Does Religious Pluralism Undermine Central Doctrines Of Christianity? Oxted Sixth Form, Theology Essay

1314 words - 6 pages

Theology Olivia-Mae 10/10/17
To what extent does a theologically pluralist approach undermine the central doctrines of Christianity?
A theologically pluralist view is the view that there are many different ways to salvation through different religious traditions. The other two approaches are that of inclusivism and exclusivism (including narrow and broad). These contrasting views and approaches bring about the soteriological problem; can people of a non-christian religion or that hold no religious beliefs still gain salvation?
Gavin D’Costa identifies as an inclusivist because to him, it doesn’t make sense with the central beliefs of God being an omnibenevolent being that he would condemn millions of people to hell sometimes through no fault of their own. He also believed that pluralism didn’t work in line with God’s grace; it severely undermines Christianity and all loyal Christians. If anyone can gain salvation through any means, then what would be the point in being a Christian at all? It would seem that those who have dedicated their lives to living as good Christians and following Jesus’ example could still have found salvation through another means, which defeats the whole point of being a Christian in the first place. This is a logical analysis of the different approaches to salvation, which makes D’Costa’s argument a convincing one. A contrasting view to this is that of Kraemer’s. Kraemer was an exclusivist which means that he believed that the only means to salvation was through Christ. He believed that salvation could not be gained through any other faith systems, and can only be achieved through Christianity, which means that if anyone from another religion desired salvation then they would have to convert. He argued that either religions accept the salvation offered by Christ or they don’t. Whilst on the surface this approach may seem logical, when looking deeper, it doesn’t seem as likely. Whilst it is true that Jesus is the one offering salvation, and there are many Bible quotes to back this up (eg. ‘No one gets to the Father except through me’), this approach also goes against one of Christianity’s most central beliefs - Jesus’ teaching of ‘Love thy neighbour’ which goes hand in hand with the notion of agape love that most Christians attempt to live by. It may be acceptable to not give salvation to those who have heard the gospel and rejected it, it makes no sense whatsoever to suggest that an omnibenevolent God would reject those who have not even heard the gospel and had a chance to react to it, for example they may have lived in a time beforehand or their culture may not be exposed to Christianity. It would make more sense to offer other ways to salvation for these people, even if keeping Christianity and Jesus Christ in the centre.
A view that supports Kraemer’s is Karl Bath’s. Bath believed that God chose to reveal himself through Christianity; through Jesus Christ - the...

Find Another Essay On Does Religious Pluralism Undermine Central Doctrines of Christianity? - Oxted sixth form, Theology - Essay

Thomas Aquinas’ Theory of Christianity Theology is Science

673 words - 3 pages Thomas Aquinas’ Theory of Christianity Theology is Science Thomas Aquinas claims Christianity is a science with the use of the writings of Aristotle on scientific knowledge. Aquinas also makes the claim that theology, or the study God, is a science accepted through Revelation. Faith provides ammunition for Aquinas to state that believers of Christianity have the affirmation of God already inside of them. This claim considered that divine

Christianity beliefs and sources of authority - Theology - Research Notes

4144 words - 17 pages CHRISTIANITY 1 Beliefs and Source of Authority 1.1 The Bible Bible = source of Christian’s main beliefs Come from Greek word biblia and contains two main sections OT and NT OT Testament=covenant/agreement—old agreement between god and humans Refers to 39 books of the Jewish scriptures. 3 main parts LAW-first 5 books include 10 commandments to Moses. PROPHETS and WRITINGS Language= Hebrew NT Language=Greek New agreement Contains

Theology and Christianity: The Works of Augustine and Pelagius

2037 words - 9 pages Augustine and Pelagius were two of the great fourth century theologians who’s work has an effect on the theology of Christianity today which centers in the areas of original sin and free will. Sin can be defined as anything that does not express or conform to the holy character of God. The issue of sin is not in its definition it is in the origin. Augustine and Pelagius were two people with two different views of the origin of sin. Pelagius

Reflection Paper For Philosophy Of Religion: The Continous Conflict Between Religious Pluralism And Exclusivism

1707 words - 7 pages way that some are right and some are wrong (exclusivism). Finally, one can also (3) think about all religions as false (atheism).Let me take into consideration the third stance first. By arguing that all religious beliefs are false, it also means arguing that God or any form of the transcendent does not exist. And by arguing this, means rejecting all of the theistic theses that were formulated in the history of man. And this is the part where the

What extent can it be argued that anti-Semitism was deep-rooted and widespread in Germany? - Sixth form, History - Essay

4028 words - 17 pages Goldhagen. Christopher Browning refutes Goldhagen's belief, and strongly suggests that the German people were manipulated by a 'popular, ideologically driven, dictoral regime' and its followers with the intent to 'harness' the rest of society.3 Although Browning disagrees with Goldhagen, that the anti-Semitic ways of the German people are what led to such genocidal outcomes, he does agree that anti-Semitism was present within German culture, however

How should Theists interpret the Abraham and Isaac story? Is this story an endorsement of divine command Theory? OR does it undermine Divine Command theory? OR does it neither endorse nor undermine...

