Education And Experience Essay

1709 words - 7 pages

Response Paper: Experience & Education
S. Reyes
University at Albany, SUNY

Introduction
Education and Experience offers Dewey’s thoughts about traditional and progressive education and the importance of a theory of experience. The two principles underlying experience are continuity and interaction. By considering these two ideas and their relationship to each other, we can try to understand experience. What is an educative experience as opposed to a non-educative experience? What do continuity and interaction suggest about growth, intelligence, and purpose?
Dewey discusses the limitations of traditional education upon the development of the young. The subject-matter of traditional education is, “so bound up with the past as to give little help in dealing with the issues of the present and future” (p. 23). What is missing is the connection of the past and present within experience. To remedy the divide between traditional and progressive education, he calls for a theory of experience.
Continuity
In order to find the connection between the past and the present and future, continuity needs to be considered. “From this point of view, the principle of continuity of experience means that every experience both takes up something from those which have gone before and modifies in some way the quality of those which come after” (p. 35). There is the past experience of others that have already established a path, a fact, some piece of knowledge, and then there is the experience of someone now in the present who takes that path, that fact, that piece of knowledge and makes it their own. Continuity is the knowledge of the experience of the past being adjusted through the lens of someone else’s experience in the present. Continuity keeps that knowledge going, in a forward direction.
It is important to have continuity for an educative experience. As one has experiences, information can be amassed into piles. Without continuity the piles of information are just that, separate piles of information. Without reflection, the information is not truly your own knowledge. Without judgment, there are no connections to what is being observed and what is being recalled from previous knowledge. There can be no growth without reflection and judgment. The experiences won’t lead to anything further so they are non-educative.
Interaction
What goes on between an individual and an object or an individual and others is interaction. The individual can be likened to Hawkins’ “thou,” and the relationship of thou and it or thou and thou. “An experience is always what it is because of a transaction taking place between an individual and what, at the time, constitutes his environment…The environment, in other words, is whatever conditions interact with personal needs, desires, purposes, and capacities to create the experience which is had” (p. 43-44). From an initial impulse, there is an interaction between thou and it. The...

Find Another Essay On Education and Experience

Learning from Past Mistakes: The Importance of Experience-Based Education

1062 words - 5 pages Learning from Past Mistakes: The Importance of Experience-Based Education The standard of education required for entry level practice into nursing has been a topic of debate for decades. There is no dispute among both the general public and those in the healthcare field that improving education could only lead to positive results. Controversy arises when dealing with varying ideas of implementation and standards. It is imperative to realize the

An Experience You Won't Forget, Arthur's Education, Informative Essay

874 words - 3 pages In T.H White’s version of the Arthurian legend, White clearly shows the importance values and knowledge a king or leader must have in order to have any form of success within a community. White demonstrates this through the interaction of his two characters Merlin and Arthur. Merlyn the great wizard isolates Arthur in the beginning stages of life to endure Arthur into a world of experience. Merlin knew in order to teach the boy or any

Using Advertising Techniques in Health Education: Changing Experience of Kazakhstan

3051 words - 12 pages analysed and for some of them there will be given some suggestions, which can probably increase their effect. Also, cigarette on-pack warning labels will be considered as an option of health education. As it was mentioned before, one of the problems that could affect the success of anti-tobacco campaign is improper use of advertising techniques in preparing adverts, which include a number of media resources such as TV advertisement, posters

My Experience with English Education

1665 words - 7 pages important? Well, no and yes.         No, English is not a dreadful thing to learn. I suppose my dislike for the subject has become greater through the eighteen some years that I have been learning the different components of the English language. It wasn't actually learning how to speak English that bothered me, my dislike for English began to form when I began getting English education in a formal learning environment. That's when I remember

Bilingual Education based on my experience

553 words - 2 pages least until graduation from high school, they study English. Since I have come back to United States, I have struggled with this second language for 30 years now.I heard in a debate about bilingual education, that four years is enough to learn English. They must be kidding, or they don't know how hard it is to learn a foreign language. Although I've been in the United States for most of my life, but I'm still learning words, phrases and idioms

