This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Drone Warfare Essay

1340 words - 5 pages

Concerning the issue of drone warfare we run into a problem with international laws as well as our own laws. This issue arises do to the fact that there are no laws that specifically apply to drone warfare. Is it legal for the president to call a drone strike on a potential target, in a country that we are not currently fighting, without the consent of congress? does it violate the Geneva convention or international law?
It has been the policy of the current administration to use drones without any consultation or consent of congress, even when the strikes were in countries that we are not at war with. It has been said that the president is given a list of names and he decides who on the list they will kill, whether this is completely true or not it is true that some of the strikes are against people that are just suspected of terrorism. many of these strikes had civilian casualties.
The Oxford Research Group says that "an important difference between the law of armed conflict and the law enforcement model is that while the former requires civilian casualties to be proportional to the military advantage gained, the latter generally does not accept casualties of innocent bystanders at all."( Knoops703) What this is saying is that, in a military action civilian casualties can in some cases be exectable as long as what you gain is worth it. However the definition of International armed conflict is "the use of armed force between two opposing states." (Knoops704) A person could argue that we are not fighting an opposing state, and so civilian casualties are unacceptable. But is it legal?
If we look at international law we can see a problem. Though there is no law specifically applying to drones, there are laws about entering other countries with military hardware and killing their citizens. We also run into issues with the Geneva convention, the Geneva convention says that a military must take all steps to avoid civilian casualties. The problem arises when there are reports of twenty to fifty casualties when we kill about ten bad guys.
There are policies describing what requirements a target must meet before a drone strike can be authorized; however, they are vague and the meaning is easily changes depending on a persons interpretation of them.
1. Suspects, such as Mr Al-Awlaki, can only be killed through drone attacks in the event that an incarceration of such person is illusory. 2. The person in question has to be involved in preparing ‘acts of war’ against the U.S. 3. Consequently, that individual should pose an immediate and significant threat to the U.S. 4. The State ‘hosting’ such an individual must not be able or willing to apprehend him or her. (Knoops700)
An issue that appears throughout this is that there is no oversight from congress deciding who we are attacking. This is especially a problem when we are invading a sovereign state too take out a perceived threat, or even more controversial taking out American Citizens.
...

Find Another Essay On Drone Warfare

test Essay

997 words - 4 pages Drone warfare may only interest those who are knowledgeable of the laws and ethics of international military affairs. The media portrays drone warfare as extrajudicial killings, the killings of a person by governmental authorities without the sanction of any judicial proceeding, acted by The U.S. President. However, the media does not acknowledge that the target audience is limited in size. “Obama’s Drone War” is an opinionated article in The

Drone attacks and it’s legal and moral battle

1428 words - 6 pages . "DisplayNews." DisplayNews. United Nations Human Rights, 14 Mar. 2013. Web. 20 Nov. 2013. "Drone Warfare | The Bureau of Investigative Journalism." The Bureau of Investigative Journalism. The Bureau of Investigative Journalism, n.d. Web. 20 Nov. 2013. Macbool, Malik. "Will Leasing out Pakistan Steel Mills to a Private Firm Enable It to Bounce Back?" The Nation. The Nation, 21 Nov. 2013. Web. 21 Nov. 2013. Pilkington, Ed, and Ryan Devereaux. "US Defends Drone Strikes as 'necessary and Just' in Face of UN Criticism." The Guardian. Guardian News and Media Limited, 25 Oct. 2013. Web. 21 Nov. 2013.

Drones are the Future

2033 words - 9 pages cameras in the world which can capture images from high altitudes and speeds. Then, after compiling the data of expected damages and effectiveness of the strike, an assessment is made on the expected result and the legality of the action being taken. Also, there are nearly 200 highly trained professionals involved in the decision to conduct a strike or not. Arguments often arise that the “push-button” mentality is used with drone warfare, and is the

Use of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles in Warfare

1234 words - 5 pages Use of Unmanned Aerial Drones in Warfare UAVs have become an important asset to the American military in recent years with their use for information gathering, and their hunter killer capabilities. In recent years drones have sparked many heated debates of whether their use are harming more civilians then terrorist, or of the legality of their use overseas. But with advancements in recent years in surveillance technology drones have become a

Is Targeted Killing Justified?

