Domestic Violence: Wronful Arrests Essay

2275 words - 9 pages

Unfortunately wrongful arrests happen way too often, as Setliff and I discussed. For example, a person may report having probable cause to claim domestic violence and request an arrest. Law enforcement must be vigilant to make sure they are handling domestic violence cases rightfully. Additionally, if an arrest is made, prosecutors should use the same care and caution in order to accurately charge offenders, and prosecute those offenders who truly do pose threat to victims.
It wasn’t until recently that attitudes regarding domestic violence have been taken seriously. Historically, the predominant thought was to blame the victim and give into myths and stereotypes. However, there has been a push to reevaluate these attitudes and begin to retrain law enforcement to understand domestic violence (Grover, Paul, and Dodge 626). In a study regarding attitudes of police officers towards domestic violence, it was found that “most of the officers (84%) felt that domestic violence calls take too much of their time and effort” (Grover et al 626). Officers “showed a high level of frustration with repeat calls to the same address (93%), and believed that too many domestic violence calls are for verbal arguments (93%)” (Grover et al 626). However, the same study also found that 87% of officers disagreed with the statement that domestic violence cases should be handled as private matters and 64% agreed with the statement, “Domestic violence offenders must be arrested even when the victims don’t feel it is necessary” (Grover et al 626). Evidence suggests that officer respect policies and procedures that have been created to assist the victim as well as protect the community.
Later on the same article reports:
“Most of the officers (88%) felt that they need more discretion in responding to domestic violence cases. Although officers felt that they were more likely to be injured during a domestic violence call (75%), only 24% of the officers agreed with the statement, “More training would help me assess domestic violence scenes.” The officers were almost evenly split between disagreeing and agreeing with having difficulty identifying the primary aggressor, and 36% have difficulty identifying which party to arrest overall. According to officers’ responses, an offender’s behavior is less important when deciding whether or not to make an arrest. Officers were divided on the influence of a victim’s cooperative behavior as well as the presence of children. Only 9% said that they would be affected by the cooperativeness of the suspect, 48% by the victim’s behavior, and 40% by the presence of children at the scene. Probable cause identification seemed to present a challenge as well, with 30% of officers considering it to be a difficult decision” (Grover et al 626).
Knowing the attitudes of law enforcement in regards to domestic violence and arrests help us realize that the offices themselves tend to have conflicting thoughts and ideologies regarding domestic violence and...

Find Another Essay On Domestic Violence: Wronful Arrests

History, Clients, Issues and Concerns, and Services in the Human Services Field of Domestic Violence Provide National Data as well as Delaware Data.

3145 words - 13 pages there is evidence of an assault. Even more states encouraged such arrests. A 1984 study showed, that arresting abusers lowered the re-arrest rate within the next 6 months for domestic violence to 10%. However, more studies are needed to replicate these findings (Facts On File News Service, 2000).C. Demographic CharacteristicsWhile wife battering happens throughout all sectors of society, certain socioeconomic factors indicate higher incidents of

Violence Against Women Act of 1994

1371 words - 5 pages creating a civil rights remedy, the VAWA casted such violence as a rights violation. This piece of legislation pulled out domestic violence from the shadows of the private sphere and into the light of the public sphere and recognized it as worthy of state action. According to Roleff (2000), “when it comes to family violence, most police officers do not make arrests, most persecutors do not press charges, and most judges do not impose tough enough

Violence Against Women In Intimate Relationships

1678 words - 7 pages prosecute an abuser because if arrests are made, “prosecutors commonly fail to prosecute…among assaulted men arrested…less than 1 percent (0.9 percent) served any time in jail”(Jones, 452). Any effort to speak out about domestic violence, pass out flyers, or broadcast commercials will help women get out of the darkness. We must all rise up and help domestic violence victims realize that they do have rights and there is a way out. Works Cited

Domestic Violence: Theory, Effects & Interventions A literature review on the causes, and societal, psychological, and physical effects of domestic violence.