2122 words - 8 pages Jake Radowski How should Theists interpret the Abraham and Isaac story? Is this story an endorsement of divine command Theory? OR does it undermine Divine Command theory? OR does it neither endorse nor undermine Divine Command TheoryThe biblical story of Abraham and Isaac presents an interesting analogy for those of the belief in Divine Command Theory (which I will refer to in shorthand of [DCT]) while also providing a jump off for which

in what ways did enlightenment undermine the concept of absolutism - gordons - essay

1056 words - 5 pages religion in Europe faced serious problems. The preceding century of religious wars had produced many contending sects and shaken the unquestioning faith of medieval times. Overseas expansion and the resulting contacts with non-Christian religions contributed to the same result. State churches, often used by kings to support corrupt regimes, also undermined respect for traditional Christianity. Added to all of this was the impact of the Newtonian

Benchmark Assignment – Theology of Missions - Essay - INT-310 - Essay

3614 words - 15 pages Benchmark Assignment – Theology of Missions – Essay By examining the four Gospels, and one can find the importance of Scriptures as the foundation for a faithful theology, so they unquestionably identify the distinct importance of contextualization. Nonetheless, individually the writers of the Gospels distinctly have a mission of making disciples, and merely not converts. The writers of the Gospels not only retell the message of Jesus as well

Does the Via Negative solve the problem of religious language?

715 words - 3 pages 'Does the Via Negativa solve the problem of religious language?' Assess this view.When using human language in a religious context we come across many problems, including that of anthropomorphising God, and using words of our limited experience to attempt to define a Transcendent and ineffable being. Many scholars have assessed whether the Via Negativa has solved this issue, and whether or not it should be an attempt used by Christians, as we

Religious Influence - University of Phoenix / Hist275 - Essay

583 words - 3 pages HTS/275 Between 300 BCE and 100 BCE were a myriad of religious and political views within the Chinese and Japanese cultures. From 300 CE and 300 BCE was the Yayoi revolution. Coming after the Yayoi Revolution was inevitably the Tomb Culture, 300 CE to 680 CE. The Chinese civilization of 680 CE and about 850 CE gave more change in Nara and Early Heian Japan. Later the introduction of Buddhism to the Japanese culture also played a heavy and

Structure of central policy making - European Studies - Essay

1378 words - 6 pages Berfin Dogru EU22001: Contemporary Challenges For Europe Tutor: Bert Schweitzer Essay 2: Discuss the structures of the policy making of the European Union with reference to the role of its central bodies and different policies (Minimum of two). The European Union became out of an aspiration for reconciliation in a war-torn and partitioned mainland. Five years after the World War II finished, France and Germany thought of an arrangement to

Similar Essays

How Does The Iroquois’ Religious Beliefs Differ From Christianity?

1116 words - 5 pages Americans who are historically important and powerful. In the following essay we will discover some differences between the religious beliefs of the Native American Iroquois and Christianity to see if culture and ways of living have an effect on the view of religion, but we will also get to know some similarities. I am going to be focusing on the Iroquois, which are the northeastern Native Americans in North America. One of the first differences

Challenges Of Religious Pluralism Essay

1200 words - 5 pages today. However, many things have happened in the past few decades to change the way religions have been conducting themselves. One theme that has overly changed over the years is that of pluralism. For many years, America has been a haven of different groupings of people. The British immigration brought with it a different ideology since they lacked unification in their own religious beliefs. This essay seeks to show how the Roman Catholic Church

Theology Charles Mathewe’s Understanding Religious Ethics Theo 214 Essay

1555 words - 7 pages religious aspect of friendship, there seems to be a common theme amongst Judaism, Christianity, and Islam that friends are inequalities in our lives that keep us form loving everyone and remembering our true relationship with God as being the most important. It is here that one can find some agreement with the information that Mathewes presents. God calls for us to love thy neighbor, and friendship causes a bias within us towards certain people

The Historical Context Of The Bhagavad Gita And Its Relation To Indian Religious Doctrines

2519 words - 10 pages The Historical Context of The Bhagavad Gita and Its Relation to Indian Religious Doctrines The Bhagavad Gita is perhaps the most famous, and definitely the most widely-read, ethical text of ancient India. As an episode in India's great epic, the Mahabharata, The Bhagavad Gita now ranks as one of the three principal texts that define and capture the essence of Hinduism; the other two being the Upanishads and the Brahma Sutras. Though this work