Edmundlear Edmund Of King Lear As Nietzsche's Free Spirit

3028 words - 12 pages

Edmund of King Lear as Nietzsche's Free Spirit


      In King Lear, Shakespeare creates a brilliant tragedy whose plot is driven primarily by its villains. Of these, Edmund stands alone as a man who makes his fortune, surrounded by those who seize fortune only when it is handed to them.  Shakespeare's ability to create a vivid, living character in the space of a few lines of speech triumphs in Edmund, who embodies a totally different moral system than that of Shakespeare's era.  Three centuries later, Friedrich Nietzsche's philosophy of the Free Spirit would respect these values.

        Like Edmund, Nietzsche's unorthodox views have been deemed villainous ever since the time they were written.  The Free Spirit is defined not by his attack on society's defined values, but the rejection of them.  Unconstrained by the values of a society he did not chose, the Free Spirit makes his own path in the world, defining morality for himself and acting in a way which is truly free.

        In Act I, Scene II, Edmund's character reveals itself.  In his first soliloquy he clearly shows his knowledge of his situation, but at the same time questions its validity.

     Thou, Nature, art my goddess; to thy law

     My services are bound. Wherefore should I

     Stand in the plague of custom, and permit

     The curiosity of nations to deprive me,

     For that I am some twelve or fourteen moon-shines

     Lag of a brother? Why bastard? wherefore base? (I.2.1-6)

        This reveals the fundamental makeup of Edmund's character - why should society name him anything for events over which he had no control?  Why should he be deprived of anything simply because he was born a year too late?

        Neitzsche's Free Spirit must constantly question the values of the world around him, but know himself.  In Edmund, these characteristics are obvious - he questions the world created by men, but at the same time reflects that he is bound to Nature.  Nietzsche likewise saw the rigid values of Christianity as false ones, clumsily laid over man's true, changing nature.  "The hierarchy of the good, however, is not fixed and identical at all times.  If someone prefers revenge to justice, he is moral by the standard of an earlier culture, yet by the standard of the present culture he is immoral."1

     When my dimensions are as well compact,

     My mind as generous, and my shape as true,

     As honest madam's issue? Why brand they us

     With base? with baseness? bastardy? base, base?

     Who, in the lusty stealth of nature, take

     More composition and fierce quality

     Than doth, within a dull, stale, tired bed,

     Go to the creating a whole tribe of fops,

     Got 'tween asleep and wake? (I.2.7-15)

 Edmund continues by expressing his outrage at the labeling of a man who is just as rightly made up as another, but is forced into a second-rate status by a society...

Find Another Essay On edmundlear Edmund of King Lear as Nietzsche's Free Spirit

Transformation of Lear in Shakespeare's King Lear

1714 words - 7 pages : resentment, regret, recognition, acceptance and admittance, guilt, redemption, and optimism. Shakespeare identifies King Lear as a contemptuous human being who is purified through his suffering into some sort of god. The first stage of Lear’s transformation is resentment. At the start of the play it is made quite clear that Lear is a proud, impulsive, hot-tempered old man. He is so self-centered that he simply cannot fathom being criticized

traglear King Lear as a Bradley Tragedy

1330 words - 5 pages King Lear as a Bradley Tragedy      King Lear meets all the requirements of a tragedy as defined by Andrew Cecil Bradley.  Bradley states that a Shakespearean tragedy has to be the story of the hero and there is exceptional suffering and calamity slowly being worn in.  Also, the current time must be contrasted to happier times.  The play also depicts the troubled parts in the hero’s life and eventually he dies instantaneously because of

King Lear as a Commentary on Greed

1136 words - 5 pages King Lear as a Commentary on Greed    In Chapter 4 of a book titled Escape from Freedom, the famous American psychologist Erich Fromm wrote that "Greed is a bottomless pit which exhausts the person in an endless effort to satisfy the need without ever reaching satisfaction" (Fromm 98).  Fromm realized that avarice is one of the most powerful emotions that a person can feel, but, by its very nature, is an emotion or driving force that can

King Lear: Egg-as-crown Metonymy

1389 words - 6 pages doth with merit challenge.” (I, i, 53-55) King Lear demands a public display of affection from his daughters because it demonstrates his dominance. The betrayal of Goneril and Regan destroys King Lear’s ability to command, as competition between the two sisters’ shatters his kingdom like an egg. Lear’s relationship to his crown can be compared to a hen and her egg; both mean the world to their owners, and both are fragile. The smallest crack means

