This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Doubt And The Meditations Essay

1715 words - 7 pages

Within Meditations on First Philosophy, Descartes undertakes a worthy goal: the discovery of the sources of doubt with the ultimate result being more truthful opinions, assertions, and arguments. Descartes was well ahead of his times, forging a pathway to more rigorous scholarship through the casting of doubt upon his “opinions”. Unfortunately, however, Descartes was either unable or unwilling to cast doubt upon his primary source of fallibility: his exaltation of all things cerebral and his concurrent disdain for the physical body. Because of this, he was either unable or unwilling to rigorously scrutinize his opinion/belief regarding the existence of God. Instead, he chose to focus his doubt-casting (skepticism) upon his senses, going so far as to suggest that since dreaming can mimic the “real world”, he cannot trust what his eyes see, or his hands uncover.
His focus upon the senses as the primary source of doubt is typical of Descartes, given that he asserted that it was his thoughts which were his essence, the very definition of who he was (who we all are). Yet, I argue that it was his inability to cast doubt upon his intellectual reasoning vis-à-vis the existence of supernatural entities (God) in any substantive way that led to his ultimately controversial approach to finding and resolving sources of doubt. Further, I argue that because Descartes insisted upon limiting his pool of useful knowledge to that which he, himself, uncovered (or thought about), he missed an obvious way to find and fix any possible errors stemming from faulty sensory perceptions; namely, the testing and validation (or elimination) of hypotheses by other researchers. If I perceive that a ball falls at the same rate as a block of wood as they both plummet from the roof of a tall building to the ground (as did Galileo), I do not have to trust what the senses tell me; I can ask several other people to conduct the same experiment and see what their senses (via their own instruments) tell them as well, thus confirming or denying my assertion and sensory perceptions.
This essay will support my arguments by first presenting Descartes' First Meditation and the dream hypothesis, including what the first meditation was meant to cast doubt upon, and next by showing that Descartes does not, in fact, cast doubt upon that which he intends. This essay will then conclude with the presentation of well-grounded arguments that refute my position, along with rebuttals that show the validity of my perspective.
Descartes' First Meditation, in his search for absolute certainty, is intended to discuss “what can be called into doubt”. Citing a long-standing opinion that to be completely rigorous and truthful in his work, he should demolish all existing opinions from his mind, he asserts that the best way to do this is to destroy the foundations of those opinions; namely, what he has learned “either from the senses or through the senses”. Such pieces of knowledge are,...

Find Another Essay On Doubt and the Meditations

Rene Descartes' Examination of the Nature of Mateial Things and What is Possible to Know of them Based on Passages from Meditations on First Philosophy. (the Wax example)

605 words - 2 pages "How do we know what we know?" This is a question asked by Rene Descartes as well as a host of other philosophers. A particular passage written in Meditations on First Philosophy by Descartes dubbed the "Wax Passage" examined the nature of material things, and what we really know about them. Descartes' thought process shall be followed, and his conclusion that if all attributes are stripped away, what is left is the "essence" of the wax, will be

Marijuana: Do you know the facts? When you cut out all the non-factual claims and off the wall rumors, the pro argument side for marijuana without doubt out weighs the cons

971 words - 4 pages Marijuana: Do you know the facts?Pot. Weed. Mary Jane. Reefer Madness. We've all heard and read the negative accusations about the illegal narcotic drug, marijuana. So why is there still any debate on the legalization of this awful drug? Well I'll tell you why. When you cut out all the non-factual claims and off the wall rumors, the pro argument side for marijuana without doubt out weights the cons. In fact, marijuana has been proven to be safer

Rene Descartes and a discription of his dream and evil demon conjectures, method of doubt, and clear and distinct testing. Also, the bad and good of his theory (opinion)

4572 words - 18 pages Tema:Rene Dekart - život i delaRené DescartesSADRŽAJŽivotFilozofijaRasprava o metodiRes cogitans i res extensaO boguRazumPravilaIntuicija, dedukcija i indukcijaO strastima dušeMatematikaNaukaZnačajLiteraturaŽivotDekart Rene (Descartes René, latinski Renatus Cartesius) rođen je 31. marta 1596. u La Eju (La Haye) u Francuskoj. Bio je član imućne građanske porodice koja je dala

The British cinema renewed itself, tardily no doubt, by orthodox commercial procedures' (Raymond Durgnat). To what extent is this a fair assessment of British cinema between 1959 and 1963?

