This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Drawing The Boundaries Of The Ethical Self

3144 words - 13 pages

Drawing The Boundaries Of The Ethical Self

This paper evaluates some philosophical views regarding the self who is an ethical deliberator and agent-specifically the traditional atomistic individualist self and the expanded biocentric self of deep ecology. The paper then presents an alternative manner of thinking about the ethical self which avoids some of the philosophical difficulties of the foregoing views. This alternative draws on the recent work by Val Plumwood and Donna Haraway. Haraway's cyborg identity is a kind of self-in-relation (Plumwood's term) which allows for ethical deliberations that take relations with others seriously without losing individuality in problematic holism (as deep ecology does). Self-in-relation is defined by the relation of intentional inclusion. This relation is given a functionalist, non-mentalistic interpretation. The notions of ontological foresight and moral foresight are introduced to enable determinations of moral responsibility without falling back into the problematic universalism which otherwise results from the functionalist view of cyborg self-in-relation.

Ethical deliberation does not typically begin with an explicit articulation of the concept of self which underlies such deliberation. But a self is assumed, and usually in Western ethical thought it is an atomistic egocentric individual self. Ethical deliberation, whether deontological, utilitarian, or otherwise, assumed a self/other boundary of some kind, and such an assumption imports bias into our ethical conclusion. Ethical deliberations frequently focus on the interests or rights of individuals, without justifying the assumption of an egocentric individual self.

If the traditionally-assumed egocentric individual self circumscribes ethical deliberation, then might a more inclusive, expanded self be less prone to produce bias in our ethical conclusions? One possible such self conception is the biocentric self of deep ecology. Deep ecologists seek to expand the self not only beyond the atomistic individual human self but also beyond all human selves. As a way to insure an appropriate concern for all life on Earth, deep ecologists urge the adoption of a self which is identified with all earthly beings. This self-identification will result in the promotion of maximum self-realization for all beings. Since I am not a being among others, my status, interests, etc., are not privileged over any others, though they are still taken into account. Since the biocentric self allows all beings to achieve maximum self-realization, conflicts between egocentric individuals are minimized.

Deep ecology seeks to overcome individual/group conflict by expanding the individual self so as to encompass, as self-interest, the interests, rights or claims of other beings which might otherwise be considered alien or hostile. The goal of maximum self-realization is accorded to all beings, since no one being can claim primary importance for its own individual...

Find Another Essay On Drawing The Boundaries Of The Ethical Self

Drawing the Line Essay

1477 words - 6 pages India and Pakistan have been in conflict over the territorial boundaries of Kashmir since 1947 and have yet to solidify resolution in this ongoing battle. After three major wars, many skirmishes, and a variety of treatises, there is still a tug-of-war being fought over Kashmir’s borderlines; and despite UN intervention, there is continuing disparity over who is right and who is wrong. A mixture of truth and fiction appear to be at the heart of

The Drawing Board Essay

1308 words - 6 pages It's been three grueling days since she left. Three days full of pain, sorrow, and week-old carryout. I shuffled to the kitchen and peer into the fridge only to find three cans of BudLite and a carton of old Mushu pork. I watched the Chinese characters rotate countless times as my pitiful dinner is reheated by the microwave, and I returned to the dark green couch with my meal in-hand. The Pacers were down by twenty in the fourth quarter

Pushing the Boundaries of Experimental Literature

807 words - 3 pages conventional text to create an original art piece. However, movements, such as Kenneth Goldsmith’s self-indulgent idea of conceptual poetics may devalue previous understandings of originality. As a result, writers will begin pushing boundaries for the sake of pushing boundaries. This creates the reverse effect: originality will become unoriginal. Furthermore, literature has always been a way of archiving history, whether writing is fact or fiction it tells our story to future generations. If conceptual writing continues to be form without content all that will remain is a copy, of a copy, of a copy.

