This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Drawbacks And Consequences With Child Beauty Pageants

1773 words - 7 pages

Last fall, the upper house of the French Parliament passed a bill that would prohibit children younger than 16 from competing in beauty pageants. One of the bill’s outspoken champions, Chantal Jouanno, praised the vote while declaring that “[it] is extremely destructive for a girl between the age of 6 and 12 to hear her mother say that what’s important for her is to be beautiful” (Rubin). Child beauty pageants, however, are not quite the big business as they are in the United States- recent television shows such as “Toddlers & Tiaras” and its spin-off “Here Comes Honey Boo Boo” have raised the profile of an industry that generates about $5 billion in revenue annually (Giroux). But is the conversation being held in France worth having in the US as well?
There are plenty of good, healthy reasons for parents to enter their children in beauty contests- they develop skills and build confidence, all while potentially opening the door for educational or other opportunities down the road. There are, however, serious potential drawbacks. What effects do these competitions have on a young girl’s emotional health and well-being? Do they contribute to a growing eating disorder crisis among children and teens? Is there a wider issue about the objectification and sexualization of children at work? While there are benefits for young girls, under the age of 12 who enter in child beauty pageants, the potential emotional and psychological damage means these competitions do more harm than good.
Parents who involve their children in beauty pageants often defend the decision as being no different from other extracurricular activities. As one parent noted, "I was always involved in the baseball, the football, the basketball, the dance and now my kids are grown. […] To me this is the same thing; it's a sport we travel to. We teach her, she practices, and you win prizes. It's just the same. It's just a sport” (Schultz). Other parents note benefits similar to athletics or other competitive activities, citing opportunities for their children to learn new skills, build confidence, and develop character. Indeed, it’s not difficult to imagine some of these young girls blossoming into adults with poise and healthy self-esteem.
Yet even with this premise, there are drawbacks. By structuring a child’s life so much around competition, the parent risks raising them to see their life as part of a zero-sum game: that their own happiness and success has to come at the expense of someone else’s. People become essentialized as Winners and Losers, perhaps hindering the development of empathy and compassion for others. Further, as these impressions become reinforced in individual children and their families, the perception becomes reality. The personal stakes for children rise, their barriers of entry into secure and happy lives become steeper, as the competitive nature of extracurriculars for children becomes a vehicle for status anxiety. As sociologist Hilary Friedman noted, “The...

Find Another Essay On Drawbacks and Consequences with Child Beauty Pageants

Ban Child Involvement in Beauty Pageants

1882 words - 8 pages their face, having fun, and enjoying their childhood with friends and family. Kayla McDowell, a freshman at Stephens College, and pageant critic, addresses “In the end, child beauty pageants force children to grow up much too soon, and they release them into a word they are too young to understand” (n. pag.) Children are being sexualized at a very young age, because in the pageant community, dressing like a hooker and dancing like showgirls is

Child Beauty Pageants, a Controversial Issue

982 words - 4 pages utter devastation. They look out into the crowd to see their parents with a weary look of shame knowing they have disapointed them. This is the classic reaction at most glitz and even small child beauty pageants. Some would believe this teaches their children overall redeeming qualities and it boosts their self confidence, but that is just the parents. What about the children? Sometimes the parents, mostly mothers, get so involved and pushy during

How Do Child Beauty Pageants Affect a Child’s Development?

1540 words - 7 pages beauty is such a biased thing to do. Beauty pageants are becoming more and more popular since they were created back in the 1920's. Especially, children pageants. The media is a big provoker in this case with their ‘Little Miss Perfect” and “Toddlers in Tiaras” shows. In which, it’s clear the level of commitment a pageant takes and how they are not bearable for children, and I mean simply unfair for them to go through the burden of a beauty pageant

What is wrong with beauty Children Pageants?

