Economic Factors' Effects On The Pilgrimage Of Grace

1921 words - 8 pages

Sparked in Lincolnshire in October 1536 and expanding rapidly through
Yorkshire and the far north, the Pilgrimage of Grace was a popular rising that
presented a “major armed challenge to the Henrician Reformation” . The first
modern writers, Madeline Hope Dodds and Ruth Dodds, argued that it was an
association of interest groups with their own worries and priorities. Shortly after,
A. G. Dickens supported the Doddsian argument stating that he saw a
“fundamental divergence of interests and attitudes between gentry and
commons” . Then, C. S. L. Davies offered an alternative argument that
emphasised religion as the cause of the Pilgrimage. In addition, Sir Geoffrey
Elton argued that the Pilgrimage was the result of the “unexpected overthrow of
Anne Boleyn in the spring of 1536 and the consolidation of power at court and in
government by Thomas Cromwell”. Thus, historians have and will continue to
argue endlessly about the true causes of the Pilgrimage; on balance, a collection
of factors contributed rather than an overriding cause. As a result, it is fair to
say that the rising incorporated a mixture of political, religious, social and
economic issues. Therefore, economic factors were only partly to blame for the
Pilgrimage of Grace.
Firstly, politics was partly to blame for the Pilgrimage of Grace; hence, by
early 1527 King Henry VIII sought a divorce from Catherine of Aragon. Though,
it is hard to pinpoint exactly why, the most plausible explanation is his belief
that “his marriage was barren because of its illegality” and Catherine’s failure to
produce a male heir. This is because Henry argued that it was blasphemous of
him to marry his brother’s widow and he needed a son in order to safeguard the
Tudor dynasty. Understandably, any hopes of the divorce being granted were
dashed because Henry was a Roman Catholic and the head of this church was
the Pope based in Rome. More importantly, the Roman Catholic faith believed
marriage was permanent; therefore, only widowers could remarry. Accordingly,
a change in strategy intended to “separate the English church from the larger
Catholic Church” in order to get the divorce without any right of appeal to the
Pope. In effect, thefoundations began with the Pardon of the Clergy in January
1531, carried on with the Submission of the Clergy in May 1532, and was
accomplished with the declaration of the royal supremacy in 1534. However, by
far the most important document was the Act in Restraint of Appeals ratified in
April 1533, which transferred the power of the Catholic Church to Henry and his
government. Therefore, it allowed the divorce to be granted legally by the
Archbishop of Cranmer. As a result, anger arose from this act of supremacy as it
asserted Henry as the Supreme Head of the Church of England. Unquestionably,
people were disgusted with how he got rid of Catherine and the break with
Rome. Although, one can note that...

Find Another Essay On Economic Factors' Effects on the Pilgrimage of Grace

Economic Factors of the Civil War

1539 words - 6 pages The Civil War's outcome could have gone either way, on one hand you have the North, which had the industrial advantage, and the South on the other who had a home field advantage and better generals too. The war pitted brother against brother and father against son, and lost many wives their sons and or husbands. The victory of the North was due to many economical factors that hindered, and ultimately defeated the South.The North was the

Effects of the 2005 budget on economic activity, price stability, economic growth, full Employment and inflation

943 words - 4 pages everyone because the lives of our citizen's matter, the decisions the Government may affect their mortgages, their businesses, and whether they can find a job.He said the Budget was brought down at a time when more Australians are in work than ever before. Our unemployment rate has fallen to a low unmatched for 28 years.The budget will have a number of effects on a number of different areas of the economy including the economic outlook, tax cuts

Effects of Corruption on Economic Growth

517 words - 2 pages Effects of Corruption on Economic GrowthCorruption has been around for a very long time and will be around in the future unless governments can figure out effective ways to combat it. This is not going to be easy. Corruption in any form is treated as an incurable disease cause of many social and economic evils in the society and it damages the moral and ethical fibers of the civilization .Indisputably, it is correct that corruption breeds many

Economic effects on the Home Building Industry

1862 words - 7 pages The manufacturing of homes has been going on for thousands of years and has gradually evolved into a large market for those looking to entertain a wide variety of interests ranging from a steady paycheck to large real estate income, or from those looking for their first place to live, to those becoming a landlord of a rental property. Home building is one of the strongest fields to examine when studying the overall economy of a nation. The

The Role of Grace

1535 words - 7 pages An analysis of Polyeucte by Pierre Corneille reveals that the presence of God’s grace is evidently alive and can be seen in the character’s actions and choices throughout the play. At the beginning of the play, the main character Polyeucte is immediately thrown into a dilemma, to be baptized or not to be baptized. On one hand he fears his wife, who is a non-Christian will become angry with him for going through with the baptism. On the other

Economic effects on soveriegnt

1034 words - 4 pages Economic Effects on Sovereignty Some commentators claim that in the modern world, medium-sized economies do not have economic sovereignty any more. Thus it is necessary to form large economic and trading blocks such as the EU in order to recover some economic sovereignty. There is some truth in the idea that modern medium-sized governments have less control than they did in the past. "From about 1930 to about 1970 governments had a historically

What Eere the Effects of the Central Bankers on the Recent Economic Crisis?

