Effectiveness Of International Mediation In Achieving Peace: Pakistan & India Conflict International Peace Essay

3110 words - 13 pages

Effectiveness of International mediation in achieving peace
Case Study: Pakistan & India Conflict
If international third party mediation has proved successful, at times in past; can it assist in achieving longer term peace in contemporary era?
Introduction
At present, there are several ongoing armed conflicts around the world. International humanitarian law distinguishes armed conflicts into two categories. The two categories are - International Armed Conflict (IAC) – which is an armed conflict between two or more opposing states, where their militaries could get involved. The only other category where conflicts, which are not between two or more states, come under is – Non International Armed Conflict (NIAC). Non-International Armed Conflicts are those taking place within borders of one state. NIAC can be a civil war, internal riots and tensions or a domestic insurgency involving terrorist groups (ICRC, 2008). Amongst the longest ongoing conflict, is the conflict between two South Asian countries – India and Pakistan. This conflict started short after the separation of two nations in 1947, following end of the British rule over India. The root cause for the conflict is territory, primarily, the Kashmir region. Wallensteen (2015) describes this sort of conflict as “geopolitik conflict”.  Pakistan and India have fought three major wars (1948, 1965 and 1971), two major conflicts (1965 Rann of Kutch and 1999 Kargil) and continue to experience countless border clashes every now and again (Mahmood, 2013). Due to wars, India-Pakistan conflict has seen the engagement of a host of mediators including The United Nations, Russia and USA.
This essay is intended to evaluate the “effectiveness of International mediation in achieving peace”. Pakistan and India have been in conflict for almost 69 years, there have been wars, peace talks, various forms of diplomacy and mediation, despite all that, the two South Asian countries have failed to achieve long term peace and bring the lifelong conflict to an end.
In this essay, effectiveness and failures of the mediations facilitated by international parties, will be assessed; the current role of foreign states and supranational organisations in resolving the Kashmir conflict between Pakistan and India will be analysed, as well as the scope and possibility of two countries achieving peace with help of external mediators. References will be made to other similar case studies in order to explain the process and result of similar peace making process and compare it to situation in the Indian Subcontinent.
History
Formation of the two states
During the process of decolonisation in South Asia, back in 1947 The British colony of India gained its independence. It was then partitioned into two separate entities: the secular nation of India and the predominantly Muslim nation of Pakistan. Pakistan was composed of two non-contiguous regions, East Pakistan (now Bangladesh) and West Pakistan, separated by Indian territory. There...

Find Another Essay On Effectiveness of International mediation in achieving peace: Pakistan & India Conflict - International Peace - Essay

Personal Essay: Conflict, War and Peace

1976 words - 8 pages in conflict with one another. Maybe violence is present in these more localized situations, maybe there is not. I believe however that we have the answer to the question, what does war look like. And I think sometimes it is all too easy for us to have war, to have conflict, to have disputes . The biblical writers asked a different question: “what does peace look like?” For the prophets of the ancient Middle East also lived in days where

conflict and peace Essay

658 words - 3 pages conflict, but also some insight into the necessity of and interrelation between different factors that lead to war. Personal: there are many conflicts going on in Gujarat, some of them are Hindu-Muslim riots, Communal War, The 2002 Gujarat violence, also known as the Gujarat pogrom, National: there are many conflicts going on in India, some of them are the Hindu-Muslim conflict, then there is the Indo-Pakistan war and conflict. Global: there are many

The Effectiveness of Amnesty International

1240 words - 5 pages The Effectiveness of Amnesty International In 1961, two Portuguese students raising a toast to freedom were imprisoned for 7 years. Upon learning about the controversy, Peter Benenson, a British lawyer published The Forgotten Prisoners in the Observer newspaper. This became the article that launched Amnesty International and the worldwide campaign to take action and fight for human rights. Amnesty International or commonly called "AI" is a

Discuss the extent to which International assistance can and should be effectively used to achieve security sector reform as part of post-conflict peace-building

3491 words - 14 pages this stage to begin to evaluate the role of the international community in achieving SSR in post-conflict societies. This paper provides an assessment of international assistance in SSR and how such assistance can be more productive in achieving SSR as part of post-conflict peace-building process. It argues for a comprehensive/holistic approach which recognizes institutional and procedural linkages between security agencies. The advocated

