This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Does The Current Conflict Between The West And Islam Confirm Or Contradict Huntington's Clash Of Civilization Thesis?

2604 words - 10 pages

Samuel Huntington's thesis on "The clash of civilisations" of 1993 provoked a plethora of varied responses. A Professor at Harvard University, Huntington wrote in order to voice his predictions and warn the world of an upcoming clash of cultures, most notably between the West and Islam. The recent reaction in the Middle East to America's self-styled 'war on terrorism' provides a timely case study for this debate. While an affinity will often exist between countries with similar cultural characteristics, great differences within 'civilisations' and the existence of national interests make unity unlikely. Certainly, cultural differences alone will not be enough to cause a clash. However, anticipating such an outcome and dividing nations into groups according Huntington's civilisations will only make the outcome more likely. Huntington also fails to convincingly outline why he believes different 'civilisation' values are irreconcilable, apparently unchanging and almost immune from each others' influence. This paper argues that the basic premise of Huntington's contention can only be supported if it is defined as the West being pitted against extreme fundamentalist Islam, characterised by political and military aggression.

The concept of a "clash of civilisations", however, is far more complex than this and requires more sophisticated analysis than just mere cultural reduction. While elements of Huntington's thesis may have merit and indeed may be perceived to have been vindicated by the events which occured on September 11, the heterogeneity of both the West and Islam needs to be acknowledged in any serious consideration of a 'Clash of Civilisations'.

Huntington's view is based on a concept of clashes in religion and ideology (as discrete, homogeneous entities), manifest in irreconcilable social, economic, and political stances, and actioned through military and political aggression. From this perspective, the contrast between Western and Islam cultures can no doubt be used as an argument for the inevitability of a clash between the two cultures. However, Huntington's view is too simplistic in the way that it describes cultural stereotypes. Cultures per se are difficult to define "partly because they are too complex and dynamic." Neither the West nor Islam is monolithic or homogeneous. Rather, each comprises and encompasses a range of perspectives and 'sub-cultures'.

Huntington's thesis is premised on an assumption of a predominantly pluralistic culture and attitude to religion in the West, directly opposed by one xenophobic fundamentalist position which underpins the Islam religion and by implication, all Muslim states. This is not accurate, however, as Islam manifests itself in many different ways. The West accommodates a range of religious expression and faiths, promotes free choice of religion, and relies more on the 'individual' in the political spectrum. Conversely, Islamic states are seen as mono-religious, do not...

Find Another Essay On Does the Current Conflict Between the West and Islam Confirm or Contradict Huntington's Clash of Civilization Thesis?

The three central protagonists in Enduring Love could be said to represent science, art and religion. In the light of this statement, how far does this count for the conflict between the characters?

1762 words - 7 pages the truth - who then is mad? I think the perspective society takes on the three issues is precisely what causes the conflict between the characters.Science is based on reality, truth, facts and rational thought. You do not believe and see or see to believe; it just Is. Art, 'the creation of something beautiful or significant' (dictionary) Therefore, although art is often an expression, there is evidence of it - it uses a human skill to create a

Comments of Huntington's "The Clash of Civilizations

1171 words - 5 pages divided and not united as one single nation, there will always be a clash of one sort or another. The point that Huntington is making is that the reasoning behind these clashes is evolving from ideas to identities. No one can predict what the next evolution of conflict will be, but for now it is over culture and religion. "The Clash of Civilizations thus occurs at two levels. At the micro-level, adjacent groups, along the fault lines between

Comments Of Huntington's "The Clash Of Civilizations"

1183 words - 5 pages divided and not united as one single nation, there will always be a clash of one sort or another. The point that Huntington is making is that the reasoning behind these clashes is evolving from ideas to identities. No one can predict what the next evolution of conflict will be, but for now it is over culture and religion. "The Clash of Civilizations thus occurs at two levels. At the micro-level, adjacent groups, along the fault lines between

Does the Theory of Evolution Contradict Creation?

