Do Greater School Autonomy And Accountability Make A Difference?

2650 words - 11 pages

Introduction
A large body of literature in economics, education, and sociology shows that students attending private schools outperform students attending traditional public schools in a wide range of outcomes. Since a common feature of private schools is their autonomy from school district offices, these findings strengthen initiatives to improve outcomes of public school students through the establishment of charter public schools in the United States, free schools in the United Kingdom, independent public schools in Australia, and community-managed schools in many developing countries. It is often unclear, however, whether private and independent public schools causally improve student outcomes and, even if they do, which characteristics drive such improvements.
Studies attempting to identify the effects of private or charter schooling and to disentangle the various causal mechanisms face several challenges. First, it is difficult to identify the causal effects of independent public or private schooling on students’ outcomes on the basis of most observational data available because unobserved selection bias is pervasive and challenging to address (Altonji et al. 2005a). Although recent natural experimental evidence based on the random assignment of private school vouchers or oversubscribed charter school slots to low-income applicants shows significant positive effects of these schools on student outcomes, it is still difficult to learn precisely which aspects of these schools explain the differences in outcomes. When these studies compare the outcomes between the randomly selected receivers (treatment group) and non-receivers (control group) of private school vouchers or charter school slots, the estimated effects of private or charter schooling capture the overall differences in peer quality and other dimensions of school and teacher quality between the highly sought-after schools and the default traditional public schools. In some cases, the newly introduced randomization programs would also put competitive pressures on existing public schools in which the control groups enroll, and hence would change the outcome trajectories of the control groups and bias the estimates. As applicants may differ from the general student population, it is also unclear whether the effects will be similar if these programs are scaled up.
The objectives of this study are two-fold. First, using a unique randomized natural experiment in Seoul, South Korea (hereafter Korea), we show that private high schools are more effective than public high schools in generating positive educational outcomes. Since the 1970s and until recently, the Korean government had implemented the so-called ‘equalization policy’ in several major metropolitan areas, where students were randomly assigned to different high schools within school districts of their residence. The random assignment in Seoul indicates that, although motivated parents may choose to live in a neighborhood with...

Find Another Essay On Do Greater School Autonomy and Accountability Make a Difference?

People who make a difference Essay

832 words - 4 pages like performances of a play. She used to plan out exactly what she would say – and how she would deliver her punch lines to make the most of her important points. She did not care if a person stood up to challenge her, she explained the truth of freedom for everyone to all people, and was a positive influence for all ex-slaves. This person should be included in the curriculum of all secondary schools and the school board should accept this new

Can Teenagers Make A Difference? Essay

658 words - 3 pages teenagers can make a difference whether it’s conquering the world or revolutionizing the weapons used to do it. There are so many more teenagers that have made remarkable contributions to our everyday lives. Samuel Colt changed the world by age sixteen. Alexander the Great conquered Greece by the time he was 18 and later the whole world by the time he was 33. Teens are just as capable as adult and often only need something to trigger that idea that changes the world, but it’s chance and more often than not they don’t get that chance.

Rwanda Churches Make a Difference

1002 words - 4 pages genocide the perish promoted that those who were being persecuted were on the side of god. Paster Stephane discouraged participation in the genocide and urged community members against the use of violence. In Kirinda the churches were depended on for basic needs, but the church established division between the classes. The greater a family’s access to church resources, the greater their changes of improving their social and economic status (212

One Person Can Make a Difference

852 words - 3 pages the experience as he gave. I’ve asked him how he found the courage to be a donor and he says he just believed it was the right thing to do. Maybe that is what makes a hero, someone who has the courage to speak out and act on their beliefs. He is certainly a hero to me. I believe one person can make a difference. I’ve seen it in my own life and I’ve seen throughout history that an individual who speaks out or acts on their beliefs can make a difference. I think of this often when I am confronted by challenges. Will I remain silent or will I have the courage to act?

Global Warming - We CAN Make a Difference

1283 words - 5 pages Global Warming - We CAN Make a Difference What is global warming, and how is it affecting the Earth and its inhabitants? The greenhouse effect and global warming both correspond with each other. The green house effect is incoming solar radiation that passes through the Earth's atmosphere and heats the earths surface. It absorbed much of the outgoing infrared radiation re-radiated by the Earths surface. As they absorb the infrared the

Nursing Shortage: What can be Done to Make a Difference?