1006 words - 5 pages makes girls be less confident in them and be more self conscious about their looks. Having a low-self steam then leads into depression. According to Martina M. Cartwright, a professor of nutritional sciences at the University of Arizona, teens that used to participate in beauty pageants are more likely to develop eating disorders and have body problem images (5 Reasons Child Pageants Are Bad for Kids). In the long run, girls could get into many

Children And Beauty Pageants Do Not Mix

1052 words - 5 pages stage performing career. The only thing is, this is children we are talking about. When they grow up in the world of beauty pageants, the image they have, will stick with them because they might think that it truly is the only way they will be loved. Works Cited Brianna. Personal Interview. 15 Nov. 2013 Cartwright, Martina. “Child Beauty Pageants: What Are We Teaching Our Girls?” (12 April 2012) Villine, Zawn. “Beauty Pageants and Children: It’s Not Always Pretty” (15 Nov. 2012)

Toddlers and Tiaras: Child Beaty Pageants

2203 words - 9 pages In 2009, TLC aired a reality television show entitled Toddlers and Tiaras. It was instantly a hit with home viewers and also brought major controversy over child beauty pageants. The show focused mainly on glitz pageants; which requires all contestant, however young, to compete with make-up, spray tans, acrylic nails and revealing costumes. Many, such as I were entertained at first with the pint size Barbie dolls; however after watching a couple

Performing and Perfecting: The Negative Effects of Beauty Pageants

832 words - 4 pages be “flawless” or “perfect,” they should be taught to be their better selves which beauty pageants are not doing. Beauty pageants also put too much emphasis on beauty itself. “Parents adorn their children with fake teeth, fake hair, spray tans, and breast padding” (Triggs). Putting these enhancements on a child only confuses them. They wonder why they’re not okay without them. Confusing children about their beauty now will make sorting out

Dangers of Beauty Pageants According to Hollandsworth and Kibourne

787 words - 4 pages pageants, is because they feel like they missed out on a part of their own life, so they need to live through their child. This article also talks about the crimes that go on during child beauty pageants, because if you think about it, who's going to watch a show with little five year olds walking around in a skin bearing outfit? Pedophiles will. And that seems to be the problem coming up recently with children beauty pageants. In his article

Causes and Long-Term Consequences of Child Abuse and Neglect

2521 words - 10 pages or adult for the stimulation and/or gratification of that person, which is not necessarily confined to physical contact and which may range from exhibitionism or involvement with pornography to full intercourse or child prostitution; where the developmentally immature victim lacks the authority or power to prevent her/himself being coerced into activities to which she/he is unable to give informed consent, which she/he does not properly comprehend

Child Abuse Versus Discipline and Their Respective Consequences

2890 words - 12 pages with a manual, and many parents may feel pressured to know how to correctly raise a child and in the process make mistakes. And that is where education plays a major role in distinguishing the differences between abuse and discipline so that children may be spared from an awful and avoidable experience. With education comes prevention and change. The difference is black and white and there are evident consequences for each. Works Cited Brodsky

american beauty and my week with marilyn

1052 words - 5 pages American beauty and my week with Marilyn is the film seems to be uniquely comfortable established with sexuality in the relationships and present unique way of showing love. The film shows oppression in each of the characters in order to view their identity as person which it creates their own emotional. However, both films using several difference kinds of techniques to create a sense of realism such as the cinematography with camera work and

Similar Essays

Child Beauty Pageants Essay

1673 words - 7 pages make-up, clouds of hairspray, extensions that give her headaches throughout the day, and the hours of practice she is forced to execute. Up to three million child beauty contestants experience this scenario per year (O’Neill). Glitz beauty pageants exploit young children, teaching them that self-worth is in physical beauty only, while natural beauty pageants teach child contestants that natural beauty and personality is most important, encouraging

Child Beauty Pageants Essay

1177 words - 5 pages win, and little girls dressing and to look like Barbie’s. Is this setting a good example for children? It teaches them that people are only judged by looks, not their personality. Instead the lesson they are learning is that looks are the only thing that matters. Look at child beauty pageants. Notice that the girl’s childhood is filled with sparkly dresses and makeup. They are trying to grow up to fast and if they continue on this path they

Child Beauty Pageants Essay

770 words - 3 pages Child Beauty Pageants: A Disturbed Childhood"I don't even know what it is to feel attractive without make-up on my face. Perhaps it's because I have worn make-up on my face since the age of four. This was when I competed in my first beauty pageant. When children enter beauty pageants at too young of an age, they can develop poor self-image, low self-esteem and even eating disorders." (Nicole Hunter) words expressed by former Child Beauty Pageant

Why Child Beauty Pageants Should Be Banned

1831 words - 7 pages ’ wishes than their safety in order not to be judged as they were in pageants. To sum up,child beauty pageants should be prohibited since it interrupts natural flow of age, influences cognitive functioning adversely and causes sexual health problems as consequences of hypersexualization. Another reason why pageants should be banned is that they lead to psychological problems such as eating disorders and depression. According to Report