Economics Of Crime And Punishment Essay

1670 words - 7 pages

The recent arrest of the so called Bali Nine for allegedly smuggling heroin into Australia (Powell & Carroll 2005, online) has caused controversy and created rifts between Australian and Indonesian relations. Resulting to a death penalty through firing squad if found guilty, what instigated these people to participate in this illegal activity? There are three approaches dominate the theories of crime - psychological, sociological and economic (Fadaei-Tehrani & Green 2002). As for the Bali Nine, we will demonstrate that an individual's lack of money is not the prime factor that cause acts of crime, as there are other factors behind these acts (Rubenstein 1995). The core of this essay is to discuss the economic approach to crime and examine whether economic theories can be applied to society in order to reduce crimes. We will use the subject of illegal drugs in Australia as an example of crime to illustrate our arguments.Gary Becker was the first economist to apply economic theory to analyze criminal activity (Rubenstein 1995). An economic approach would take into account the expected costs against expected benefits of committing a particular crime, assuming criminals are rational persons acting in their own self interest. Criminals view the cost of crime in two parts: the opportunity cost of committing a crime and the time expected to be jailed because of their activity.Before committing a crime, criminals analyze its opportunity cost. The opportunity cost is the income foregone by devoting time to criminal activities. In other words, it is the rate of return on legal market activity (Rubenstein 1995). The opportunity cost of an individual committing a crime is determined by various factors in the economy (Rubenstein 1995). One factor is the unemployment rate given that it determines the chances of employment. The levels of real wages as well as income equality are factors which determine the level of income during periods of employment. The welfare policy is also another factor as it represents income during periods of unemployment. Lastly, economic policy determines opportunity cost as it establishes the future wages and the chances of maintaining a job. For most criminals, the opportunity cost of committing a crime would be low as they would have little skills and low education.To further illustrate this point, consider the case of one of the Bali Nine suspects, Renae Lawrence, who was debt ridden (Moore, M. & Connolly, E. & Baker). By partaking in drug smuggling, which offers her $15000 (estimated to take a month), her opportunity cost would be retaining her old job at a catering firm, which she would have earned approximately $2400 (assuming she earns $20 per hour and 30 hours a week). Here Renae earns more from drug smuggling soThe second cost to criminals is the time they expect to be imprisoned because of their activity (Rubenstein 1995). This cost is far greater than the former cost. From the criminal's point of view, the...

Find Another Essay On Economics of crime and punishment

Crime and Punishment Essay

1149 words - 5 pages Crime and Punishment Crime for what, and punishment for whom? May happens in a park and maybe in a room! Maybe at night or afternoon, here or there or close to the moon. A man who makes a crime may be a tycoon or maybe just a vagrant without a small home. Now the problem is for what, for whom do a little vagrant or a tycoon want to be a prisoner or a dark moon? Making crimes comes as a result of many various things in life. The first and the

Crime and Punishment Essay

899 words - 4 pages In order to determine what the law was in the Elizabethan Age for crime and punishment, you must research crime and punishment in that age, the laws and the acts. In the Elizabethan Age there were many different crimes. Each of those crimes had their own punishment or punishments. They were very strict about what they could and could not do in this age. If you have ever thought about planning a crime, you would have to really think about the

Crime and Punishment

728 words - 3 pages Society has many different views on crime and punishment. During earlier times, the crime fit the punishment meaning an “eye for an eye” approach. If a thief was caught, their hands would be cut off. If a man killed another man, they would be killed as well. They did not have a chance to tell their side of the story, if people thought they were guilty, they were. Much has changed in the way we handle crime in the world today. In today’s world

Crime And Punishment

754 words - 3 pages In the distinguished novel Crime and Punishment, by Fyodor Dostoyevsky, some of the most significant events are mental and psychological taking place in the mind of the protagonist, Raskolnikov. Throughout Crime and Punishment, Dostoyevsky manages to give these internal events a sense of suspense, excitement, and climax associated with the external action.The entire novel is purely psychological, primarily internal, "taking the reader on a

Crime and Punishment

1321 words - 5 pages Crime and Punishment In his book “Crime and Punishment”, Dostoevsky explores the path of Raskolnikov who has many problems and obstacles throughout his life. He commits murder and is faced with the long and mentally extremely painful journey of seeking redemption. Raskolnikov believes that by a law of nature men have been “somewhat arbitrarily” divided into two groups of “ordinary” and “extraordinary”. Raskolnikov believes that the duty

