This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Doctor Assisted Suicide Essay

1109 words - 4 pages

Have you ever thought about what you would do if you became diagnosed with a terminal illness that changed your life completely? There are many choices in the world that one could make, such as seeking physician-assisted suicide or deciding to live with a terminal illness. It is not everyday a person sits around and think about what they would do if an illness became unbearable to them. One could agree with Diane Coleman’s article “Doctor-Assisted Suicide Should Not Be an Option” or one could agree with Kathryn Tucker’s article “People Should Be Allowed To Choose Doctor-Assisted Suicide.” To better understand the authors’ opposing positions concerning physician-assisted suicide, one must examine their differing views on the reasons for choosing suicide, the possibility of doctors’ abuse or coercion, and the societal impact of legalization of doctor-assisted suicide.
The reasons why one would choose physician-assisted suicide may vary from patient to patient due to their individual diagnoses; however, both Coleman and Tucker believe that the lost of activities of daily living plays a major part in one concluding to seek assistance in suicide. Tucker states, “The patient’s most frequently cited concerns include a decreasing ability to participate in activities that made life enjoyable, the loss of autonomy, and the loss of dignity” (Tucker) as reasons for wanting to hasten death. Coleman concurs by stating, “The reasons doctors actually report for issuing lethal prescriptions are the patient’s loss of autonomy, loss of dignity, and feelings of being a burden” (Coleman). While Tucker believes her reasons are valid enough to seek assistance, Coleman does not think the reasons are valid. Coleman implies that becoming more dependent on another person may be a disability, but one has to learn how to acquire a different lifestyle and not let it take one’s dignity away from them. Understanding the different motives of why people choose to hasten their death may help you decide if you are ever in this predicament.
The possibility of doctor abuse or coercion is discussed in both articles. Coleman informs the readers of her article that doctors have a financial interest in aiding with suicides. These physicians, according to Coleman, are allowed to come to the conclusion of which patients is in need of their assistance and decides what information to discuss concerning treatment for their illness. Coleman says, “Oregon Law gives physician too much power” (Coleman). It allows the physician to say who is coherent enough to make the decision and if this is a good choice for that individual. Although, Coleman believes that physician is coercing patients, Tucker implies that doctors do not encourage patients to hasten death. In Tucker’s article Arthur Caplan states, “I was worried about people being pressured to do this. But this data confirms, for the seventh year, that the policy in Oregon is working. There is no evidence of abuse or coercion or...

Find Another Essay On Doctor-Assisted Suicide

Legalizing Doctor-Assisted Suicides has Increased the Suicide Rate

740 words - 3 pages The suicide rate has rapidly increased in the past years. In 2007, suicide was the tenth leading cause of death in the United States, accounting for more than 34,598 deaths. This would mean 11.3 people commit suicide per 100,000 people. There has been recent talk of legalizing doctor-assisted suicides. Legalizing doctor-assisted suicide would be a terrible idea. One of the reasons I say this is that they could just be over reacting in that

Euthanasia and Doctor-Assisted Suicide - The Will to Live

605 words - 2 pages available may be a guardian or even the person's doctor. Such surrogates are daily authorizing the cutoff of food and fluids to patients who are unable to speak for themselves and never gave any indication that they might want to be starved. Only in the comparatively rare cases when there is some dispute among relatives, such as in the Wendland case in California, the earlier Hugh Finn case in Virginia, and the Schindler-Schiavo case now in Florida

The United States Should Legalize Physician Assisted Suicide

2635 words - 11 pages Physician Assisted Suicide could be difficult to choose; living wills, right to die act and death with dignity act could help to ease that burden. Physician Assisted Suicide occurs in many different forms. The Physician assisting in the suicide can assist directly or indirectly. When a doctor directly assists s/he is present during the time where the lethal drug enters the body. A doctor may also indirectly assist the terminally ill patient by giving

The Prevelence of Assisted Suicide

662 words - 3 pages , drugs, medical or surgical procedures. Physician-Assisted Suicide - Suicide accomplished with the aid of a medical doctor intentionally providing a person with an overdose of prescription medication. Assisted Suicide - Suicide accomplished with the aid of another person. 2. Physician-assisted suicide and euthanasia are legal and widely practiced in the Netherlands where: About 9% of all deaths were a result of physician-assisted suicide or

