This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Economic Determinist Criticism Of "Barbie Q" Essay

1226 words - 5 pages

Sociological/ Economic Determinist Criticism of "Barbie Q", by Sandra Cisneros What does it mean to be rich? Is it not possible for a person to be wealthy without having a penny to their name? Most of us, including myself, in the middle to lower class population of the world like to believe in the idea that wealth is somewhat connected to money. After reading the short story "Barbie-Q" by Sandra Cisneros I believe that many more will change their prospective in regards to this idea. After all what is more simple than the concept that when two little girls with old odd dolls receive two new wonderful dolls that they become more wealthy. But is it that wealth that makes them happier? With that in mind is the America dream the idea of wealth or happiness? The propose of this paper is to give a sociological/ economic determinist criticism over "Barbie-Q" by Sandra Cisneros. Cisneros' economic condition in Barbie-Q is that she and her sister are part of family that live in poverty. Cisneros explains this when she is describing to us what their Barbie dolls looked like. She states that "Yours is the one with the mean eyes and ponytail" (Cisneros 414) "Mine is the one with the bubble hair" (Cisneros 414) "But that is all we could afford" (Cisneros 414). She and her sister know that their Barbie dolls are not the greatest dolls value wise, but they do realize that those dolls are the best that their family can afford and they make the best out of what they can get. The sisters go as far as making their Barbie dolls elegant "dress invented from a old sock where we cut holes in" (Cisneros 414). The economic condition of the sisters changes throughout this piece of work. It is the basic concept that 1+1=2 and two being greater than one means you have an increase. At the beginning of the story the sisters "don't have money for a stupid looking boy doll and rather ask for a new Barbie outfit next Christmas" (Cisneros 414). In the end the girls then find two new Barbie dolls still in the boxes at a flea market at and their parents get those ones for them as well. Now instead of having only one Barbie and one outfit apiece the girls both have two Barbie dolls and two outfits apiece, which gives them an increase of 100%. This increase does not only make economical richer but more importantly emotional rich as well. The girls become extremely excited by their new dolls. So much so that "on the outside you and me (the girls) are skipping and humming, but on the...

Find Another Essay On Economic Determinist Criticism Of "Barbie-Q"

Critical Perspective Essay

860 words - 4 pages Have you ever been obsessed with money? In the story Seize the Day by Saul Bellow money basically runs everything. The main character, Tommy Wilhelm, invests his money with a friend of his father and loses everything. This story falls into the critical perspective of Economic Determinist and Marxism. The critical perspective of Economic Determinist and Marxist evaluates literature from the perspective of economic and social class inequality and

The Mattel Barbie Doll Essay

1624 words - 6 pages El Segundo, California headquarters (The Creation of Barbie). This is where Mattel's material and economic experts decide where and who they should look to to provide the plastic, fabric, and other Barbie parts for the creation of its doll (The Creation of Barbie). All of the important decisions of production, labour, and retailing are made in El Segundo as this is where Mattel’s headquarters and corporate management

Barbie: Independent Woman or Damaging American Icon?

2690 words - 11 pages /2). Barbie's popular all-American "look" has even been imitated. Cindy Jackson received media attention in England and Germany when she spent $100,000 on plastic surgery to look like Barbie (Green 1/2). Mattel has always been conscious of Barbie's criticism and bad reputation. Despite the common Barbie critiques, many believe that Barbie is a positive model. For example, in the 60's, mothers didn't like Barbie because she

Barbie: Her Intentions and Her Impact

1319 words - 6 pages major career roles after the creation of Ken without having to assist him as her new role. Then when her sister Skipper was created, Barbie had responsibilities and had to answer to her parents. Handler’s response to this criticism of Barbie limiting young women was “if that is so, it’s because the little girls who is playing with her chooses to concentrate on those facers of a woman’s life” (Shannon). She felt that the purpose of Barbie was to be

The Ultimate Babe in Toyland

554 words - 2 pages this is no ordinary toy. She is a timeless creation who does more than smile and look pretty. In a journey through the sea of pink she is known as everything from the ideal American of femininity, to a disgrace to all women, and a bimbo. Despite criticism from feminists and other activists, Barbie has survived four decades of political, social, and cultural changes. In the toy industry that is a huge defeat. Toys normally have a short life span

