Do Gene Selectionist Approaches In Evolutionary Theory Entail Genetic Determinism?

1632 words - 7 pages

"...what answers we find satisfying will always depend on the questions we ask." (Rowland 2004: 11)Gene selectionist approaches in evolutionary theory entail genetic determinism. Gene selectionist approaches concerning the individual do not entail genetic determinism although genomic structure is highly influential on an individual. Moreover the popular doctrine and dogma of genetic determinism needs to be revised in order to lessen confusion and clarify what genetic determinism really is. One need only scrape the surface of evolutionary theory to see the enormous amount of information in regards to it and the equally gargantuan number of conflicting theories under its broad banner. Epigenesis may be beneficial in providing a broad new paradigm and creating synthesis between continually specializing disciplines. It provides solutions in study of the individual and contributes to a greater understanding of the contributing factors of genes in evolutionary theory.'A doctrine of genic selectionism is that natural selection is the sole mechanism of evolution.' (Dusek 1998). This is true, for what exists that is not a product of and subject to the laws of the natural world? One may talk of sexual selection, cultural conditioning and human choice. All of these are influences within the parameters of natural selection. It is clear that genes are heritable and contain information for creation, so genetic determinism is obviously apparent in the study of evolution. It is valid in the study of evolution because it would appear genes are the mode of transmission and demonstrate the effects of natural selection. Environment acts upon and alters genes; genes are passed on through generations according to natural selection. Many differing understandings of genetic determinism have passed through much literature. Currently the widely circulated concept of genetic determinism is as follows:1. Genes determine characters in a straightforward, additive way: one gene-one protein, and by implication, one character. Environmental influence, if it occurs, can be neatly sorted from the genetic.2. Genes and genomes are stable, and except for rare, random mutations, are passed on unchanged to the next generation.3. Genes and genomes cannot be changed directly in response to the environment.4. Acquired characters are not inherited, as germline genes are not influenced by the environment."- (Ho 2000)"The determinist says what outcome we get depends upon just what happens; the pre-determinist says the outcome we get is fixed, and cannot be changed by what happens." (Franklin 2001)Genetic determinism can provide clues to the past, help us understand the present, and maybe even see further ahead into potential futures. In the scope of evolutionary theory, not of the individual, genetic determinism must be present. Environment most certainly plays a determining role in natural selection, but it is through the genes that scientists are able to...

Find Another Essay On Do gene selectionist approaches in evolutionary theory entail genetic determinism?

Some people think that "soft sentiments" and "romantic words" are essential ingredients in love poetry. How do three or four poems show different approaches to writing about love?

2406 words - 10 pages Plan of EssayPoems to include are The Beggar Women, Our Love Now, and To His Coy Mistress.Demure = to Coy = to Shy = To His Coy Mistress.Banal = Common place = conventional = stereotypical = clichéHow is equal to the language used by the poet.Different kinds of love include:Two poems are similar that they both in love in the cliché way or have been in love in this way the poems involved include To His Coy Mistress and Our Love

"Wuthering Heights" by Emily Bronte: To what extent do you see differing approaches to the analysis of your text useful in understanding the author's intention?

1507 words - 6 pages welcome her, she dare hardly touch them lest they should fawn upon her splendid garments." This crystallizes the concept of the importance of appearances in the subculture of Wuthering Heights. Catherine "displays fingers wonderfully whitened with doing nothing, and staying in doors." Catherine has been living the life of the upper class where the upper class rely on others i.e servants to do work. Whiteness was regarded as sign of the upper class and

The Nature-Nurture Debate

1695 words - 7 pages significant impact on the way the nature-nurture debate developed. Social Darwinism is a doctrine based on genetic determinism and natural selection, advocating a laissez-faire capitalist economy and promoting eugenics, racism and the inherent inequality of such a society. Extending Darwin's theory of evolution to social thought and political philosophy, the biologically-deterministic view culminated in the extremism of Nazi Germany. After the horrors

Nature vs. Nurture

2511 words - 10 pages Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection, Murray), proposing that simpler structures evolve into more complex organisms, the old certainties were threatened because the adaptations of creatures to their surroundings no longer needed to be explained in terms of an Almighty. Evolutionary qualities could be explained, at least partly, by genetic influences. Mary Midgley, referring to the sociobiologist, Edward O. Wilson said, Wilson's

Freedom-Determinism debate

1693 words - 7 pages genome is producing increasing evidence of genetic influences. For example a high IQ may be related to the IGF2R gene (Chorney et al., 1998). Although it is doubtful that total genetic determination will ever be found for any behaviour. Some determinists see some logic in freewill and they try and mix the two concepts into one. These people are known as soft determinists, as opposed to hard determinists that believe determinism is true and

