This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Does It Matter, Why And Why Not?

2069 words - 9 pages

IT does not matter, is he right, why or why not?
Nicholas G Carr makes his argument comparing the developments of the Industrial Revolution such as the rail road, electricity, and the telegraph with the fairly new experiences in Information Technology like the Internet, personal computers, and investments in infrastructure technology using terms from Microeconomics and Macroeconomics, Marketing, and Strategic Management such as spending power, competitive advantage, supply and demand, economies of scale, barriers to competition, oligopolies, differentiations, and others. It cannot be argued that he is an expert in those fields at least in theory, which is inferred from the reading of his biography in Wikipedia. According to the online encyclopedia, he is an accomplished writer, professional speaker, and researcher who won much recognition like the Pulitzer Prize for nonfiction; therefore, it is challenging to argue his article from those perspectives. After reading his article three times, it became clear that he is right in most of his comments. In fact there are only a couple of instances in which he contradicts his own ideas. But the agreed statements outnumber them by a large margin; probably 25 to 2; then, after noticing the outnumbering of pros against cons, the purpose of this response became clear: yes he is right, “ IT does not matter.” In order to support that he is right, some statements from his article, in which there is agreement, will be backed up by research and opinion from different sources in the Internet. Before demonstrating agreement with his statements, there are three caveats to keep in mind: There are a few fallacies that contradict some of his statements like the fallacy of authority, argument by selective observation, and ambiguous assertion published by Penn Gillette in “A List of Fallacious Arguments” in the website: They are mentioned for the reader to know that at one point or another there can be disagreement and that Carr can be debated. The second caveat is that not everybody agrees or disagrees with him. There are several websites blogs that do not agree while others do. John Stuckey, the Director of University Computing at Washington and Lee University, Lexington, agrees with Carr’s comments, while VA Hal R., professor of business, economics, and information management at the University of California, Berkeley says, “In my view, companies cannot afford to ignore information technology, or relegate it to the back burner. Commoditizing it does not necessarily mean innovation slows. If anything, it could accelerate as more and more innovators experiment and tinker with those cheap, ubiquitous information technology commodities”; obviously he does not agree with Carr. The point is that there are many blogs with comments in the Internet that side with Carr and others that do not and the two authors mentioned above are for illustration purposes...

Find Another Essay On Does IT Matter, Why and Why Not?

Why It Is Not Fake Essay

1404 words - 6 pages handbook, it goes over attention-getter. An attention-getter should be short and sweet, and make an attempt to easily capture your audience’s attention, and to keep it simple so you are not to overwhelm your audience. (179) The speaker used going to the theatres and playing video games as a way to connect it to wrestling. Saying that movies and video games are fake, but people are willing to spend their time and money on watching and participating in

why video games matter Essay

840 words - 4 pages Fallout 3, so much so that without playing the video game, I could visualize what was happening and how post-apocalyptic the world had looked. Emotionally he conveyed how he felt throughout the article. “I am interested more in what games can do and how they make me feel while they are doing it (360).” What Tom Bissell does in “Why Video Games Matter” is state his perspective on video game culture and how they make him feel. Many people assume

Why Organizaitonal Ethics Matter

1291 words - 5 pages Why Ethics Matters There are many situations in which ethical perspectives are in contrast to another person's opinion on the same subject matter. Every person has found themselves looking over his shoulder asking himself "am I doing the right thing?" Ethics is what a person does when no one is watching. Whether it is a corporation or a government entity, they all expect their employees to behave ethically. What are ethics? Webster defines

Why practices matter

652 words - 3 pages Christian church, are important for this same reason If we are to understand the “why” of why we do things we must look at how they have been done before and how they have been practiced in the past. The practices of the church or the practice of “doing” church have changed many times over the two-thousand years of the history of the Christian Church. It is well known that the first century Christian church met in homes and worshiped together as small

What is Suicide and Why Does It Occur?

1083 words - 4 pages . Stress does not always have to be present, but may help to trigger or boost depression. Depression will affect everything about an individual, from the way they think to the way they act. Depression can be present even when a person feels and appears happy. Millions of people, in American alone, suffer from depression every year. Women, who are of the ages ranging from 25-44, make up the majority of depressed people. As a matter of fact, 7 million women battle depression every day. Depression comes in many different shapes and sizes depending on causes and varying patterns.

