This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Do Medical Practitioners Need The Virtues?

2924 words - 12 pages

A revival of Aristotelian thinking with regard to morality, in particular the idea of virtue ethics, has been in the ascendance for the past twenty years, and now forms the basis of a theory of morality which challenges the dominant utilitarian and deontological schools of thought. These two principal theories have shaped the ideas underpinning the teaching and practical application of medical ethics for the second half of the last century, and into the current one1. Whether or not the resurgence of virtue theory in philosophical circles should lead to a questioning of this status quo in medical ethics is open to discussion, and this essay aims to evaluate this debate.

The ascendance of utilitarianism has its roots in the scientific revolution of the 19th and 20th centuries, and depends on the classification and measurements of the outcome of an action in terms of consequent happiness and unhappiness. A good act is defined as one from which a net positive amount of happiness will result2. Shortcomings of this approach include the inapplicability of concrete ethical rules to myriad differing situations, and the "tyranny of the majority3"; the disturbing realisation that through utilitarianism we could find ourselves deliberately inflicting pain on a minority to cause pleasure in a majority in order to increase the "net" happiness. Kantianism arose in the early 19th century and places importance in the motives of an action, unlike the utilitarianism preoccupation with consequences. Kantian deontology is based on universal moral rules defining duties individuals should abide by4. Its inherent inflexibility leads to frequent conflicts when one moral rule appears to contradict another. From a medical ethics point of view, a further fault becomes apparent in that it is possible to conceive of a doctor scrupulous in his or her adherence to the doctrine of utilitarianism or deontology, yet still lacking characteristics we would seek in a "good doctor." There seems to be something lacking in the detached, calculating, analytical reasoning offered by the dominant doctrines.

Aristotle founded the doctrine of virtue theory in the 4th century BC. He agreed with Plato that humans are essentially social beings, but diverged from his teacher by concentrating on commonsense application of ethical concepts involving goodness and moral philosophy as opposed to a study of theoretical abstracts. The basic principle is that an adherent of virtue theory can become more moral by habituation; aspiring to become more virtuous, this aspiration is reinforced when a good act is performed, the reward being a feeling of advancement towards the virtuous ideal. Through this process, the aspiring virtuous person will eventually find themselves equipped with an array of virtues; honed character traits through which they can evaluate ethical scenarios, and act in such a way as to perform only good acts. The cultivation of virtues is the means to the end of...

Find Another Essay On Do Medical Practitioners Need the Virtues?

When not to cook and what you need to do before cooking. The most important thing to remember

515 words - 2 pages can be transferred through the food. Some of these illnesses are diarrhoea, hepatitis A, vomiting, fevers, skin infections, eye or ear discharge and jaundice. Food-borne infections such as typhoid and dysentery must be reported to the employer. Even similar symptoms. You may need medical attention or require a doctor's clearance before commencing work again with food.Cuts and Broken SkinTo prevent spreading of bacteria to food, all cuts, scratches

Why Dieses-Causing Bacteria are Resistant to Antibiotics and what can the Medical Profession do About This

976 words - 4 pages more quickly if you do not finish your prescribed medication and can start causing infections in your body. 3. Ask your doctor if the antibiotics that are prescribed are beneficial to your illness or unbeneficial. Ask what you can do to make yourself feel better and stronger without taking antibiotics (if you don’t need antibiotics or if there are other ways to get better). 4. Take the correct prescribed medication for your illness and not

"Do We Need Labor Unions in America?" and "What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Union Membership."

957 words - 4 pages A question that is often asked is whether labor unions are still necessary in America as we know it today. It is a very difficult question to answer and in order to do so we must first take a look at what it does, as well as what the advantages and disadvantages are. A labor union is an organization of many workers that has come together to negotiate and achieve certain conditions such as proper pay, work environment, hours, and rules and

What can we do if there is a new product that you need to promote to the market

3891 words - 16 pages marketing. Target marketing means a set of buyers sharing a common need marketing mix that the company decides to serve in order to obtain a mutually satisfying exchanges. There are three strategies for selecting target market: undifferentiated, concentrate and differentiate marketing.The children market is the main market that our company wants to target and the young girls market is the niche market. We want to choose the children market

"The past is a different country. They do things differently there" Is this an appropriate comment concerning medical history? Give some specific examples from tutorials and lectures

3116 words - 12 pages The world of the past:Since the ancient times to modern days, there has been progression in most aspects of medical history including technology and perspectives of human beings towards different medical approaches. This is because of the widening of understanding, and also ones will to understand beyond their scope.However, background from the past is needed in order to do things today. During the past, people believed in treatments and

