This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Education: Tenure Protects Freedom Essay

1073 words - 4 pages

Introduction
The question to be answered in this paper is rather faculty tenure should be eliminated within higher education. The debate with faculty tenure goes back some 70 plus years. In the past twenty years the face of tenure has changed, which has led to the need to re-evaluate the issue in higher education. As stated by Schloss & Cragg (2013);
“Tenure protects academic freedom. Yet, the percentage of tenured faculty members has decreased relative to other types of institutional employees of higher education, and in recent legislative proposals has sought to eliminate or curtail it, raising questions about the best ways to ensure academic freedom in the 21st century” (p. 224).
Tenure is vital to the value of a student’s education, high levels of commitment and performance of faculty, and academic freedom. Tenure protects the learning and research that is produced through colleges and universities.
Discussion
Student’s Value
The value of a good education for a student is the ability to learn, graduate in a timely manner, and implement in their jobs what they have gained from their education. Another value for students is engaging them so that they will go onto further their education through graduate studies. As stated by Ehrenberg & Zhang, (2005) “increases in either the percentage of faculty that are part-time or the percentage of full-time faculty that are not on tenure-tracks, is associated with a reduction in graduation rates” (p. 651). The percentage is greater in larger public colleges and universities (Ehrenberg & Zhang, 2005, p. 651). The value of a student education is magnified when they have professors that are experienced and have the expertise in their field of study. The experience and the expertise comes from the ability to research and provide though provoking experiences, that without tenure may impaired the faculties desire to pursue.

Commitment and Performance of Faculty
High levels of commitment and performance of faculty come from having a sense of security in their jobs. As stated by Premeaux (2012), “Tenure may help attract well-qualified individuals to higher education, because without job security protection would opt for higher paying private-sector jobs” (p. 122). If faculty feel that, they are in a secure position they are then lifted of obstacles that distract them from research and educating individuals. I believe this makes the quality of education higher for students.

Academic Freedom
The third and maybe most important reason for tenure is academic freedom. It is important to understand that “academic freedom has long been a controversial but cherished privilege granted to the stewards of higher education” (Schloss & Cragg, 2013, p. 186). Faculty should have the freedom in research and in their publications to evaluate topics that will provide an add value to the institution and the community to serves. They should be able teach controversial issues that help students gain an overall understanding...

Find Another Essay On Education: Tenure Protects Freedom

Teacher Tenure in American Public Schools

3565 words - 14 pages . Twenty-six out of fifty states are currently Forced-Unionism states and therefore are affected by tenure. (National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation). Secondary education teachers do not preform research that is potentially controversial- so it is not an issue of academic freedom. In today’s regimented education, teachers can hardly deviate from a fairly specific curriculum. “Employment in a K-12 classroom does not require engagement in

We Must Reform Teacher Tenure Essay

1532 words - 6 pages “questionable” and observed by a superior or parent, they could be dismissed from their position as a teacher. Teacher tenure was a much needed hero for many scrutinized teachers. Breeding Complacency The basic problem of tenure is that it protects teachers who should not be teaching. The job security that tenure provides allows teachers to do very little without the threat of losing their job. Teachers can simply show up with the bell, if they

We Need a Reform on the Tenure System

1176 words - 5 pages to the idea of children first? If teachers are so protected to the point where bad, tenured teachers get to retain their jobs when seniority is taken into account, then how can we improve the education system when the heart of the system, the teachers, aren't having a positive impact? Tenure does provide job security which is important for innovation and freedom to teach. Controversial subjects, such as evolution, and literature, such as

Tenure in higher education

1212 words - 5 pages English 201 Rhetoric and Composition II Argumentation6/20/2005TENURE IN HIGHER EDUCATIONTenure is a topic that has produced much hatred discussion in recent years. Some argue that tenure is an outdated concept, and if institutions are going to stay in a competive nature, they need to be able to have more flexibility to hire and fire faculty as student needs change. Others argue that tenure is vital to the protection of academic freedom and that

