Douglas Mc Gregor’s Human Side Of Enterprise

1579 words - 6 pages

The purpose of this paper is to critique Douglas McGregor’s The Human Side of Enterprise, including other expert perspectives and its relevance in today’s organizations. Douglas McGregor’s opening statement in The Human Side of Enterprise, implies that industry in the 1950’s has been able to successfully utilize physical science and technology for the benefit of mankind, but has yet to incorporate the social sciences to positively affect the human organizations (Natemeyer & McMahon, 2001). In 1957, McGregor suggested that the social sciences may possibly be as cutting edge to human organizations as atomic energy was to the physical sciences (Natemeyer & McMahon, 2001). Based on his academic background in psychology, coupled with his profession experiences in multiple facets of industry, McGregor was in a position to propose a ground breaking concept of management in the workplace. According to a book review by Eileen Kelly (2000), McGregor left an indelible impression of the American business landscape and on management thought with his Theory X and Theory Y. Interestingly enough, the aforementioned book review was done on a book called Douglas McGregor, Revisited: Managing the Human Side of the Enterprise that was published in 2000, which highlights the fact that McGregor’s work is still relevant and worth revisiting and reviewing over forty years after it was published.
In order to understand McGregor’s proposed theory to management that incorporates the social sciences, called Theory Y, it is imperative to understand what he refers to as the conventional view, or “Theory X”. McGregor explained that Theory X’s conventional managerial assumptions are that employees are lazy, incapable of self-direction and autonomous work behavior, and have little to offer in terms of organizational problem solving (Kopelman et al, 2008). According to McGregor, “conventional organization structures and managerial policies, practices, and programs reflect these assumptions” (Natemeyer & McMahon, 2001). McGregor understood that the observed human behavior in industrial organizations may indicate such negative assumptions about the nature of man, but he argues that this observed behavior is more of a consequence of the nature of industrial organizations management philosophy, policy and practice (Natemeyer & McMahon, 2001). In an attempt to validate his ideas about why these negative assumptions about man may be wrong and perhaps a consequence of the industrial environment of his day, he introduced a social science concept pertaining to human motivation. McGregor was fascinated with the concept of workplace motivation; he wanted to know what motivated a person to work hard and what managers could do to encourage employee motivation (Bobic & Davis, 2003).
McGregor’s approach to human motivation was greatly influenced by Abraham Maslow’s hierarchy of needs (Kelly, 2000). McGregor simply stated, “Man is a wanting animal – as soon as one of his needs...

Find Another Essay On Douglas McGregor’s Human Side of Enterprise

Exploring the Dark Side of Human Nature in The Killers

2277 words - 9 pages Exploring the Dark Side of Human Nature in The Killers        Hemingway's "The Killers" illustrates that unexplained violence is an integrated part of society.  To acknowledge the cruelties of life is to come to terms with horrifying events that can not be denied.  A person may lack the maturity to cope with everyday life if they do not realize that evil can exist in any given society.        The story is told in the objective

"The Gathering" by Isobelle Carmody portrays the dark side of human nature.

1111 words - 4 pages "The Gathering" by Isobelle Carmody portrays the dark side of human nature. It shows that man's behaviour does not vary over long periods of time and across different cultures. It shows that each and every single person has an evil or dark side to them and it is whether they succumb to this evil or follow the paths of light and goodness that decide what kind of person they are.Cheshunt, where the story is set appears to be a fairly normal town

Theory X and Theory Y

1225 words - 5 pages , and according to McGregor, production would then be increased (Barnett). McGregor developed his theory and published it in his book “The Human Side of Enterprise” in 1960 where he stated that classical theorists viewed employees as essentially having negative attitudes towards their jobs; this negative attitude was the basis for McGregor’s Theory X behaviors. Theory X had three main assumptions about workers and managers. First, McGregor suggested

Douglas McGregor’s Theory X and Theory Y

770 words - 3 pages -known companies. Theory X and Theory Y In 1960’s, Douglas McGregor wrote a book called, The Human Side of Enterprise. In his book, McGregor explained that he researched on individual’s behaviour at work, and he developed two theories: Theory X and Theory Y. He discovered these two theories when, he interviewed several managers and asked them, what their opinions are on employees’ behaviour at work. Theory X Theory X managers