Crime and Punishment

1311 words - 5 pages In his book "Crime and Punishment", Dostoevsky explores the path of Raskolnikov who has many problems and obstacles throughout his life. He commits murder and is faced with the long and mentally extremely painful journey of seeking redemption.Raskolnikov believes that by a law of nature men have been "somewhat arbitrarily" divided into two groups of "ordinary" and "extraordinary". Raskolnikov believes that the duty of the ordinary group is to

Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment

772 words - 3 pages In Crime and Punishment, Raskolnikov concocts a theory: All men are divided into ‘ordinary’ and ‘extraordinary’. The extraordinary man should have the right to eliminate a few people in order to make his idea known to all humanity; however, the ordinary man has no right to transgress the law. Because he believes this theory is an idea that must be known to all humanity, he considers himself extraordinary

Crime and Punishment Summary

3658 words - 15 pages wakes up in the evening, and fears he may have missed his chance. He immediately bustles about, making his preparations: the deed that has been obsessing him is the murder and robbery of the pawnbroker. He plans to retain complete control over his reason and will, and thereby commit the perfect crime, and perhaps use the fruits of it (i.e. the stolen goods) to help others. Raskolnikov makes his way to Alyona Ivanovna's. He enters on the pretext

The Two Personalities of Raskolnikov in Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment

582 words - 2 pages The Two Personalities of Raskolnikov in Crime and Punishment Raskolnikov, the main character of the novel Crime and Punishment by Feodor Dostoevsky, actually possesses two completely contradicting personalities. One part of him is intellectual: cold, unfeeling, inhumane, and exhibiting tremendous self-will. It is this side of him that enables him to commit the most terrible crime imaginable - taking another human life. The other part of his

Themes in the Opening Passage of Crime and Punishment

1316 words - 5 pages Themes in the Opening Passage of Crime and Punishment What important themes, characters, atmosphere and images are set out in the first chapter of Part one of Dostoyevsky's 'Crime and Punishment' ? From the very first word of this extraordinary piece of literature, the thoughts and transgressions of Raskolnikov penetrates the heart and mind of the reader with exceptional insight, skillfully constructed suspense plots and a dynamic

Crime and Punishment: Dostoevsky's Portrayal of Anti-Nihilism

1778 words - 8 pages During the mid- to late- 1800s in Russia, a radical phenomenon swept the nation. The idea that life was meaningless and that there was no "mind" or "soul" outside the physical world infected the minds of Russia's elite and Russia's poverty-stricken. This became known as Nihilism. According to Whitney Eggers on "Philosophies in Crime and Punishment," "Nihilists argued that there was a distinction between the weak and the strong, and that in fact

Similar Essays

Meta Criticism Of Crime And Punishment Essay

531 words - 2 pages Meta-criticism of Crime and PunishmentIn "Critical Responses to Crime and Punishment", two critics' approaches to Fyodor Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment are juxtaposed with both favorable and negative opinions on the Russian novel. I. Pisarev in his review of the novel, "The Struggle for Life", outlines a fierce objection, accusing the author of painting his protagonist, Raskolnikov, as "a madman whom Dostoevsky attempted to portray as typical

Heart Of Darkness Vs Crime And Punishment

777 words - 3 pages In the novel’s “Heart of Darkness” by Joseph Conrad and “Crime and Punishment” by Fyodor Dostoevsky, the author’s discuss good and evil and how it relates to reality and illusion. Conrad discusses it through Marlow’s journey through the Congo and its comparison to his homeland of imperialist Europe. Dostoevsky discusses it through the development of the main character, Raskolnikov, after his murder and his “split” personality. There are

Effects Of Guilt In Crime And Punishment

1009 words - 4 pages Guilt Guilt is a force in all that has the ability to bring people to insanity. When guilt becomes great enough, the effects it has on people go much deeper than the surface. People's minds and body's are overpowered by the guilt that consumes them every second they live with their burden. The devastating effects of guilt are portrayed vividly in Dostoevsky's fictional but all to real novel Crime and Punishment. In the story, the main

Crime And Punishment Essay

755 words - 4 pages in season or on private property, Petty theft which is a lesser version of theft, and finally vandalism (Mitchell). Crimes then did not go without a punishment much as they do now, though there was trial that could be considered unfair much as there are trials today that could be said the same. One main punishment that was occurring was hanging which usually occurred after a crime was considered Capital or Indictable. Hanging occurred to all