Do we need government intervention in the form of Competition Policy ? if so, Why? Applied and discuss based on case study or research

1715 words - 7 pages and better products.In the real economy, is it always necessary for government intervention in the form of Competition Policy?Let's consider The United States Airline Deregulation 1978.This deregulation is seen to be successful, it brought benefit to customers. However, it also raised some problems such as congestion, limited re-emergence of monopoly power and with it, and the exploitation of a minority of customers. So when do we need

A psychology abstract on the article "Thinning Down School Food." Talks about increasing childhood obesity, and what schools need to do to change it

576 words - 2 pages Thinning Down School FoodMany cafeteria workers across the United States do not believe children standing in their own lunch lines don't suffer from obesity. "Obesity? Not in my school." A study that was recently done in Pennsylvania shows that many cafeteria personnel don't think school meals are a factor of obesity in children.Claudia Probart, a TK at Penn State University, says that those personnel tested believed there was a childhood

Do you Need to be Strong in the Three Events to win a Triathlon?

2358 words - 9 pages In order to investigate, a lot data would be needed. Data that would be need is as follows: Time taken for the competitors who are strong in 1 event but are average in the other 2 events to complete the triathlon and the time taken for the competitors who are relatively strong in all 3 events to complete the triathlon. Time taken for each event for each of the competitors would also need to be taken down to record the overall speed, that both

Retail Clinics

2586 words - 10 pages nursing practitioners instead of physicians. Many people consider these clinics as a boon because of their easy accessibility, less expenditure, and evidence-based care. Many others, especially physician bodies and large hospitals oppose vehemently citing a possible fall in safety and quality, the possibility of the underserved being neglected, the possibility of giving up the medical care received through medical home, (Retail Clinics: Six state

Patients Acceptance of Nurse Practitioners

938 words - 4 pages equipped to deliver high quality care. Although nurse practitioners receive the same schooling and are equally qualified to do their job, each state has their own scope of practice for what they can do. According to Pearson, “in some states, nurse practitioners provide care without any involvement from a physician. In other states, providing the same care requires that nurse practitioners collaborate or even be supervised by a physician” (as cited

Research Study: Nurse Practitioners as Staff Leaders for Patient Care

1147 words - 5 pages management and improving overall outcomes. Supporting Evidence In 2007 and 2012, the Pennsylvania General Assembly addressed the scope of practice for nurse practitioners in both House Bill No. 1253 and ACT 68 of 2012. ACT 68 addresses additional amendments in expand the scope of practice including (but not limited to): ordering home health and hospital care, ordering of durable medical equipment, issue oral orders in the same fashion as physicians

Similar Essays

Sixties Culture Shows The Need To Legalizing Medical Marijuana

3406 words - 14 pages medically? The success stories do not end there, within this same documentary there were other stories mentioned of mothers all over doing the same thing for their aggressive children. A mother in Rhode Island blogged about how she baked medical marijuana her nine year old’s cookies and tea, while other parents of ten year old Californian, Sam, gave medical marijuana to him in his melons, and “it has worked wonders,”(Mother gives son marijuana to treat

What Does The Doctrine Of The Mean Have To Do With Virtues? Classics In Ethics Phil 342 Philisophy

979 words - 4 pages ; courage standing between rashness and cowardice does not equate to courage being in the exact middle of the two linear vices. As discussed by Aristotle in the Nicomachean Ethics practical sciences do not consist of common laws or precise formulas. Matters are resolved uniquely through reviewing instilled virtue and applying practical knowledge. Aristotle’s chief clam was that virtue could only be truly mastered through repeated practice (trial

Complicated Medical Issues: Are Doctors Allowed To Do Everything What’s Medical Possible Without The Willing Of The Patient?

882 words - 4 pages medical reason to do it that way at this point of time. But there is also an economical factor to think about it. The parents want to care for Ashley at home and want her to stay a small kid. That’s a big advantage for the parents in a financial way. They have to pay once for the treatment (in the case the insurance will not pay for it), but then they don’t need to pay for external care. When she stays at her size the living costs are reduced

What Do We Need To Change About The Indian Education System? 10 Dis Yyyyy

864 words - 4 pages Hundreds of years. Even Rabindranath Tagore wrote lengthy articles about how Indian education system needs to change.  Funny thing is that from the colonial times, few things have changed. We have established IITs, IIMs, law schools and other institutions of excellence; students now routinely score 90% marks so that even students with 90+ percentage find it difficult to get into the colleges of their choice; but we do more of the same old stuff