What is fascism and why does it emerge?

1418 words - 6 pages of informative sources such as newspapers television and other sorts of communication. These are tactics the fascist utilises if the population does not consent to the government.Fascism emerges as a response to capitalism. It is a revolutionary promise to rehabilitate a nation in economic depression or unemployment by uniting and focusing the economic power of all social classes. This in turn is to restabilise a nation economically. It utilises

Why the death penatly does not work

991 words - 4 pages murder. The goal of society and sovereignty has been to bring those who commit crimes to justice while deterring those who might sway from morality, from following that same path of destruction. The death penalty has been around almost as long as human existence, and so has murder. The idea of an eye for an eye has been played out for thousands of years and murders have still continued. The time has come to look at what we are doing and why it

Gun Control and Why We Should Not Have It

1389 words - 6 pages “Guns are not the problem. It is us that is the problem” (Kieta Shimizu). On the topic of gun control there are many arguments that can be made for both sides of the coin no doubt. In this essay you will hopefully learn why we do not need gun control in the great country that is The United States of America. Three main topic will be covered the effects of private gun ownership, gun control in society, and guns and their usage. Private gun

Child Abuse; Why Does It Occur?

2483 words - 10 pages , and anger can contribute to an adult purposely hurting their child physically, mentally, socially, sexually, or simply neglecting a child. Although there is no exact definition of child abuse, there are four major ways to define a parent as abusing their child. Many believe that child abuse means a parent is physically harming their child. Even though this is one of the most dangerous and painful forms of child abuse, it does not correctly

What does Durkheim mean by anomie and why does he regard it as problematic?

1928 words - 8 pages since Durkheim and conclude with an assessment of the usefulness of the concept today.In understanding the transition to modernity, Durkheim, like Marx, took a holistic approach and argued that society cannot be reduced to individuals...'society' was, argued Durkheim, a phenomenon in its own right. It did not depend upon the intentions and motivations of individuals for its continued existence. In his aim to establish sociological autonomy, to

Why Business Matter to God

1060 words - 5 pages considered an “evil” job because all of the rivalry it brings to the different institutions, it can be used as instrumentally by God to help develop and complete His Kingdom here on earth. This book talks about how businessman can glorify God by doing their job even though people might think that you cannot glorify God in what they call “secular” jobs. In the following paragraphs I describe the six most important ideas I found in the text “Why

Similar Essays

Succession Planning In Government Organization: Why Does It Matter?

2885 words - 12 pages Succession planning sometimes is called succession management to emphasize the active and continuous nature of the efforts in preparing people to meet an organization's needs for talent over time. Rothwell, J.W (2005) defined it as any effort designed to ensure the continued effective performance of an organization, division, department, or work group by making provision for the development, replacement, and strategic application of key people

What Is The Purpose Of Work And Why Does It Matter? Business Essay

725 words - 3 pages completely accurate. In the story of King David and Moses, they could not have made it too the end without having to endure the “useless” careers in the beginning. Without gaining the knowledge from their previous work, which may have seemed to be useless at the time, they definitely would not have made it to becoming King, in David’s situation, or the deliverer of God’s chosen people, like Moses’ situation. Similar to these two significant people

Is It Self Or Not Self, And Does It Matter?

762 words - 4 pages fall within the Buddhist rubric of the ego? If ESP exists, and is shown to be evident does it prove the self exists, or is it simply a matter of going in the direction one was destined. Einstein said one can affect the outcome by thinking it, physicists note that light particles know where they are traveling and adjust their behavior accordingly. The Buddhist interpretation, I believe would say that O’Keefe premonitions were a metaphysical

In What Ways Does Aristotle Exhibit Ambivalence Toward Slavery And Why Does This Matter?

1840 words - 8 pages . As a result, this capability or function becomes more important when regarding the slave’s human form or humanness. For instance, human comprehension (not rationality) gives the ability to follow orders, the hands can operate the loom and the eyes can see as a lookout on a ship. The idea of artificial slaves becomes a justification through his strong focus on function, illustrating why human slaves are necessary. However, he does not mention