Does Racial Profiling Actually Occur Essay

1753 words - 7 pages

The concern about racial profiling is erupting throughout the nation. Many cities and states have decided to study racial profiling, or how race and ethnicity may play a part in traffic stops by law enforcement in their jurisdictions. There seems to be a generally accepted understanding of what profiling is. Profiling is the law-enforcement practice of scrutinizing certain individuals based on characteristics thought to indicate a likelihood of criminal behavior. Yet, there are two variations concerning the application of racial profiling. Profiling either utilizes race as a sole means of directing police attention, or uses race as a part of a larger set of characteristics and behaviors that lead to police involvement (2011, pg. 75). Regardless of the definition of racial profiling, the debate over racial profiling centers on two questions. Does racial profiling actually occur? and Is racial profiling being used and is profiling a legitimate tool of law enforcement?
Generally, the announcement of a racial profiling study by police and/or other public officials typically includes a denial that racial profiling exists “within this jurisdiction,” but also an acknowledgment that it would be helpful to study the pattern of police stops within the jurisdiction (2012, pg. 3). The prevalence of racial profiling and understand that this practice descended from stigmas created during slavery to socially control African Americans. The very act of undertaking such a study reaffirms the general public policy goal that policing decisions should be race-neutral.
Purpose of Study
With such activity being conducted by law officials for well over 100 years, why is it only now that the issue of racial profiling is making large news within the mainstream media as well as in the sociological realm (2012, pg. 1)? I theorize five reasons behind the recent news that racial profiling is receiving. First, in recent years African-Americans have attained a social and economic status in sectors in which their voices are not so easily ignored. Second, the visual and reported evidences of occurrences of mistreatment toward blacks by police, although not traffic profiling cases, broaden the view of police activity to include profiling involved by traffic stops. Third, more and more individual African-Americans are filing complaints and taking harassment cases to higher authorities (courts). Fourth, more affluent and high social class status African-Americans are charging that they have been stopped merely because of their skin color. Fifth, more and more cases of racial profiling are being publicized and investigated by collective organizations such as the ACLU (American civil Liberties Union) and the NAACP (National Association for the Advancement of Colored People) .
However, it also signals to law enforcement officers that extra caution may be needed to ensure that the data they collect while performing their duties should reflect a lack of bias in their own...

Find Another Essay On Does Racial Profiling Actually Occur

The extent and ethics of racial profiling

6064 words - 24 pages officers. As such, the International Association of Chiefs of Police (IACP) has said that "However prevalent racial profiling actually is, public perceptions implore police executives to address it (IACP, 2006).The question that I will attempt to answer in this paper is; is racial profiling a widespread problem amongst law enforcement agencies in the United States and if so, what are the ethical implications?Of course, to answer the question about

Racial Profiling in Canada Essay

1265 words - 5 pages .” whereas criminal profiling “relies on actual behaviour or on information about suspected activity by someone who meets the description of a specific individual” (Facts Sheet, para 2). This definition is also shared by Casola but Coles considers them as the same. It is important to separate fact from feelings when discussing racial profiling; stereotypes are offensive, however identifying one’s race in a criminal profile does not make one

Racial Targeting and Profiling in the United States

1463 words - 6 pages Racial Targeting and Profiling in the United States The practice of targeting individuals for police investigation based on their race alone in the last few years has been an increasingly prominent issue in American society. Numerous magazines, newspapers, and journals have explored the issue of race-motivated police actions. Recently, the ABA Journal did a study of New Jersey and Pennsylvania traffic stops from 1998 to 2001, concluding

Let's Not Add Insult to Injury.