The Cycles of International Conflict

1298 words - 5 pages with this instate conflict international actors may choose to step in adding to the struggle in an attempt to eliminate the abuses against human rights. Nikitin explains that this intervention is usually “…with military means against a regime abusing human and ethnic rights on a massive scale or in situations where ethnic cleansing and genocide take place” (Nikitin, 2000, 6). Recently we have seen this more often as a result of the Arab Spring

The Effectiveness of International Aid in the Development Process

2049 words - 8 pages The Effectiveness of International Aid in the Development Process If an individual was having trouble in some way, wouldn’t one’s natural instinct be to help him or her out? This does not merely apply to persons, but also on a larger basis. All over the world, countries are suffering from many problems. The majority of these sufferers are ELDCs (Economically Less Developed Countries). Whether their crises may involve

The Effectiveness of the Arab and Israeli Peace Initiatives

1863 words - 7 pages The Effectiveness of the Arab and Israeli Peace Initiatives The Arab and Israeli peace initiatives that have taken place between the 1970s and 1990s have been both successful and unsuccessful; however the successful initiatives have been limited in reaching the ultimate goal of peace between the Arabs and Israelis. There have been three major peace initiatives that include the Camp David Accords, Madrid Peace

The Effectiveness of the International Criminal Court

2978 words - 12 pages individualist values, the person and private property. The individualist conception has become a norm and we see an international shift through from collective feelings of the commons towards the individual in addition to the replacement of crimes against the divine to crimes against humanity. This shift has created a culture of accountability and is an important long-term contribution to sustainable peace-building. The ICC is also effective in

How does IR Theory explain the United Nation’s contribution to the maintenance of international peace and security?

2039 words - 9 pages role in maintaining peace and security. The UN peace and security activities have climbed to unmistakable quality as tools of international activity because of its promise of the formation of extra impartial world. After its beginning in 1945, the UN embraced the idea of collective security, played an important part in decolonization and began a range of activities like peacekeeping, peacemaking, peace enforcement, peacebuilding, conflict

Lords Resistance Army and Conflict and Peace Building in Uganda

2555 words - 10 pages killed thousands and displacing millions of Africa natives. Despite several attempts at meetings in addition to arrest warrants from the International Criminal Court against Kony and his troops, Kony has refused to cooperate and this war still rages on as one of the longest-running conflicts in African history. Conflict background and causes The conflicts in Uganda historically a power struggle between two primary actors such as northern tribes

Nuclear Deterrence: A case study of the India-Pakistan Conflict

1555 words - 7 pages between its own offensive capabilities and that of China. Following the Chinese advancements, India started its own nuclear program although it was highly criticized by the International Society. In addition from the evident rationale of creating its own nuclear program, India also had to worry about the threat from Pakistan which was magnified due to the ‘anti-status quo’ alliance with China. India’s conflict ridden history with both Pakistan and

Similar Essays

Limits Of Mediation: Sudan Peace Mediation

1624 words - 6 pages Limits of Mediation: Sudan Peace Mediation Is the Sudan peace mediation by IGAD the answer to the questions of whether the mediators are guaranteed by the conditions and demands how about the parties to the conflict or can they strike out? With little contemplation as to the alternative or consequences the IGAD mediation team did chose to be in bound by the parties. Something exceptional was the Machakos Protocol which was short and the

Achieving Peace Through Militarism Essay

2077 words - 8 pages democratic peace, positive peace, and negative peace all contain different aspects of achieving this peace through warfare. International Relations defines democratic peace as “the proposition, strongly supported by empirical evidence, that democracies almost never fight wars against each other11.” These democracies refuse to wage war on one another because their political ideologies are similar. Both believe that the only way to achieve a peaceful

Achieving Peace Through Militarism Essay

1857 words - 7 pages ,” or Islam (Bacevich, 2005). They invaded Afghanistan to catch the “evil” Osama Bin Laden and to help turn their government into a healthy democracy. But they continue to occupy the country and cause conflict. In the case of Iraq, America claimed that they needed to invade the country to oust Saddam Hussein in the name of peace and freedom, and to get rid of the alleged weapons of mass destruction supposedly present in the country. However, when the

'the Un Has Failed In Its Central Role, The Maintenance Of International Peace And Security." Discuss

2045 words - 8 pages The United Nations was established in 1945 after the end of the Second World War. It was established in order to 'ensure world peace and to establish the economic, social and political foundations through which this can be realised' It aimed to achieve three main goals: "to maintain international peace, to develop friendly relations among states, and to cooperate internationally in solving international economic, social, cultural and