McGregor’s Theory X and Theory Y

1113 words - 4 pages McGregor’s Theory X and Theory Y Introduction Human beings have been studied systematically and objectively for many years to determine if they are resistant to work or self-governing. In addition, managers who tend to utilize McGregor’s Theory X generally receive poor results from their employees. This report essay will address McGregor’s Theory X and Theory Y in contrasts to include how these theories benefit the criminal justice system


2387 words - 10 pages (Taylor, 1911). This theory was established in the context of the industrial age and thus is outdated for today’s analysis but it still provides a basic assumption which is often referred to by other authors. The total neglecting of a worker’s intrinsic motivators is a starting point for discussion for authors that conducted research in that area after Taylor. Douglas McGregor presented Theory X and Theory Y in his book “The Human Side of

What it Means to Be Free

1327 words - 6 pages humans. Freedom was about the ability to be a self-reliant, self-governing, and literate individual who was seen and treated as a human. Douglas and Jacobs both showed their readers that being free was a God given right, not something that someone let them earn. Americans were all talk and no action when it came to the statement “all men are created equal.” One should be born free, not born being owned by someone else. Douglas and Jacobs’s slave narratives are haunting, but they caught American’s attention to how badly people wanted to be free. Both of these writer’s knew early on that there was one thing in life that everyone deserved, and that was freedom. .

organizational theory

2284 words - 9 pages Question #1 “Despite the economic progress brought about in part by scientific management, critics were calling attention to the ‘seamy side of progress’ which included severe labor management conflict, apathy, boredom, and wasted human resources to examine the discrepancy between how an organization was supposed to work versus how the workers actually behaved. In addition, factors like World War I, developments in psychology and later the

Key Aspects of Training and Development

2297 words - 9 pages today. They more relevant it gives the staff more incentives and also keeps them motivated and well trained. The second motivational theory that is relevant to Southgate College is McGregor’s Y theory, but he also has an X theory. First of all the X theory conveys a negative side of human nature. Showing employees as lazy, unambitious people who dislike work and need to be controlled through punishment. McGregor argues

Human Relations Perspective In Management

1476 words - 6 pages Human Relations Perspective In Management The human relations perspective is a way to manage a corporation where the employees are viewed as social beings with complex needs and desires as opposed to just units of production. It is based on the works of Abraham Maslow and Douglas McGregor in the mid twentieth century. This perspective places an emphasis on the social networks found in a corporation and uses gratification, not depravation, to

Employee Motivation and Capitalism

2332 words - 9 pages there is not a problem with worker motivation, workers will be obedient because of fear of losing their job motivates them to do well. Whereas Maslow and McGregor’s Theory Y argues that there is a problem with worker motivation because of class conflict between the worker and the manager. The worker is after more than just economic benefits, they long for personal fulfilment and freedom. A Marxist view is that the managers are exploiting the

Similar Essays

Case Analysis Of The Human Enterprise

1500 words - 6 pages The Human - 1 - Case Analysis: The Human Side of Enterprises By MGT332 March 17, 1998 The Human - 2 - The Human Side of Enterprise All managerial decisions and actions rest on a personally held theory, or as Gayle Porter put it in his summary of The Human Side of Enterprise, "a set of assumptions about behavior. McGregor, the original author of The Human side of Enterprise, believed in two theories. The first one, theory X, dealt with the

The Human Side Of Management And Leadership

1074 words - 4 pages The human side or management and leadership is a complex idea, and an even more complex thing to try to apply. The human side of management can apply to all aspect of a business but there is a lack of seeing business that have a human touch anymore. The most powerful aspects of the human side of management are personalization, service, innovation, and overall management. Personalization can have a huge impact on the overall success of failure

Vertigo: A Darker Side Of Human Nature

759 words - 3 pages Barbie doll. Moreover, the male's inability to see women as fully human ..." (225). In conclusion, the movie Vertigo was not only about the male desire towards unconscious women and obsession, but also about a darker side of human nature. One may state that the movie is about passionate love but it clearly shows that the men can be fanatically preoccupied onto one another. Released in 1958, Hitchcock's Vertigo was an incredible exposition of sexually possessed love and obsession.

Dark Side Of Human Nature (Lord Of The Flies)

712 words - 3 pages Dark Side of Human Nature William Golding¡¦s, The Lord of The Flies takes place on an island where only schoolboys survive an air crash. As things progress, the boys go wild and hate, power, a loss of innocence and fear start to show throughout the book. The book¡¦s main protaganist is Ralph and he is the initial leader of the group of stranded boys. Jack, the antagonist, was the choir leader in the boys&iexcl