Don Quixote: Which Interpretation Is The Most Correct?

2972 words - 12 pages

Moore 1Nirmine P.A. MooreMr. John CabascangoIB English HL27 October 2014The Many Interpretations of Don Quixote: Which one is the most correct?Being an old book of over 400 years, Cervantes' Don Quixote has been read by many all over the world and has been translated into 60 different languages (online-literature.com). However, being available to such a global audience makes the novel susceptible to being interpreted in several different ways; from the belief that the novel was written only to make people laugh at Don Quixote's foolishness, to the belief that the character of Don Quixote is a symbol that represents the islamophobes present in Europe at the time the novel was written. One cannot be absolutely certain as to which interpretation is the correct one, but, by looking at a variety of interpretations and historical fact, one can conclude that, because of Spain's intolerance of non-Christians at the time and Cervantes' Jewish ancestry, the most plausible interpretation is that there is hidden Jewish meaning in Don Quixote.There has long been an argument between those who believe that Don Quixote was meant to be a fool for the audience to laugh at, and those who believe he was meant to be a hero that inspires people. Those who see Don Quixote as a fool are called hard critics, their opposition known as soft critics. Those who do not fall into either category are called perspectivists or relativists. A significant amount of the English audience sided with Quixote and, although they may laugh at him, instead of ridiculing him, they sympathized with him. They saw him as a hero because he stood firmly by his beliefs, no matter how ridiculous they may have seemed (spainthenandnow.com). Harold Bloom, an American literary critic and Sterling Professor of Humanities at Yale University, believes that Don Quixote was not a madman nor a fool. He says that Don Quixote's vision was double, meaning he saw what everyone else saw, but he also saw something else and that it was something that Don Quixote wanted to share with others (wikipedia.com. theguardian.com). Some say that Don Quixote aimed to make all wrongs right and, although his approach was not modern for his time, he still managed to bring some good into the world around him and that this indirectly made him a hero. They see his delusions as a representation of the desires that are present in all humans for a perfect, fairytale world (onlinephilosophyclub.com). Others say that Don Quixote was a hero because he only aimed to make the earth an exceptional place. They see him as someone who wanted to rekindle an old practice and that, although the things he did may have seemed absurd, they were all done with noble intentions (enotes.com). However, since the 1960s, many people have been pushing for others to reappraise the popular view of Don Quixote as a heroic character; they believe that people must go back to seeing Quixote as a comical figure (spainthenandnow.com). They see Don Quixote's...

Find Another Essay On Don Quixote: Which interpretation is the most correct?

The Duality of Truth in Don Quixote by Miguel Cervantes

3657 words - 15 pages characters. All these aspects profoundly change the traditional concept of truth and introduce a new notion of truth which has dual sides rather than a fixed single side. “At the heart of Don Quixote is the discrepancy between external appearance and internal perception.” says Wirfs-Brock (2). In that respect, Don Quixote is depicted as a character who is guided merely by his internal perceptions, disregarding external appearances. Most of

The Ingenious Gentleman Don Quixote of La Mancha, by Miguel Cervantes

1079 words - 4 pages the audience to believe that Don Quixote is a simpleton. Due to Don Quixote’s grave fascination with medieval books, he becomes engrossed in these stories to the point where it is abnormal. This interest leads Don Quixote to make irrational decisions, which earns him the censure of Cervantes. “His foolish curiosity reached / such extremes that he / sold acres of arable land / to buy these books of / chivalry” (Cervantes 826). Cervantes uses a

The Satiric Subject, its Practices and Purposes in Miguel de Cervantes' Don Quixote

1007 words - 4 pages most fiercely, is ultimately founded upon mutual respect. In the debates they gradually take on some of each other's attributes.Using the form of satire, helps Cervantes, who is an opponent of direct criticism, to hide his judgments about the moral believes in the 16th century. He intended to make a parody of chivalric-romantic books. The author of Don Quixote experienced slavery, poverty and destruction of wars, this experience is shared by many

Which is the Most Important Supporting Character in Jane Austen's "Pride and Prejudice"?

729 words - 3 pages I think that Mr Wickham is the most important supporting character in Pride and Prejudice, because he is central to both Lizzy and Darcy's changes of attitude. Lizzy misjudges Mr Wickham, and in her discovery of his 'true nature' she finds that she has also been wrong about Darcy.The novel Pride and Prejudice has many characters, and each brings their own richness and substance, or lack of said substance, to the story. Obviously the most

The Importance of the First Amendment: Which of the Amendments to the Constitution is Most Important and Why?

