on Mariano Azuela's "The Underdogs," and how women were portrayed in it, as well as whether or not we felt the portrayal was accurate.

2386 words - 10 pages from the novel.Women in Mexican Society: Pre-RevolutionIn order to effectively understand how women's roles in Mexican society changed during the Mexican Revolution, we must examine the societal expectations of women's behavior before this tumultuous time in their history. Women in Mexico between the 18th and 19th centuries experienced many changes as the enlightenment swept across Europe and impacted Spain. Were women only good for producing

Compare the three speeches (The Gettysburg Address, St Crispin's Day Speech, We Go To Liberate Not To Conquer)

1974 words - 8 pages Gettysburg Address', 'St Crispin's Day speech' and 'We go to liberate not to conquer'. The audiences for those three speeches were, to a certain extent, linked to the military affairs, wars and battles. ('The Gettysburg Address' - American civil war, 'St Crispin's Day speech' - The battle of Agincourt and 'We go to liberate not to conquer' - Iraq War)Shakespeare's St Crispin's Day speech is written for his play 'Henry V' in 1598 - ten years after

A Comparison of The Mill on the Floss by George Eliot, Passage to India by E.M. Foster, and When We Were Orphans by Kazuo Ishiguro

2966 words - 12 pages A Comparison of The Mill on the Floss by George Eliot, Passage to India by E.M. Foster, and When We Were Orphans by Kazuo Ishiguro The three extracts I have chosen are all written in a relatively similar style, I am rather partial to this style, ergo the motive for choosing them. This will however, make contrasting them a little harder, however I believe that the consequent refined subtleties will provide a more

Document Based Essay Question describing the Great Depression. Summary and how it affected the US - problems we faced and how they were resolved

1908 words - 8 pages problems elsewhere in the world. People were stuck relying on dictators to lead them out of hard times. Roosevelt, on the other hand, used the powers of the Federal Government to restore economic health and preserve liberties.Overall, I think that the New Deal was helpful for the nation. It could have been worse; we could have been stuck with Hoover and not have had any solution. Fortunately, for President Roosevelt, we were able to pull ourselves

A Study of the Operations Management at HOLLY FARM- an icecream manufacturing company. We were required to find the feasibility of expanding teh facilities and production processes.

3659 words - 15 pages capacity constraints would be caused.2.2.2 Milking ParlourAccording to this case, the number of visitors who want to see the milking parlour on a busy day in2003 was 206. However, the capacity of the gallery for watching milking parlour is 200 visitors per day (Calculation 2). It could be said that they are about going over the capacity in 2003. Moreover, Gillian wishes to increase the number of farm visitors in 2004 by 50%. The problem would grow

The 19th centuary has had a huge impact on our lives today without the inventions, ideas and philosophies that were developed then we wouldnt have what we have today.

598 words - 2 pages Movers and Shakers of the 19th CenturyWith each period of history, come great people. This is to say the same for the 19th century, for with this time came inventions, philosophies, literary works and much more that have helped developed the world as we know it today. Women were not treated as equals, religious views were different and the question if there was a god came to people's minds. Also, if it weren't for this period in history, science

Me and My Bestie. This essay was written on a personal experience level. We were to pick a conflict and look at all the possible outcomes.

2141 words - 9 pages I have been best friend with Amy for almost six years. The bond between the two of us is so deep at times it's scary. It even reached a point where I knew what she was thinking before she had a chance to say anything out loud. We were constantly together having a great time! Often people who met us together thought we were sisters and confused our names. In a weird sense we were sisters, minus the DNA connection. It's odd, things had been this

This is a Discriptive Essay needed for English 101. The title is "Going Home". We needed to describe in our essay so people could "see" what we were talking about.

687 words - 3 pages yellow and black sunflowers while the blue blossoms are appearing on the pinto beans. It is halfway until harvest time.The last half-mile, down the driveway was the worst. The house looks just like I remember in my dreams. The quanset, barn, grain bins and the fields, nothing has changed. We pull up to the garage; grandma and grandpa come out of the side door. Everyone piles out of the truck to fight for the hugs and kisses that were missed in the

This paper is about realizing that everything that we do here on this earth will count for us or against us in the day of judgment...

3129 words - 13 pages account thereof in the Day of Judgment.Romans 14:12So then every one of us shall give account of himself to God.Today, we are going to look at how our characters are the accumulation of the decisions that we have made, how our character is either growing in a good direction or a bad direction, and realize that with every action, choice, or thought we are becoming more like God or more like the devil: and with these choices and actions we are

Similar Essays

"The Greek Authors Were The Pioneers Of Modern Day Literature" Discuss This In Relevence Of Texts You Have Studied. Text We Studied ~Homer The Iilad Book 22 ~Sopohcles King Oedipus ~Plato Crito

738 words - 3 pages The Greek authors were the pioneers of modern day literature. They were some of the very first to ignore practicality - they used their writing, not just to record the past, but to entertain. Art. The Greeks were the ones who took the first steps toward what we know as society today. The Greek authors were sophisticated, they were knowledgeable, but, most importantly, they knew how to conjure up a good story. And using their innovative skills in

"We Were The Mulvaneys" By Joyce Carol Oates.

1002 words - 4 pages The book, "We Were the Mulvaneys" by Joyce Carol Oates, is the story of an "all American family" that falls apart after their daughter is raped. The father, who once had a successful roofing company, lets his business slide and devotes his life to alcohol and law suits, and the three brothers either abandon the family or try to find a method of gaining vengeance for their sister. This particular excerpt describes a scene by the brook, where the

If We Were To Overthrow The Current Political System, What Should We Replace It With?

2150 words - 9 pages gain more. As a result of the renounce, people receive a part of the whole. To be precise, the general will consists of both particular wills of everyone and will of all. Particular wills are people’s interests; whereas will of all is a shared interest which could also be wrong. The general will goes further these categories in order to benefit the entire society. The social contract turns interesting if we focus on the importance that the author

There Were Twenty Or More Pre Trials Or Trials That Day. The Speed In Which They Were Handled Was Surprisingly

1434 words - 6 pages we quickly went to the fifth floor courtrooms to find a trial. Upon reaching the fifth floor we found that on that particular Thursday there were several pre-trials being held instead of a single trial. These are the observations that we made in Courtroom 2B on that day. The courtroom was very busy that day as we entered. Many well-dressed attorneys were scrambling about the courtroom talking to their own clients