E.P Thompson's The Making Of The English Working Class

1110 words - 4 pages

E.P Thompson's The making of the English Working Class

From looking at The making of the English Working Class it seems quite obvious that E.P Thompson’s main arguments throughout his book are about the notion of ‘class’, in particular the ‘making of the working class’ ; and in order to evaluate his theories we must attempt to look at other historians opinions about his book, and his suggested theories, in order to come to an impartial evaluation.

Many historians have their own interpretations when trying to define class, like Bourke who links class to characteristics such as accent, clothing; Marx who states that class was ‘no more or less than an objective social category’; and E.P.Thompson’s definition, that class happens ‘as a result of class conscious experience.’ Therefore it is quite clear that class is a contested concept as there is no exact definition, thus making it more difficult for historians to come to a conclusion with evidence to prove it.
The Making of the English Working Class is according to Kaye and McClelland, ‘the obligatory starting point for any contemporary discussion of the history of the working-class formation.’ This gives us the indication that Thompson had not just written another piece on the concepts of class but that his book ‘opened interpretive eyes to a new way of seeing class.’

In his book Thompson’s main purpose was to write adjacent to the grain of economic history by implying that ‘the working class did not rise like the sun at the appointed time. It was present in its own making.’ In this we can see how Thompson seems to envoke the working class experience in a vivid way, which is arguably one of the reasons why his book received such appraise.

However his book also received much criticism, as Kaye and McClelland point that his ‘own theory of how class formation is determined remains highly ambiguous.’ This suggests that perhaps Thompson did not go into specific detail on how class was formed and when, which remains a highly debated topic. The fact that Thompson argues ‘thus the working- class presence was, in 1832, the most significant factor in British political life’, is argued by the Marxist historian Anderson, that class was not specifically made in the 1830’s due to its decline, but was perhaps made in the 1880’s. The fact that he insinuates that the English working class was not ‘made’ by the 1830’s suggests that Thompson was ‘too voluntarist and subjectivist’ in his approach to explain the origins of working class consciousness.

However, it is argued by Palmer that ‘the platonic models of Anderson-Nairn thesis tidied up all the messiness of class struggles in a kind of tunnel vision that could scope only in the linear sightings of one-dimensional boundaries of hegemony,’ suggesting that Anderson had put all the essential struggles that the working class experienced. However Thompson was not just focusing on this, but the aspect of ‘the extent to which, even in defeat, the...

Find Another Essay On E.P Thompson's The making of the English Working Class

Two Views of the working class of Chicago

1787 words - 7 pages Hawa AbdallaDr. Kenneth ScherzerHistory 2020-D01July 20th, 2014Comparison of the Two Views of the Working Class In ChicagoAt the turn of the 20th century, Chicago, which was famously known for being the meat packing industry capital in the United States, was almost entirely composed of hopeful yet ignorant immigrants. With the hopeful wishes of coming to the United States to become successful and wealthy, many immigrants readily accepted jobs

Separation of the Working and Middle Class Child

1695 words - 7 pages prospect for education because of the difference in wealth. The Great Depression brought hard times for all Americans and expanded the working class while shrinking the middle class. Because the working class children held close ties and responsibilities to their families and faced more poverty than the middle class, they had a lesser chance to move out of the working class as they had a commitment to work to support their families, or children

Slims Table: The Life Of A Working Class Black Person

1484 words - 6 pages Slims Table: The Life Of A Working Class Black Person Slims Table, written by Mitchell Duneier has been called a true stereotype buster due to its content in which it truthfully examines the lifestyles of working class black men. The book is designed to break the common misconceptions imbedded in a majority of peoples minds over how a black man lives his life and why he in a sense "does what he does," "thinks what he thinks," and "acts the

The Dispossessed: What Is a Working Class?