5819 words - 23 pages two states (Pennsylvania Coalition Against Domestic Violence Manual, p. B-8). Old English Common Law allowed husbands to beat their wives provided that the stick they used was not thicker than his thumb; hence the phrase "Rule of Thumb"(Heart on a Chain [Video]). Although times have changed in this regard and laws have been enacted in order to protect women from abuse, the fact remains that acts of domestic violence occur every 15 seconds in the

The Act of Violent Crime

1567 words - 6 pages behavior. The focal point of the article is “to overlook the administration of arrests and police involvement in domestic violence” (Kevin et al., 2014:427). It illustrated that the increase in girl’s custody represent the violent against parents as compared to boys. According to the Uniform Crime Reports and media reports, the girls convicted rate is more than boys. It also indicates that criminal justice policy has increased in the arrest of

Battered Husbands

9465 words - 38 pages 2007016 Running head: BATTERED HUSBANDS Battered Husbands [The Writer's name] [The Name of the Institution]Battered husbands Introduction Over the past thirty years, community response to wife abuse resulted in radical changes in the perception and treatment of domestic violence. The tireless efforts of many feminists and other activists to highlight the severity of wife abuse brought

Police Discretion

1353 words - 5 pages policy – then the idea of controlled discretion may seem to be a self-contradiction” (Gottfredson p.276). Discretion can be used in many different situations. I will be discussing discretion used in dealing with the mentally ill, drunk driving, disorderly conduct, the use of force, and domestic violence. If a police officer uses his/her discretionary power correctly, not only will it help the police officer in their situation, it will help the


1012 words - 5 pages would be over. However, the honeymoon period did not last long, and the abuse worsened (Herrera, 2013). This is a cycle of violence domestic dispute. Often the victim of the abuse would forgive the abuser during the honeymoon period, only have a short period of peace. Tension would build up in the relationship and a violent release of anger by the abuser. This cycle can go on for years. The victims are often trapped, unable to escape the

Youth Violence Myth

747 words - 3 pages and violent crime rates are higher among adults in their 20s and 30s than among teenagers. Adult violent crime rates would be higher still if the chances of being arrested for committing domestic violence approached those for street violence. Family violence is the chief danger to children and women, murdering three times more kids than all "youth violence" combined.Nor are rare, public crimes such as school shootings a "youth" phenomenon. These

Race and Juvenile Justice

1534 words - 7 pages Race and Juvenile Justice addresses the correlation between race, juvenile delinquency, and justice. Through various essays addressing historical backgrounds, part one discusses racial disparities regarding the juvenile delinquency of White, Latino, Black, Asian American, and Native American youth. Part two explores significant issues such as domestic violence, gang involvement, the application of the death penalty to juveniles, disproportionate

The Subconscious Intrusion

2042 words - 8 pages a long running study (Sherrow 93). He gathered nine and ten year olds to watch violent television shows and movies. Ten years later, he interviewed the same people; the strongest predictor of aggression among boys was the amount of television violence they watched as children. Men who had watched the most violence as children had higher rates of aggressive behaviors, domestic violence, crimes, and arrests (Sherrow 93). The aggressive behavior

Similar Essays

Domestic Violence Essay

2096 words - 8 pages involved, but do not seem to have consistent enough consequences for the offender, or strong enough protection for the victims. Domestic conflict is the largest single cause of violence in America, yet police have traditionally been reluctant to make arrests for such assaults. In the past decade, however, that reluctance has been overcome, with a 70% increase in arrests for minor assaults, heavily concentrated among low-income and minority groups

Family Violence: A Problem Further Explained

2549 words - 10 pages against criminal justice agencies for failure to protect male victims, which in turn caused many agencies to make arrests in domestic violence situations mandatory. However, some police officers, rather than finding out the true offender or victim, simply arrest both parties. This type of action is possibly related to the rise in arrest rates of females in family violence cases (Shuler, 2010). However, the rise in arrests of females could also be

Shelter From The Storm Essay

1561 words - 6 pages SHELTER FROM THE STORM Domestic Violence is a prevalent issue facing men and women in the United States. The only way to put an end to domestic violence is to acknowledge it and report it. With the help of the government, local charities and the concern of Tucson community members, many different resources have been created to help and support victims of domestic violence as well as rape. Every year in the United States

Police Perpetrated Domestic Violence Essay

2703 words - 11 pages they NYPD and they arrests that are occurring. In Stinson et al (2011 p. 140) research they mention the Commission to Combat Police Corruption (CCPC) inside of the NYPD and the altercations that were going on were involved in domestic violence disputes when they would get intoxicated. Involving police officers there are three major problems they face: misuse of fire arms, intoxication, and domestic violence (Stinson et al 2011, p. 142). The only