Does The Rape Shield Law Support Nesson's View That Verdicts Are To Instill Confidence In The Public Rather Than Maximizing The Truth.

1297 words - 5 pages

THE RAPE SHIELD LAWThe Rape Shield Law that limits the use of a victim's prior sexual history as an attempt to undermine the credibility of the victim's testimony supports Charles Nesson's view of verdicts. It supports Nesson's views in the sense that verdicts are not about the evidence but rather by the event. Furthermore the Rape Shield Law promotes public confidence in verdicts because the public especially rape victims, are encouraged to report rape incidents.Public confidence in verdicts is promoted a result of the Rape Shield Laws. Prior to this law, some courts restricted evidence of the victim's sexual relations with men other than the defendant to testimony of general reputation. Witnesses could be asked if the victim is known to be unchaste in the community. Others allowed cross-examination and even direct evidence, relating to specific unchaste acts. Also when a woman took a stand, the defense counsel could cross-examine her about the details of her past relations with other men. In some States too, evidence of past specific acts must be available, not only for the purpose of being considered by the jury in deciding the weight and credibility of the victim's testimony, but for the purpose of inferring the probability of consent and discrediting her testimony. A defendant would surely like that privilege however it is embarrassing and discourage women from reporting rape cases. Susan Estrich (The Shield Law 291) also informs us that a defendant's knowledge of a woman'ssexual history would be relevant in determining his state of mind at the time of the intercourse, whether he believed that she was consenting to his advances. In this caseone might say that the prejudice of the evidence of a woman's sexual history exceeded its very probative value. However, with the prior rape law, the admission of evidence of a woman's sexual history was not limited to cases where the defendant himself knew his victim's reputation or history. If the defendant finds out that his victim was sexually experienced he could and would try to hide behind that fact at trial.The rape shield laws promote public confidence in verdicts since women are not judged on their sexual history but rather about the event that took place. Therefore a person who has been raped would have confidence that the verdict of the court would not be against her but in favor of her.The Rape Shield Laws does not seek in maximizing the truth. In State V. Smith, the supreme court or Louisiana reversed and remanded the case at hand. Smith the defendant, had been accused of touching the victim in inappropriate places. Evidence of past similar false allegations by the victim had been excluded. The evidence of prior false allegation in my opinion is relevant since the victim could be lying again. Rape is punishable with good amount of years and if she can lie about it once, then there is a strong possibility that she might be putting an innocent person in trouble. Of course including this...

Find Another Essay On Does the Rape Shield law support Nesson's View that verdicts are to instill confidence in the public rather than maximizing the truth.

The Crucible, Arthur Miller "How and to what extent does The Crucible show that it is more damaging to deny the truth, than it is to acknowledge it?"

753 words - 3 pages In The Crucible, Arthur Miller gives many examples that show that denying the truth, and lying to do so, is far more damaging than it is to simply acknowledge it. The play demonstrates the potential damage that can occur to a person's reputation and livelihood when false accusations are placed upon them. It shows that when certain individuals are willing to deny the truth in order to avoid the consequences of acknowledging it, that denial forces

Discuss the view that consolidation rather than expansion was the prime objective of Roman foreign policy between 69 and 211 A.D.

1850 words - 7 pages . Indeed, it was Augustus who envisaged an 'imperium sine fine', but it seems that after A.D 69 emperors did want to consolidate and bring the existing empire together rather than extend its frontiers. It is possibly easier to see the retardation in Roman conquest after A.D 69, not as a long-term political strategy, but as the result of individual emperors responding to the specific difficulties and problems which faced them. It was a mixture of

Explore the features of the language used in digital communications which suggest that they are closer to spoken rather than written language. Com...

2120 words - 9 pages feeling anxious about what to say as they are discussing their own personal life; which can be hard. Another element of spoken language that has made its way into digital communication are pauses which is also an example of a non-fluency feature and is spontaneous so therefore suggests that online language is closer to spoken rather than written language. In post 2 of Text G, the person posting says, ‘I loved the special effects . . . and that kiss

How far do you agree with the view that the tragedies in ‘Ethan Frome’ and ‘A View from the Bridge’ are brought about by individual characters rather

2216 words - 9 pages to that of other communities as they seem to have a negative opinion of the law. They prefer to keep things personal and discuss as well as solve their problems between themselves behind closed doors. Their view of justice differs from the law as it does not follow any written rules as they’re determined by society. Eddie's downfall to tragedy had a lot to do with the community he was brought up in. Both his own and the community's views of

Catcher in the Rye Theme:Human beings are advised not to judge books by their covers, rather that they should look further than the obvious and try to apprehend the implied meaning

1892 words - 8 pages Catcher in the Rye's pallid cover, adorned only with seven multicolored bands in its upper-left corner, is not what one would call eye-catching. Its reverse side lacks criticisms or reviews of any sort; in fact, it is bare of anything except a copyright date. Human beings are advised not to judge books by their covers, rather that they should look further than the obvious and try to apprehend the implied meaning. The world has peered past

This is a speech directed to the audience of the 2003 Academy Awards arguing that feature films are made for money, rather than entertainment.

