This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Do You Have A Self? Essay

1210 words - 5 pages

In this paper, I will look at the no-self view Nagasena argues for, and question its demand for a permanent self. I will argue that the self exists because it is created, that the self does exist from its point of creation. I will then attempt to justify my argument’s premise as they help to resolve the contention that the self’s memory and history, which Nagasena does not account for, are what defines the self.

In The Questions of King Milinda, Nagasena argues that the self does not exist. Using the analogy of the chariot, he argues:
1) The chariot is not its pole, its axle, its wheels or any other of its constituent parts only.
2) The chariot is not anything outside its constituent parts.
3) The chariot is not all of its constituent parts.
Therefore, the chariot does not exist.
Rather, the name “chariot” is only a “generally understood term” for something that has all the constituent parts of the chariot put together. Names of composite things are merely empty sounds that exist as ideas, and are used to refer to the collection of its constituent parts when they put together in reality.

In relation to the self, the names we assign to the self would then have “no permanent individuality implied in [the] name,” because the there is no fixed collection of constituent parts that would form the same self. The constituent parts of the self are continuously changing, and hence, the name we use to refer to a self does not refer to the same combination and arrangement of a particular group of constituent parts through time. That is why he believes that “there is no permanent individuality involved in the matter,” where the matter refers to his name, “Nagasena” and the self to which the name refers to. As such, the name we use to refer to the self is a “mere empty sound” because it does not always refer to the same combination of constituent things. Because the name is a mere empty sound, it does not refer to anything in reality. Therefore, the self does not exist in reality because there is no permanent thing that can be used to define it.

I agree with the premises in Nagasena’s argument. I also agree that the constituent parts of the self are continuously changing. However, I do not agree with the conclusion from these premises that the self does not exist because there is not always the same combination and arrangement of constituent parts coexisting to form the self. The conclusion above suggests that the self does not exist because its constituent parts cannot define a permanent self. Nagasena’s argument requires the self to remain permanent. Instead, the history of the self can be considered an integral part of the self, which allows experiences to help shape the self and exist through the continuum of time.

I believe that the self does exist. The self exists because:
a) The self is created once at a point in time.
b) Things created at a point in time exist.
Therefore, the self exists.
The self is thus defined as a person formed with...

Find Another Essay On Do You Have a Self?

How reliable a narrator do you think Nick is based on what you have

572 words - 2 pages How reliable a narrator do you think Nick is based on what you have read in chapters 1 and 2 Throughout the opening of the book we meet Nick Carroway and he exposes many strengths How reliable a narrator do you think Nick is based on what you have read in chapters 1 and 2 Throughout the opening of the book we meet Nick Carroway and he exposes many strengths and weaknesses as the narrator of the book “Great Gatsby”. In this essay I

Do What You Have Been Told

925 words - 4 pages wants her daughter to be a prodigy. She says to her daughter, “ ‘you can be best anything’ ” (Tan 1). When they are watching Shirley’s old movie, the mother thinks the daughter can be Chinese Shirley Temple. She expects her daughter to be an amazing child. when she sees a nine-year old girl play piano on the Ed Sullivan Show, she thinks her daughter can do that too, even better than the girl. Even though these expectations are different, all of

To what extent do you agree that schools have a uniform

869 words - 3 pages Oliver DaviesTo what extent do you agree that schools have a uniform?From the ages of 5 to 16 by law every child in the UK must attend school; whether the school is state funded or privately funded they almost all have some form of school uniform. School uniforms are a requirement at almost all schools but in some state schools the regulations on school uniforms are a little looser than others, Meaning that some pupil wear pretty much whatever

To what extent do you agree that schools have a uniform

869 words - 3 pages Oliver DaviesTo what extent do you agree that schools have a uniform?From the ages of 5 to 16 by law every child in the UK must attend school; whether the school is state funded or privately funded they almost all have some form of school uniform. School uniforms are a requirement at almost all schools but in some state schools the regulations on school uniforms are a little looser than others, Meaning that some pupil wear pretty much whatever

Managing in a Crisis Environment - Do You Have Your Fireman's Gear?

1945 words - 8 pages Have you ever heard of the saying, "Man, your sweat pumps are on the line" or "Busier than a one-handed paper hanger"? That is how many workers feel in the engineering management arena these days. Everything seems to be in crisis mode more times than not. And why is that? Why is it that all of us are so busy all of the time? Our cell phones never stop ringing, our laptops are never more than an arm's length away, and we send emails during

Do you think that all sub/counter cultures have a right to exist?

