This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Does One Obey His/Her Religious Beliefs When They Are In Conflict With The Laws Of The State?

1083 words - 4 pages

I believe that in the play, "Antigone" by Sophocles that one does not obey his or her religious beliefs when they are in conflict with the laws of state because Creon believes that all should obey the laws set forth by him, even if other beliefs in their moral or religious state. But Antigone on the other hand, who is a citizen of this society, believes that the laws of the gods should be obeyed above all others especially when in respect to her family. Creon has a very strong opinion about the laws of the city and the laws passed by him, but does he have the right to let the citizens to believe in the gods of law and to make a decision over one's family member? Many people obey Creon's laws because they fear him as a king and they will keep following Creon's orders as long as he is a king.Creon has a very strong opinion about the laws of Thebes and the laws passed by him but does he have the right to let the citizens to believe in the gods of law or not? His method of enforcing them is very strict. Creon orders that Polyneices will not be buried because of his dishonor towards Thebes when Polyneices attacked Thebes and betrayed Creon and his people. If anyone is caught burying him they will be killed for disobeying his order. But, that should not still give the rights to Creon whether to bury someone or not, even if their religion is to be buried under water or underground. A good example is when Ismene's regard for Creon's laws, she tries to talk her sister out of burying her brother because of what could happen to her if Creon found out that she went against him. Ismene says "We must obey them.....I yield to those who have authority" (pg, 11) What rights does Creon have to make a decision over one's family member? In this society he has every right, and that is why no one can obey their religious beliefs over the state of law. Antigone stated: "For I had lost a son, or lost a husband, never would I have ventured such an act against the son from him if I had lost a son. But since my mother and father have both gone to the grave, there can be none henceforth that I can ever call my brother." (pg, 24) Antigone honors her brother as much as her father and mother.Not only do the people of Thebes obey the laws of the city, but because they obey them of fear because it is a shame to dishonor the king. If one were to go against the king and dishonors the king, that person is to die a more shameful death then Antigone's mother and father. But Antigone does not want to let her brother be left without a proper burial. She believes that she must show respect and show her love towards her brother so she must bury him. Antigone believes in "The sacred laws that heaven holds in honor" are far more important than those set by the king. She believes that the king cannot and has no right to...

Find Another Essay On Does one obey his/her religious beliefs when they are in conflict with the laws of the state?

Explain how the principal beliefs of Christianity as they are expressed in the Bible, influence the lives of adherents

1572 words - 7 pages There are five core beliefs in the Bible that has a significant impact on the Christian faith and the lives of its adherents. These five beliefs are, the divinity and humanity of Jesus, the death and resurrection of Jesus, the nature of God and the trinity, the revelation and salvation. These beliefs are all clearly demonstrated in various forms and quantities across all Christian denominations. One of the main principles of Christianity is

Forms of Imprisonment. This deals with the mind of criminals and how they phsyically are in a prison but also how normal indivduals with mental disorder are in a state of imprisonment

729 words - 3 pages conditions not only physically but mentally as well. This experience may be too much for which a person cannot handle, especially those who have lead a normal life and made a mistake which they regret and learned from. When an individual experiences an extreme state of despair, he or she may be unable to mentally relieve the heavy burden of total desperation. Both of these individuals are clearly held in forms of captivity. One of the only ways that

?Revolutions Occur When Governments are Weak.? Discuss in Terms of the Russian Revolution and One Other

1852 words - 7 pages with which the corrupt and weak government cannot cope. However this is rarely the case as, ?the simple fact of oppression does not lead to revolution.? In fact the reality is quite the opposite. As Alexis de Tocquevile pointed out, ?revolutions seldom start when things are bad, rather when they are getting better.? This may seem contradictory but if one considers Aristotle?s principle, ?that the distribution of political power tends to approximate

The Philosophical Beliefs of Geoffrey Chaucer: Why has Chaucer's works been kept alive for so long? What are his beliefs?

1108 words - 4 pages taught virginity is the epitome of morality and righteousness. Chaucer exposes the contradictions in these Christian ideals. He agrees that virginity is noble, but he does not understand how Christianity can be continued without procreation. In addition, the amount of virgins in today's times is very insignificant. "Chaste of her body and her soul was she, and so she flowed in her virginity with all humility and abstinence in temperance and patient

When Religious Beliefs Overpower Human Rights

1719 words - 7 pages the course of history, when people have sincerely looked into their own minds, they have found a great deal of aggression there” (85). He further suggested that Buddhism survived because it was designed to accommodate the transformation of the patterns of ignorance, hatred and greed which are the main cause of self and collective oppression, which is what leads to suffering. To this point, combining church and state may benefit in the liberation of all sentient beings, insofar that the goal of the religious institutions involved is to act with compassion and nonviolently.