Life in the Dream America

2056 words - 9 pages visualization unlike Barbie’s luxurious life is not about having a closet full of pink shoes, rather, it is about having the opportunity to succeed. Sure there is a huge difference between Barbie’s and the Latinos visualization of the American lifestyle but Barbie’s influence is so strong that attracts Latinas into it. Barbie has been a popular doll since the 1950s and on the past decades has faced strong criticism for being unrealistic and misleading


750 words - 3 pages have as much as others. This is shown by the poor girl wanting to get the dolls. She prefers to get many of the burnt dolls which she will cover up with nice clothing, just so that other people can see that she has nice Barbie dolls. It is like people in our society who may have barely enough money for their family to survive comfortable, yet they want to drive a Mercedes Benz.7.The title's significance is that she wants the Barbie dolls (Barbie-Q

Themes in Woman Hollering Creek by Sandra Cisneros

949 words - 4 pages Themes in Woman Hollering Creek by Sandra Cisneros Woman Hollering Creek is a book of short stories published in 1991. The author, Sandra Cisneros, separated her book into three sections. The section that will be analyzed is the first section where the narrators are female children. Out of the many stories in section one, the three that will be focused on are, "Mericans," "My Friend Lucy Who Smells Like Corn," and "Barbie-Q." The children

Behold The Barbie: Education, Power and Symbology

2347 words - 9 pages . Barbie is a posterchild for stereotypical behavior within her assigned gender, as she embodies a multitude of various stereotypes including a love of shopping and materialism that comes to bear on a socio-economic pane as well. The connotation of the language of the word “beautiful” contains meaning in particular cultures that, coupled with how it has manifested itself throughout the course of history renders its usage varied and vast. However

Barbie : A Study of Spaces of Consumption in the Global Village

1565 words - 7 pages the main emphasis is given on the consumer culture. Barbie, Consumer Citizenship and Transnationalism The idea of consumer citizenship (a consumer citizen is a consumer who makes reasoned choices based on ethical, social, economic and ecological considerations) along with transnational sensibilities is so much embedded in the mindset of people that the youth identify themselves as cosmopolitan, boundary-less identities with cravings for

Hippie Barbie

1055 words - 4 pages a sense of existence and belonging. Currently, Barbie dolls are being marketed in 150 different countries, being one of the most popular toys among children. Capitalism is under the same idea, by being an economic system based on private ownership of capital. Once again she seeks for freedom, but now the author takes an extra step: freedom from government. The word order of this poem is very important; she uses the end of each line as a

Similar Essays

Destructiveness Of Feminine Idealism In Barbie Doll And Barbie Q

1590 words - 6 pages The phrase, Beauty is only skin deep, does not appear to apply in this era of idealism and perfectionism. From the time babies are born through their adulthood, they are raised to conform to specific social roles. Specifically, little girls are expected to grow up becoming perfect feminine beauties created to bare children and care for their homes and husbands. Sandra Cisnero's “Barbie-Q” and Marge Piercy’s “Barbie Doll” portray the female body

Analysis Of Barbie Q By Sandra Cisneros

715 words - 3 pages Analysis of Barbie-Q by Sandra Cisneros Cisneros' Barbie-Q really stood out as a great piece of literature. Barbie-Q is a quick glimpse into the life of a poverty-stricken child and her way of life. Though my life as of yet has been rather short, my earliest childhood memories are overwhelmingly my fondest and her account really struck a chord. Sandra Cisneros' accurate reflection of a young mind and intricate writing methods expressed

Rhetorical Analysis Of Barbie Q Ohio State Essay

964 words - 4 pages Will Chiraz English 1110.02 Rhetorical Analysis 02 October 2017 Story Chosen: “Barbie-Q” Rhetorical Analysis on “Barbie-Q” by Sandra Cisneros In Sandra Cisneros’ short story, “Barbie-Q,” she describes the obsession of Barbie dolls by two young girls. These two girls come from low status families and are not able to afford many dolls and accessories for their dolls. However, one day they were walking through a flea market and next to piles of

Q: Write A Causal Argument About An Economic Issue Of Your Choice A: The Unequal Pay Of Women Still Relevant In American Society

766 words - 3 pages The unequal pay of women causes increase of poverty rate for elderly women, oppression of women, and the expansion of feminism. Through out the century, the percentage of women in the workplace have increased dramatically. However, sexism still plays a role in society when it comes to the wallet. Though women are a more frequent occurrence in the work industry, many aren't being paid as much as their male coworkers. In 1963, President John F