This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Doubts Over The Effectiveness Of Free Trade Economic Theory

940 words - 4 pages

Paul Krugman’s article “Is free trade passé?” (1987) espouses the argument that free trade economic theory today is “more in doubt than at any time since the 1817 publication of Ricardo’s Principles of Political Economy” (p. 131, citing Ricardo, 1821). Ricardo was the first to put forth the theory that “[t]he value of a commodity, or the quantity of any other commodity for which it will exchange, depends on the relative quantity of labour which is necessary for its production, and not on the greater or less compensation which is paid for that labour” (Ricardo, 1821, p. 1.1). It was his theory that specialization, even to the point of eliminating certain industries in a country, optimized a country’s trade advantage (p. 31.17). As Krugman points out, governments’ strategic trade policy intervention in free trade, through import restrictions or quotas, export subsidies, tariffs, and other trade interventions, have substantively moved international markets away from free trade. As the course module emphasizes, “The Ricardian model of trade…is of limited application to the complexities and realities of modern trade because it provides no insight into the sources of comparative advantage” (Colorado State University-Global Campus, 2014, p. 2). Krugman argues that although free trade may not be passé, the theory has become the reasonable rule of thumb rather than the optimum result, as it is not always the right policy.
Rethinking International Trade Theory
Krugman points out that from the early 1800s to the late 1970s, international economic theory believed that countries only traded to take advantage of their differences. This Heckscher-Ohlin-Samuelson factor endowment theory emphasized income distribution effects that were absent in the Ricardian model (Krugman P. R., 1987):

(Carbaugh, 2013, p. 68). Many international economists had already started to recognize that comparative advantage was not the “whole story, that increasing returns can be an independent
cause of international specialization and trade” (p. 132, citing literature surveys of Helpman, E., & Krugman, P., 1985, and Krugman, P., ed., 1986).
Increasing Returns and Imperfect Competition
New models of international trade, stressing increasing returns and imperfect competition, began to emerge in the 1970s:
These models immediately established the idea that countries specialize and trade, not only because of underlying differences, but also because increasing returns are an independent force leading to geographical concentration of production of each good. Indeed, at a logical level, increasing returns are as fundamental a cause of international trade as comparative advantage. (Krugman P. R., 1987, p. 133).
While this approach supported the existence of trade as opposed to no trade, it began to move away from free trade as the only answer in international economic theory.
Consequently, while government intervention does not always work, it has become more of the norm in current...

Find Another Essay On Doubts Over the Effectiveness of Free Trade Economic Theory

The Theory of International Trade Essay

1051 words - 4 pages Free Trade The concept of that all countries will be benefited from the international, no matter what the circumstances are, that was one of the facts that all economists have been talking about. The theory of international trade relied on comparative advantage; the well-known feature that advantages countries took a part in the commercial trade. But the traditional theory of international trade, forced some of restricted conditions to the

The Free Trade Area of the Americas

582 words - 2 pages American nations. This will be called the Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA).NAFTA is supposed to promote conditions of fair competition in the free trade area, and increase investment opportunities. It's also supposed to provide effective protection and enforcement of intellectual property rights.The debate over NAFTA divides members of both the Democratic and Republican parties. Many fear that jobs are lost because the agreement makes it easy

The Pros and Cons of Free Trade

1107 words - 4 pages helps to insulate against shocks. This corresponds with a new World Bank study which, used data from 80 countries over four decades, confirmed that openness boosts economic growth and that the incomes of the poor rose one-for-one with overall growth. Economic analysts say trading among other countries with no stipulations improve global efficiency in resource allocation (Tupy, 2005). Free Trade delivers goods and services to those who value them

Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA)

1573 words - 6 pages . The economic downturn that affected South America in 1998-99 also clouded the FTAA negotiations. Brazil’s devaluation triggered a trade dispute with its neighbors (especially Argentina) that threatened to destabilize MERCOSUR. The member countries of the Andean Community face dire economic and political problems that could spill over their borders and undermine not only the Community but the FTAA as well. In contrast to the situation in

The Advantages and Disadvantages of Free Trade

1774 words - 7 pages BUSINESS ECONOMICSASSIGNMENT-4 Q1) What are the advantages and disadvantages of free trade? A1) Advantages-  The thought that everyone benefits when countries convert and offer unashamedly what they do by and large capably. At the end of the day, everyone ought to invest noteworthy time in what they have practical experience in and governments ought to assume just a negligible part in this methodology.  Protectionism is excessive