1215 words - 5 pages launched from an unmanned aerial vehicle on a target in a foreign country. According to a study by the New American Foundation, President Obama has authorized four times as many drone strikes in his first four years in office as President Bush did in eight years. Given that a drone can be launched without the risk of American loss of life, it is easy to see why it is such a popular form of warfare and foreign policy. Like a high performance

Uneasy Drones

905 words - 4 pages For many people, just the word drone sends a chill down their spine. The infamous reputation of these unmanned flying objects comes from their heavy use in war zones where they are meant to track and kill. The purpose of these drones is to complete a mission without risking the lives of soldiers. Contrary to popular belief, most drones are used for purposes other than warfare. The public rarely hears about the positive side of drones and thus

Drones Have Changed the Character of War

2434 words - 10 pages -area’ of warfare. As conflict has become more pluralist, often with a wide-range of allies and collaborative stakeholders made-up from the international community (i.e. UNPROFOR, ISAF, NATO etc.), an ethical and moral objection to the use of drone strikes is likely to transform into legal challenges against their continued use7. Air-power and the use of drones in-particular is perceived by many as a ‘cruel overmatch or a blunt instrument’ of

Drone Persuasive Essay

2038 words - 8 pages . 2013. Web. 28 Apr. 2014.Boyle, Michael J. "The Costs And Consequences Of Drone Warfare." International Affairs 89.1 (2013): 1-29. Academic Search Premier. Web. 5 Apr. 2014.Cullen, Peter M. "The Role Of Targeted Killing In The Campaign Against Terror." Joint Force Quarterly 48 (2008): 22-29. Academic Search Premier. Web. 28 Apr. 2014."Drone Wars Pakistan: Analysis." Welcome to The National Security Program. The New America Foundation, n.d. Web. 26

Drones: Ethical for War

786 words - 4 pages In 1975, American aerospace engineer Alvin Ellis worked on a prototype for the Israeli company Tadiran: a camera strapped to a model airplane (Drone Age). With this prototype, Ellis kickstarted the modern drone industry. Many countries began to use drones for war including the United States, which has been using unmanned aerial vehicles, or drones, in warfare since the 1980s. When they were first adopted, the military had only sixty drones

Technology

2649 words - 11 pages , drone technology is expected to be in reach of terroristic groups or "rogue" nations as highlighted by Benjamin and Ehrenreich () who think, "Drone Warfare sketches out the nightmare possibilities posed by this insane proliferation." 2. What is a techno-economic paradigm? According to Hanna (2009), "A techno-economic paradigm provides the means for modernizing all existing industries, activities and infrastructures... A techno-economic paradigm

Should U.S.A. Use Drones to Combat Terrorism?

1434 words - 6 pages assassinate high priority terrorists. Regular ways of warfare are not working in Afghanistan and Pakistan because the terrorists are very good at hiding, and looking for them on foot is a not only a tedious job, but it is also extremely dangerous. Just like with any new technology, especially technology that kills, there are always controversies. Although there is problems with the current drone technology and the drone program in general, all these

Similar Essays

Drone Warfare Essay

2064 words - 9 pages have at the moment. In the future, drone warfare is unavoidable. When drones were first invented, of course, they did not work amazing. Throughout the years that drones have been around, they shown that they are becoming a more advanced and needed machine. The world is becoming increasingly technology based. Drones pose as a safe alternative to sending maned jets into harms way. Drones remove the chance for our troops to be put in harms way

On Drone Warfare Essay

1594 words - 6 pages in the debate, one endorsing armed drones as an efficacious, novel form of warfare, whereas another criticizing it as problematic. In this paper, I will introduce the arguments of both sides, namely, why some people endorse the use of drones and others oppose to it. I will then introduce Bradley Strawser’s viewpoints on drone warfare and explain why I find them persuasive. I will anticipate a few objections to Strawser’s position and demonstrate

Drone Warfare: Rethinking Morals Essay

2492 words - 10 pages of UAV technology. It is not unreasonable to foresee UAVs eventually becoming autonomous so that a human is completely out of the loop (DoD has already investigated looking at a human-on-the-loop versus in-the-loop defense models). What do the advantages presented above mean for the morality of drone warfare? Make no mistake: I am not advocating a “fair” war. War is not a little league baseball game where everyone needs to play by the rules. As

To What Extent Can We Increase Funding To Combat Drone Research

868 words - 4 pages Peace, a word that is always used, yet with results that are never achieved. Peace, a word that will surely be flung around throughout today’s world and peace, a word that cannot be achieved if we are killing innocent civilians with combat drones. A combat drone is an unmanned aerial vehicle, capable of killing terrorists, yet sadly, innocent civilians are killed in the process. We need to alleviate this problem, by increasing the amount of