1058 words - 4 pages for a moment am I condemning the entertainment value of feature films. These movies are an important escape from reality for the viewing public, who does not necessarily want to immerse themselves in a world that confronts the very core of their beliefs. Just answer me one last thing: In a society that considers itself to be more enlightened than ever before, why is it necessary to look to a medium that would rather assure us of our own correctness than expand our minds?"

If judges interpret the law, does that mean they are law makers?

1991 words - 8 pages statutes. So by the very definition of law, cases are part of law. As judges are the originators of cases they do in fact contribute to the law. Thus the question whether judges are law makers seems to be ubiquitous in the light that they contribute to the existence of a very source of law. The question though arises from where do they derive their wisdom. The question has to be limited to analyse the thin line between interpretation of statutes and the

Rape law in the United States

1553 words - 6 pages heterosexual relations. She like Estrich feels that the rape laws are written to proect the perpetrator rather than the victim. Estrich feels that the problems are embedded in the law itself. Her major problem is the exclusion of "mens rea", or guilty mind. This is needed for all criminal acts except for rape. She feels that the law is incredibly ineffective because it puts the victim on trial rather than the offender. No other crime does this. If in a case

Achiles’ Shield in the Iliad

3954 words - 16 pages move from the confusion of the war and wretched grief of Achiles to the serene heights of Mount Olympus and the beauty and order of the world depicted on the shield (27). This change of seting alows for a new perspective, a change of view. Duethorn goes on to say, the dramatic efect of the Shield is like that of certain choruses in the plays of Aeschylus and Sophocles which lift one out of the immediate dramatic action onto a realm of truth and

What should the government do about segregation in our public schools today? Does it matter to you, that students often attend public schools that are populated only by students of their own race?

665 words - 3 pages removed.National governments can try to do what they did not do back in the seventies. The national governments should pass laws to give state and local governments' power to try to help desegregate the public schools. One of the laws could be for example, that all state governments have the power to come into the public schools and see how the classes are sorted. If they come in and see that some classes are only filled with a single race then they can go

The Support of Air Defense in Desert Shield and Desert Storm

1744 words - 7 pages could contact troops on the ground and inform them of the predicted impact locations. The 11th Brigade Air Defense Artillery, “The Imperial Brigade,” supplied the majority of the units using the Patriot weapon systems in Desert Shield and Desert Storm. (Kangas) The Brigade (BDE) would play a direct role in the success of Desert Shield and Desert Storm. Their support to the mission made important contributions to the liberation of

Similar Essays

Why Are Statutory Rape Laws In Nc More Favorable For The Girl Rather Than The Guy?

1945 words - 8 pages , while the male has to suffer with a lifetime sentencing against his character and reputation. Statutory rape laws should not be sexually biased even though they are, and it is a sad thing to see. The laws that govern this issue are sexually biased against the male to the fullest extent; if you are going to put a law in place then the law should be fair across all gender guidelines no matter the circumstance. It should not be harsh toward the men

"Those Who Are Inspired By An Idealism Rather Than Self Interest Make The Biggest Impact On History." To What Extent Does The Study Of Leon Trotsky Support This View?

1184 words - 5 pages to convert Marx's concept of class struggle into a tool for the achievement of his main goal, the seizure of power, that made Lenin a giant in history." Trotsky admires Lenin for his ability to implement his ideals of communism, rather than his popularity and self - interest in power.To a major extent the study of Leon Trotsky supports the view of inspiration for the cause of communism rather than self - interest. Trotsky, in spite of being

Evaluating The View That Poverty Is Caused By Economic Inequality Rather Than Cultural Attitudes And Lifestyles

2000 words - 8 pages Evaluating the View that Poverty is Caused by Economic Inequality Rather than Cultural Attitudes and Lifestyles There is much debate in sociology that poverty is caused by structural factors such as economic inequality and those who state that it is caused by cultural factors such as attitudes, values and lifestyles. The first group say that the poor are made to be poor by the economic and political systems, they state that

Assess The View That Leni Riefenstahl Was Documenting History Rather Than Creating Propaganda.

2977 words - 12 pages promotion, however, it is evident that at this time she had not known the effects of the ideology presented in her films on German life. The view that Leni Riefenstahl was documenting history rather than creating propaganda is not one-sided. It cannot be said that she was doing one or the other because through her documenting history and recording what was in front of her, in what she saw was a groundbreaking artistic way, she created propaganda