Benefits of free trade

2025 words - 9 pages Trade Agreement (NAFTA, a tri-lateral trade-bloc between Mexico, Canada and the United States of America) and also the European Economic Area (EEA, containing members of the European Free Trade Association, such as Norway, Iceland and Liechtenstein, and also every member of the European Union, except for Croatia), both establishing open markets with no or very few commerce restrictions. Countries that specialize in manufacturing commodities where

Tobacco: The Cost-effectiveness of Current Smoke-free Policies

1338 words - 5 pages policies and programs are limited, especially for low- and middle-income countries. Specifically, there are few if any studies published in the peer-reviewed literature examining the cost-effectiveness of smoke-free legislation in a national or sub-national setting. In the past several years, low and middle-income countries have seen an increased number of smoke-free policies (World Health Organization, 2009). However, some of these policies do

The Effectiveness of Wittes Economic Reform in Russia

798 words - 3 pages The Effectiveness of Wittes Economic Reform in Russia When Sergei Witte became minister of finance in Russia in 1892 he recognised that the economy had to be modernised if Russia was to become a world power on a par with the west. The Industrial Revolution that had taken place in the west had led to its massive economic growth and an increase in power and Empire building. Being able to buy cheap, raw materials like

The Effectiveness of Feudalism as an Economic System in Japan

1924 words - 8 pages This investigation will attempt to examine the effectiveness of feudalism as an economic system. It is relevant as it examines a form of governing and its impact on the economic status of a country. This allows it to be decided whether or not it was successful, and therefore if it is relevant to use in the modern world and what consequences might follow. Specifically, it will be focusing on feudal society from the Kamakura Period

The Negative Effects of the North American Free Trade Agreement

1211 words - 5 pages The Negative Effects of the North American Free Trade Agreement In January 1994, the United States, Mexico, and Canada implemented the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), forming the largest free trade zone in the world. The goal of NAFTA is to create better trading conditions through tariff reduction, removal of investment barriers, and improvement of intellectual property protection. NAFTA continues to gradually reduce

The Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA)

2997 words - 12 pages domestic production interests of all signatories to the Agreement."Canada is not negotiating for labour or environmental policies that will benefit member countries, but it "is seeking a commitment by all FTAA countries to have the WTO Agreement on Technical Barriers to Trade (TBT) govern their rights and obligations." Pierre Pettigrew, Canada's Trade Minister, believes "differences over farm subsidies could also impair efforts to create a Free

Similar Essays

Evolving Trade Policy: The Benefits Of 'fair Trade' Over 'free Trade'

1204 words - 5 pages Trade Policy is a crucial part of our society in the United States, along with many others across the globe, that greatly depend on the profits and materials accessible due to the transfer of goods, ideas, and other materials between countries. Currently the trade policy that seems to dominate the trade market is ‘Free Trade’ which tends to leave the larger, wealthier counties with the most benefits while the developing countries are struggling

Does Global Trade And Empire Explain British Economic Development Over The Course Of The Eighteenth And Nineteenth Centuries?

1957 words - 8 pages between trade with the nations of the empire and those out side. The experience of British trade in India is very different to that of North America. The exploitative relationship between Britian and the empire makes the economic advantages from one very different from the other. The exact difference between the nations lies partly in the fact that non empire nations play the dominant role with respect to exposing huge "markets for domestic

The Benifits Of Free Trade Essay

2755 words - 11 pages of the motivation for NAFTA. Although Mexico was a relatively large U.S. trading partner, a number of people argued that the agreement would have only a small effect on the U.S. economy but would help secure the large amount of trade and other economic liberalization that Mexico had enacted over the previous decade.Opinion in favor of pursuing free-trade agreements is by no means unanimous. Some critics worry that FTAs might divert the world away

The Doubts Of Eating Out Essay

1431 words - 6 pages preparing home cooked meals with the family, it is certain that the meals will have fewer germs. In a fast food restaurant many are unaware of who is making the food they are about to consume. What if the person frying the burgers is sick? He may have coughed all over the curly fries! When eating out, the person making the food may be having a rough day. Maybe the chef decides to spit on the third burger served because the costumer complains about the