1365 words - 5 pages What do you think of when you hear “working-class?” One perhaps might think of a specific race, gender, sexuality or a specific type of lifestyle. In William Deresiewicz’s “The Dispossessed” aims to raise awareness to his audience that people of the working class still exist and should be recognized. His targeted audience being the educated, younger generations of middle and upper class. Through the use of logic and building his

Working Women in the Victorian Middle-Class

612 words - 2 pages Working Women in the Victorian Middle-Class Charles Dickens’ character Miss Abbey Potterson is “some sixty and odd” years old, obviously unmarried (Miss), and a business owner (she owns a bar). Despite the fact that Victorian middle-class women were supposed to aspire to idleness, a growing number of women were becoming employed in the 19 th century for a number of reasons. The growing number of “redundant” (unmarried, like Miss Potterson

The argument of the bourgeoisie vs. the working class in Marx's "The Communist Manifesto"

1089 words - 4 pages happiness for many people; to be successful was to be richer. The proletariat, the oppressed working class, was controlled by the bourgeoisie and used for industrial production. They had no means of production of their own and were reduced to selling their labor power in order to live. As the bourgeoisie's economic conditions improved, the proletariat's economic conditions deteriorated. Marx presents many criticisms of the bourgeoisie. He states

The Pursuit of the American Dream by African Americans, Native Americans, and the Working Class

1672 words - 7 pages groups of people living in America as they pursued comfort in social and economic aspects. The “American Dream” has long been a part of American society and culture. In particular, Native Americans, the working class, and African Americans have all experienced the struggle and accomplishment that comes with the “American dream”. Native Americans faced many struggles in their efforts of achieving the “American Dream.” Shortly after the West became

Effects of Industrialization and the Conditions of the Working Class in England

1347 words - 5 pages infested, crowded, and unhealthy living conditions. The factories were causing large amounts of pollution making the air harmful to breathe. By 1850 half of England’s population had moved into the cities. There was a large separation between the rich and the poor creating a dismal society. The socialists saw this as an opportunity to gain support. Now that most of the society was part of the working class they would be open to the idea of making all

The Joy of Working

795 words - 4 pages The majority of the teenagers in this day and age, this concept of loving work may seem like a humorous joke that will never get old. However, this laughter could be a mask covering the fear and doubt of the future. Yet they do not even realize this concept stated by Steve Jobs actually opens a new prospective about work and life. If we knew our passion in life and knew what we would love to do, would we dread the future as much as we do now

Class Structure in the Importance of Being Ernst - English - Essay

588 words - 3 pages didn’t live in a class-structured society. If they didn’t live in a class-structured society, Jack wouldn’t have to go through an interview with Gwendolyn’s mother, to see if he was a good fit for her. Therefore, this could have been avoided, if the classes didn’t play such an important role. Ms. Prism seems to look down upon the lower classes for making so many children for Chasuble to christen; she appears to see it as a question of thrift. "I

The Effects of the Industrial Revolution on the Working Class as Represented by Gregor’s Transformation in Franz Kafka’s The Metamorphosis

1434 words - 6 pages In Franz Kafka’s the Metamorphosis, the author conveys the consequences of the Industrial Revolution on the working class of society as they became increasingly dehumanized through Gregor Samsa’s transformation into a bug as he slowly loses his human characteristics and privileges as a human. The novella is set in the early 1800’s, which is during the Industrial Revolution. The Industrial Revolution marked a period of technological advancement

Similar Essays

Exploitation Of The Working Class Under Totalitarian Rule In Animal Farm English Final Essay

1957 words - 8 pages A government’s duty is to maintain political order and enforce laws without the use of fear. They achieve this by regulating fair systems that do not take advantage of anyone no matter their class. The citizens under this government rule often feel safe and equal. In an oppressive government, however, this is not the case. There is no limit as to how much the government can control its people through manipulation and mistreatment. The working

The Working Class Essay

1379 words - 6 pages distribution of income, bank reform, and a reduction of the influence of corporations in government. Karl Marks would have said this was the bourgeoisie verses the proletariat, but I would have to say we would need to redefine this as the working classes (wage workers, middle class, and small business owners) versus the large corporations and the extremely wealthy. With only one percent of the population controlling a majority of the wealth

The Struggles Of The Working Class 1860 1914,

1625 words - 7 pages will be an equal or almost equal rival to those that oppress. The coercion of the working class continued throughout the eighteenth century. Horrible working conditions, poverty, and hunger were blooming in the world of the industrial proletariat. The fruitless revolts did not change the situation and just when it seemed like the treatment of the waged people could not get any worse, the resolution appeared in all its glory. This historical

Analysis Of The Working Class During The Great Depression

1319 words - 5 pages worse in the industrial field. Throughout the analysis of the working class during the Great Depression and the attempts that FDR had made to improve the working environment one can now have a better understanding of the life’s the people of the 1930s had to endure. There is obviously a reason for the naming of the Great Depression and as much as the Great New Deal tried to improve the economy for the better a lot of lives were still negatively