Effectiveness Of Antidepressant Drugs Essay

662 words - 3 pages

Effectiveness of Antidepressant Drugs

In Issue 13 of Taking Sides, the controversial question Have Antidepressant Drugs Proven to be Effective is analyzed. Psychiatrist Peter D. Kramer argues in this issue that antidepressant drugs "can transform depressed patients into happy people with almost no side effects" (p.212). On the contrary, professors of psychology Seymour Fisher and Roger P. Greenburg "claim that the studies that demonstrate the effectiveness of antidepressants are seriously flawed" (p.212). Kramer's agreement with the statement above is due mostly to the testing he did with his patient Tess and antidepressant drugs. However Fisher and Greenberg disagree with the statement mainly because of the bias drug studies that are done.
Psychiatrist Peter D. Kramer experienced with the antidepressant drug Prozac with one of his patients Tess. In doing this, Kramer learned many things about Prozac and it's effects on people. The experience also leads him to ask many other questions about the drug. Tess was a patient who came from an abusive childhood and therefore as adult suffered from depression, which made Kramer feel she was a candidate for the antidepressant drug Prozac. In Tess taking the drug Kramer found out very quickly what remarkable changes it had on her. Kramer learned that the drug had a "quickly alteration in ordinary intractable problem of personality and social functioning" (p.218). Kramer also learned that Prozac enabled a person to understand what was important to them and who they were and wanted to be. Although Kramer saw the effects Prozac had on Tess, Tess also taught him to look at the border picture. Tess made Kramer think what if this "redefinition of self led to a culture in which this biologically driven sort of self understanding becomes widespread" (p.222). Kramer found it unbelievable what the drug Prozac could do to a patient, something that psychiatrists have always hoped to...

Find Another Essay On Effectiveness of Antidepressant Drugs

Healing Depression Without Antidepressants Essay

1193 words - 5 pages Over the last 20 years, many young adults have been taking antidepressant drugs such as Sertraline, commonly referred to as Zoloft, to ease their pain and struggles. Antidepressants are drugs which were initially used for the treatment of depression, but knowingly proved to be effective for other types of diagnosis, such as anxiety disorders, eating disorders, obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD), sleep disorders, chronic pain, migraines

Depression and its Causes Essay

2595 words - 11 pages the effectiveness of the drugs are limited. Antidepressants are used to treat problems such as ‘moderate to severe depression, severe anxiety and panic attacks, obsessive compulsive disorders, chronic pain, eating disorders and post traumatic stress disorder’ (Royal College of Psychiatrists, 2013a). However, according to the Mental Health Foundation (2013) the use of medication is not usually the first treatment provided, especially if the


1081 words - 4 pages are the prices." I'm generally a happy person -with the help of antidepressants, that is..."-Rachel Machacek, The Science of Single: One Woman's Grand Experiment in Modern Dating, Creating Chemistry, and Finding LoveThe antidepressant drug industry is booming being one of the most prescribed drugs in the US.More specifically, the third most prescribed drug as told by WebMD. Bringing in almost ten billion dollars to the US market in 2009 alone

Antidepressants and Peritoneal Dyalisis

1364 words - 5 pages patients diagnosed with PD and the researchers concluded that there was limited data to support the effectiveness of antidepressants (Ghazi-Noori, Chung, Deane, Rickards & Clarke, 2003). Further research is warranted on the effects of medications used to treat anti-parkinsonism symptoms in tandem with drugs used to treat depression. The most common antidepressant used with PD is selective serontonic re-uptake inhibitors (SSRI), and interestingly

History of Chemistry

753 words - 4 pages . Tricyclic antidepressants are named after their chemical structure, which contains three rings of atoms. This medicine is taken to help depression. The 1950s saw the clinical introduction of the first two specifically antidepressant drugs: iproniazid, a monoamine-Oxidize inhibitor that had been used in the treatment of tuberculosis, and imipramine, the first drug in the tricyclic Antidepressant family. Iproniazid and imipramine made two

Medication used in Psycho- Gerontology Unit

1618 words - 6 pages antidepressant drugs used for elderly include: Monoamine oxidase inhibitors, Tricyclic antidepressants (TCAs), and Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs). Lithium also can be used to prevent relapse in recurrent depression.These are powerful drugs with well known side effects. Their use should be carefully monitored with any patient, but especially when given to elderly people (Glasman & Roose, 2000).The basic biological causes of