The boundaries of strategic corporate social responsibility

8567 words - 34 pages facilities in order to cut costs.Clearly, the boundaries of ethical CSR are not clear; otherwise we would nothave so many interesting ethics discussions in corporate boardrooms andcollege classrooms. However, the parameters for ethical responsibilities arebeyond the scope of this paper, which focuses on why altruistic CSR iswrong and strategic CSR is right[3]. Here, I shall restrict the discussion ofethical CSR to that of ethical

Defining the Boundaries of Magical Realism in The Porcelain Doll

1470 words - 6 pages Defining the Boundaries of Magical Realism in The Porcelain Doll      Scholars have debated the defining characteristics of Magical Realism since its infancy as an emerging art form in the early twentieth century. From Franz Roh, the art critic who coined the term Magical Realism, to contemporary leading scholars such as Amaryll Chanady, a myriad of confusion has surrounded this term. In an effort to narrow the defining boundaries of what

Courage Is Stepping Out of the Boundaries of Society

804 words - 4 pages “[Courage is] when you know you’re licked before you begin but you begin anyway and you see it through no matter what” (Lee 149). In the novel To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee, courage is an obvious overlapping theme that portrays radical, determined characters that have the willingness to defy common views. Likewise in The Help by Katheryn Stockett, the reader sees what happens when people persevere against the evils of society and take

Boundaries, Symmetry and Continuity in Radcliffe's The Mysteries of Udolpho

1610 words - 6 pages Below is a passage from I.2 of Radcliffe's The Mysteries of Udolpho concerning the concept of "precepts" in relation to the characters of St. Aubert and his daughter Emily: I have attempted to teach you from your earliest youth, the duty of self- command […] not only as it preserves us from the various and dangerous temptations that call us from rectitude and virtue, but as it limits the indulgences which are termed virtuous, yet which

Understanding of the Self

1945 words - 8 pages can occur through language, linguistic practices and conversations. Language can be used for internal symbolisation. (Wetherell and Maybin, 1996). In order to explain the boundaries between an individual self and the society, Mauss proposed that the self identity comprise of two components, the "moi" provides awareness of one selfhood in the individual sense, whereas the "personne" comprises of social influences, such as appropriate social

Discovery of the Self

1836 words - 7 pages Philosophy originates from the Latin words Philo and Sophia meaning 'love of wisdom'. This love of wisdom doesn't always come easy, and often students of philosophy will question everything they previously knew, but questioning is the precise purpose of philosophy. Sometimes the answers aren't always there, and everyone's answers are not the same; this is the joy of philosophy. An important aspect of philosophy is the aspect of the self. In the

Profile of the Self

623 words - 2 pages Profile of the Self   “You are requested to close the eyes.” This urging that Sigmund Freud experienced in a dream helped to unlock repressed feelings, and gave him insight into his personality. Fortunately, there are now tests available to help us to understand ourselves. Our behavior can be determined and understood by analyzing different aspects of ourselves. The four main aspects are: Decision Making, Self-Concept, Interpersonal

The Decline of Self

2955 words - 12 pages The Decline of Self The Tenth Edition of Merriam Webster's Collegiate Dictionary has this to say on the subject of self: self n., pl selves 1 a: the entire person of an individual b: the realization or embodiment of an abstraction 2 a (1): an individual's typical character or behavior (2): an individual's temporary behaviour or character b: a person in prime condition 3: the union of elements (as body, emotions, thoughts, and sensations

Similar Essays

The Ethical Boundaries Of Universal Healthcare

1091 words - 4 pages Princeton economist Paul Krugman one such solution is to provide Universal Healthcare in the United States in turn lessening the financial burden on organizations and the workers they employ. The dilemma this raises is around the ethical boundaries of Universal Healthcare. Roper stated that Paul Krugman believes that the U.S. needs to provide health care to all Americans “paid for by taxing the economy winners (2008).” His belief is that

Sanity: Boundaries Of The Mind Essay

1381 words - 6 pages Sanity: Boundaries of the Mind      The mind is a beautiful thing. The boundaries that someone can extend their rationality is different in each and every person. In Shakespeare’s Hamlet, the balance of sanity and madness is tested. Hamlet’s way of thinking is changed, but in a way that his personality is only a front. By looking at the different events that Hamlet overcame, we can observe the passion for acting that

The Art Of Drawing And Architecture

1701 words - 7 pages drawing materials that have been standard for hundreds of years, the art of drawing is far from the same. The architect’s role is to be a creator of form, a design specialist who will initiate and lead a design process. In the early phases of design they first must produce a series of design drawings, or typical study drawings which are the designer’s principal means of thinking. The presentation aspect of drawings are a major part of the design

Drawing Down The Moon Essay

2071 words - 8 pages ;  Although, I did not agree with everything that Margot Adler had to say, or with some of the interviews she chose to include in Drawing Down the Moon, I am happy that I chose to read it for my final paper. I do not feel that we cover enough about Pagan religions in our class, and this assignment gave me the opportunity to learn more about Pagan religions other than my own. Brief Summary      In America today