Lack Of Diversity In The Judiciary

1345 words - 6 pages

It is widely acknowledged that the judiciary within England and Wales is not representative of the wider society. The composition of the judiciary is regularly subject to criticism on its apparent homogenous identity’ being largely comprised of elderly, white male barristers educated at Oxford or Cambridge. This ethos has prevented diversity within the judiciary, particularly the upper echelons of the judiciary. Academics such as John Griffith have suggested that the narrow range of the judiciary threatens to undermine public confidence in the judicial system. Similarly, Baroness Hale argues that a representative judiciary is paramount for directives associated with the promotion of equal opportunities and strengthening of judicial legitimacy. The government has attempted to combat these issues with statutory and procedural changes to the Courts and Legal Service Act 1990, the Courts Act 2003, the Constitutional Reform Act 2005, and the Judicial Appointments Committee. However, the government’s reforms have made little impact on the demographic profile of the judiciary, as the cornerstone of all judicial appointments is merit. Until diversity can break into the judiciary, particularly the upper echelons of the judiciary there will continue to be a lingering threat to the publics confidence of the judiciary as diversification has yet to materialize.

Structural changes prior 2005

Prior to the 2005 reforms, the appointment of judges to England and Wales’s judiciary was fraught with secrecy and bias with a total disregard for transparency and accountability. The old ways of appointment have been described as an “old boys” network of informality creating a self-sustaining system. John Griffith argues this in his work, Politics of the Judiciary, that the limited range of backgrounds from which members of the judiciary are drawn has resulted in the existence of a judiciary that is biased in preserving their traditional and established interests. These problems blossomed in the old system of selecting judges. The Court and Legal Service Act 1990(amended by Courts Act 2003, s71) was the governments initial attempt in diversifying the judiciary. It aimed to formalize the appointment process while expanding the ability to acquire rights of audience to any legally qualified person; whilst, making appointments to the judiciary dependent on practical experience. However, this proved unsuccessful, culminating in a published report in 2003 by the Judicial Appointments Commission expressing, “ that there was systematic bias in the way that the judiciary and the legal profession operated. This bias prevented women ethnic minorities and solicitors from applying successfully for judicial office”.
In 2005, the Constitutional Reform Act, created a new procedure for appointing judges up to and including the High Court. The Act states that there is a need to encourage diversity in the range or person’s available for selection 64(1) but...

Find Another Essay On Lack of Diversity in the Judiciary

The Power of the Judiciary Essay

1653 words - 7 pages Albert LairsonPS 1Professor MitchellTHE POWER OF THE JUDICIARYWhen the founding fathers of our country, and by that I mean the Federalists, were creating the system of government for America, they knew that a separation of power would be necessary to protect the American people from the evils of a monarchy or dictatorship. In doing this, they created the three branches of government; Legislative, Executive, and Judiciary. The plan was to have

The Lack of Family Ties in Frankenstein

866 words - 3 pages , depressing times in Frankenstein’s life. The boy only wanted attention from his father. The scene of greatest depiction of Frankenstein’s gluttonous, self-indulgent negligence is that of his child’s first moments of life. It takes but a night to steer his creature to the path of destructive apathy. Frankenstein has no care for those around him, and should never have been given the secret to life, considering his lack of interest in family and his

Lack of Creativity in the Medieval Period

1161 words - 5 pages Lack of ego, violence, and unproductiveness were some of the few characteristics Manchester attributed to the medieval mind. During this period of history, the people lacked creativity and only used the mechanisms that were created by the generations before. Violence helped noblemen rise to define themselves while the creative ones took generations to build a cathedral because they only cared about glorifying God. Knowing their identity in life

The Lack of Man in Lac Léman

1982 words - 8 pages a sense of inertia in the individual. This notion of water is connected to the repression of Quebec nationality. The book discusses water in a variety of different contexts: as the primary foundation for the story (as interpreted by the translator), as a metaphor for self and as a replacement for language. Water, weaved into a nationalistic allegory, is given conflicting attributes and is both a life giver and life taker simultaneously. This