725 words - 3 pages simply from choice if whether you should listen or not. Cultures have beliefs for their own ways of life, but so do people. Except where we differ is that instead of one person having one belief, a culture has beliefs as one. So considering how one whole culture has beliefs could their actions be right or wrong? Well I think first off if they believe that they are not doing anything wrong then they are right. But if an issue of law come into play

Do You Have What It Takes? A Breakdown Of The Educated Person

913 words - 4 pages Do You Have What it Takes? A Breakdown of the Educated Person An educated person is a well rounded person. To be educated is to knowledgeable in many areas. Diversity is essential in the sense that many different things inspire thought, which then derive permanent conclusions from these experiences. Anyone who has the audacity to call themselves educated needs to have a firm grasp of many different areas. These categories span through

The October Crisis: Do You Have A Permit For That Freedom?

3073 words - 13 pages The purpose of government is to create peace and order to maintain a functioning society. Legislation from the federal government of Canada is to do exactly that, but at what point does the law over state its presence and harm the people it attempts to protect? The October Crisis that occurred in 1970 under the Trudeau government is one such contentious issue: while it may have been supported by some it was highly criticized for damaging human

Do You Have What it Takes to Be Divergent?

1267 words - 6 pages In our society we are lucky to have so many choices about how we live. We can be smart yet still respect others, we can be brave yet still sincere. In the second book, Insurgent, from the dystopian series Divergent, the people are not as lucky and do not have choices. Veronica Roth wrote this science fiction book showing a futuristic look at Chicago, in which people are placed into factions (groups) based on certain characteristics and an

What Is Dyslexia and What Can You Do If You Have It

1429 words - 6 pages Dyslexia is a congenital disorder characterized by unexpected difficulty learning to decode and spell words in relation to one’s verbal intelligence, motivation, and educational opportunities (Gray E. S, 2008). People have many misconceptions regarding dyslexia which includes visual impairment, low IQ, dyslexia is curable, and this learning disability affects males more often than females. Indicators of dyslexia change over time since it is a

"Bolt claims, 'All my plays and films have a modern relevance'. What do you think is the modern relevance of A Man for All Seasons?

987 words - 4 pages LiteratureA man for all seasons"Bolt claims, 'All my plays and films have a modern relevance'. What do you think is the modern relevance of A Man for All Seasons?Bolt's play portrays a modern relevance. We can compare the two ideals of "A man for all seasons" alongside modern society. People such as rich are identified amongst our modern community, we compare the immoral pragmatic people to such the likes of Politicians, who, will take the easy

Similar Essays

Do You Have A Low Self Esteem?

1171 words - 5 pages confidence. I believe that in order to succeed and be successful in life you must have self-confidence. Eagerness to learn new things, pride in doing a good job, being a nice person, having the confidence to know “I can do it”, and altogether liking oneself are some attributes of having self confidence. Liking yourself is key in everything that you do. I do not know of one person that does something well and does not have self-confidence. Just like a

Do You Have What It Takes To Be A Spartan?

1053 words - 5 pages sticks. There are scenes of people helping each other over walls and up ropes. They exhibit teams of amputated and disabled veterans, struggling through the obstacles. The images shown are inspirational. The ads seem to make you question yourself and your abilities, without ever asking a question. They depict relatable human struggle and our power to overcome overwhelming odds. The advertisements do not need words, they speak to viewers with

Leader To A Leader, What Do You Have?

1529 words - 6 pages that I believe should be the cornerstone of a leader’s profile. Take note. After reading this you may realize you do not have the qualities of a leader or better yet, that you actually have all of them. Are you prepared to trust in the items that I am about to write? If so, then you are recognizing the first trait of an effective leader. Trust is essentially the backbone to a leader. Without trust, then they would not be able to gain the

Do You Have The Right? Essay

2152 words - 9 pages occurred under British rule would not happen again. They were added after the signing because at the time the congressmen did not believe that the government would ever infringe upon people’s rights and become tyrannical. Today we often take these rights for granted and do not exactly realize how much of a role they play in our lives. Look at your city. The people of the city have the ability to gather and protest, this is the freedom of assembly