This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Duty Or Virtue Essay

2222 words - 9 pages

Happiness is defined as a “state of being happy”. This concept of happiness seems rather simple to the ordinary person. According to Aristotle and Immanuel Kant, happiness is not merely a state. In fact, there is a lot more substance within the dimension of happiness that one must acquire and comprehend to achieve. While Aristotle defines happiness as the final end and self sufficient (8), Kant does not. Instead, Kant emphasizes the kingdom of ends, in which all are subject to the categorical imperative as rational autonomous beings with the intention of universalizing one’s maxim, not happiness. This paper will explore Aristotle’s definition of happiness in comparison to Kant’s.
According ...view middle of the document...

Hence, Aristotle is stating that out of all the parts of our soul, we must activate our rational part. For instance, Aristotle writes that “ Being happy, is found in living and being active”. Aristotle therefore states that “the activity of the good person is excellent, and [hence] pleasant in itself, as we said at the beginning; what is our own is pleasant; and we are able to observe our neighbors more than ourselves, and to observe their actions more than our own” (30-35). Thus, a good person finds pleasure in the actions of excellent people who are his friends, since these actions have the naturally pleasant features.
In Book 1 chapter 7, Aristotle discusses the ultimate end, happiness, using three arguments. Firstly, it is complete, meaning that the ultimate end is an end that is not choice worthy, but in itself is a complete one (1094a18-22). Secondly, it is self-sufficient, meaning that one would choose it over anything else (1094a18-22). Finally it is preferable, meaning that the means to happiness is better than anything else compared to it (1094a18-22).
More so, Aristotle is concerned with character and disposition. Aristotle’s virtue theory offers guidance and direction but does not provide a set, unalterable calculation that can be worked out when determining right from wrong to achieve happiness. Aristotle explains that excellence of character is concerned with two points, emotions and actions, as well as likes and dislikes, also known as pleasures and pains. The actions a person preforms exemplify the emotions they are feeling; these emotions, according to Aristotle, include anger, fear, envy, and joy, among others. The other feature of excellence of character has to do with the pleasure or pain derived from performing a certain action. The good man will preform an action because it is a natural indicator of his emotions; he acts according to his true likes and dislikes. However, the self-controlled man has to learn to control himself and forces himself to act contrary to his emotions and likes and dislikes. On the contrary, a self-controlled man does not take pleasure in the actions he participates in because he is simply forcing himself to act that way and therefore, facing an internal struggle. When a person becomes excellent of character by acting according to these guidelines, then he or she will be able to abide by the Doctrine of the Mean. This is because finding the mean, or the virtuous action, involves acting properly according to one’s emotion as well as not giving in to pleasures will produce the most happiness because one is acting for the sake of the ultimate end. Aristotle regards practicing virtues in the right manner helps one become a virtuous person. He explains, “it is not the excess or deficiency of [it] that we censure” (483). Therefore, one will reach happiness by excelling at practicing virtues in the right manner and becoming a virtuous person.
By way of contrast, Immanuel Kant does not view happiness...

Find Another Essay On Duty Or Virtue

Advantages to a Rigorous Approach to Environmental Virtue Ethics

1854 words - 7 pages ethics attempts to describe morality on the basis of character traits that people might have. Good or right traits are called virtues; wrong or bad traits are called vices. This stands in opposition with the ethics of duty, which describes morality in terms of right or wrong actions and the ethics of consequence, which describes morality in terms of the consequences of our actions. In the ethics of virtue, we define a set of virtues and

The Virtuous Pamela of Virtue Rewarded

920 words - 4 pages The Virtuous Pamela of Virtue Rewarded       Samuel Richardson began his literary career when two booksellers offered him the opportunity to amass a publication for unskilled letter writers. While preparing this volume, a small sequence of letters from a young lady asking her father's counsel when endangered by her master's advances, entranced him. His enthrallment resulted in a shift in his work. The result was the tome Pamela; Or

What is Virtue Theory? "Virtue Ethics is of little practical use to someone faced with a moral problem." Discuss

1103 words - 4 pages lying to the murderer about his whereabouts, would it not be more moral to lie? If we put virtue ethics to use in these moral situations, it seems to have dreadful consequences. Virtue ethics fails to look at these.However it is does look at the individual, which other theories fail to do. This way we are able to use it practically without becoming unhappy or seemingly careless, as can happen with Kantian theory, when 'duty' overrides happiness

Virtue Ethics

627 words - 3 pages concentrate on the right action as such; the right action according to virtue ethicists is the one that the virtuous person would do. Virtue ethics takes the central feature of morality to be the virtuous character, and the account of what the virtues are as the basis of the theory. The virtuous person is not someone who focuses on their own happiness or pleasure, or someone who follows the same rules and orders as everyone else. But rather, the