King Lear as a Tragic Hero

1588 words - 6 pages tragic hero must feel suffering and contrast those good times to the suffering, except his suffering leads to chaos and ultimately his death. The definition of a tragedy from our class notes is, “an honorable protagonist with a tragic flaw, which is also known as a fatal flaw. This eventually leads to his/her demise” (Class Notes). The definition of a tragic hero if laid out in black and white and King Lear meets all these requirements and his

The Nature of King Lear

1071 words - 4 pages his family. The subplot in King Lear is of Gloucester and his sons Edmund and Edgar. Edmund, the illegitimate, bastard son, can be seen as somehow unnatural according to the laws of society at that time. Gloucester himself says to Kent, regarding Edgar, "But I have, sir, a son by order of law..." (I.i. 18). The subtext here is that Edmund's conception was outside the law and unnatural to the social structure. Like Lear, Gloucester fails

Analysis of shakespeare's KING LEAR

1125 words - 5 pages perhaps we could also say Edmund is one of the characters whoundergoes a transformation in the end. However, up until thatpoint, Edmund remains a classic villain, whose human nature isentirely evil.At the beginning of the play, we see Lear as a proud, vain,quick-tempered old king, not necessarily evil, but certainly notgood. His folly leads to the alienation of his one truly lovingdaughter Cordelia, and the revelation that Regan and

Jacobean Reading of King Lear

1580 words - 6 pages King Lear was written around 1603-06. A contextualised political reading interprets King Lear as a drama that gives expression to crucial political and social issues of its time: the hierarchy of the Jacobean state, King James' belief in his divine right to rule, and the political anxieties that characterised the end of Queen Elizabeth's reign: fears of civil war and division of the kingdom triggered by growth of conflicting fractions and a

King Lear Quotes Of Imagery

1008 words - 4 pages Imagery · Eyesight Imagery Shakespeare's King Lear is extremely full with eyesight, vision, and blindness imagery. As a matter of fact the blindness versus vision theme runs rampant throughout the story. King Lear begins his journey as a man who is "blind" because he cannot see beyond the fake and flattering comments that his daughters Goneril and Regan throw at him. He blindly and angrily cuts his favorite daughter, Cordelia, out

King Lear - Victim Of Love

1177 words - 5 pages it's through words, but everyone deserves to feel loved, and Lear, being the simple man that he is, is content with words as proof of love. His 2 older daughters, Regan and Goneril do a fantastic job of appeasing him, delivering immaculate, embellished speeches that meet and exceed what his simple mind would be satisfied with. Upon his most cherished Cordelia's turn, all she can say is "Nothing". That right there is a lie because we all know she

The Reinvention of King Lear

2118 words - 8 pages The Reinvention of King Lear         On any given night within the global theatre community, chances are good that somewhere upon a stage there is at least one production of a Shakespearean play being performed, and whether it is Hamlet set in Nazi Germany (Eine Klein Hamlet) or The Tempest reworked as children's theatre (The Island of Anyplace), this production is, more often than not, a new interpretation of the ancient text. While the

Similar Essays

"King Lear" By Shakespeare Examination Of Edmund.

700 words - 3 pages In order to understand the characteristic of any character, especially Edmund, one must be aware of his background. In the beginning of the play, "King Lear," the reader views Edmund as a character who should be pitied upon; not as how critics assert him to be one of the most evil characters in all of literature. This viewpoint of Edmund is evident in the proceeding pages of this play. When the reader is first introduced to him, through Kent and

Edmundlear Edmund's Soliliquy In Act 5 Scene 1 Of Shakespeare's King Lear

998 words - 4 pages Analysis of Edmund's Soliliquy in Act 5 Scene 1 in King Lear     The portion of `The Tragedy of King Lear' I chose begins on line 55 of act five scene one and continues to line 64. I chose this selection because it includes much information about plot and character. Prior to my selection Regan questions Edmund closely about his relationship with her sister, Goneril, because Regan suspects they have been intimate. Edmund

Nietzsche As Free Spirit And New Philosopher

1890 words - 8 pages art of nuances"; they are "extra-moral" and "immoralists" - that is, they do not bind themselves to the conventional beliefs about morality in which most people place their faith (Nietzsche 31, 32).   The primary characteristics of the free spirit, however, elucidate this type in a specific way that denies that the free spirit is merely a rare person. Nietzsche's characterization of free spirits defines them as a type that is primarily

Shakespeare's Use Of Madness As A Theme In King Lear

2548 words - 10 pages failing to achieve balance in one's life. King Lear is a lesson on the catastrophic consequences of having an unbalanced life. Initially the audience is clueless as to what will happen to Lear as a result of his behavior, but Shakespeare provides some much needed foreshadowing throughout the course of the first act. Without these moments where Lear gives the audience insight into his fate, Lear's sudden turn to madness would seem random and out of