Does Congress Have Too Much Power Over Commerce?

2338 words - 9 pages

Does Congress Have Too Much Power Over Commerce?
Works Cited Missing

Narrow construction is not found in the Constitution, but the powers granted to Congress to regulate commerce are found. Exactly stated, “Congress shall have power to regulate commerce with foreign nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian tribes.” This clause has no definite interpretation, but has included many aspects of regulating. The word “commerce” is defined as the exchange or buying and selling of commodities on a large scale involving transportation from place to place (Webster 264). Congress has exercised this delegated power in many cases. The nature and basic guidelines of Congress’ power over commerce is first laid out in the case of Gibbons v. Ogden. In addition, the case United States v. Lopez is a prime example of Congress’ ability to carry out the Commerce Clause to the furthest extent. Lastly, the case National Labor Relations Board v. Jones & Laughlin Steel Corporation brings to light the Wagner Act of 1935. Through a review of these three cases, it can be concluded that there are no real limitations on Congress when regulating commerce.

The Constitution of the United States explicates the enumerated powers that the people have granted to their public administration. A narrow interpretation of the Constitution would mean denying the government the powers granted to them to keep order, equality, and fairness. An expanded interpretation would “extend words beyond their natural and obvious import, and we might question the application of the term…” (244). It is the government’s responsibility to exercise powers that cannot be exercised by its governed people. There are no guidelines in the Constitution’s composition that discloses how to interpret the language; therefore, it is in the hands of three federal branches of government to decipher the Constitutions meaning.

A historical case that first outlined Congress’ commerce power was Gibbons v. Ogden. The courts acted here, in view of commerce, to stretch the interpretation of what was considered to be within its limits. In 1807, steam navigation became productive way of doing things. Robert Fulton was the first to make the voyage from New York to Albany by steamboat. Fulton and his partner, Robert R. Livingston, were granted special operating rights and a “five-year extension to his monopoly, which was not to exceed thirty years.” Without receiving a license from Fulton and Livingston, no one was allowed to travel New York waters by steam. A controversy arose between Ogden, who had obtained the license from Fulton and Livingston, and Gibbons, who had obtained his license through the United States government. Ogden petitioned the New York Court to “enjoin” Gibbons, his formal partner, from continuing with this business in that state. The Court favored Ogden and granted the injunction and Gibbons appealed to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court upheld the right for Congress to have...

Find Another Essay On Does Congress Have Too Much Power Over Commerce?

Obesity is an external consequence that an individual does not have much control over

1678 words - 7 pages more often, even shortly after finishing a meal. Moreover, brain scans revealed that people with the double FTO gene were experiencing the same brain responses that an individual experiences through alcohol and recreational drug use, simply from eating (WebMD, 2013). These facts demonstrate that the causes of overeating may be the result of specific genes in your body that you have no control over. Furthermore, problems associated with health

Define institutional investors. Do institutional investors exercise too much power in relation to corporate governance?

4052 words - 16 pages remuneration policy linked to shareholder value."In a word, Institutional investors are now playing an active role in securing better corporate governance, which includes taking a positive interest in the composition of the board and making positive use of their voting rights.4. Do institutional investors exercise too much power in relation to corporate governance?The heightened awareness of the importance of the responsibilities of institutional

Does McDonalds Have A Competitive Advantage Over O

1726 words - 7 pages Does McDonalds have a competitive advantage over other fast food restaurants? If so, why? Introduction The aim of this enquiry is to investigate whether McDonalds outlets have a competitive advantage over other fast food stores, in particular Burger King restaurants. If this is true then I will evaluate what their competitive advantages are and how exactly they help McDonalds to achieve their success.To aid me with my investigation I will carry

Nuclear Power: How Does it Work? Does it Have a Future?

2300 words - 9 pages and Chernobyl accidents. Natural gas and more efficient coal-fired power plants have supplied growing world energy demand up to the present period. Now the focus has shifted to renewable energy and “third generation” nuclear power. According to analysis by Citigroup Global Markets, the construction a 1,600 megawatt (MW) plant would be €5.6 billion. Without government support, either these plants will not be built or once they are, will not be

The debate is whether one society can truly have one structure of power that lasts over time and this essay will agree with the pluralists, that power

2343 words - 10 pages Absract: The debate is whether one society can truly have one structure of power that lasts over time and this essay will agree with the pluralists, that power is ever-changing and elite domination can at best only be fleeting and temporary. However, this essay will also argue that this is not just down to the issue of power, but elite domination is also a flawed theory, in that history shows it fails in practice. It should be made clear that

Too Young For Life? - Should age be the basis on which young people are discriminated? Do adults really know that much more than young adults and does that make them better people?