1030 words - 4 pages "Even the most expert, subtle forms of racial profiling are imperfect, discriminatory, morally dubious, but probably necessary tools that one hopes are a temporary means to a desirable outcome," says Kurt Andersen, a columnist for New York magazine. Racial profiling and police brutality are not synonymous terms. Being especially alert to someone based on their appearance is biased, but does not have to become a violent or traumatizing event

Racial Profiling in America

2328 words - 9 pages offenders would strike next. In compiling this data, law enforcement was able to predict on a fairly regular basis the nature of the crime that would be committed, the general area in which it would occur and the probable race of the offender(s). Officers would conduct surveillance in the area in the predicted time period, looking for potential suspects who "fit the bill." Although this is technically racial profiling by definition, New York City

Criminal Profiling: Real Science of Just Wishful Thinking

2451 words - 10 pages organized or disorganized or just a mixture of both. In recent times, there have been speculations on whether it is just luck, subjective presumptions or is criminal profiling a true scientific answer to many tricky crimes? If asked the same question, I would perhaps reply by insinuating that while it may actually be luck profiling really helps in the narrowing down of the list of possible offenders and thus in my opinion it is quite effective. The

Racial Profiling is Wrong

2317 words - 9 pages basic human rights and freedoms to which every person is entitled. As we all may know racial profiling comes in different forms. Some may occur more often than others. Its not only officers that uses racial profiling we the people do as well. A Motor vehicle search can be a possible application of racial profiling. In the United States black drivers are much more likely to have their car stopped and searched than white drivers or any

Racial Profiling: The Color of Justice in America

1120 words - 4 pages how erroneous it is to judge people without evidence. Although Cole and William were very successful in matters of showing situations and qualitative information about racial profiling in their articles, both of them fail at some points. In the article Road Rage, Williams does a good job trying to make society aware of the racial profiling problem and also trying to make each citizen more conscious about its consequences through communities

Racial Profiling Is Ineffective

751 words - 4 pages Racial Profiling has been around ever since the 911 incident for the sake of the National security. Although it must not be a reason to keep the peaceful civilian in a threat of getting captured just because of their outlooks and their nationality, religion etc. It does not mean if one person is a national threat, the ones whose alike are all terrorists. All human beings are individual, and unique we cannot characterize a person without knowing

An Argument Against Racial Profiling by Police

1612 words - 6 pages racial profiling in more sever situations such as terrorism. Since the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center and Pentagon on September 11, 2001, Arabs and Muslims have been racially profiled more than everyone else when it comes to national security. The federal government claims that anti-terrorism efforts does not compare to racial profiling, because the federal government is just trying to protect the lives of the American people from

racial profiling

596 words - 3 pages Racial profiling has been a common controversy between law enforcement and communities, specifically those of a minority population. This activity has been ultimately allowed by federal and state governments as they benefit from the aid in pinpointing or otherwise targeting criminals or illegal aliens. Furthermore, racial profiling has become more of a commonly encountered practice especially after the September 11 attacks. Racial profiling is

Similar Essays

Police And Racial Profiling Essay

2178 words - 9 pages profiling that occur in law enforcement. However, the hardest ethical choices for police officers will arise in the gray areas. Police discretion can be improved with many of these new training procedures. I think that the only answer is to ensure that police profiling does not occur, but insure that police officers pull over anyone they feel may be committing a crime. Bibliography (2004). American Civil Liberties. Retrieved September 20,2004

How Racial Profiling Led To The Death Of Trayvon Martin

1002 words - 5 pages , but just because a citizen or officer of the law felt like they were does that make it okay to take matters in their own hands? Law enforcement has a job to protect, if their racial profiling judgment is in fact wrong, they can lose trust and creditability. Through there may have been cases were racial profiling has worked, due to luck; the cases in which they have been wrong have ended in devastating ways. Racial profiling continues to be a

Racial Profiling By Police Is Not Justified

4309 words - 17 pages problem of racial profiling. On the other hand, people need to remember that the media has its own agenda and are selecting the stories that will intrigue the listener or reader. Likewise, it seems as though the media does, in fact, portray crime to be different from the way it actually is. For instance, white on black victimization is reported on more frequently than black on white victimization. Is this because it happens so infrequently

Professional Racism And Discrimination Essay

1431 words - 6 pages excessively beat King. This incident caused uproar in the African-American community who retaliated with riots. Racial profiling can easily lead to racially motivated violence among the people. It’s because Rodney King was African-American that the police officers brutally beat him, if he was White he would have only been arrested. Racial profiling does not only occur on the streets; it also occurs in the justice system. Young Black males are more