This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Duty Of Care And Psychiatric Injuries Ll.B : Law Of Tort Essay

3295 words - 14 pages

Psychiatric Injuries: Duty Owed?
INTRODUCTION

The law of negligence deals with relationships, harm, suffering and losses and within the confines of many statutes, the common law and equity, must make determinations on such emotions and outcomes.

Whilst the source of many claims under the tort of negligence come about because of harm, this is not the primary concern of the field ? it is a fine balancing act between the harm suffered and the rights possessed so as to claim for such sequential suffering.

Whilst It is believed, a far reaching duty of care is owed to all
, this is in fact not always the case and there exist areas of the law of negligence which are severely restricted- notably the law of psychiatric injury for secondary victims.

Within this essay an examination of the law of psychiatric injury, and examine the reasoning for why a duty of care is not always owed.
A brief analysis of the development of the area will be given before examining the current state of the law and show how case precedents have created truly restrictive constraints for many victims on the back of policy and the courts misguided appreciation of psychiatric harm.
PSYCHIATRIC INJURY: SLOW TO DEVELOP
Psychiatric harm is a form of personal injury which falls under the confines of the law of negligence liability. Historically, the courts? view of psychiatric injury was distinct from that of physical harm,
resulting in its slow development within the confines of the wider jurisprudence.

In the early developmental periods of modern day negligence in the 1930?s
, there was still a general lack of understanding relating to how the mind worked and further ignorance of how comparable psychical and psychological disorders can be, notably in their impact on an individual?s wellbeing.

Given the limited knowledge of psychiatric injury, there existed real fear within the courts that any broad recognition of psychiatric harm
would result in many fraudulent claims, as individuals sought to take advantage of the courts lack of understanding.
Further to this was the ?floodgates?
argument, which is noted in Alcock
. It was feared that permitting a far-reaching duty of care would open the flood gates to an array of compensation claims resulting in a burdensome impact on the legal system.
In addition, it was argued that financial incentives could curtail a victim?s motivation to seek rehabilitation
and recognising a duty of care should not encourage greed and dishonesty
. A final argument elucidated was the potential unfairness to the defendant of imposing damages out of all proportion to the negligent conduct, a far-reaching injury would potentially dilute the notion of proximity and foreseeability
and would have across-the-board consequences in relation to additional burdens to insurers and insurance policy holders.

All the above policy considerations have been, and to a certain degree today, still contribute to the routine...

Find Another Essay On Duty of Care and Psychiatric Injuries - LL.B : Law of Tort - Essay

Duty of Care and the Public Policy issue

2446 words - 10 pages presence of duty of care.22 - Stovin v Wise (n 15)23 - R Dworkin, Law's Empire (1st edn, Belknap Harvard 1987) Pg 276-277Bibliography:Books:Bermingham, V and Brennon, C, Tort Law Directions (2nd Edition, OUP 2010)Dworkin, R, Law's Empire (1st Edition, Belknap Harvard 1987)Hodgson, J, and Lewthwaite, J, Tort Law (2nd Edition, OUP 2007)Murphy, J, Street on Torts, (12th Edition, OUP 2007)Cases:Anns & Ors v London Borough of Merton [1977] 2 All ER

Problem Question Tort Law - University of London - Law of torts essay

2484 words - 10 pages There is a widespread debate in regards to whether the “assumption of responsibility” leads to liability in the law of negligence. Whilst many may believe that assuming responsibility automatically makes liability follow, others may oppose this view. In addition, the statement provided by Lord Slynn refers to the test regarding “assumption of responsibility” recognized under the duty of care. Through the examination of case law, this essay will

Analysis of Duty of Care 2007

1555 words - 6 pages their duty of care to students and to help parents and students understand when and if a duty of care exists. It discusses instances when other persons, in a supervisory position towards students, must also provide a duty of care (Western Australia, Department of Education, 2007). The profession of teaching is increasingly affected by the law as parents and students are becoming more aware of their rights and expectations, (Newnham, 2000). This

Tort law in Canada and what this area of law is all about

1111 words - 4 pages the city's insurance will go up if they have to payout such a large settlement. We pay for the abuse of others. I do agree that an injured person should be compensated for their injuries, but within reason.As shown by the examples, tort law can be good and bad in society. Tort law is being abused because whenever a person is injured they immediately want to sue, even if the other person has not done anything wrong. There are reasons against tort

Critically Evaluate the implied duty of fidelity - Employment Law Leeds University - Essay