Personal Experience: Developing World Education Through a Charity Organization

2090 words - 9 pages object, are deified to something more precise and holy. And I said to the headmaster, why is this that you have 500 kids showing up but you don’t have any books? And he said, “in Nepal, we are too poor to provide and education, but until we have education we will always be poor.” A nd that statement struck me. So profoundly, (repeats quote) Too poor to afford but until we have it we wil stay poor. Cause everyone of us has a grandparent or a

This paper is a personal story of my travel to a part of town that has a high amount of people of a particular ethnic make up. It was part of a personal experience for a education class

741 words - 3 pages learn Spanish myself and have tried to pick up a few words here and there.My experience with this field trip was similar to the time when I traveled overseas, it did not matter what my race, ethnicity, culture or ethnocultural group was, and I was treated with respect. Before traveling overseas, friends said to me, "They hate Americans over there!" And when I traveled there, I did not experience anything like that at all. The people there treated me with respect, they were very polite. That was the same experience I had during this field trip

Is single-sex education beneficial?

599 words - 3 pages environment and helps them achieve more based on my personal experience at a girls-only school. Before attending my present girl school, I received co-education for over ten years. Comparing these two types of education, I incline to my present school for its purity and preferable activities designed only for girls. Instead of being blocked from various viewpoints of boys, we girls pay more attention on academics without distraction from boys: We choose

Health Education Systems in Finland, Norway, and Ethiopia

1579 words - 7 pages studies is generally 210-270 ECTS (European Credit Transfer System) points, which means 3.5-4 years of full-time study. (Suomen sairaanhoitajaliitto 2013a, Admission 2013). After the bachelor of Nursing and three years’ work experience you can apply to the Polytechnic master’s education ( 60-90 ECTS). It takes 1,5-2 years, and it’s equal to a university master’s degree. (Opetus- ja kulttuuriministeriö 2013c.) The entry requirement to polytechnic is

Education and Training Comparisons

1062 words - 5 pages Training Note: Based on Arthur Chickering’s work in Education and Identity, Jossie-Bass, 1993. Retrieved from http://www.evolllution.com/opinions/education-versus-training-selecting-the-right-lifelong-learning-experience/ History of training roots back to the guild system. Training vocations varied from building, painting, baking, etc. During those times, training was referred to as “apprenticeships” where the apprentice learned particular

Education

589 words - 3 pages , but also can release the place that the facilities are now occupying. Lastly, experience plays a major role in traditional education. While in class students and pupils have the opportunity to gain new experience and use those experiences for the future. However in online classes students cannot have the ability to obtain experience and practice skills. They are only having to stay at home and study, but cannot fulfill to reality what they have

Similar Essays

Main Aspects Of Education: An Argument For Experience, Curiosity, And Commitment

1842 words - 7 pages , these two types of education are based upon five components of education: experience, curiosity, mentoring, communication, and commitment. No matter what we do or where we go, as long as we face new obstacles, we are learning. In Ryszard Kapuscinski's Travels with Herodotus, Kapuscinski immerses himself in several different foreign countries, constantly picking up cues on the culture and mannerisms of the different people in the regions

Explore An Aspect Of Primary Education Relating To Your Experience In School And/Or Your Personal Development. How Has Your Thinking And Understan

1831 words - 8 pages This assignment aims to explore an area of primary education relating to my experience within the classroom. It will specifically address the importance of music education on emotional development and how music can be incorporated in other areas of education. Furthermore, this assignment will also discuss how my thinking and understanding of the importance of music education has changed and developed as a result of my experiences so far. The

Experience Education Essay

3035 words - 13 pages Education provides the masses with the knowledge needed to succeed in life. Most people define education as the schooling found in public institutions. However, a majority of the population gains most of their knowledge not from schools, but from their surroundings. A person’s environment teaches the lessons firsthand, letting that person develop their own way of reacting and learning. This creates a personalized education that provides the

Field Education Experience At Christian Counseling

1485 words - 6 pages Write a paragraph about your Field Education Experience. Include such details as site, mentor, length/time, and your responsibilities. It was my privilege to engage in a Field Education Experience for my degree in Christian Counseling at a private counseling practice specializing in art and play therapy. Dan Bayly is an LCPC and the counseling director at Paradise Creek Counseling in Moscow, Idaho. Mr. Bayly was my mentor during my 2 months