Postpartum Depression and Analysis of Treatments and Health Determinants

909 words - 4 pages on the biology of depression, treatment options, therapeutic adverse events and understanding the need for a social support system. The aim of Gjerdingen’s (2002) study was to complete a literary quantified analysis of the different interventions and based on statistics determine the most effective form of treatment. Gjerdingen (2002) discusses a form of biological intervention; antidepressant drugs. Assessing several drug trials consisting

Comparing the efficacy of Cognitive Therapy and Antidepressant Medication in the Treatment of Depression

1746 words - 7 pages that the expertise of the therepists can have affected the outcome of the treatment. The results suggest that both cognitive therapy and medications are effective in the initial treatment of severe and major depression. The degree of effectiveness may however largely depend on a high level of therapist experience and expertise. In another study, Dimidjian et al (2006) developed a trial with the objective to compare the efficacy of antidepressant

Late-life depression

2922 words - 12 pages behavioral group therapy for residents in assisted-living facilities. Journal of Psychosocial Nursing & Mental Health Services, 37(10), 9-16.Karel, M. J. & Hinrichsen, G. (2000). Treatment of depression in late life: psychotherapeutic interventions. Clinical Psychology Review, 20(6), 707-729.Kirsch, I., Moore, T. J., Scoboria, A., & Nicholls, S. S. (2002). The emperor's new drugs: an analysis of antidepressant medication data submitted to

Medical Marijuana - Legalize

1186 words - 5 pages The use of marijuana is a prevalent topic in the news today. The controversy centers on the recreational use of marijuana but the hidden story is about the medical use of marijuana. Due to the safety and effectiveness of medical marijuana it should be widely available for all patients.Marijuana is one of the most commonly used drugs in the United States. It is described as a dry, shredded green/brown mix of flowers, stems, seeds, and leaves of

Disorders and Treatments

1795 words - 8 pages review by McGinn (2000) states that although it has been noted the scope of encouragement for CBT is remarkable, affirmation is still needed to support the effectiveness of short-term CBT as a treatment for depression especially for people experiencing severe depression. However, McGinn (2000) studies revealed post treatment after twelve months showed relapse rates among patients that received CT (39%) were lower than the antidepressant medicated

Similar Essays

Flying With Prozac Essay

1089 words - 4 pages In late 1987, the FDA approved one of the most well known and commonly used drugs that we know today. Fluoxetine, better known as Prozac is used everyday all over the world by 11 million people. It became popular for two main reasons. One, it has fewer side effects than other drugs like it, in their second generation antidepressant class. MAO or Monoamine inhibitors and tricyclics typically have more side effects than Prozac and often become

Combining Treatments In Psychiatric Illness Essay

634 words - 3 pages in the short-term. 3 The final studies states that the majorities of patients were critical of drugs and felt ?fobbed off?.There is good evidence from trials that antidepressants are effective in acute treatment of all grades of depressive disorders. 4 In addition, no clinically significant differences in effectiveness have been shown between different kinds of antidepressant drug. 4 On average, people seem to tolerate selective serotonin

Medicine: The Last Resort. Medicine Should Not Be Used Often; Rather, Therapy Should Be Used.

1216 words - 5 pages the antidepressant drugs Geodon, Abilify, or Ziprasidone committed suicide in 2002. In addition, recent research and studies show that the common antidepressant drug Celexa can induce severe violent behavior that may lead to suicide ("Celexa Side Effects"). These deaths happen because of complications from the side effects of medicinal drugs.Is it worth risking death to cure a mental illness with drugs when it is possible to cure it with human

Dysthymia Could Be Caused By Biological Factors: A Truth Or A Myth?

1758 words - 7 pages depression scale scores in patients given an antidepressant compared to subjects given placebo who has no significant change in the scores. Even though 90% of the patients had seek psychotherapy, they weren't successfully treated but the administration of antidepressant had shown significant effectiveness. This is further supported by two other studies which compared the effectiveness of psychotherapy alone, pharmacological treatment with