897 words - 4 pages In 1791, after the final completion of the warfare fought for our nation's independence, our forefathers drafted and ratified the Constitution for the United States of America, which contained the single most important document for any American citizen - the Bill of Rights. This precious document outlined the basic rights sought after by all the nation's citizens, ranging from the freedom of exercising one's inborn rights to the constitutional

Which had the most far-reaching impact on American culture:

958 words - 4 pages The Enlightenment had the most far-reaching impact on American culture. The Enlightenment stemmed from the Scientific Revolution. The Scientific Revolution caused people to start thinking on their own and stop believing in, or at least question, the Bible. Although the Enlightenment started in England, it quickly spread through the colonies. The Enlightenment was key in helping set in motion the thought process that would eventually lead to

How have dualist tried to explain the apparent two-way causal interaction between mind and body? Which version of dualism is the most plausible theory of mind?

1144 words - 5 pages How have dualist tried to explain the apparent two-way causal interaction between mind and body? Which version of dualism is the most plausible theory of mind?The theory of dualism is based on the separation of the mind and body into two types of stuff - spiritual and physical. Dualists believe that the mind consists of spiritual stuff absent in the material world, while "the body is composed of ordinary matter" . Cartesian, or interactionalist

'All Quiet on the Western Front', by Erich Maria Remarque explores a number of issues related to the horrors of war. Which issue is most significant to you?

1006 words - 4 pages the only romanticized element of the novel and are virtually the only emotions that preserve the soldiers' fundamental humanity. These are their brothers, their lovers, and their only real family. Thus the idea of parting from them, whether when the war is finished or when they die, is hard to bear. Most of this generation will become traumatized. No one who has not shared their experiences can understand them. They are alone.To conclude, the anti

Analyse at Least Two Recently Proposed Solutions to the Problem of E-Waste in Order to Determine Which is the Most Effective

1338 words - 5 pages easily disposed of and it should be recycled in a proper way. However, it is mostly disposed of in landfills and incinerators, which results in environment and health problems. To prevent contamination and pollution some developed countries export their e-waste to developing countries, which regard e-waste as the source of valuable elements, but not as the potentional issues with people health and pollution. Taking all this into account a pressing

Oral Interpretation: This is an interpretation using the book "On the road" by Jack kerouac

742 words - 3 pages writings. On The Road literally takes place on the road. These are his thoughts while traveling across the country.One of his first conversations to take place in the book is between Jack and Dean, which is his friend he is bringing along on his trip. Dean some what inspires Jack to go on his journey; even though Dean himself is coming to Kerouac with questions on how to be a writer..."Hell, man, ,I know very well you didn't come to me only to want

The most common type of crime is property crime most

827 words - 3 pages The most common type of crime is property crime most likely because it can be committed anywhere and by anyone. T. Gabor in the book ?everybody does it! crime by the public? gives the definition, as ?the unlawful acquisition of another?s property through theft or deception? property crime can be as small as taking towels from a hotel room with you. So it could be send that everyone at some point in their lives has committed property crime no

Similar Essays

"Don Quixote": The Book That Revolutionized Literature

1030 words - 4 pages idiosyncratic and immobile character, whose solutions often go wrong ("Don Quixote").This was a very controversial decision, which broke away from anything done at the time. The Holy Roman Empire was very connected to the church, and thus, would always echo some sort of sentiment. Again, de Cervantes treated this with humor, and changed the meaning of a novel, which is very apparent today.As shown, Don Quixote change the course of literature in the

Don Quixote: The Writings Of Cervantes

863 words - 4 pages . Despite critics’ opinions that the stories in Don Quixote are irrelevant, Cervantes included the stories on purpose to develop Don Quixote’s character through themes such as deception/manipulation and delusion/imagination that are seen in the main narrative and side narratives. Although delusion and deception are synonyms, the significant difference is that delusion is a passive act that acts upon the mind without active participation of the

The Outsider In Don Quixote And Frankenstein

1497 words - 6 pages Regarding the seeds of creativity that produced her Frankenstein, Mary Shelley paraphrases Sancho Panza, explaining that “everything must have a beginning.” She and Percy Shelley had been reading Don Quixote, as well as German horror novels, during the “wet, ungenial summer” and “incessant rain” of their stay with Lord Byron at Villa Diodati in Geneva in 1816. In his introduction, Maurice Hindle notes the connection between the

Which Eu Institution Is The Most Powerful?

2698 words - 11 pages Which EU institution is the most powerful? The European Union (EU) is currently made up of 25 countries, known as Member States, which together form the largest voluntary and peaceful block of countries in the world. Many people mistakenly view the European Union as a single body whilst in fact; the EU consists of a number of different institutions that together carry out activities on behalf of the Member States. There are many