5233 words - 21 pages accountability do not bode well for a profession that lacks the authority to create systemic change within the highly complex health care delivery system.Why would a nurse who spent countless hours in school learning to be a nurse, study for boards and pass the exam turn around and abandon the career they have worked so hard for? The reasons are varied why nurses are not following through with their career choice. When nurses were surveyed when they leave the

Trying to Make a Difference in the World

1786 words - 7 pages gambling. Trying to make a difference in the world seems to be less exciting than sex, drugs, and rock and roll, so less people tend to take the obviously more challenging risk, even though the reward seems to be far greater. People want the “here and now” experience, not the “put in lots of work and potentially fail” experience. Not only does risk taking have to do with sensation, but also personality and behavior. If one doesn’t want to

Can Economic Aid Make a Difference in Flow of Drugs?

1069 words - 4 pages number of Latin American people, they disagree about whether or not economic aid from the United States can make a big enough difference to slow the drug flow into the country. 2. Some experts believe crop substitution is one way the economic aid money could be used to curb drug trafficking. Bruce Michael Bagley, from the Journal of International Studies and World Affairs, reports that the United States could help the Latin American

Exploring How I Would Make High School and College A Better Place

697 words - 3 pages Exploring How I Would Make High School and College A Better PlaceEvery day teenagers are asked many questions about school when coming across adults who are wild about school and college. The most popular question asked to us is "Do you like your school?" and the answer is normally "no." However, no well thought out explanation about why we do not like our school is ever said. I attend Frederick K.C. Price the 3rdhigh, a college preparatory

Major Effects of Globalization Like Adapting to Changes, Lower Tariffs and Cheaper Labor Cost Make a Difference on Philippine Economy and Firms

2687 words - 11 pages Major Effects of Globalization Like Adapting to Changes, Lower Tariffs and Cheaper Labor Cost Make a Difference on Philippine Economy and FirmsA research paperPresented toJose Cristina Pariña, Ph.D.In partial FulfillmentOf the Requirements forENGLRES2012-2013Nikka Jennine L. EscoberAlejandrea A. LalataApril 1, 2013OutlineIntroductionAdopting to ChangesA. Technological developments1. Communication2. TransportationB. Internet as an agent of

Strong drink is a greater menace to man kind than drugs? do you agree?

513 words - 2 pages person under the age of 18 may purchase alcohol, but drugs on the other hand are much easier to obtain. Adding to this problem is that people who have sufficient money and the right contacts can obtain substances to make cheaper and more harmful drugs, which they will sell to desperate teenagers. This will lead to a great amount of deaths within our youth.There are more high school dropouts because of drugs. Dagga impairs concentration and the ability

Similar Essays

Make A Difference Essay

1124 words - 4 pages Make A Difference I have always wanted to be an elementary school teacher ever since I was young. My grandmother was a third grade teacher, and after every school year she would give me her old books that she no longer used. I was so excited when she gave them to me. As soon as she handed them to me I would make my younger brother play school with me. From the first day she gave me her old school books, there was no doubt in my mind

To Make A Difference Essay

932 words - 4 pages To Make A Difference We build our lives upon what we have been taught. From basic skills in reading, writing, and arithmetic to the importance of social interaction, teachers are given the opportunity to make a difference in the lives of their students. I feel that the greatest impact a teacher can have on their students is to fill them with a desire to learn. I think the nature of students can vary tremendously depending on several

Make A Difference Essay

919 words - 4 pages takes place at school every single day. Some teachers do not always see every side to every story so there is not much they can do about it. If a student witnesses one of their classmates being bullied, there are plenty of ways to help. When kids see bullying, they might not know what to do. They might be worried or feel like they might get bullied themselves so they just stay silent and keep their mouths closed. But, if they feel brave enough they

Can Teenagers Make A Difference? Essay

887 words - 4 pages do. One teenager who made a difference was Samuel Colt; he was born in Connecticut in the year 1814 on July 19. He got his inspiration to make the revolver when he was on a boat and the ship’s wheel intrigued him, mostly that it could alternately spin or be locked in a fixed position with the use of a clutch. Samuel Colt invented a revolver that could be fired multiple times before having to reload it. Then in the year 1846 during