2863 words - 11 pages mean critical acclaim. I would consider there to be several definitions of 'success' within the field of film and cinema, from the number of awards won to spectacular audience attendance not forgetting the box office return on production costs of the film. Some films will only fall into one of these classifications whereas others may fall into more than one. With this definition in mind I have decided to focus mainly on the films Billy Liar! (1963

Descartes’ Ultimate Purpose of the Meditations

1836 words - 7 pages 11). “Descartes has decided that the Augustinian method of knowledge of God and soul is the way to knowledge of the physical world [science]” (Menn 549). I will demonstrate that this initial “ordered” perspective creates serious doubt of the existence of God, while a re-ordering of the Meditations produces a logically sound argument that facilitates an arrival at the intended goal while keeping the arguments intact. First, I

The Meditations of Rene Descartes

700 words - 3 pages attempt to solve the many questions about life, existence, and God. At the time of their publishing many philosophers did not quit accept his writings. Today however the Meditations are widely read and reviewed throughout the world. In the First Meditation Rene begins by stating that he know doubts his previous views and is forced to take a serious look at what he considers to be true. Rene will go as far to doubt God and whether he is truly

Descartes' First Meditation

1797 words - 7 pages as to what was actually true and existing. In order to show that the sciences rest on firm foundations and that these foundations lay in the mind and not the senses, Descartes must begin by bringing into doubt all the beliefs that come to him by the senses. This is done in the first of six different steps that he named "Meditations" because of the state of mind he was in while he was contemplating all these different ideas. His six

The Meditations 400 Years Later

1271 words - 6 pages methods and conclusions. Modern philosophers have determined what is known as methodical doubt, the steps Descartes took to systematically doubt the existence of as many of his surroundings as possible in the first two Meditations, as an unavoidable first step for modern philosophical thinking. In fact the founder of phenomenology, Edmund Husserl, went as far as to say that the first two meditations are the only significant parts of Descartes’ work

Descartes and God

1158 words - 5 pages probably, however we will only look at one such person. Rene Descartes attempts to use his own logic to come up with the conclusion that a perfect being does exist and that being is in itself God in his book Meditations on First Philosophy. We must first look at the background of Descartes thought process in the first two meditations where he explores the existence of himself and the use of methodic doubt, in order to get a feel on his position of

If A Tree Falls in the Philosophical Forest, Someone Managed to Undermine Descartes Ambitions for Epistemology

2155 words - 9 pages doubts, Descartes asserts a basis that he claims is free of presumptions. Essentially, Descartes seeks to prove to skeptics, those who believe there is absolutely no certain knowledge, that even by eliminating all assumptions with beliefs there remain several truths that evolve. From Meditation One, he then moves on to his further meditations that support human existence, the mind, God and the physical world. As stated, doubt is central to

Certainty in Descartes' Meditations on First Philosophy

618 words - 2 pages thinking is that doubt itself is a form of thought. Only the intellect can organize and make sense of what we perceive (through clear and distinct perception). The senses only perceive a jumble of information: the intellect is what helps us to understand it. Even with this new understanding, however, Descartes is left pondering the certainty of everything he knows except that of his own existence. Works Cited Descartes, René. Meditations on First Philosophy. Trans. Cress. Indianapolis, U.S.A: Hackett, 1993.

Similar Essays

The Mind And The World: Descartes Meditations

1194 words - 5 pages C. Santos Professor R. Boeker The Mind and the World Due: October 18, 2013 Descartes presents three skeptical arguments in his meditations which shows he has reason to doubt all of his sensory beliefs. Descartes ultimately aims to free himself from all bad beliefs. His quest for certainty is driven from his belief that our belief system is built on a foundation of basic beliefs, that are not justified, in turn, causing him to believe

Faith And Doubt In The Poetry Of Gerard Manley Hopkins

1621 words - 6 pages with my family, friends, and most importantly God. Gerard expressed both faith and doubt in his poetry because he was going through rough times. Events in his life made him question his path with faith as well as his actual faith. Scholars understood this and realized that it was affecting Gerard’s poetry. He was not achieving his goals as a priest’s assistant. He became melancholy because of the papers he had to grade at Royal University of

The Folly Of René Descartes’ Discourse On Method And Meditations On First Philosophy

1488 words - 6 pages The Folly of René Descartes’ Discourse on Method and Meditations on First Philosophy In order to embark on his quest for truth, Descartes first devises his four rules which should serve as a solid foundation for all else that he comes to understand. Those rules are here evaluated in terms of what they fail to take into consideration. The rules are examined individually and consecutively, and are therefore also reiterated in order to be

Queen Elizabeth's Use Of Imagery And Language In The Doubt Of Future Foes

777 words - 3 pages Queen Elizabeth's Use of Imagery and Language in The Doubt of Future Foes Queen Elizabeth persuades her subjects to be faithful and discourages her foes from the pursuit of her throne in the stark imagery of “The Doubt of Future Foes.” Elizabeth uses the three appeals of successful argument to evoke fear and respect in those that may attempt to challenge her position as Queen. The Queen captivates her audience with solid logical arguments