1724 words - 7 pages logical explanation of the importance that shows why the theory of evolution is not in accordance with Islam and the fact of creation . Basic dogma of Darwinism proposes that life came into existence by itself spontaneously as a result of coincidences . This view is completely contrary to the belief in the existence of God's natural creation . The biggest mistake of those who believe that the theory of evolution does not contradict the fact of

Samuel Huntington's The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order

2665 words - 11 pages may be associated, as belief systems are not bound by politics. However, for the purposes of this paper, one must associate each religion with one or two countries to have some basis for analysis of the current events pertaining to each religion, and more importantly, the clash between that religion and Western thought. Therefore, Sinic/Confucian thought will be associated mostly with China, Hindu with India, Islam with the Middle Eastern and

The Clash of Civilization in Macau

669 words - 3 pages don't feel and believe that I am Chinese. I think I still have something different from the local Chinese, but of course I don't think that I am superior to them!" The difference between Ana and most local Chinese is their religion. Ana is a Catholic. Ana goes to the church on every Sunday. She also hopes to have her wedding ceremony in the church in the future. Ana's boyfriend, Luis, is also a Macanese. "I will choose Macanese as my boyfriend

Reanalyze the Relationship of the West and Islamic Civilization Future

1502 words - 7 pages Samuel P. Huntington thesis has been in center of debates for many years. Moreover, his prediction that main conflicts in near future is between the West (the United States and allies) versus Islamic Civilization has triggered controversy among International Relations scholars. This paper tries to analyze three main supportive arguments from Huntington thesis in the West v. Islam conflict. Democracy System v. Islamic Laws Samuel P. Huntington

Napoleon: Confirm or Deny the Revolution

1161 words - 5 pages While there is debate over whether Napoleon confirmed or denied the French Revolution there is one thing that is clear and un-debatable; he was what ended it. Whether it was with his death or with the beginning of his reign is what is debatable. There is evidence that leads to both the ideas of him confirming it or him denying it and, in the end; the fact may be that the way the evidence is interpreted by a single person may determine what the

The Clash of Civilizations: Culture & Conflict

1390 words - 6 pages , they both wanted to be the dominant country in the world in order to spread and introduce their cultures to other countries. Huntington (1996) also states that the non - Western countries have resented the rise of the West and reacted against it as they gain power. Thus I agree with Huntington that a new clash with global conflict will break out as the non - Western cultures appear and start to counter the Western civilization because they want to

Samuel Huntington's "clash of civilizations"

1178 words - 5 pages Samuel P. Huntington's paper "The clash of civilizations" defines the shifting of causes for friction between nations. He describes the changing of the guard, between secular ideological friction, such as democracy versus communism, to cultural and religious reasoning. Huntington's hypothesis is based heavily on examples of recent struggles between civilizations all over the world. I agree with Huntington's hypothesis because it is evident that

Clash of Civilization

1288 words - 6 pages and culture as in relation to Islam and the West having reference to different arguments and visions presented in the following scholarly sources. Samuel P. Huntington in his book “ The Clash of Civilizations”has predicted that the source of conflict in the new world shall not be ideological or primarily economic, as the great divisions among humankind and dominating source of conflict shall be cultural.Although nation states will remain to be

Similar Essays

Critically Evaluate How Said's "Orientalism" Thesis And Huntington's "Clash Of Civilization" Thesis Apply To Asian

992 words - 4 pages in fact the Confucian-Islamic military connection has not come into being. If Huntington uses the ammo trades as the evidence for clash of civilization, how can he explain the fact that United States is the maximal munitioner in the world? According to Huntington's logic, if Untied States sells weapons to other countries, which are non-western civilization, whether or not we should understand this is a connection between western and other

Clash Between Cultures Of East And West

1154 words - 5 pages the hands of the infidel. He called the Muslims as "an accused race, a race utterly alienated from God" Populist response to this call was immediate and widespread. The word "crusade" entered the vocabulary and generally meant removal of the enemy. After all, there are those today who similarly image a cultural clash between East and West. Each side insists that the other endangers civilization itself. Of course, only a crusader mentality does

"The Central Axis Of World Politics In The Future Is Likely To Be The Conflict Between The West And The Rest" Discuss

2880 words - 12 pages groups belonging to the same civilization than any sort of clash of civilizations. The road to full scale war between civilizations seems as unlikely now as it does in the future.Asadi (2007) however views Huntington's (1993) theory of future conflict between the "west and the rest" from an entirely different perspective. According to Asadi (2007) the clash of civilizations thesis is part of an attempt by the United States political economy to justify

Conflicts Between Arab And Israeli What Are The Roots Of The Conflict?, What Were The Events Since 1948, What Were The Recent Events And The Current Situation?

1026 words - 4 pages , there were over 150 Jewish settlements in the West Bank, mostly agricultural but with some more industrial. Israel's winning of the West Bank created many refugees, and Israel refused, and still does, to let them return to their land. Israeli policy on Jerusalem has remained the same since the Jews united the city under their rule. It was adopted as their capital; as it was before the Diaspora of 70AD, and the Jews will never back down on their