1546 words - 7 pages were available to almost everyone without questioning their creditability. This was a huge mistake because many could not repay this debt and started defaulting on their loans. By 2007, more than 25 subprime lenders filed for bankruptcy. In The Alchemists: Inside the Secret World of Central Bankers, Neil Irwin reasserts that the housing bubble is a main cause in the eventual economic downturn. And because the United States’ economy has the most

The Economic Effects of the Slave Trade on Africa, Britain, and America

1487 words - 6 pages also produced over half of all the United States export earnings. Slavery almost single handedly was the main reason for economic growth. While the south was focused on cotton the north was focused on other sorts of industries. Slavery’s economic benefits persisted until the day it ended and was one of the main reasons America was able to grow and develop into the nation it is today. Unlike Britain and America the African nations who

The Economic Factors Involved with the Rising Price of Gasoline

3072 words - 12 pages The Economic Factors Involved with the Rising Price of Gasoline The year 2004 has seen a steady climb in the price of gasoline. From January of 2004 to May of 2004 there has been a jump of approximately .50 cents a gallon (Energy Information Administration). For many Americans high gas prices have been a hot issue with them, and there seems to be no rhyme or reason to these fluctuations. With the continued popularity

Social and Economic Effects of the Plague on Medieval Islam Societies

1379 words - 6 pages particularly devastating effects on the military. The expedient spread of the epidemic through militaries affected the outcome of a number of minor conflicts throughout the Islamic world. The epidemic even devastated the resilient Mamluk army of Egypt so sufficiently that the weakening of its military capabilities was a substantial factor in its defeat and eventual downfall to the Ottoman Empire. The massive depopulation of both urban and rural areas as

The different faces of grace

2067 words - 8 pages used to mean favor and then to mean gratitude. Through the years, grace has made an impact on many people's lives. Some form of grace can be found in songs, plays, businesses,royalties, poems, and Christianity.According to The Oxford English Dictionary (OED) the English spelling of grace comes from the French word grace. The word grace goes back to the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries when it was spelled grass or grease. The history of grace

Similar Essays

Pilgrimage Of Grace Dbq Essay

1284 words - 5 pages policies which included new taxes, increased power of the monarchy in Northern England, dissolution of Roman Catholic monasteries, and confiscation of the lands that belong to the Church. Enraged, commoners and nobles alike began marching and protesting in what was known collectively as the Pilgrimage of Grace. These individuals that numbered in the tens of thousands, marched for political and religious reasons, while the opposition also claimed

The Effects Of Economic Trends On Society

1443 words - 6 pages used responsibly to provide for ones needs instead of wants. In recent years the respect of money has fallen and financial responsibility has been ignored. People have begun to lose sight of what they need and instead focus on satisfying their unnecessary desires. Money has become easier to obtain as economic conditions have improved. Now people act as if they can attain happiness through possessions. Individuals obsessively strive to accumulate

To What Extent Was The Pilgrimage Of Grace A Protest Against The Religious Policies Of Henry Viii's Government?

2057 words - 8 pages of enclosure was also of great resentment by the people as it caused a loss of jobs as sheep need less care than crops. This, along with rumours of more taxes to follow and the attack on their religious beliefs, made people unhappy.The Political upheaval leading to the Pilgrimage of Grace was of "immense magnitude" (ed. Mac Culloch, 1995, pg 50). It was the culmination of the Ten Articles, new order of prayer, Royal Injunctions, as well as the

The Effects Of Socio Cultural Factors On Individuals

730 words - 3 pages Martin Luther King Jr. once described racism during the mid-twentieth century as a time, “[W]hen your first name becomes [negro], your middle name becomes "boy" (however old you are), […] when you are forever fighting a degenerating sense of "nobodiness.” Martin Luther King Jr. went through extensive efforts to end African-Americans’ social burdens, which ultimately resulted in his death; however, discrimination, although more concealed than it