1396 words - 6 pages and justify how you have made your choice. Within Employment contracts there are implied duties that are expected of the employee. Namely these duties are the duty of obedience, the duty to adapt to new methods and techniques, the duty of care owed to the employer, the duty not to compete, the duty of confidentiality and the duty of fidelity/good faith. The duty of fidelity encompasses a number of more specific duties these are, honesty: an

Psychiatric Evaluation and Diagnosis of Virginia Woolf

1015 words - 4 pages treatment, etc. References: American Psychiatric Association. (2000). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition, Text Revision. Washington, D.C.: American Psychiatric Association. Antai-Otong, D. (2006). The art of prescribing: Treatment considerations for patients experiencing rapid-cycling bipolar disorder. Perspectives in Psychiatric Care, 42(1), 55-58. Carmango, Thomas. (1992). The Flight of the Mind: Virginia

Health Care and Tort Reform

1649 words - 7 pages redress on wrongs done to them (“United”). That tort reform may simultaneously benefit citizens by providing affordable health care prices does not matter, because this legislation would take away these fundamental rights. Legislation must never take away rights, no matter at how minimal a level – a loss of freedom always beings at a minimal level. And then it continues until people are no longer free. Furthermore, law and government must stay in the

The Purpose of Tort Law in the Irish Legal System

3219 words - 13 pages have lost this consideration. Tort on the other hand is seen as the law of personal wrongs, and although it too contains a breach of duty, is different from contract law. An example of a tort is negligence, this is the failure of a person to take the degree of care necessary in order not to injure another party. If someone is injured due to the negligence of another, the wrong doer may be held liable and have to pay compensation to the injured

Essay on tort law history, in particular looking at the British and Australian tort law development through the 19th century

1396 words - 6 pages Prior to the industrialization of America and England in the early 19th century tort law had a limited scope primarily due to a lack of diversity and lack of quantity in tort cases. However with large factories and railroads grew a complex relationship between employee, employer and consumer. Due to this it was necessary for the legal system to re examine lines of reasoning. Despite academics such as Friedman suggesting that the law became a

Common Law in Australia: The Tort Of Negligence

9095 words - 36 pages adequate illumination of the car park. Held, on appeal, that D's failure or omission to leave the park lights on might have facilitated the crime and thereby caused the injuries sustained by P. However D's omission to leave the lights on did not cause P's injuries. Per Gaudron J: "the law is and in my view should be, slow to impose a duty of care on a person with respect to the actions of third parties over whom he or she has no control". In Modbury

Document Analysis of Duty of Care to Students

1870 words - 7 pages Introduction The term duty of care originates from common law practices and is the background to most school policies and procedures (Government of Western Australia Department of Education, 2007, p3). Teachers need to be aware of their obligation in relation to students left in their care and the Duty of Care Policy sets out to clearly state what a teachers and schools obligation are towards their students. The policy states what is

Similar Essays

Discuss The Extent To Which Public Servants Owe A Duty Of Care Under The Tort Of Negligence

2565 words - 10 pages payer. Secondly, public servants would begin to adopt cautious or defensive practices which would hinder the investigation of crime, protection of children etc. Given these policy considerations it is unlikely that the courts will extend the duty of care considerably in the future.2372 wordsBIBLIOGRAPHYTextbooksElliott, C. and Quinn, F. 2005. Tort Law 5th Edition. London: LongmanGiliker, P. and Beckwith, S. 2004. Tort 2nd Edition. London: Sweet &amp

Legal Systems: Duty Of Care And Negligence

1406 words - 6 pages Legal systems are critical to the functionality of any given society. In particular, issues of duty and responsibility are fundamental to address especially when one party causes harm or injury to another. In this respect, the concept of duty of care and its connection to negligence serve a key role in the society. Tort law provides for legal processes following acts of negligence that exhibit duty of care. The underlying liability in negligence

Duty Of Care For Patients Essay

667 words - 3 pages capacity. When a health care practitioner starts a patient-doctor relationship they have identified that a duty of care exists in their relationship. However there are also the legal aspects as well as the guidelines and risks that comes from establishing a duty of care i.e. negligence law. ( Townsend & Luck, 2013). Duty of care is essentially a legal obligation set out to ensure that all health care professionals and first aiders perform to a set

Duty Of Care For Students Essay

1411 words - 6 pages A. Introduction Children are at risk of injuring themselves at any time. Parents have different expectations of teachers as a professional than that of themselves when caring for their own children. When forcing parents to put their children in school by law at the age of six years and six months (Department of Education Western Australia, 2011), the Department must implement a Duty of Care to help protect Teachers and the children that are in