Evolutionary Development Biology

2165 words - 9 pages debates regarding its meaning as well as difference over whether it is explained sufficiently by different forms of regulation of gene. Evo-devo conceive like an integration of numerous biological fields, where genetics of developmental is only one between some intersecting approaches (Müller, 2007). The relationship between evo-devo and neo-Darwinian theory of evolutionary is mainly contested (Hoekstra and Coyne 2007). This essay will look at

Evolution of MRSA

935 words - 4 pages scientists associated with the theory of evolution include Charles Darwin and Jean-Baptiste Lamarck. Charles Darwin contributed majorly to the evolutionary theory and was the first to consider the concept of natural selection. The evolutionary theory states that evolutionary change comes through the production of genetic variation in each generation and survival of individuals with different combinations of these characters. Individuals with

Qumran: Identity, Spirits, Science and Dualism

2324 words - 9 pages the philosophy of religion cannot reasonably be applied to the problem of evil. Somewhat contrary to Rogers and Cain, Mawson, in 2004, determined that every conceivable attempt must be made to prove the possibility of the existence of the free will of agents without the existence of determinism in a world created by a good and just God, and then made several arguments in an attempt to do so with no success. He concluded that the free will

Gene Therapy

1121 words - 4 pages In 1972 two men by the name of Theodore Friedmann and Richard Roblin had published an article in a book called science that was titled “Gene therapy for human genetic disease?” Which referred to Stanfield roger’s proposal in which “Good DNA” could be used to replace the defective DNA in people with genetic disorders. Researchers are testing several approaches to gene therapy, including: •Replacing a defective gene that causes disease with a

Metaphor, Sociobiology, and Nature vs. Nurture: The Biological Battle of the Century

2375 words - 10 pages claim that the individual’s genetic material influences the environment, and vice versa, to result in a society that works collectively, resembling an organism: the individual is taught, in accordance with his/her inherent nature, how to play a role in society. However, anti-sociobiologists do not disregard genetic behavior; rather they state that nature and nurture converse in a dialogue where neither is overpowered. But here come the


5675 words - 23 pages as J.B.S. Haldane, Sewall Wright, and Ronald Fisher, set the foundations of evolution onto a robust statistical philosophy. The false contradiction between Darwin's theory, genetic mutations, and Mendelian inheritance was thus reconciled.[45]In the 1920s and 1930s a modern evolutionary synthesis connected natural selection, mutation theory, and Mendelian inheritance into a unified theory that applied generally to any branch of biology. The modern

Similar Essays

The Relevance Of Evolutionary Theory In Biomedical Science

1936 words - 8 pages science. Biomedical science consists of seven major disciplines; hematology, transfusion science, clinical chemistry, histology, virology, cytology, immunology and medical microbiology. However, significance of evolutionary theory had a drastic impact mostly on hematology and some virology. The branch of hematology in biomedical science has a significant effect on society in the modern world. The understanding of several diseases that occur due to

Gene Therapy And Genetic Engineering: Should It Be Approved In The Us?

3126 words - 13 pages receiving the treatment the patients' scores on movement tests improved on average by 30 percent.(Gene Therapy Special News Items, 1.)” Genetic engineering, and its form dealing with humans, gene therapy, is a process in which genes are replaced or "tweaked" to acquire a certain trait or cure an illness or disease. This can be performed in the fetal stage through adulthood. While genetic engineering and gene therapy can help prevent disease and

Critical Review: Bradley A. Thayer, Bring In Darwin: Evolutionary Theory, Realism, And International Relations

1203 words - 5 pages rooted in our gene as well (Thayer, 2000, p.132). Evolutionary theory also recognizes a “dominance hierarchy” in any forms of social organizations which contributes to the fitness of the species as well (ibid.) “Dominance hierarchy” suggests a social structure that particular individuals holds dominant power in a social group while others being submissive in which the tribe avoids conflicts (Thayer, 2000, p. 133). Therefore, the struggle for

Economics Theory And Crime. Why Do Criminals Commit Crime. Why Is Law Enforcement Failing In The War On Drugs.

568 words - 2 pages smaller in scale than average lawful businesses in other markets. Studies by Reuter and Rubenstein seem to confirm that indeed "criminal firms are relatively small... and decentralized, exactly the opposite of what we see in movies and novels." Rather than being organized, the criminal market is more of a "network of individuals that cooperate ...and do things for each other to their own mutual [economic] interest."Examining the "War on Drugs