Lack of Privacy in the United States

1095 words - 4 pages “They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.”― Benjamin Franklin. Despite the fact that these words are three centuries old, they are magnificently related to the present. The world nowadays is going towards constant technological advances and political turmoil. Evolution of technology is considered as the best thing that happened to human kind; however, the lack of privacy comes

The Lack of Credibility in Homer's Iliad

1405 words - 6 pages fact that it was an oral story long before it was written in the form it is today, is the cause of oversight of the narrative qualities of Homer's Iliad by many critics. The narration of the story has, however, been noted as a classic example of in medias res. "The term is derived from Horace, literally meaning `in the midst of things'. It is applied to the literary technique of opening a story in the middle of the action and then applying

Essay about the importance of the independence of the judiciary in Australia

1830 words - 7 pages Foundations Essay - Independence of the JudiciaryTo understand the expression 'the independence of the judiciary' you first must understand what is meant my judiciary. The judicature is:The judicial power of the commonwealth shall be vested in a Federal Supreme Court, to be called the High Court of Australia, and in such other federal courts as the Parliament creates, and in such other courts as it invests with federal jurisdiction. The High

The Lack of Women's role in society in the 1950s

1702 words - 7 pages Due to the idealization of domesticity in media, there was a significantly stagnant period of time for women’s rights between 1945 and 1959. Women took over the roles for men in the workplace who were fighting abroad during the early 1940s, and a strong, feminist movement rose in the 1960s. However, in between these time periods, there was a time in which women returned to the home, focusing their attention to taking care of the children and

The Beauty of the Lack of Structure in My Antonia

1593 words - 6 pages with a language barrier), and Jim's close knit family that shelters him greatly from the harshness that the Shimerda's face.    The ending shows Antonia's success in Nebraska and Jim's failure in the East because he lives in the past.  "He is generous enough to rejoice her good fortune, but it merely underlines his own lack of progress, and even regression...The more she tells him about her successful present, the more his mind wanders back to

Impact of the Lack of Female Representation in America’s Government

1650 words - 7 pages covers of magazines when freshman senators were running for office. This phenomenon was not caused by the media’s lack of coverage on female authoritarians; it was caused by the fact that very few of such women exist. I began to wonder: why is there such a lack of female representation in the United States national government? Furthermore, what are the implications of this lack of representation for women like myself and for the citizens of this

The Effects of Lack of Sleep in High School Students

779 words - 4 pages homework assignments that take several hours and cause them to sleep late. As a result, high school students who need a minimum of eight to nine hours of sleep barely receive seven. This shortage in sleep often causes several detrimental consequences. However, there is a simple solution to this dilemma. High school classes should start later in the day because the associated lack of sleep negatively affects behavior, academic success, and

Similar Essays

Women In The Judiciary Essay

2720 words - 11 pages Women in the Judiciary You can't be shining lights at the bar because you are too kind. You can never be corporation lawyers because you are not cold-blooded. You have not a high grade of intellect. You can never expect to get the fees men get. I doubt if you [can] ever make a living. Of course you can be divorce lawyers. That is a useful field. And there is another field you can have solely for your own. You can't make a living at it, but it's

The Judiciary In Ireland: Interpreter Of The Constitution

1560 words - 6 pages The Judiciary’s foremost role is to defend and uphold the constitution and to assure rule of law prevails in a country. In some ways it is the watchdog for the rights and liberties of the citizens. The Judiciary acts as a guardian of the constitution, arbitrates between the people and the legislature. Having said that has the Judiciary become puissant? Should we cap the amount of power it posses at present? I will discuss the question at hand

How Is The Independence Of The Judiciary Guaranteed In Australia?

880 words - 4 pages a) How is the independence of the judiciary guaranteed in Australia?While the Westminster system had largely developed because of the doctrine of separation of powers, the Australian system of government is largely based on the Westminster. This doctrine of separation of powers proposes that the three institutions of government, the legislature, the executive and the judiciary should be exercised as separate and independent branches. It is this

The Power Of The Judiciary Essay

1514 words - 6 pages The Power of The Judiciary      When the founding fathers of our country, and by that I mean the Federalists, were creating the system of government for America, they knew that a separation of power would be necessary to protect the American people from the evils of a monarchy or dictatorship. In doing this, they created the three branches of government; Legislative, Executive, and Judiciary. The plan was