Explain how a student of religion who may or may not have religious convictions would set about the examination of a religion with which they are unfamiliar?

1317 words - 5 pages ourselves or enhance the belief that we already have? The question of whether a persons existing religious beliefs may affect the way they treat the beliefs of others does need to be asked. To cite a rather exaggerated example, a Southern Baptist in America embarking upon a study of Islam may have difficulty dismissing the words of one of its churches prominent figures, Jerry Vines, who claimed Mohammed, the Islamic prophet and founder of the church

How does the David Williamson use conflict as a way of exploring ideas in his play, 'Brilliant Lies'?

720 words - 3 pages greed, personal gain and the worst of human nature. As Susy and Gary fight for the upper hand in their conciliation meetings and they battle with each other for advantage points, each reveals their character flaws.Susy tells two conflicting stories about her harassment and the audience is left in doubt about what events have actually occurred. The impression is that Susy fabricates at least one story for money, her goal being to start up "a

Discuss competition between women in "The Snow Child," and "The Company of Wolves." If women are subjugated in these stories, why do they work against one another instead of banding together? What...

1776 words - 7 pages principles do exist. Hence, when offering the snow child refuge and protection, the Count abandons the Countess, almost as if to fool the snow child into believing that the Count does not objectify her, but rather truly loves her as he is willing to reject his now obsolete wife as an act of good faith and devotion. Therefore, it can be examined that men are able to manipulate and control women to the extent that they compete against one another

"Mortal Law Verses Divine Law"-- In the play Antigone, there is a clear conflict between the written law made by the king, and the higher law, dictated by the religious beliefs of the time

1057 words - 4 pages . Different people from different times and different cultures are obviously going to have varying views. In the days when everyone had the same value system because they were all the same religion, these values were reflected in the laws. As people progressed, they separated into different religions and beliefs so the laws changed with them, becoming more based on fairness and equality than enforcing moral values. This made it possible for people of many different beliefs to live together in relative peace and harmony.

Thomas Hardy and His Religious Beliefs

716 words - 3 pages Thomas Hardy and His Religious Beliefs Thomas Hardy was born into a very active Christian family. He was the son of Orthodox Christians who made sure that he regularly attended services. Many of Hardy's relatives were involved in the church. Some were members of the clergy and some were musicians at the local church. Hardy, a member of the Stinsford parish, taught a Sunday school class when he was a young man. He even had aspirations of

What options do managers have in such conditions when they are negotiating with employees?

2094 words - 8 pages dining room and their garage. One woman has two machines in her bedroom - an overlocker and a sewing machine. They are often very dark and confined spaces with not much air and there is a lot of dust in the air from the cloth they are using.The TCFUA claims that conditions have declined in recent years...Managers have the option, then, of forcing workers to become sub-contractors as well as failing to respond to wage demands. And workers are being

Similar Essays

The Conflict: One State Solution Essay

1419 words - 6 pages Since 1920, about 115,000 people have been killed as a direct effect of the violence in Palestine and Israel. (2014 Index of Economic Freedom.) The One State Solution will only work if both sides commit to a democracy, separation of state and religion and an end to violence. They have to learn to do these soon because if they don’t everyone in Palestine and Israel will be wiped out. Making a One State Solution will make one strong economy

How Does O’brien Use The Things They Carried To Cope With The Psychological Impact Of His Experience In The War?

874 words - 4 pages is known as a piece of fiction, the stories that O’Brien tells show how he was coping with his situations. One of the themes that are present in the novel is the physical and emotional burdens that the characters carry. None of the characters that O’Brien created were perfect; they all had some kind of disorder. Physically, they all carried their necessities, such as a nylon-covered flak jackets, compasses, guns, and a poncho. But at the same

How Does The Iroquois’ Religious Beliefs Differ From Christianity?

1116 words - 5 pages between the Iroquois’ beliefs and Christianity is the theory on “the creation of life”. The Iroquois believe in a creator God called ‘Hahgwehdiyu’, which was the good spirit of the twin Gods of Wind Breath. He shaped the world with the palm of his hands and recycled the corpse of his dead mother to create the sky, moon and the sun. He planted a grain of corn in her to give the world fertility. It is believed that when the Sky Woman, or the mother

Compare The Iroquois Constitution And The U.S. Constitution With Regard To The Separation Of Church And State (Separating Religious/Spiritual Beliefs From Governing Policy)

653 words - 3 pages 6.2 Consumers Turn Right-Work FileUse the information found on the 6.2 Activity page to find the answers to the questions below.Fill in the blank with the appropriate consumer right.1. The right to _______________ means consumers will be protected from products that are dangerous.2. The right to ____________means consumers have the right to make their own choices.3. The right to ______________ means consumers can speak out when they want to be