1665 words - 7 pages back to reality. Think about now and the life that you have. The truth is that you are still only 16 years old: too young to drive, too young to vote, too young to drink, too young to be out of school, too young to go to the clubs; too young to matter. You're only 16 years old, you don't know what real life is like and because you don't, your opinions or beliefs don't and shouldn't matter. Because you are so young, you apparently don't know much

"The Power of Price". An analysis of Chapter 10 in Dan Arielys "Predictably Irrational", showing why our minds have a lot of power over how effective our medicine is.

1251 words - 5 pages performance, with the more expensive usually performing better. This shows how big of an impact expectations can have on us. It also shows that we put too much into how much material goods cost. However, it is understandable that people want to think they're getting the best treatment when it comes to their health. We just need to realize that we need a better basis for performance other than dollar signs. The purpose behind writing this chapter was to

Anti-rape Legislation and the Commerce Clause

1262 words - 5 pages constitutional power of Congress to regulate them is ultimately a judicial rather than a legislative question, and can be settled finally only by this Court. (Justice Rehnquist, US vs Lopez," These statements imply that Congress does not have the final say on the effects of actions on interstate commerce, rather the decision remains with the Courts. Last but not least, allowing this law to exist would severely undermine the concept of


1617 words - 6 pages president becomes incapacitated it is up to Congress to determine him as unfit to continue his duties. Another way Congress checks the president is that it must approve any treaties to ensure that the president does not have too much power when it comes to foreign affairs. The Senate must ratify all treaties by a two-thirds vote. People will argue that Congress gives the president too much power in the area of foreign affairs. Bush embarked

The Interstate Commerce Clause: How the Supreme Court Interpreted It Over.

2446 words - 10 pages Commerce Clause? "The Congress shall have the power to ... regulate commerce with foreign nations and among the several States and with the Indian Tribes" (Burke). As important as those powers are, that is a stretch from what the "Framers" had mind. The States were to have majority of legislative power and the powers of the Federal Government, "were to be limited, not general" (Reynolds, 3)."Congress shall have the power to regulate commerce

The US constitution: A radical departure from Articles of Confederation

635 words - 3 pages power over the nation's economic affairs. The main weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation are that it legislated for states but not for individuals. Congress had no power to tax or regulates trade. It lacked power to control commerce. And it was too difficult to change any of the articles. Then the Constitution was put into place 1787 to overthrow the Articles of Confederation. The Constitution put far more powers into Congress. It gave the

Similar Essays

Does Microsoft Have Too Much Power?

947 words - 4 pages ?Usually, when we mention Microsoft in any form, we must have the registered trademark symbol right the word. The name is a well-known word in virtually everyone's life. Although it is the super-empire it is today, Microsoft was once a small software business ran by a young Bill Gates in a tiny office. Consisting of a few young adults, they were not progressing as much as they would like too. Their competitor, Digital Research, created the first

Does Media Have Too Much Control Over Our Society Today?

902 words - 4 pages exposed. They are starting to take it too far. Nothing is a secret anymore for anybody, and people do not realize that anything they put on the internet or television cannot be taken back. With thousands of channels on television, there are so many biased opinions which are being talked about every day. Media has a major role in human’s lives today. Throughout the day, people are surrounded by the media in some form, whether they realize it or

'topic: Lady Macbeth Has At First Too Much, And Then Too Little, Power Over Her Husband'. Do You Agree?'

622 words - 2 pages the end of Lady Macbeth’s power and dominance in her relationshipLady Macbeth’s supremacy in her relationship with Macbeth is significant at its’ beginning but as the play progresses her influence weakens. She is able to gain initial power over Macbeth at a time when he is uncertain of his future but as his authority as king increases so does his power in his relationship.References:Macbeth, William Shakespeare, Penguin Publisher

Where Does Power Lie In Congress?

1744 words - 7 pages Where does power lie in Congress?Congress in the US is granted all legislative powers by the Constitution, the power to appropriate funds, regulate trade and commerce and to formally declare war. Although the President imposes his will on all of these activities Congress is still an extremely important and powerful body; arguably today it has a superior mandate as President Bush was elected on a popular minority and less recently. Congress is