Tenure Proposal

2023 words - 8 pages .). The truth about tenure in higher education. Retrieved from www.nea.org/home/33067.htm O’Neil, R. M. (2006). Limits of freedom: The Ward Churchill case. Change, 38(5), 34-41. Retrieved from http://eds.a.ebscohost.com.proxy1.ncu.edu/eds/pdfviewer/pdfviewer? sid=4ccbd3bd-7cda-4cc4-b6df-9093d45bacf8%40sessionmgr4002&vid=5&hid=4113 Schmidt, P. (2013). Well-marked paths to tenure put new professors at ease. Chronicle of Higher Education, 59

Motivation Towards a Postive Education System

980 words - 4 pages guaranteed a job after only a few years into their practice. While tenure does protect good teachers, it also protects the bad ones. Educational activist Geoffrey Canada said, “(Canada) Teachers need to know that they will not be fired arbitrarily, but the current tenure system in many school systems has gone too far. A system that favors seniority and ignores merit sends a terrible signal to anyone thinking about teaching.” He was right. Tenure

Anthony Kennedy: Supreme Justice Law Maker

609 words - 3 pages build a substantial practice as a lawyer, while his mother was active in civic affairs. Starting at a law office Kennedy acted what would be his lifelong interest in education; he then accepted a position to teach constitutional law at the University of Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law. In Kennedy’s years of private practice as he followed his father’s foots steps in political affiliation in the Republican Party. He assisted Governor Reagan in

Tenure and Termination

1761 words - 7 pages Tenure and Termination Tenure is a position aspired to by all beginning teachers. Tenure is a form of job security that teachers can earn after they reach a certain level of professionalism (Scott, 1986). Once a teacher has earned tenure they are able to maintain an ongoing employment contract within an educational system, as long as they abide by the rules and regulations outlined in their contract. Many states have created tenure policies to

Teachers: Love vs. Lazy

1489 words - 6 pages What makes a teacher a loving, selfless model vs. a lazy, selfish hindrance, and does tenure have anything to do with it? In education there are two different kinds of teachers, one being an example of leadership and love, and the other an individuals that can?t teach or forgot how (or are too lazy) and should have chosen an alternate profession. The loving model teacher wakes up most days and looks forward to teach. The lazy teacher wakes up

What is Oleanna?

1187 words - 5 pages What is Oleanna? What is Oleanna ? Is it a perfect world, or is it a world… The play Olenna by David Mamet gives us a real perspective on our modern education system and society. John the white male college professor is the victim in this play. And Carol the female student is the fascist. John is an exceptional teacher that love to teach and refuse to let the fascist takeover the academic freedom of our

How is the independence of the judiciary guaranteed in Australia?

880 words - 4 pages doctrine that stresses the need for the independence of the judiciary from the other two government institutions in order to protect the freedom of individuals. It is under this doctrine that no person can be a Member of Parliament and a judge at the same time. The doctrine of separation of powers offers several advantages, it proposes separate, specialized and efficient branches of government and it also reduces the abuse of government power by

Similar Essays

Tenure In America Essay

1328 words - 5 pages difficulties, and the public disillusionment with the tenure system in order to support their stance that tenure be abolished. Proponents of the system argue that tenure is the one barrier that allows teachers to maintain academic freedom in the U.S., and effectively educate students in America. Regardless of the administrative difficulties of tenure, or the lack of public support, tenure is a vital component of the education system in America

Is Teacher Tenure Worth Keeping Essay

1952 words - 8 pages tenure. In fact, some claim tenure is the reason why the United States’ education system quality is on its downward slope. In order for one to determine if the country’s education is suffering from tenure, one need to have a full understanding of its function and how teachers use tenure. One would also need to know the benefits of this contract by understanding how tenure relates to discrimination, academic freedom, freedom of expression, freedom

Definition Of Tenure For Teachers Essay

2968 words - 12 pages teachers. Quality teaching is essential to assuring student success. Recent studies have shown that the most important factor related to student academic achievement is teacher quality. Tenure protects teachers who provide a good education for children as well as protecting teachers who do not provide a good education for students. Without willing teachers in the classrooms, students will receive mediocre education that will hinder their future

Academic Tenure Essay

1500 words - 6 pages Typically the role of a professor or a teacher can be distorted or compromised. These issues are typically not real, or are results of lies or misunderstandings. However at different times they are proven to be true. Our society taken measures to safeguard professors from bound injustices or false accusations. Certain ground rules and establishments have been set regarding tenure in the higher education field have been set in place to offer