Aristotelian versus Kantian Ethics

1780 words - 7 pages achieving happiness are through the excellence of one's being. The term Aristotle uses here is aretê, or virtue. Essentially, virtue is the excellence of something, in this case moral action (1095b20-30). Virtue leads to happiness because it "seems to be more durable even than the kinds of knowledge" (1100b10-20). Earlier, Aristotle came to the conclusion that happiness is something that is not changed easily. If not, then happiness would be based on

Ethics

878 words - 4 pages According to Aristotle, virtue involves rationality and the use of a person?s rationality. Rationality and happiness are activities of the soul, and virtue is the excellence of these activities. Humans are the only life forms that have a soul, the source of rationality. Thus, humans have a duty to always use their intellect.Three things are found in the soul: emotions, capacities, and characteristics. Emotions are things humans feel, like

Virtue Ethics

1187 words - 5 pages determined by the will or command of God meaning whatever Gods says must be right at all times while the virtue ethics theory is about great attributes and character formation, not a list of dos and don’ts. In egoism, one’s self, motivations, and goals is the only thing that matters. The only duty of someone who is an egoist is to do what is best for them and what is in their best interest. Egoistical people do not mind helping or doing things for other

Sections of The Soul

1284 words - 6 pages considered a way of living the right way. For example, if someone is a butcher and he or she slaughtered the cattle, cut up the cattle into meat and sold the cattle then he or she has accomplished his or her duty to society. Fulfilling the duties of one’s role in society makes him or her successful or good at that task. Regardless of social roles, all humans share one common task, being a good person. Aristotle believed in something called the Golden

Virtue Ethics and Business Ethics

2835 words - 11 pages to emulate them. Aristotle would argue that when we speak of ‘flourishing’ that we should have the drive to do what will benefit oneself and one’s character. Therefore, for Aristotle, by giving to charity and not exploiting workers in a business by underpaying them or providing them with poor working conditions, would benefit one’s character because the right choice has been made, and is one more step closer to virtue

Birth Control

969 words - 4 pages the determining factor of what is right and wrong instead of the result of the action. Virtue ethicist on the other hand, focuses mainly on what makes a good person or the traits of a person's character that will lead to a good life. The virtue-based approach is the idea that actions do not determine a person's virtue but the character of the person when he or she performs those actions. From this perspective, "just cause" does not define virtue

Torture or not to Torture

899 words - 4 pages terrorist is tortured. There are many theories that might help to answer the question to torture such as utilitarianism, Kantian duty-based ethics, virtue ethics, and Christian-principle based ethics. Utilitarianism would answer whether to torture the imprisoned terrorist based off the amount of benefits for the given amount of people. Since utilitarianism “is concerned with maximizing the benefits for the maximum number of people” (Holmes, 2007

Similar Essays

Comparing Virtue And Vice In Utopia, The Bible, And Othello

881 words - 4 pages Comparing Virtue and Vice in Utopia, The Bible, and Othello The definition of virtue varies between cultures and societies. Utopian ideas of virtue do not necessarily agree with Biblical or Elizabethan England views, however, More’s "Utopia," the Biblical accounts in Genesis of Joseph and Jacob, and Shakespeare’s "Othello" all present the concept of virtue prevailing over vice. Although at times vice may appear to triumph over virtue

Virtue Ethics Ia Essay

1007 words - 5 pages sum it up in a positive manner as I believe, for many different personal reasons that it is my duty to make the reader have a pleasant reading experience. This is where one of the main problems of virtue ethics arises, that being the fact that in virtue ethics a lot of emphasis is given to emotions and feelings and it does not address the questions of “how should I act” etc. but rather ask the questions of “how should I live my life” or “what

Kantian Vs. Virtue Ethics Essay

1673 words - 7 pages to follow rules that we could accept as universal laws, or rules that we would be willing to have everyone follow in all circumstances (Kant, p 159). It strictly prohibits certain behaviors that are considered bad. In a nutshell, Kantian ethicists believe what makes a person truly good is their good will and the fact that the will acts out of duty to the moral law. Virtue ethicists pose a similar question to that of Kantian ethicists. Virtue

Virtue Theory Essay

2522 words - 10 pages Virtue theory is a branch of moral philosophy which lays emphasis on character rather than rules and consequences as the key element of ethical thinking. Virtue theory goes back to the Ancient Greeks who introduced concepts such as arête (excellence or virtue), phronesis (practical or moral wisdom) and eudaimonia (flourishing).PlatoAccording to Plato, one should try to do the right thing or be good because it is in one's own self-interest