Assisted Suicide and the right to die

1418 words - 6 pages suicide is when the patients have to request the act to be done and for the doctor to agree. The purpose of this research paper is to bring more awareness of physician assisted suicide and if it should be legalized. There are many people against physician assisted suicide for many different reasons. One of the main reasons people are against physician assisted-suicide is because the safety of the patients. Some people believe that the patients are

My Life, My Body, My Choice

1151 words - 5 pages .” According to, an online encyclopedia; there are certain requirements that need to be met in order to be eligible for physician assisted suicide, such as the patient being within six months of death. In addition, Wikipedia states "The process is set forth in law, including the requirements that the patient must be of sound mind when requesting assisted suicide, as confirmed by a doctor and other witnesses, and the patient must be

Assisted Suicide

874 words - 3 pages Assisted Suicide Assisted suicide should be legal if the person asks or agrees to it. If someone is ill or about to die from other causes they should have the right to death by their doctor. If a doctor suggests it and the person or close family member agrees to it the doctor shouldn't be charged for murder. It should become a law that if a person wants to die that badly their doctor can do it for them

Physician Assisted Suicide

641 words - 3 pages ‘incurable’. Pulling into the hospital parting lot, you began to slide out of your car and notice he had been waiting in the lobby to take you into the family conference room, where you knew that every serious situation was discussed. Your mother’s doctor told you about your mothers questioning in physician-assisted suicide. If this was your situation, would you encourage your mother to go through with the physician-assisted suicide, otherwise know as

Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia

1222 words - 5 pages Assisted suicide brings a debate that involves professional, legal and ethical issues about the value of the liberty versus the value of life. However, before conceive an opinion about this topic is necessary know deeply its concept. Assisted suicide is known as the act of ending with the life of a terminal illness patients for end with their insupportable pain. Unlike euthanasia, the decision is not made by the doctor and their families, but by

Arguments against Physician-assisted suicide

1248 words - 5 pages approving assisted suicide degrades the reputation of American medicine. The definition of physician-assisted suicide, according to the American Medical Association, is “when a physician facilitates a patient’s death by providing the necessary means and/or information to enable the patient to perform the life-ending act” (“Opinion 2.211”). This means that an individual takes their own life with the tools given to them by a doctor. An example of this

Physician Assisted Suicide: A Crime or Not

864 words - 3 pages Assisted suicide should be legal if the person asks or agrees to it. If someone is ill or about to die from other causes they should have the right to death by their doctor. If a doctor suggests it and the person or close family member agrees to it the doctor shouldn't be charged for murder. It should become a law that if a person wants to die that badly their doctor can do it for them. If it became against the law we might start to have people

Similar Essays

Doctor Assisted Suicide Essay

1170 words - 5 pages -assisted suicide, a form of euthanasia. The legalization of a similar act would improve the quality of life of terminally ill patients, preserve tissues for organ donation and follow the ethical practices of doctors in deciding treatments. A reduced quality of life is associated with patients diagnosed with degenerative or incurable diseases, as advances in medical treatment ultimately extend a predicted life expectancy (Canada. Social Affairs and

Doctor Assisted Suicide Essay

2434 words - 10 pages ABSTRACTIs doctor- assisted lethal injection expectable for terminally ill people?Many find it to be suicide, while others find it a great comfort. Religiousbeliefs, morals, self-value, and laws have divided in our society by thisdecision. Is the process better for the patient? Should it be against the law?There are many questions about doctor-assisted lethal injections now wetake a closer look to the affects and you can decided.INTRODUCTIONWhen

Doctor Assisted Suicide Should Not Be Legalized?

954 words - 4 pages Suicide is the one of the common types of death and is increasing every year in the United States. People use suicide as an alternative method in order to get escape from their sufferings in life. There are different ways people commit suicide. Some people commit suicide using poisonous drugs or hanging them. However, one of the suicides that will be discussed is doctor-assisted suicides. Doctor-assisted suicide is the “voluntary termination of

Essay On Euthanasia And Doctor Assisted Suicide

1188 words - 5 pages drugs that has been provided by a doctor for the purpose of causing death. It would also be assisted suicide if a patient pushes a switch to trigger a fatal injection after the doctor has inserted an intravenous needle into the patient's vein.   It's true that modern technology keeps people alive who previously would have died earlier. A century ago, high blood pressure, pneumonia, appendicitis, and diabetes likely meant death, often